HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Semirhage

718 karma · joined April 9, 2018

submissionscomments
Semirhage··on The Race to Save the Axolotl
Amphibian species are thought to be the proverbial canaries in the coal mine of extinction. Frog species have been crashing, salamander species are crashing, insect numbers have been crashing, reef systems are dying.

When it all falls down on our heads, we won’t be able to say we didn’t have massive flashing warning signs.

Semirhage··on China, India grapple with the consequences too many men
Maybe that’s because it wasn’t an argument, or framed as one? “I’ve noticed” and “people often” struck you as an exercise in formal logic? The only part that represented an argument was the assertion of your willful ignorance of human nature and history, which ironically you ignored.
Semirhage··on China, India grapple with the consequences too many men
Denying the humanity of a fetus isn’t denying the humanity of people, and I said nothing about it not being “real life” either. We routinely kill and eat real life that is far more intelligent and empathetic than newborns, but it’s ok because they’re not people. Pigs for example, are intelligent and feeling creatures.

All I’m doing is failing to put human life on a pedestal, while acknowledging the difference between what something currently is vs its potential. A fetus isn’t a person, it’s something with the potential to become a person. Biology and the law both recognize that, religion and sentiment don’t.

Semirhage··on China, India grapple with the consequences too many men
That’s not so much old fashioned as willfully ignorant of how humans have been comporting themselves for all of recorded history. It isn’t really an opinion as much as a moral and intellectual dodge, sort of like prohibitionists preaching abstinence. I’ve also noticed that so many people lose interest in the life of child the instant it leaves the birth canal. People who thinks it’s a moral imperative to protect s fetus, don’t see, to take similar hard lines on protecting the welfare of children in general. The position seems to hold only so long as someone else is bearing the consequences.

These same people are often against paying a cent in taxes for healthcare, education, food, housing. Those same people don’t even seem to bemoan genocides in places like Rwanda or Sudan, or the Congo until long after they end. To me, it reeks of screwy priorities, and control.

Semirhage··on China, India grapple with the consequences too many men
You may not want to hear this, but the line isn’t so fine or instant in anything except the law. When dealing with laws and regulations you ultimately have a somewhat arbitrary quality because that’s the nature of a line. Speed X is fine and dandy on the roadway, speed X+1 can get you pulled over and heavily fined. What’s the practical difference in 1 kph? Essentially nothing, except that for reasons beyond that difference of 1, a line had to be drawn.

Rational people don’t think that some magical process occurs between one instant and the next as a fetus goes from “ok to abort legally” to “illegal to abort.” The law also isn’t as involved in the spiritual or emotional content of the debate, but the practical implications. As such, law represents a compromise, hopefully a reasonable one.

Part of the problem is that some people look at a fetus and think, “small baby” and others see a potential baby. For some there is a moral imperative to support that potential, and for others there isn’t. Yet others look at a newborn and see a person, others see a potential person. The problem is that this debate is ultimately too emotionally charged for the hard biological reality to enter for most.

As a result, the law picks viability of the fetus as a line, not because of some magical transformation, but for practical reasons. It does this because outlawing abortion in no way stops abortion, it just drives it underground. The law also recognizes that the mother is a fully viable and developed person with their own rights, and (this is going to sound harsh) playing host to a parasitic organism.

Needless to say none of what I’m saying goes over well with people who don’t have a strong background in biology. The idea that the life of the mother might matter more than the life of another potential person doesn’t sit well with some people. The idea that even newborns are less “people” and and more “grub-stage people” tends to be downright offensive to many.

Semirhage··on It's Time for the 99% to Give Back to the 1%
...are repeating what they heard or have read it and failed to comprehend her ideas.

Remember saying that? I’m getting tired of having to “remind” you of what has been said, so yes, we’re done.

Semirhage··on Gwynne Shotwell: SpaceX's Plan to Fly You Across the Globe in 30 Minutes [video]
So there’s noise pollution on a grand scale, it depends on natural gas extraction or a breakthrough in electrolysis, and it will produce CO2 when burned in flight. Great. It will also cost a fortune, and even SST isn’t viable, yet somehow this will be?

I could not be more skeptical.

Semirhage··on Gwynne Shotwell: SpaceX's Plan to Fly You Across the Globe in 30 Minutes [video]
What would be the environmental impact of ubiquitous rocket launches for business travel?
Semirhage··on It's Time for the 99% to Give Back to the 1%
There’s nothing new here.

That is ad hominem against a straw man, so I’m applying grains of salt heavily to your commitment to logical and rhetorical integrity.

Is the first thing I said. Meanwhile I stand by it, but it seemed prudent to break it down point by point until you had nowhere left to go. “All of these people I must invented haven’t even read the books!” Is still just what I said it was.

Semirhage··on It's Time for the 99% to Give Back to the 1%
Reassertion of your unsupported claim about who has and hasn’t read something still isn’t an argument, it’s stil a straw man. Do you have any substance to offer?
Semirhage··on Why Invest in Cities? There's Always Another Boise
California is massive, and it isn’t all SF and LA. You’d think that electing Schwarzenegger governor would have been a hint as to some political leanings! California has a sizeable rural community, which is typical Right wing.

http://cdn.abclocal.go.com/content/kfsn/images/cms/automatio...

Semirhage··on It's Time for the 99% to Give Back to the 1%
I was responding to this gem of your’s: A government is an institution which has monopolized the use of force in an area.

What you’re on about now, I have no idea.

