17,815 karma · joined December 6, 2011
Github: http://github.com/SilasX/
email: sbarta@gmail.com
Location: Austin, TX (left the Bay Area August '18).
Studying infosec to make a new career out of it.
[ my public key: https://keybase.io/silasbarta; my proof: https://keybase.io/silasbarta/sigs/EIsQUp3Ln8z5fOgzWFj9alDI8Ci9Vl4JSgP5OZQcmjU ]
Heh, I had a weird nightmare about that. I was typing on my laptop at a cafe, and someone came up to me and said, "Neat, you're going real old-school. I like it!" [because everyone had moved to AI voice transcription]
I was like, "But that's not a complete replacement, right? There are those times when you don't want to bother the people around you, or broadcast what you're writing."
And then there was a big reveal that AI had mastered lip-reading, so even in those cases, people would put their lips up to a camera and mouth out what they wanted to write.
Oh ... and I still can't customize my controls fully. (Add-ons only take effect after a page load.)
Had they actually kept their scope small and focused, they could have put the difference into an endowment that would let them give the middle finger to the Chromes of the world forever. Yet here we are.
One famous example is Anton Yelchin, who played Chekov in the new Star Trek movies. The new Jeep shifter design made it less obvious whether you put it in neutral or park, and so it rolled toward him when he got out and pinned him to death.
Then you do get information once you know someone always lies (and has a correct worldmodel) because you know to update the opposite direction. I don't know the impact on these puzzles.
This is in the vein of “we eliminated a massive category of accidental deaths? But… but then what about the organ waitlist?”
So there's an important point here: the benefit of energy efficiency improvements is not that it will get total energy usage down by itself (and thereby hit GHG targets), but rather, that it will reduce the total hit to consumption/utility that we experience when regulations disincentivize (GHG-emitting) energy usage.
In contrast, energy itself is very vulnerable to Jevons effects because there is always a marginal use of energy it can be applied to as more is freed up.
https://seekingalpha.com/news/4412466-mongodb-acquires-voyag...
I mean, why not just say the organ shortage is bad, without pointing the finger at the latest hip, hot button issue, out of all the possible life-savers?
Like, in what other context would you raise this concern about saving lives?
It's the same kind of dishonesty, picking out one hot-button source of pollution, apportioning out its health impact, and complaining about it alone.
[1] https://slate.com/technology/2016/12/self-driving-cars-will-...
So I used a SAT solver to find a combination of numbers, not using prohibited bytes, that add up to the number I really want.
https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/19K7SK1L49reoFgjEPKCF...
>Most personal finance math is basic arithmetic – the same arithmetic that most of our students currently struggle with. The hard part is everything else: impulse control, peer pressure, status anxiety, and the fundamental uncertainty of the future.
>Teaching teenagers about compound interest won’t help them resist the urge to keep up with their friends’ spending any more than teaching them about calories will stop them from eating junk food.
Still, you can at least separate out those skills as being independently worth teaching: how to figure out the impact on your budget, and the social dynamics driving your options.
What's even more confusing/frustrating is that, despite being developed with very elaborate, mature frameworks, they still lack basic UI accommodations, like making clickable elements detectable by add-ons, or allowing you to open up a detail view in a new tab.
I get if Joe Shmoe's cobbled-together app forgets some things, but why wouldn't stuff like that be rolled in as a default, with all the development hours applied to it?
Sure, but I was making that point in the context of a discussion that accepted the premise that we do want kids to be good at a practical skill (personal finance) and we want to know how to best adapt schools to achieve that.
> But the third element, "cultivation," is the one that people today most often overlook. It's the Roman word for tilling soil, which you do not because it makes plants grow (that's sowing seeds) but because it prepares the ground for plants to grow when you do sow them. There are some educational activities that do not have direct and immediate utility but do open up new capabilities that can lead to future utility. Learning geometric constructions, for example, may not have immediate practical utility, but it may prepare the mind for trigonometry.
It seems like you're agreeing with my point there, about the need to ground the knowledge in what it will be used for, and thus some meaningful criteria for whether you're doing it right, that you can reason able. See my paragraph about "When are we ever going to use this stuff?": yes, it would tremendously help to teach tilling soil with an eye for "which tillings will actually make the soil receptive for seeds?" because then it would make a ton more sense why they're telling you to do it one way vs another!
