HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Smithalicious

2,086 karma · joined December 7, 2018

submissionscomments
Smithalicious··on Ask HN: How have you integrated LLMs in your development workflow?
Right now I'm working on my first large clojure codebase, so I do a lot of "what is the idiomatic way to do X?" questioning, pasting in small functions and asking if there's a good simplifying refactor etc. Before this I was writing a lot of numpy and doing a lot of math, so it was a lot of "there's what I want to calculate, how do I make numpy do that?".

I use Claude now that they've successfully made chatgpt too insufferable to use.

I haven't tried any of the special AI editors since I don't know if I would survive the traumatic injury of having emacs taken away from me.

Smithalicious··on I Am Tired of AI
Do people really view so much content of questionable provenance? I read a lot and look at a lot of art, but what I read and look at is usually shown to me by people I know, created by authors and artists with names and reputations. As a result I basically never see LLM-written text and only occasionally AI art, and when I see AI art at least it was carefully guided by a real person with an artistic vision still (the deep end of AI image generation involves complex tooling and a lot of work!) and is easily identified as such.

All this "slop apocalypse" the-end-is-neigh stuff strikes me as incredibly overblown, affecting mostly only "open web" mass social media platforms which were already 90% industrially produced slop for instrumental purposes anyways.

Smithalicious··on Judges rule Big Tech's free ride on Section 230 is over
Hurting kids, hurting kids, hurting kids -- but, of course, there is zero chance any of this makes it to the top 30 causes of child mortality. Much to complain about with big tech, but children hanging themselves is just an outlier.
Smithalicious··on Ask HN: Why Is Stack Overflow Fading Away?
Part of it is that SO wants to think of itself as some kind of long term knowledge base and is obsessed with the idea of pruning "duplicates", even though whether aqquestion is actually a duplicate and whether the original answer is actually still up to date requires deeply understanding the old question, the old answer, the new question, and what the answer to the new question would be.

A very large part of SO questions is "how to use this poorly documented library feature?" or "what is the idiomatic way to solve X problem?", and answers to these kinds of questions become stale and useless very fast. Even more frustratingly, if you have a question like this and an old answer does exist, there's a good chance that you wouldn't be able to tell if the old answer is applicable without further assistance.

Additionally, hardcore SO contributors and SO senior management are constantly at each other's throats, very stubborn about their own interests and often out of touch with and callous about the question-asker plebs' experience in different and conflicting ways.

For many, SO karma internet points are a CV item.

EDIT with some other points:

I feel like documention of libraries and such has often gotten a lot better. AI is actually really useful and can help solve a ton of problems in the space of things I don't know how to figure out myself by reading docs, but don't need to have an actual human expert look at my situation, which is most of the stuff that ends up on SO. Support chatrooms for libraries have gotten a lot more polite and accessible, with clearly marked streamlined paths for asking your questions and much less "hop into #foobar-support on irc so you can be told to RTFM".

There's a bunch of misaligned interests on something like SO:

- Upper management is running a business, cares about user metrics and actually making money;

- Actual question-answering follows a power law, with a handful of power users being responsible for most answers. Like I said, these people often consider this internet reputation as something important to their livelihood, plus your usual ego stuff;

- Question askers don't care about SO as a platform. They are working on some kind of project, run into some kind of blocking issue, and want to find a way to get that resolved ASAP so they can continue with what they were doing.

Smithalicious··on Why fans of nuclear are a problem today
Meanwhile China can keep building nuclear plants at breakneck pace no problem. It's the same playbook for decades -- first we block nuclear at every opportunity, then we set impossible standards that make it impossible to build, then we say it's "out of time" and "taking away energy from renewables".

For decades these people have been saying "sure, nuclear would've been great if we'd built it decades ago, but there's no time now!" -- at this rate, we'll see those exact same articles keep getting written in 2064.

Of course solar is great too -- I'm highly in favor of having a diverse set of energy sources. Solar has base load problems, nuclear needs fuel, etc -- many strategic benefits and downsides for both.

Smithalicious··on Why doesn't advice work?
I was going to object to number three, considering my spouse and I are both engineers, but to be honest, almost all the time I do just want him to "fix it".
Smithalicious··on Apple apologizes for iPad 'Crush' ad that 'missed the mark'
It's a great ad. 620 comments on hacker news, got me to watch it voluntarily even though I never see ads. Even got me to share it with someone else.

Ads don't exist to make you feel good, they exist to make you notice them.

