654 karma · joined September 21, 2014
It's quite possible that those researchers and historians do exist, but are working instead of posting about notetaking. It's like saying the people who write Python tutorials never seem to ship anything impressive, so Python must be useless.
It's like deciding to quit smoking but using an empty cigarette pack to carry your credit cards. Sure, I'm not smoking, but every time I pay for something I have to squash the urge.
Only if you get stuck at the entry level. L5, is considered terminal and no one will push you out for not going for L6.
(Google also recently 'declared' L4 a terminal position — likely so they could be stingier with L5 promotions — but what your manager considers terminal is what matters most)
The latter might notice the former having an easier time, but "hey, it works for them" is the wrong takeaway. Commit to the hard work of building resilient institutions; don't join in the destruction because it's easier.
There's also an element of "Never (...), they will drag you down to their level and beat you with experience."
There's also a difference between not wanting to do something, and not being capable of it.
Do you also consider yourself incapable of jump starting a car because you might have to look up instructions first?
Not to mention the level of customization and tooling that companies like Apple have themselves built out around the PCB tool. Playing around with Cadence at home is going to be a different experience than using it at a large tier1 company.
I was mostly sticking with more systemic factors against AI adoption, but I agree with you completely.
As you said, professional PCB design has largely automated the easy stuff, and the hard stuff is going to be largely illegible to an LLM. A competent engineer could route a 10L HDI board which powers on in under a week, getting it ready for mass production is what takes the other 8+ months and 5 design spins, and I don't see much opportunity for AI to help there.