141 karma · joined May 29, 2012
I don't entirely agree with the outrage but the fact that this is done by Fox who are real jerks about their own copyright really sets off the hypocrisy alarm.
[0]: http://blogs.rnw.nl/medianetwork/google-wants-to-put-wireles...
That seems really low. I live in a small house and here are my utilities:
Phone: $50
Internet: $60
Water/sewer/garbage: $100
Electricity: $80 (less in the summer, more in the winter)
Gas: $10
And you left out mandatory insurance which is ~$150 for car + home.
Total: $450/month
What I can say is that the area that the term covers is arbitrary and that you can discuss one facet of it without involving the others.
There is no reason that trademarks need to be discussed when talking about content distribution systems just like there is no need to talk about expiration dates when shipping plastic lawn chairs.
You are being absurd. A physical book and a digital representation of the information are completely different. The only thing that they have in common is that once used you get the same information. If you steal a book, that is theft. If you copy a book that is copyright infringement. The difference is that the person who had the book stolen from then is deprived of property in one example and in the other they are not.
This is not a simple matter. Making a copy is not theft. There are not clear lines here.
I am saying that digital content will one day be freely available (or available on a subscription) because it costs nothing to copy. Never before has content been restricted when it could be copied freely. Radio is free television is free and websites are free. I think that is the natural end point of intangible goods it is just a matter of figuring out how to pay the content creators.
Why is this lucky? Are the books being used?
Fiat money is ridiculous in exactly the same way. Would you say that it seems ridiculous to ignore the power of Xerox because it doesn't pay the bills for sellers of physical goods?
That makes no sense. I don't see what you mean. Right now the internet could deliver content to more people more efficiently than a retail store but it is being restricted by laws that have been put in place to guarantee a paycheck for the content creators. I don't think that this is bad but I do think that we are in a state of transition and that in the not so distant future you will not go to a store to get music movies or books (except possibly as a novelty)
I guess what I am asking is this: Do you think that 'public ownership' of IP is impossible, impractical or immoral?
As a content creator do you have an objection to public content on principle? Or do you dislike it because you don't see it being possible?
I am asking this out of pure curiosity. I am just kind of surprised to see someone on hacker news of all places saying that information should not be free. I can understand saying that now is not the time or that models are not yet ready but it seems ridiculous to think that we should ignore the power of the internet for content distribution forever because it doesn't pay the bills now.
It's like looking for the 'perfect distro'. Just pick one and learn to love it.
Baring some large redistribution of wealth the most effective thing we can do is to remove all the barriers that we can and encourage improvement.
There are many people who are direct descendants of slaves who don't qualify for affirmative action and there are people who's families moved here in the 70s who do qualify.
We need to stimulate the black belt, the effects of racism are highly geographical.
Everyone has to make judgement calls with their votes, that is how democracy works. There are some people who have little interest in the internet, there are some that don't have an opinion on a woman's right to choose. This doesn't make them bad people, it just means that the issues that drive their votes are different than the ones that drive your own.
If these issues had a broad consensus they wouldn't be such big election topics. Believe it or not, there are some people voting for candidates because they are pro-life, if there weren't then candidates would not publicize their stance on the topic.