Semirhage··on Is dark matter made of primordial black holes?
It’s not impossible, but we’d have no way of knowing because the result would be just another black hole. What I can say with some confidence is that unless some wildly unexpected physics emerges, there’s no way antimatter only occurred in dense clumps and collapsed before it could annihilate. So could there have been a freak occurrence yielding a black hole from a dense cloud of antimatter? Unlikely, yet possible, but it would still do nothing to explain why matter ended up dominating antimatter.
Semirhage··on Is dark matter made of primordial black holes?
Of course a black hole’s temperature is inversely proportional to its mass, so a tiny black hole would be terrifically hot. Ironically a much more massive black hole is undetectable unless it’s lensing something, or “feeding” on something. A small black hole would have a very high temperature just from Hawking radiation.
Semirhage··on Is dark matter made of primordial black holes?
It isn’t totally discredited, but the constraints on it make it exceedingly unlikely. Against it:

No gamma ray signals as hoped/expected from evaporating PBH’s.

LIGO is not seeing PBH mergers at a rate that would support the numbers required.

Micro lensing studies don’t support it.

Is it’s possible, but it’s much less likely than other theories which allow for less fine tuning of parameters.

There’s a very good graphic that shows what I’m talking about. https://astrobites.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/constraint...

From: https://astrobites.org/2017/08/31/could-dark-matter-be-black...

Semirhage··on It's Time for the 99% to Give Back to the 1%
And in Somalia, there is no such monopoly, so everyone is free to use force on everyone else in a fully unregulated environment. The strong conquer the weak, and are conquered in turn. You’d love it, I’ll buy the ticket for you.
Semirhage··on It's Time for the 99% to Give Back to the 1%
You opened with this: The vast majority of people who have opinions on Ayn Rand or her philosophy of Objectivism haven't read a word of what she wrote and are repeating what they heard or have read it and failed to comprehend her ideas.

That is ad hominem against a straw man, so I’m applying grains of salt heavily to your commitment to logical and rhetorical integrity.

Semirhage··on Is dark matter made of primordial black holes?
That’s just not true, it’s an artifact of the Bohr model of the atom which doesn’t take the wave-particle duality of the electron into account. The wavefunction of the electron is “smeared” around the atom, which is not empty.

The black hole as dark matter theory is also largely discredited (MACHO theory for MAssive Compact Halo Object) because gravitational lensing studies don’t support it.

Semirhage··on Amazon May Have a Counterfeit Problem
I’m really tired of tech giants claiming they’re just platforms when it’s convenientm for them. Twitter, Google, and Facebook claim they’re not publishers, just platforms. Meanwhile they’re acting like both. Amazon isn’t engaged in commerce, it’s just a platform, but again is very much both. It seems that some regulations on this kind of “platform” is inevitable, and probably overdue.

The degree to which companies on the internet thrive through aggressive doublespeak is frustrating beyond belief.

Semirhage··on Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognition test in Europe
Not only is the tech turned on, but users who click through to the settings to try and turn it off will also find Facebook attempting to dissuade them from doing that — with manipulative examples of how the tech can “protect” them.

Facebook is such a bad actor, I hope that politicians figure out that they could make a name for themselves kicking them in the teeth. Hopefully GDPR can come in and hurt them too. I realize that the default attitude of many in tech is that most people don’t know or care about this, but I think they’re wrong. People do care, but it takes time and repetition to make the point stick. Helpfully Facebook only has two speeds: scumbag, and turbo-scumbag.

All around the world, we need to start electing politicians who understand technology, know what dark patterns are, and can intelligently fight for us.

Semirhage··on Chat is Google's next big fix for Android's messaging mess
And they just killed it.
Semirhage··on Chat is Google's next big fix for Android's messaging mess
E2E encryption isn’t a product Google will want to offer unless they have keys to a back door for marketing purposes, and to give to their TLA and Pentagon pals.

Signal exists, and that’s where my hopes lie. It’s not perfect, but it works.

Semirhage··on All Lyft Rides Are Now Carbon Neutral
In the same way that all knights who bought indulgences from the Pope were free of sin. This is marketing, pure and simple, and at best if you’re a deeply optimistic person, the rides are “offset” and not neutral.
Semirhage··on California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Conditions
I looked, but as far as I can see you’re right, and it’s consistent. That’s really impressive, and I’m sorry for calling you out like that, I was wrong.
Semirhage··on Jeff Bezos' annual shareholders letter
I live in Italy, sorry I should have picked a US city.
Semirhage··on California Opens Investigation into Tesla Workplace Conditions
Is this skepticism consistent? If I browse a few weeks of your comment history, will this tendency to doubt “anything posted on the internet with nothing more than an email requirement” be your norm?
Semirhage··on No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abuse Facebook Login
Seeing this and being surprised is like watching a teen movie where the gossiper invites the entire school to listen in on the phone line while the protagonist is (unwisely) sharing a secret with them, and thinking as you watch, "that's totally out of character for the gossiper - even though they want to collect people's information themselves, there's no way they would invite other people to listen in as they're in the process of receiving that information."

Doesn’t that depend on who’s surprised? My parents would be shocked by this, people working in the software industry should be less shocked. I bet that a poll of 100 randomly selected people asking, “What does documentation mean in the context of software?” would discover that few knew the answer. Never mind actually reading the docs, or understanding their implications.

Facebook goes to some trouble to ensure that only a small minority of people grasp the implications of how they’re monetizing their users.

Semirhage··on Jeff Bezos' annual shareholders letter
That’s a hundred thousand more people than the population of Florence!
Semirhage··on Elite Dating Apps Threaten to Make America’s Wealth Gap Worse
Sing it with me! We all live in a yellow journalistic submarine...

http://paulgraham.com/submarine.html

Semirhage··on Many Bitcoin Miners Are at Risk of Turning Unprofitable
Other than individual-scale mining being an inefficient greenhouse heater, (or just heater in general) what are some of those dual uses you’ve seen so many times? On what scale compared to the bulk of mining activity?
← PreviousPage 6 of 7Next →