174 karma · joined March 15, 2012
Web: https://SeanKilleen.com Twitter: https://twitter.com/sjkilleen Mastodon: https://mastodon.social/@sjkilleen
--
About Me
* VP of Innovation and Products at SCT Software * Microsoft MVP (one of roughly 120 Dev Tools MVPs in the US) * Organizer of .NET DC * Fun fact: I once led a team to deliver a modernization project that analysts called "more complex than the moon landing". * I'm the lead of the NUnit docs team and (as of Feb 2023) am a member of the NUnit Core Team. * I am a huge fan of the agility & DevOps mindsets. You can find me collaborating for smaller loops almost everywhere I go. I love taking groups from A -> B. * I love teaching and have been a certified instructor for the ScrumAlliance CSD certification and the ICAgile Agile Testing & Automation certifications.
[ my public key: https://keybase.io/seankilleen; my proof: https://keybase.io/seankilleen/sigs/272yKruz_hpcDbhhszQV4rUnwUZIgRoXm4TBQUJpjWA ]
Below is one of his poems, "The Rain Stick", which I love and for some reason have always thought of in terms of how we create and invent things -- music we never would have known to listen for. Today, I plan to accept his challenge to "listen now again" to the music in my life that I know to listen for. Thanks, Seamus.
Edit: HN doesn't preserve line breaks, so below is a link to Pastebin instead.
The U.S.'s obsession with celebrity gossip fodder makes it far too easy for news outlets to focus on the low-hanging fruit, the story that more closely aligns with an already-determined narrative. If Snowden's story was published as a TV drama right now, you could hear the selling points: "Fugitive on the run from the state!" "Spy intrigue!" "Hero or villain?" "Man or legend?"
...None of that has to do with the issue that that Snowden exposed, the inherent secrecy of the court system that allows it to happen, and efforts to reverse what a large portion of the American public views to be unconstitutional/undemocratic behavior by a country that lectures the opposite to other nations.
There are so many interesting and important issues to unpack in this whole ordeal. I wish we could trust the media to unravel these complex issues instead of spoon-feeding us the easy story. We ingest our own ignorance as a result.
* Waze is designed only to be used by a passenger. Any field that requires typing, etc. warns you if you're moving and makes you acknowledge that you are a passenger to continue.
* Waze has a hands-free capability where you can wave your hand in front of the phone and interact with Waze via voice. It actually works pretty well.
* The UI is designed with big buttons, so even if you choose to interact with Waze regularly, you can usually complete a road road report, etc. very quickly (1-2 seconds).
Regarding its "encouragement". I think alerts and the fact that they're available via audio as well reduces the risk. In the end, it's up the user to configure Waze according to how safe they want to be (which, hopefully is pretty safe).
(I'm a huge fan; I've been using Waze from the beginning. No attachment beyond that though)
Consider:
1) the amount a normal business spends on its employees happiness (especially tech) and the fact that the IRS likely doesn't have most of those things to begin with
2) Government pay has been mostly frozen for what, 3 years now? Would you stay in an environment where you can't advance? From a business perspective, how do you keep talent in this situation without giving anyone a raise?
3) the IRS is one of the most (unnecessarily) reviled institutions of government, even before its recent troubles. Historically it has caused people psychological stress based on this factor alone (read about it previously; I'll try to dig up some links to substantiate.)
I think the interesting discussion here is to compare what the IRS did to what a tech company would do and then dig into why we cheer one and boo the other. Unless we think of the IRS as mindless trolls and not smart people who really do want to serve the public, we have to recognize that people don't deserve to toil in stagnant unhappiness just because they chose public service instead of private.
See http://www.dailykos.com/story/2013/04/23/1204296/-Rand-Paul-...
(article is biased liberally; I'm more of a moderate but it's where I saw the information.)
I'm happy that he actually used the spoken filibuster instead of hiding behind rules-based filibusters (which have been the cause of some of the worst obstruction in our country's history), but I no longer hold the belief (as I did right after his filibuster) that it was some sort of principled stand.
This is a time when, though it might not be my personal taste, I believe that a portion of taxes should go to either subsidies or the elimination of fees for these sort of checks.