>Grade school art class never made anyone a Michelangelo or Monet, but learning to hold a brush or sculpt clay does promote fine motor skills that will enable one hold a pen later in education or maybe, with more practice, a scalpel in medical school.
And again, you're agreeing about the need for practical application of a skill (actually using the brush).
>Financial literacy for those who do not yet have wealth to manage, even if it doesn't seem practical in the moment, still opens up new capabilities to enable future growth.
No, the issue is that it won't -- unless it hooks into some meaningful understanding that prevents it from folding into "useless esoterica where you have to guess the correct answer and then forget about over time", that most education falls into the trap of.
It's vanishingly unlikely that any student who learns "personal finance", with no practical application, is going to retain it for the 5+ years until they'll actually need to use it. Learning doesn't work that way -- with, as you note, a few exceptions for unusually motivated students ... who would probably be able to learn it on their own when the time comes.
Ditto for the famous meme about "why don't schools teach something useful, like doing my taxes?" Because it would come across as an ungrounded, garbled mess that you'd forget by the time it was actually relevant.
So yes, I'd say that generally, education should work by grounding lessons in some kind of practical application. And indeed, like the other comments note, that's how it works for some of your other examples, like actually cooking something for home ec, or doing CPR on a dummy (which mimics most of the dynamics of the real thing, even if imperfectly).
I think there's a real human need being expressed by the common complaint, "When are we ever gonna use this stuff?" I'd phrase it as, "You're not grounding this material in a way that allows me to reason about it, and what's important vs isn't."
So, to the extent that we want to prepare students for "the real world" -- in particular, things like "doing your taxes" and "evaluating a car loan" -- I'd say the best way to address it would be by teaching the (meta-)skill of "learning an unknown domain". (Yes, "learning how to learn" ... but as an explicit skill, not one applied to material that is itself too artificial.) That's something you could apply to practical problems, even if they're not the same ones students will be solving later.
Applying this insight to the teaching of literary analysis: frame it as refuting an internet comment that doesn't understand that a song is a metaphor.
In fact, one thing that frustrates me about how the teach estimation in math is that they teach a useless version of it: you do something that takes about as long as calculating the exact value, except you add some rounding steps because you're told you can't give an exact answer. What you should instead do is give a timed test, which much more problems that usual, and only require approximate answers. Then you're forced to save time by rounding.
Late edit:
>Using the logic underpinning this article, the only things taught in school should be how to play video games, how to find the best parties and how to get laid; since those are the only things actually relevant to students at that stage of their life.
Yes, it does annoy me when the education system neglects the teaching of some skills that don't come naturally to some students, but not other skills.
That's just not true. While the conclusion may be correct (about it not being feasible), it's something that would depend on more that just this first-principles analysis. Remember, the goal is only that the output is "not atmospheric CO2". So that means it could be CO2 somewhere else, or some lower energy state of the carbon, or even a higher energy state that isn't as high as the fuel that was burned to produce it.
And while, again, those methods might not be feasible, it depends on much more than the (false) premise that the only way involves completely reversing whatever process was originally used to extract the energy.
The problem is that, as n goes to infinity, you're not using the same hash function -- you can't. So even if you can assumed that one hash function has constant time, the later ones you need as you scale up wouldn't be.
And I don't know why you think you need to bring up probability distribution properties -- I made clear by now that the above points apply even to the mythic perfect hash function.
>Hopefully I've explained it better. Different models of computation are a fundamental part of theoretical computer science, since of course,
And it's fine to use different models! It's not fine to silently switch between them in an ad hoc way, which is what's necessary to make the exceptions that get you O(1) lookup for hashtables. I have never seen anyone expect the relevant caveats when quizzing coders for the correct answer on that question. That makes this part of computer science more like memorization or stamp collecting than a genuine mathematical model from which you consistently derive answers.
No. If it look up big-O in a math book, it's not going to say anything about that. You can add assumptions on, but that's not big-O anymore, but something different. That's the point.
1) Welfare-enhancing
2) Politically-popular
3) Simple
Pick any two.
There are policies that meet all three ... but they've already been implemented, and no one debates them.