HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

SilasX

17,815 karma · joined December 6, 2011

blog: http://blog.tyrannyofthemouse.com

Github: http://github.com/SilasX/

email: sbarta@gmail.com

Location: Austin, TX (left the Bay Area August '18).

Studying infosec to make a new career out of it.

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/silasbarta; my proof: https://keybase.io/silasbarta/sigs/EIsQUp3Ln8z5fOgzWFj9alDI8Ci9Vl4JSgP5OZQcmjU ]

submissionscomments
SilasX··on Antirender: remove the glossy shine on architectural renderings
Reminds me of how the Statue of Liberty went from being brownish gold to green:

https://old.reddit.com/r/interestingasfuck/comments/u22v09/t...

SilasX··on There is no comfortable reading position
You can get prism glasses, which let you see at an angle (head forward = looking at your feet), which avoids neck strain in sitting or lying positions.
SilasX··on The URL shortener that makes your links look as suspicious as possible
This! I've run into very frustrating examples of legit sites doing that, for no defensible reason at all.

For example, the healthcare.gov emails. For links to that domain, they would still transform them with lnks.gd, even though:

1) The emails would be very long and flashy, so they're clearly not economizing on space.

2) The "shortened" URL was usually longer!

3) That domain doesn't let you go straight to the root and check where the transformed URL is going.

It's training users to do the very things that expose them to scammers!

SilasX··on So, you’ve hit an age gate. What now?
I wrote an April Fool's parody in 2021 that Google is going to get rid of authentication because they're following you around enough to know who you are anyway (modeling it after their No Captcha announcement[1]):

http://blog.tyrannyofthemouse.com/2021/04/leaked-google-init...

Edit:

>I think the truth is, they just want your face.

I just realized the parody also predicted that part (emphasis added):

>>In cases where our tracking cookies and other behavioral metrics can't confidently predict who someone is, we will prompt the user for additional information, increasing the number of security checkpoints to confirm who the user really is. For example, you might need to turn on your webcam or upload your operating system's recent logs to give a fuller picture.

[1] https://security.googleblog.com/2014/12/are-you-robot-introd...

SilasX··on Scott Adams has died
Not that your exactly guilty, but that comes close to the cringeworthy attitude of "haha, what a great troll! Those poor fools can't tell when he's being serious, so brilliant! Wait, wait, you touched my sacred cow? Well, now you're obviously toxic and I've discovered empathy."
SilasX··on Microsoft May Have Created the Slowest Windows in 25 Years with Windows 11
>The reason for this is that it's hard to hire native UI developers, but easy to hire web devs.

This ... has been very opposite of my experience:

1) I've seen websites turn into poor imitations of mobile apps that lose all the features of web UIs that I want: ability to open links in tabs, use of affordances to scroll up and down, dense packing of information, ability to edit the size, etc. (Edit: almost forgot how they run the back button too!)

2) Generally, I see that the more UI specialists they have, the worse the UI gets. There's the saying, "developers are responsible for mediocre UIs, designers are responsible for horrible UIs".

SilasX··on Microsoft May Have Created the Slowest Windows in 25 Years with Windows 11
So, you're just screwed if you need a working editor in safe mode now?
SilasX··on Using fewer syllables to express numbers
Thanks for the second confirmation.
SilasX··on Microsoft May Have Created the Slowest Windows in 25 Years with Windows 11
This. It was infuriating to find Notepad got updated to a bloated app with rich text and Copilot. It's so different, it just should have been another program. The whole reason I use Notepad is because it's a simple, dumb, fast, predictable program. If I wanted the rich text, I would use any of the numerous other options!

And for the kicker, the update made it forget my font settings.

SilasX··on Using fewer syllables to express numbers
The whole point is that you don't need to get anyone to consciously follow any proposal, you just push common usage in the direction of saying "sen" to the point that it becomes correct, and you can take action now to assist it, without having to coordinate, and without breaking your existing communication.

With respect, your comments read as ignoring all the points I brought up in in order to show off knowledge you're proud to have.

SilasX··on Using fewer syllables to express numbers
That runs into the issue I was talking about in the proposal, where it's not backward-compatible and requires people to be informed of and sympathetic to the renaming. "Sen" will already be accepted as referring to 7, without such coordination, so long as it has enough context to be parsed as a number.
SilasX··on Using fewer syllables to express numbers
Omg! I had just been thinking about this and had written up a proposal but hadn't published it. We could organically make common usage accept a single-syllable 7. Here's the writeup:

MAKE 7 MONOSYLLABIC

There is a lot of research that, in languages where the numbers have more syllables, native speakers have a harder time remembering sequences of numbers, because your brain has to store the cognitive load of saying it. So native Chinese speakers are much better at it than Spanish.

English is fortunate in in that all the digits are one syllable ... except for seven. If we could fix that, then we could cause a massive amount of good, when summed over all the times people have to remember numbers.

The good news is that we can promote this in a backward-compatible way, without having to coordinate in advance. Just commit to pronouncing 7 as "sen" (pretend you clipped the word as se--n), and eventually it will be the accepted pronunciation and codified as standard. As long as the listener is expecting a number there, they will automatically fill in the missing sounds and parse it as a 7.

Try it out some time! "Oh, there weren't very many, just six or sen."

Who's with me?

SilasX··on Stranger Things creator says turn off “garbage” settings
Probably not, or they don't go by it, since there seems to be a massive problem with people being unable to hear dialogue well enough to not need subtitles.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37218711

It was a real eye(ear?)-opener to watch Seinfeld on Netflix and suddenly have no problem understanding what they're saying. They solved the problem before, they just ... unsolved it.

SilasX··on New York to require social media platforms to display mental health warnings
Late edit: looks like you had already mentioned the link being dead, sorry.
SilasX··on New York to require social media platforms to display mental health warnings
Was that because of Prop 65, though? The day-to-day effect seems to be alert fatigue and people ignoring the warnings because they're everywhere.

I read the links to find the proposed mechanism (NIH link is dead btw), and it says that businesses pre-emptively reformulated to avoid having the label, but the LA Times story also says this is a mixed bag, often resulting in a switch to less-tested, possibly unsafe substitutes simply because they weren't on the list.

>>But swapping one chemical for an unlisted substitute has sometimes resulted in its own consequences.

>>For example, when bisphenol A, an ingredient in plastics, was listed in 2013, chemical concentrations in blood and urine samples subsequently fell by 15%. However, that was followed by a 20% rise in bisphenol S — a closely related chemical also linked with reproductive toxicity.

SilasX··on NYC phone ban reveals some students can't read clocks
>Having discrete jumps on a mechanical analog clock is not a particularly hard problem.

I meant at the creation of the first clocks.

>For that matter getting a purely digital display out of a mechanical clock is not diffucult either either.

I don't know where I implied otherwise.

SilasX··on Rob Pike goes nuclear over GenAI
I mean ... there's a continuous scale of how much effort you spend to express gratitude. You could ask the same question of "well why did you say 'thanks' instead of 'thank you' [instead of 'thank you very much', instead of 'I am humbled by your generosity', instead of some small favor done in return, instead of some large favor done in return]?"

You could also make the same criticism of e.g. an automated reply like "Thank you for your interest, we will reach out soon."

Not every thank you needs to be all-out. You can, of course, think more gratitude should have been expressed in any particular case, but there's nothing contradictory about capping it in any one instance.

SilasX··on NYC phone ban reveals some students can't read clocks
That's a good point. The hour hand moves continuously as an artifact of technical constraints on the original clocks -- which I think is a great example of achieving a balance between UI and technical feasibility -- but we don't technically need them to work that way anymore, and digital clocks work exactly like that.

With that said, it's not obvious that we should use the jump hour UI[1]. It's desirable to have the hour hand be close to 4 when it's close to 4 o'clock. Like the neighbor comment says, that prevents you from confusing 4:58 with ~4.

[1] See my "continuity heuristic": https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11687391

SilasX··on Some Epstein file redactions are being undone
Also the pedophile that tried to obscure his face in pictures with a swirl effect that they were able to reverse enough to identify him:

https://www.minnpost.com/politics-policy/2007/11/you-can-swi...

IIRC there was a Slashdot discussion about it that went "Oh yeah, obviously you need to black out the face entirely, or use a randomized Gaussian blur." "Yeah, or just not molest kids."

SilasX··on Some Epstein file redactions are being undone
This. Similar issue if you introduce someone to how you can "view source" and then edit (your view of) a website. They're like "omg haxors!"