Such a program would ensure that gun owners chip in (through their taxes), and that a portion of everyone's taxes would be used to ensure both safer gun record keeping and the ability of gun ownership & transfers.
I know nobody likes the idea of more taxes, but does this seem an equitable solution? Interested in your opinion.
----
I appreciate your viewpoint, but I think you have a simplified idea of the context and history surrounding efforts at gun control legislation.
The Second Amendment reads: "A well regulated militia being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed."
Therefore, I have no problem with people owning as many weapons as they need...in the context of a well-regulated militia. Unfortunately, the Second Amendment has, over a long period of time, been co-opted and transformed from "a well-regulated militia" to "everyone should be able to own an assault rifle". This is, by no coincidence, backed by the NRA, who long ago became less about the rights of gun owners and more about the interests of gun manufacturers. (can't blame them; it's where the money is.) I don't see the type of gun control proposed here as eroding the Second Amendment in any way; however, supporters see any legislation that doesn't make it easier to get any gun as eroding the amendment. It has become a symbol, rather than people considering it in its context. Even strict interpreters of the constitution should find it hard to ignore the phrase "well-regulated militia". And it's not an answer to say "oh, in today's context that would totally mean any citizen who wants a gun."
Outside this context, I see guns for hunting as fine and guns for personal protection as fine, because I think we can agree that removing those would impede upon safety and liberty. However, outside of the context of a well-regulated militia, I fail to see a scenario where a citizen would need an assault-class weapon designed for a theater of war, even in a distressing scenario of personal attack.
Also, background checks are not an invasion of privacy, though that's a convenient claim to make. Whenever someone could impact the lives of others (e.g. teachers, government workers with sensitive information), they are required to undergo a background check. I see no reason to oppose background checks anytime someone is going to own something that could end my life and the main purpose of which is to inflict deadly harm. 89% of Americans agree with me on that, including the majority of both the GOP and the NRA's member base. And yet, the legislation was defeated -- not by a vote, but by the inability to break a standard filibuster practice that now routinely requires 60 votes for a law to pass.
The issue of privacy as a civil liberty and bearing arms as a civil liberty are completely separate amendments, and need to be considered in their separate contexts. The issue of privacy could have been applicable, if the gun legislation contained a national gun registry. There's a legitimate argument to be made there, and it would have made me slightly squeamish too. However, the law specifically did not include such a registry and would not lead to one; even John McCain and several other senators (with A ratings from the NRA) said as much. A misinformation campaign was spread to poison the bill based on fear, and it got the minority riled up, and was just enough to cower the senate.
I do think that an actual hypocrisy exists in this debate, but from a slightly different perspective -- time and time again, the same groups that claim they need guns to protect against the government, also rally to stop the military's budget from being cut in the slightest, claiming it endangers our security (despite the fact that our military budget outpaces the closest 10+ nations combined). The same folks who envision needing a small arsenal to protect themselves against the government are the same people who are totally OK with drones, seemingly without thought that those are the same weapons that would be used by a hostile government against them. Thus, the fantasy lives on -- folks stockpile weapons in a fantasy to play the hero against the tyrant, and at the same time support all the tools of supposed said tyrant. These are not the majority of gun owners, but they number a large portion of those who rally around the ownership of assault and military style weapons for use by civilians.
I understand the inclination to make these sorts of arguments; it's easier to say "it's everyone's fault, really" -- than to get down into it and be drawn in the sometimes vile world of partisan politics. I've been to a shooting range, and I don't demonize those who desire to own guns. But at some point, a reality has to become clear -- people are dying because we're doing nothing. We can argue about what should be done, but when near-universal agreement exists on something as simple as a watered-down background check, and it still can't pass congress, we've gone a little too far my taste.
NOTE: The article is not mine, and I was unable to find the original. I've reached out to Tom Junod, and if I hear back from him, I'll be posting a link of his choice and any comments prominently at the top of the article.
Either way, happy to have a solid "no" on this answer and annoyed that it took a 12-hour filibuster to bring that about.
---
One follow-up point now that I've thought about it: a lot of that statement depends on the definition of "engaged in combat." If I wasn't mistaken, wasn't part of the problem that the definition of this was so loose?
Would also be nice to understand what the intended pricing model will be (if any). If the plans are to keep this free, that would be pretty great.