Smithalicious··on 45% of people have 20 browser tabs open at a time
I generally have 200-500 tabs open at a time, appropriately sorted into groups and hierarchies using sidebery
Smithalicious··on EU-wide maximum limit of €10K for cash payments
A lot of people here say that it's very rare to spend this much money in cash for legitimate purposes as though that is some universal rule and not a cultural happenstance. I'm currently holidaying in Japan and here it is quite common to make large cash transactions and settle things in person with paper money that couldn't be settled easily that way in my home country of the Netherlands. I actually prefer the Japanese system, since digital transactions often fail; it was only a few days ago that I had to try two different credit cards and two different paypal accounts to make a payment for a flight go through, for instance. I really don't understand people who harp on about the reliability of the traditional finance system (also comes up a lot in discussions re: cryptocurrencies), since that is absolutely not my experience nor the experience of people I have personally spoken to.

This is just a side show to the real issue however, the issue of rights. Our rights are something that limits the power of the government, that protects us from the government. It is not immediately obvious that we should need rights - in well-functioning societies like the EU, the government is overall a benevolent entity, using its power to aid citizens and protect them from bad actors. We give power to the government because it is good to us, so from a first-order evaluation, limiting the government's power seems counterproductive. Yet we know from thousands of years of experience in statecraft that things do not pan out this way. Governments make mistakes. The whole of the government can be good while parts of it are bad. The government can be good at one time, and then turn bad at a later time. The government is often good to most people while being bad to some, and these people are often the marginalized and invisible.

Digital transaction afford the government (and other powerful actors in the system) two important powers: surveillance and the ability to freeze or confiscate assets. Especially the freezing of assets is devastating when done to individuals. And these things can and do happen illegitimately. Unethical mass surveillance and the freezing of assets of protestors, journalists and other political undesireables is not a theoretical possibility but a real reality. We are lucky that in the west this is mostly limited to canary-in-the-coalmine people on the margins, people whose speech is so extreme that few of us can find it in themselves to feel sympathy for them. But it doesn't take much democratic backsliding for things to get much worse. I think it's important for us all to really internalize the fact that politics does not always move in the direction of freedom and progress; things do regress, as recent history should have made more than clear to us all. We need backstops, ways for people to live lives at odds with the government. You can't live in modern society without being able to transact.

Make no mistake, by the way; these kinds of laws very much do lead to the end of cash. These kinds of laws (and laws in general, actually) tend to only get stronger, seldom weaker. Even just leaving this law on the books without doing anything else slowly squeezes the noose tighter. Ten thousand euros today are worth only about half as much as ten thousand euros thirty years ago. I am personally of the opinion that all laws should have an expiry date and all sums of currency in law should have automatic inflation adjustment, but that is a story for another time.

Smithalicious··on A mediocre Dutch artist cast 'the forger's spell' (2008)
When someone's crimes constitute fraud and doing business with nazis, sometimes two wrongs might make a right.
Smithalicious··on In some instances the fetus helps repair a ruptured amniotic sac
Are you not made of cells that follow biochemical processes? Where do the cells following biochemical processes end and your agentic self begin?
Smithalicious··on GIMP Turns 27
Are they the ones with a weird complex, or are you? Your post suggests that you feel like GIMP has something to prove much more than the four word throwaway line you're criticizing to me.
Smithalicious··on We are sorry to inform you that you are in a cult
This is a pointless article that baits the reader into thinking there is a point, as evidenced by the fact that you can read many comments here of people trying to extract meaning out of it and not find anything that is actually profound and not incredibly overwrought.
Smithalicious··on The erasure of women from online pregnancy literature
The point, I presume, is making money.
Smithalicious··on My ADHD founder toolbox
I'm gonna back you up here. My life is much better without the meds. I have no issues with people who do prefer being medicated, but as the comments to this show there's a weird non-acceptance of people who do not want to be medicated.

Being on meds destroyed my creativity and emotional life, gave me devastating crashes every day and made me feel like I had to fit my entire life into the 6-12 hours a day they were active. If my career required me to go back on meds I would choose a different career, and that is just fine. Structuring your life so that it fits your unmedicated, natural self is just fine. Taking medication if it truly makes you happier is also just fine. Don't judge.

Smithalicious··on Ask HN: Anyone go through Montessori education until age 12 (end of grade 6)?
It wasn't clear to me, either - there's an education system conventionally called "classical education" and it is not what you refer to when you use that term.
Smithalicious··on Sam Bankman-Fried and the geometry of conscience
Scott is incredibly smart but I have him down as very biased and take everything he writes that is not hard science with a huge grain of salt.
Smithalicious··on Tether's Troubles in November 2022
I've asked this before and every time it's been ignored and downvoted, but it's a genuine question that I do want answered, so I'll ask again: what does this mean? how does the US military guarantee the value of the dollar? It seems to me like the main capability of the military is killing people, and the definition of the "the dollar has value" is "people will accept dollars in exchange for goods and services". Is the military going to kill people who refuse to accept dollars as payment? What does the scenario where the military gets involved in this look like?

If this is somehow an offensive question or reads as trolling I would love to know, because I don't understand the statement and I don't understand why nobody is willing to answer me.

Smithalicious··on World population to reach 8B on 15 November 2022
I think current population levels are about right. It's not sustainable right now, but it can be made sustainable.
Smithalicious··on Ask HN: Devs with ADHD do you use specialized tooling?
I use org-mode a lot as well; I keep a "life.org" file that includes among other things a section called "heap" where I keep my general to-do list of discrete chores (e.g. "buy toilet paper", "email Joe about the foobar", "move pictures from my phone to my PC"), a section called "leads" where I put ideas worth looking into (e.g. "learn to use awk", project ideas), and a section called "dally planning" where I make a subsection each morning containing whatever things I plan on doing that day. All of this could be managed with a normal txt file as well, you don't need to adopt org-mode (though it's a joy to use).

I also do ~20 minutes of meditation each morning which is extremely helpful. Also very helpful are getting regular exercise - even just walking around for half an hour each day helps a lot if you're mostly sedentary - and taking frequent breaks.

Start slow! Phase productivity hacks in piecemeal over a long period of time. Start projects early and slowly and exploratory. Slow and steady wins the race.

Smithalicious··on We should measure well-being instead of failing to measure economic productivity
A causes B (first order)

B causes C (second order)

C causes D (third order)

Smithalicious··on Ask HN: How did you stop drinking?
Finding something else pleasurable to do instead helps me avoid my vices. A lot of the time wanting to get intoxicated is an excuse for taking a break or spoiling myself. Instead of buying alcohol, buy some other delicious drink or food - maybe cook something yourself or make some nice lemonade. Read a good book, watch a movie, go on a trip, catch up with a friend. Put in the effort to have more wholesome, meaningful fun instead of being lazy and going for what seems like the easy, low-effort pleasure you get from taking substances, eating junk food or doomscrolling. Make relaxation and fun times a priority and resolve to do them right. This works much better for me than grit and stoicism.
Smithalicious··on Toilet Meal
There is this odd phenomenon where social phenomena first identified in Japan are assumed to be characteristically or exclusively Japanese, to an extent that I don't see happen for other countries. I don't think eating meals in toilet stalls is particularly uncommon in the west among people who are bullied or stigmatized. Probably not as common as in Japan, as Japan has more of a "the nail that sticks out gets hammered down" culture, but not rare.

To be honest, I don't really feel like "toilet meal" is a distinct enough concept to have a Wikipedia page; I don't think there's much point in distinguishing between "toilet meal", "car meal", "under the stairs in a quiet corridor meal" &c

Smithalicious··on Study links omega-3s to improved brain structure, cognition at midlife
Care to elaborate?
Smithalicious··on Cairo: Alternative Windows Desktop
I'm on Linux but I have a similar setup, with no permanent UI elements at all - I have a script to show a notification with the time and remaining battery (on laptop) and so on that I run when I need to see that info. I use a tiling window manager, three monitors and heavy usage of workspaces.
Smithalicious··on Ask HN: New to having wealth, how to protect my assets?
Did you get the idea that I'm not happy in Europe? If you did, I'm not sure why, as I am quite happy here - I just don't feel comfortable having large amounts of money sitting around denominated in Euros, as the value of the Euro is rapidly depreciating.
Smithalicious··on An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to Redox OS
Absolutely tragic that the US government's war on anonymous transactions is getting in the way of FOSS receiving donations here. I presume the donations itself is an attempt to make a statement, and I applaud it. Make people feel the impact of this attempt of absolute financial control without hurting them. I hope the developer can get access to the funds in the end!
Smithalicious··on GPU mining no longer profitable after Ethereum merge
Prediction: this is not gonna lead to even close to the levels of cpu price drops that people expect, especially not for new GPUs.
Smithalicious··on It seems that the good times for online Minecraft play are over
I feel like this is pretty shitty. Me and my friends were playing minecraft before many of the children that supposedly need to be protected now were even born. I'm sure server owners will work around this, but I feel like the well is poisoned now, some amount of innocence has been lost. Hosting a minecraft server has always been administering your own little kingdom, it's where me and many others got our first experience self-hosting services. Now Microsoft is squarely inserting itself in what used to be a relationship directly between server admin and player.

Of course part of me also thinks that handing out the occasional game-wide permanent ban that can be quickly circumvented by buying another $25-or-whatever-it-was license is good business for a game that everybody already owns, but that's probably too cynical.

Smithalicious··on Blocking Kiwifarms
Is it? Attacking someone's livelihood is a very real and impactful form of aggression. Compared threats of violence there's more cases where it's warranted, yes, but I think I would personally rather be on the receiving end of threats of violence than of someone attempting to make me lose my job and become much harder to employ.

Of course actual violence is a different case altogether.

← PreviousPage 3 of 23Next →