True story: one time I used that technique to ask for a higher credit card limit than the options the website presented. Interestingly enough, they handled it gracefully by sending me a rejection for a higher amount and an acceptance for the maximum offered amount (the one I edited). And I didn't get arrested for hacking!

SilasX··on Japan to revise romanization rules for first time in 70 years
Did you read the second sentence of that paragraph? The same thing would happen with a legit adjective, like if the forum had been named "FinancialBets": "Guys, this is financial bets, not financial prudent hedges."
SilasX··on Japan to revise romanization rules for first time in 70 years
This. People act like it's a hyper-complicated rule that English speakers magically infer, when in reality, a) other languages do it, and b) it's a much simpler rule (that you've given) which someone overcomplicated.

As a counterexample (in line with your explanation), consider someone snarking on the WallStreetBets forum: "Come on, guys, this is supposed to be Wall Street bets, not Wall Street prudent hedges!" Adjective order changes because the intended significance changes. (Normally it would be "prudent Wall Street hedges".)

Side note: please don't nitpick about whether "Wall Street" is functionally an adjective here. The same thing would happen if the forum had been named "FinancialBets".

SilasX··on Is Mozilla trying hard to kill itself?
They...already do that? They stopped allowing unsigned addons, even if you allow them in about:config (a power-user feature). Even Chrome allows you to toggle the option to do that -- in a more user-friendly way! -- and actually honors it, so I don't think it's the massive security hole everyone claims.

Edit: My Hitler parody of when Firefox introduced this (almost 10 years ago now!): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=taGARf8K5J8

SilasX··on Overconsumption is a spiritual problem
But that's a false benefit. You don't want to stimulate the economy for the sake of it, you want to stimulate the economy to the extent that it satisfies genuine human wants. It would be better if that other person's salary came from doing so, not from Making Number Go Up.
SilasX··on Why are 38 percent of Stanford students saying they're disabled?
That's over the entire population, which includes the elderly. For the 18-34yo block, it's 8.3%, and you'd probably expect it even lower for ... well, the population that, to put it bluntly, succeeded in life enough to get into Stanford.

https://www.census.gov/library/visualizations/2024/comm/disa...

Edit: And to clarify, just to be fair, I can accept there are many things that would qualify as "a disability that the education system should care about" but which don't rise to the level of the hard binary classification of "disabled" that would show up in government stats. I'm just saying that the overall 25% figure isn't quite applicable here.

SilasX··on When 1+1+1 Equals 1
>there are other operations that aren’t quite involutions – “near-involutions”, one might call them2 – that nonetheless have the property that thrice is the same as once, four times is the same as twice, etc. ... Unlike mod-two arithmetic, which is about counting “zero, one, zero, one, zero, one, …,” the kind of counting that governs these operations goes “zero, one, two, one two, one two, …”

Interesting! Earlier I had a shower thought about "what would be an variant of idempotence?" That's where an operation has the same effect whether done one or many times.

One variant would be "has the same effect whether one two or many times". Another would be "can be in any one of two possible states after done one or many times" (as opposed to one possible state for idempotence). This looks like the latter!

SilasX··on Zohran Mamdani wins the New York mayoral race
I don’t see where I was disputing that point.
SilasX··on UPS plane crashes near Louisville airport
Yeah I was going to say, that sounds like a much more salient reason not to live near an airport than the possibility of that rare crash.
SilasX··on Zohran Mamdani wins the New York mayoral race
>As it is we have a system of private "insurance" that can't consider the risk level of those being insured. All that means is the companies charge everyone else more to subsidize the cost of those who are more at risk.

That's what social insurance/welfare systems do throughout the developed world -- make sure everyone's covered at some minimal level even if it wouldn't be profitable when evaluated individually; it's just using insurance companies as an arm of the state to pull it off.

If, as it seems, your only objection is to labeling it "insurance", that's not a substantive objection to the merit of the policy, only how it's marketed.

SilasX··on Robert Hooke's "Cyberpunk” Letter to Gottfried Leibniz
He was ahead of his time, definitely, and binary logic is one critical step in getting there, but we're a long way from having a formal language to represent all claims that would ever arise in human argumentation to the point that it's simply a matter of calculation to resolve them.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →