HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

SilasX

17,815 karma · joined December 6, 2011

blog: http://blog.tyrannyofthemouse.com

Github: http://github.com/SilasX/

email: sbarta@gmail.com

Location: Austin, TX (left the Bay Area August '18).

Studying infosec to make a new career out of it.

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/silasbarta; my proof: https://keybase.io/silasbarta/sigs/EIsQUp3Ln8z5fOgzWFj9alDI8Ci9Vl4JSgP5OZQcmjU ]

submissionscomments
SilasX··on Int a = 5; a = a++ + ++a; a =? (2011)
Heh, one time when I got this style of question[1] (but for JavaScript), I took a glance at it and said "Um ... you really shouldn't write code like that." The interviewer replied, "Oh. Yeah. Fair point." And then went on to another question.

[1] By which I mean predicting the behavior of error-prone code that requires good knowledge of all the quirks of the language to correctly answer.

SilasX··on The conflation of money and things
Haha agreed, but remember, it's posted on lit[erature]hub, not tech[nical]hub.
SilasX··on Ted Turner has died
Whoa there. The US being wrong to make war in Vietnam absolutely does not vindicate those who supported the Viet Cong!
SilasX··on Google Chrome silently installs a 4 GB AI model on your device without consent
Yeah, I was surprised to learn that Ticket to Ride (downloaded on Steam) uses like a half gigabyte, but the most data-intense thing it does is a few musical tracks and 2D images with scaling. They fit Final Fantasy 3 (SNES) with 3 CDs of music (albeit low quality) and Mode 7 graphics for the airship onto like 3 MB.
SilasX··on Kalshi CEO expects US DOJ to prosecute insider trading cases
Goodhart's law does not cleanly apply here, because the group cares about more than making money, and would bear all the costs of not doing (what observers regard as) being in their interest -- both in that case, and whether potential counterparties regard it as being predictable enough to make reliable long-term agreements with.

To illustrate with an example, your point is like saying that if we had a prediction market for "Will the United States cede Texas to Mexico in 2026?", then the US government would give up Texas just to get that sweet sweet prediction market payoff.

I would agree with a smaller point, that an org would accept minor tweaks it doesn't care about in order to game a market, but this just means it can tolerate being unpredictable about lower-order bits of its decisions. You see that in cases like Trevor Noah making a minor change to a speech to influence a particular bet.

SilasX··on A new spam policy for “back button hijacking”
Even on old.reddit, it breaks the back button. When you navigate back, it usually reloads the entire page you were on and ignores all your collapse actions on conversations.
SilasX··on FBI used iPhone notification data to retrieve deleted Signal messages
Hmmm this is interesting. Because I've long had the complaint that notifications are frustratingly ephemeral. There have been many cases where I've gotten a notification that my phone clearly has but which I can't read, because when I tap it, it's purged permanently, and then I have a spotty internet connection, so I can't see it in the actual app that loaded.

I'm always like "JFC, can't you cache the notifications, so I can see it there while waiting for the app to gets its act together?" But no, that's never an option.

So I'm getting a laugh out of how notifications last long enough to be extracted by someone just not the person that they're for. (Though to be fair, it could be a case of a notification that was never tapped, and therefore hadn't been purged yet. I couldn't tell from the story.)

SilasX··on Newly created Polymarket accounts win big on well-timed Iran ceasefire bets
>In America we generally make bad things illegal, not activities that could become motivation for bad things.

Not really, even in America. Like, take alcohol regulation. Your model would be "drunken bar fights are already illegal, so just prosecute that, problem solved."

Except that, historically, there's so much of that that it overwhelms the ability of law enforcement to keep up. So we try to remove the driving factors: "Okay, you can drink in public, but only[1] at these licensed places that are heavily incentivized to prevent fights before they start."

I'm not advocating any particular position, I'm just saying that if there's a persistent situation that heavily incentivizes violence, then it's not unreasonable to push back on that mechanism rather than just try to mop up the violence after the fact. Which specific situations merit that is up for debate, but it shouldn't be controversial that some situations should be handled this way.

[1] Yes, I'm simplifying, just focus on the general point here.

SilasX··on Iran demands Bitcoin fees for ships passing Hormuz during ceasefire
Iran is a recognized national government, not a pirate.

Oh crud I just opened a can of worms with that, didn't I?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pirates_and_Emperors

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UQBWGo7pef8

SilasX··on Iran demands Bitcoin fees for ships passing Hormuz during ceasefire
I did a double-take at it being Bitcoin fees, since you'd think they'd want some stablecoin (even if not USD) so as to avoid inheriting the volatility, but no, they want Bitcoin specifically:

>“Once the email arrives and Iran completes its assessment, vessels are given a few seconds to pay in Bitcoin, ensuring they can’t be traced or confiscated due to sanctions,” FT reported, citing Hosseini.

https://beincrypto.com/iran-bitcoin-toll-hormuz-strait-tanke...

SilasX··on U.S. stocks are set to deliver their worst quarter in nearly four years
People don't have encyclopedic knowledge of the same things you care about.

Putting quotes around a quote isn't hard.

SilasX··on U.S. stocks are set to deliver their worst quarter in nearly four years
It's fair to expect people to pay attention to political issues that can affect them.

It's not fair to expect everyone to be intimately aware of every political gaffe, and instantly make the connection when you repeat it so they know not to reply to the comment seriously -- as the original comment was doing.

FFS, just put it in quotes so people know you're quoting someone. (Or if it's not a direct quote, mention that it's from the mentality of the person you're mocking.) Is that so hard? Is it so important that you feel special as someone who knows about that incident that you just have to provoke a confused flamewar?

SilasX··on U.S. stocks are set to deliver their worst quarter in nearly four years
... and comments requiring the reader to be that way too should be downvoted/flagged. Look at the replies it produced: troll mission accomplished, "productive conversation" not so much.

At the very least, they could have put the comment in quotes to indicate they're quoting someone and it shouldn't be read at the object level.

Edit: Seriously? Am I wrong here? Are you all really okay with Poe's Law-ifying HN, where people post comments that are easy to read as serious when they were intended as ridicule of the person who said them, and the comments erupt in confusion and flames? That's not what we should be expecting out of HN.

SilasX··on U.S. stocks are set to deliver their worst quarter in nearly four years
And somehow expecting everyone will get the reference.
SilasX··on ChatGPT won't let you type until Cloudflare reads your React state
While I would generally sympathize on that front, it doesn't really apply here.

None of the management-level desiderata he appealed to require that the user experience be broken this bad. There is very little bot deterrence from prevention of typing at that stage, while it heavily impacts user experience, especially on mobile.

I elaborate here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47575982

SilasX··on ChatGPT won't let you type until Cloudflare reads your React state
It has not been negligible for me, and, however you're doing this, there is significant room for improvement.

There have been times when, across about ten minutes of usage, most of which is me typing on iOS Safari, it drained 15% of my battery. There is no functional justification for this beyond poor code quality. (It was on a long conversation FWIW.)

This when I'm logged in, with a paid (Plus) account, connected to a very old email address with a real user profile. That can't be the result of super-clever bot defense measures, because it's merely an inconvenience on desktop. And if you genuinely believe that email has been compromised, why aren't you reaching out the to the account owner, as the account isn't otherwise connected to fraud by your heuristics?

However brilliant the LLM agent it is, I'm seeing a lot of unforced errors regarding how you implement a web interface to it. If it makes you feel any better, it doesn't really register compared to all the bloat I see on other sites.

SilasX··on ICAO issued new power bank restriction on flight
I don't see where that's contradicting my comment.
SilasX··on LinkedIn uses 2.4 GB RAM across two tabs
Then why does pretty much every site seem to have a "memory leak" of this type (besides unicorns like HN that try to be minimal)?
SilasX··on LinkedIn uses 2.4 GB RAM across two tabs
Really? Then why else do adblockers seem to take up so much memory, other than an arms race with countermeasures that sites take?
SilasX··on ICAO issued new power bank restriction on flight
Correct, but I agree with the parent that this is a dubious case to apply that reasoning.

To make it clearer, imagine another context: "It's dangerous for a passenger to have a gun on board. Therefore, we're strictly limiting passengers to only two guns."

Like, no. The relevant sad case is present with one gun just as with two.

Of course, what complicates it is that these power banks present a small but relevant risk of burning and killing everyone on board. So yeah, you might be below the risk threshold if everyone brought two, but not three. So it's not inherently a stupid idea, but requires a really precise risk calculation to justify that figure.

SilasX··on Bored of eating your own dogfood? Try smelling your own farts
Funny/informative story about this: There was a project, OpenHatch.org c. 2011 that tried to get people to be comfortable enough with programming to contribute to open source projects. In one of the tutorials (I think introducing command-line git?), if you followed the instructions, it would dump you into vim. It hadn't introduced to you vim by that point or explained that's what was happening, so you wouldn't even know enough to google the error. And this was a project that was supposed to be primarily focused on being newbie-friendly!
SilasX··on How to defer US taxes
Your comment made it sound like any re-investment back into the business would count as a cost that then cancels the profits that would be taxed. Even with your clarification, it still sounds like that. This is orthogonal to taxes that would be levied on things other than profit.
SilasX··on Our commitment to Windows quality
Ugh. They horribly borked Notepad. The whole reason I use it is because it's dumb and simple. The moment you change it into a full-featured rich text editor with AI assistants and autocorrect ... you should just make it another app, because it's solving a different problem.

At the very least, don't forget my font setting on the update.

SilasX··on How to defer US taxes
>As a business owner in the U.S. I can opt to reinvest all revenue back into the business,

Not entirely, no. Any of those reinvestments that count as capital expenditures aren't immediately deductible, but only on a throttled schedule, which is why the concept of depreciation exists in tax law:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15061439

SilasX··on Death to Scroll Fade
Sure, but that's a big if: "Oh, just this one small thing for interactivity would be nice ... and this other thing ..." just like with how the early web expanded functionality.
SilasX··on Death to Scroll Fade
This. It's fundamentally a social problem. The moment that reader mode becomes the default, they'll start gradually extending it with "useful" additions until it's just as bloated and painful again, and then we'll have some rebrand of the concept of reader mode, and the cycle starts anew.

"Why can't we have a functional version of the site for the blind, and the normal one for everyone else?"

'We have that! It's called HTML!"

Edit: Earlier version of this point: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20224961

SilasX··on US SEC preparing to scrap quarterly reporting requirement
Well, that's a whole area of active research, referred to as "info hazards":

https://www.lesswrong.com/w/information-hazards

SilasX··on How far back in time can you understand English?
Wiktionary doesn't mention it for either word, but it looks to be cognate with German schweigen, "to be silent":

https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/schweigen

SilasX··on British drivers over 70 to face eye tests every three years
AIUI, that's a misleading figure, because the elderly self-correct, in awareness of the greater difficulty, by driving a lot less, so the greater danger is masked in the per-unit-time accident rate.

So, in theory, policy could appropriately adjust for this dynamic by only requiring the test of over-70s driving more than X miles/year, but that adds hassle to enforcement.

SilasX··on xAI joins SpaceX
Whoa, I had to do a double-take on the Dorsey mention -- like, didn't he take the money and run while laughing at the folks that overpaid? But it seems he's retained a 2.4% ownership stake in Twitter/X, according to Wikipedia:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jack_Dorsey#Twitter

Still, don't make the mistake I did, which was to read the above comment to mean "he put more money in at the time of the buyout", since he was called an "investor in X".

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →