HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ShannonAlther

312 karma · joined April 27, 2017

submissionscomments
ShannonAlther··on RISC-V Pros and Cons
The article says that the developers expect companies to add their own features and support, so I guess we're just waiting for some established player or startup to pick up the ISA and roll something out with it?

But it specifically says "same model as Linux", and that bothers me because RISC-V is not an operating system, and I'm not sure that Linux's business model is appropriate here...

ShannonAlther··on The US has forgotten how to do infrastructure
> Unless you are driving quite a long distance and/or on the open highway, car travel is not as much faster than foot travel as some people seem to believe.

The average speed limit on municipal roads in Ontario is 50 km/h, which means that anywhere within 5km will take 6 minutes and, within 10km, 12 minutes.

Running 5km takes me 18 minutes, and running 10km takes me closer to 40 minutes. Humans walk at about 5km/h, which means that 5km would take about 1 hour, and 10km would be 2 hours or more, since exhaustion starts to factor in.

Car travel is unimaginably faster than walking. I don't know anybody who wants to spend 2 hours on a round-trip to a grocery store 5km away when they could do it in 10 minutes in a car.

ShannonAlther··on The US has forgotten how to do infrastructure
This is only true for certain scales relating IQ to construction costs. The average IQ in Africa is, what, ~15 points lower than America? Suppose the first 2 points increase construction costs by a factor of 1.5, and each subsequent 2-point reduction by a smaller factor, until you reach some limit (IQ average too low to be realistic, NGO aid, something like that).
ShannonAlther··on Ask HN: Lost $400k USD in a deleted email, how contact a Gmail engineer?
If you're a little faster than average on the draw and have money to burn, the profits from the successful investments outweigh the money lost on the unsuccessful ones. E.g. if you have $50k, and spend it on five companies, only one of those companies has to be Apple for you to make way more than you started with...
ShannonAlther··on Bitcoin VS Ethereum
I think he means that the USD is valid currency for all debts, public and private, and this law is enforced by the US gov't.
ShannonAlther··on When the Patient Is a Gold Mine: The Trouble with Rare-Disease Drugs
I'm more interested in immunology than respirology so I know very little about CF. Your idea sounds plausible (I'd give credence to the possibility that reducing stress is part of it, and maybe also the placebo effect), so some day you might be validated. Thanks for talking!
ShannonAlther··on When the Patient Is a Gold Mine: The Trouble with Rare-Disease Drugs
Then I will ask directly: what lifestlye interventions have you implemented, and how are they helping you?

Edit: Nevermind, you said it involved dietary change to handle acidosis. That's great, but is it related to the bacterial problem?

ShannonAlther··on When the Patient Is a Gold Mine: The Trouble with Rare-Disease Drugs
I don't believe I've been disrespectful or dismissive at all. I included the reasons I think you're mistaken, and I've cited Wikipedia because going through the back issues of the NEJM and the Canadian Respiratory Journal for citations would take too long to respond in a timely fashion. If you'd like to explain why you think lifestyle interventions are helpful for other cystic fibrosis patients, please do! I can also grab better citations, if you really want.
ShannonAlther··on How AWS Cloud is demolishing the cult of youth
Δ That's really insightful. Thanks for taking the time to talk to me!
ShannonAlther··on When the Patient Is a Gold Mine: The Trouble with Rare-Disease Drugs
> Your claim amounts to refuting the idea that anything new can be done, that the outcomes we currently have is as good as it gets.

Poppycock. The Wikipedia page lists a small handful of promising technologies[0], and there are others not listed there: improvements in organ transplantation and/or cloning would do wonders. I'm particularly fond of the idea of synthetic chloride channels that do the work of the CFTR protein.

But the reason that cystic fibrosis is lethal is because of the mucous. The lethality of the mucous is unrelated to your lifestyle choices, since the lungs of a CF patient are colonized by bacteria that prefer the different type of mucous. This sort of thing is exacerbated by fraternizing with other people who have CF, since they're likely to infect one another.

Over time, the bacteria become resistant to the antibiotics used to treat the disease. So more antibiotics are definitely in order, although that's not the be-all end-all. Again, I'm just saying that lifestyle interventions are almost certainly not effective (I can't even see how).

But there's a critical point in here: sure, Ignaz Semmelweis was laughed at for positing an unusual theory. But so were tens of thousands of others who came up with actually crazy ideas, too many to list. All I'm saying is, just because people disagree with you doesn't mean they're wrong.

[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cystic_fibrosis#Research

ShannonAlther··on How AWS Cloud is demolishing the cult of youth
I still don't believe it's possible, at least not often. Hiring a senior rockstar/ninja/10x whatever means you have to offer them more money than they're currently making (which you have to imagine is a lot) and/or they need to really be so invested in your idea that they're willing to drop everything and join you.

I'm not saying this from a position of authority, I haven't founded a startup or anything like that. But the average age of a startup founder is mid-20s IIRC, and you'd have a hard time convincing an extremely talented individual, who's older than you, to sign on.

ShannonAlther··on When the Patient Is a Gold Mine: The Trouble with Rare-Disease Drugs
I don't believe I've accused you of anything except being wrong, Mz, and furthermore your blog notes that you have a rare CFTR mutation, a milder form of the disease (I only briefly scanned so I may be wrong). That's awesome! Your quality of life is probably really high compared to the average CF patient!

But the only intervention that's lifestyle-y that I know of is chest physiotherapy. I'm glad that the person you found now feels better, but the data does not support your claim.

ShannonAlther··on How AWS Cloud is demolishing the cult of youth
I don't think that demographic exists (really motivated people with 20 years experience). I remember Paul Graham saying something along the lines that he would never do the startup thing again even if he was dead sure it was a good idea because Viaweb took years off his life. Why would he go back and do it again? Why would anyone with a career and a family want to do that? It's hellish.
ShannonAlther··on Kik Messenger App Debuts Own Digital Currency Amid Bitcoin Boom
That's really interesting and makes sense. However, given how common credit is, the fact that you must accept USD as payment in the US means that USD circulation is going to be really high, and therefore vendors that don't accept it for sales are going to be demolished by others that do. As opposed to BTC, where if you don't accept it, so what? and if you do, you're at least a little unusual.
ShannonAlther··on How AWS Cloud is demolishing the cult of youth
Misleading title; Amazon is hiring experienced engineers for their experience. They can do this because they can afford it, and they are doing it because they want to enhance their services.

None of this demolishes "the cult of youth". If you're running a startup, hiring young people with no families and the stamina to give 110% to their job is still the way to go. As experienced as James Gosling, Tim Bray, et al. are, they're not going to be working 12 hour days, nor are they critical to Amazon's survival.

ShannonAlther··on Kik Messenger App Debuts Own Digital Currency Amid Bitcoin Boom
There are many reasons why a single currency may be preferable to many in a single market. The biggest is company scrip[0] but there are others, like the fact that this just creates more market speculation and that vendors have the option to not accept any currency they aren't required to by law.

[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Company_scrip

ShannonAlther··on When the Patient Is a Gold Mine: The Trouble with Rare-Disease Drugs
Since you actually have CF, it would be trite to point out (but I will anyways for the peanut gallery) that the mutation in the CFTR gene causes secreted mucous to be much thicker than necessary. In the lungs, this causes difficulty breathing, rampant infections, and death by the age of 50 at the optimistic. Lifestyle interventions are not as helpful as you think in the general case, and the only reason you didn't die in your crib is because of aggressive antibiotics use.
ShannonAlther··on Chinese Online Retailer Developing One-Ton Delivery Drones
JD.com thinks this will be an efficient way of maintaining a transportation network in the future. I'm not convinced, mostly because it seems like the fuel cost would be much greater. Feel free to let me know if I'm wrong though.
ShannonAlther··on Facebook flooded with 'sextortion' and revenge porn, files reveal
> "54,000 potential cases... and 33 of the cases reviewed involved children."

That's 0.06% of reviewed cases, which is frankly less than I would have thought. I suspect that child abusers are a more savvy lot than the average chucklehead who does something like this.

ShannonAlther··on Frighteningly Ambitious Startup Ideas (2012)
Children are expensive and time-consuming, because in our society we're expected to take care of them, and the standard for that is very high. In developing countries, the standard is much lower and children are able to help run the household, so they're incentivized to have more children. As the things that make a country 'developed' spread in developing countries, the equation starts to tip the other way...
ShannonAlther··on U.S. Startups Fail to Attract Expected Crowd of Small Investors
Bloomberg, apparently. It's just like day trading: sure, you might get lucky, but you have to know or have something the rest of us don't to get consistent returns. Just invest in an index fund.
ShannonAlther··on The Hearing Aid's Pursuit of Invisibility (2016)
> (Also, falling out.)

More or less the same way headphones do.

ShannonAlther··on Google acquires Owlchemy Labs
I don't think Nintendo ever stopped creating content for their consoles.
ShannonAlther··on Solar Roof
> I mean, he could have started with a low performance, average-looking, electric, family sedan.

There are other reasons Tesla started with a high-end model. Because building the cars was going to take a lot of R&D, Tesla supported the cost by starting with fancy sports cars, which have a better ROI, and then used the technology to manufacture less pricey cars later on.

Source (ctrl + f "the business plan"): http://waitbutwhy.com/2015/06/how-tesla-will-change-your-lif...

ShannonAlther··on Unmanned U.S. Air Force space plane lands after secret, two-year mission
> How, pray tell, does anything "perform risk reduction"? Does that phrase have any meaning in English, or any other terrestrial language?

This may not be what you meant, but suppose that my sister Alice is an alcoholic, and drinks during the day at her job (they're very tolerant). I am concerned that she will cause a traffic accident, so I encourage her to enroll at Alcoholics Anonymous, or I offer to pay her taxi fares or buy her a bus pass. Ta-da, risk reduced!

In this instance, I think they're either referring to the risk of crashing the plane or something conveniently censored by government classification.

ShannonAlther··on How Your Phone Is Designed to Control Your Life [video]
Ah, makes sense. But ratings and likes serve another purpose: determining which content is worth looking at. Snapchat aside, those services have the following they do because the content is tailored to the user: Facebook has their algorithms, r/all is filtered by 10M users, and so on.

But HN has an advantage in that it has a specific audience (the sort of people who know that Ycombinator is a thing). So the content is already probably relevant. Maybe that model has advantages we haven't fully explored yet.

ShannonAlther··on How Your Phone Is Designed to Control Your Life [video]
I confess that I can't see what gradient this ranking follows. It looks like the users get progressively more anonymous, except Reddit has the most anonymous users and it's in the middle; it also looks like the average use time per day goes down, except I have no idea whether that's the case.
ShannonAlther··on How Your Phone Is Designed to Control Your Life [video]
Well, grocery stores already do that. And it's hard to imagine what a 'healthier version' of an app, say Spotify, would look like. Unless you're suggesting they move to Netflix's business model, but that's a market niche that's already filled.
ShannonAlther··on Case studies in copy protection
Maher concludes that this was successful due to 'asymmetry' between the devices that wrote the disk and the ones that read it had different capabilities, but the actual reason is probably due to the creativity and complexity of the scheme. Not only did the game have a section of code that was more or less impossible to duplicate, the instructions to validate the code were hidden in unlikely places, and (perhaps the most important point) the game did not immediately fail if it detected that it had been pirated. Every 'definitely cracked' copy circulated increased the demand for an actual working version of the game.

It's crucial that Dungeon Master was an excellent game[0] because otherwise, players might have simply decided it wasn't worth their time or money.

[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dungeon_Master_%28video_game%2...

ShannonAlther··on How Your Phone Is Designed to Control Your Life [video]
Netflix's incentive structure is slightly different: they want their clients to enjoy the service, so that they will be inclined to subscribe to them in the future. Spotify, on the other hand, wants to maximize time spent using the service, which in turn maximizes exposure to advertisements and thus inflates their ad revenue.

For Spotify, binge use is the end goal, whereas for Netflix it is merely a consequence of producing an enjoyable service.

You're right though, it would be difficult to directly incentivize something as nebulous as 'improving lives' beyond providing services that do just that, since corporate incentives generally follow the money.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →