HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Snargorf

368 karma · joined March 19, 2016

submissionscomments
Snargorf··on Warmest March in Global Recordkeeping
That's a narrow comment about a specific dataset, and is supported by evidence.
Snargorf··on Ex-Reddit exec launches 'Imzy,' a warmer, fuzzier Reddit
"Healthy, positive communities" is an oxymoron.

A healthy community has healthy and sometimes necessarily intense disagreement in its discourse (just as a healthy mind questions itself).

A "positive" community has no disagreement at all - or at least none that go deep enough to resolve really serious differences.

The only way to maintain a "positive" community the way they mean is to simply ban everyone with views outside a narrow opinion corridor. But whose opinions will define that allowed opinion corridor? From the euphemistically fuzzy language and focus on good emotions, I think I know.

Snargorf··on Warmest March in Global Recordkeeping
Wait, so to you, a statement affirming part of the carbon cycle is equivalent to "there is no such thing as climate change"?

Wow. Wow.

Snargorf··on Warmest March in Global Recordkeeping
Neither quote says or implies "there is no such thing as climate change".

In fact, the second one - "it is a theory that can never be disproven" makes it clear that he understands that climate change is constant and has always happened.

Snargorf··on Warmest March in Global Recordkeeping
Have Trump or Cruz ever used the word "hoax", or is that your reinterpretation of their position?

Have either one of them ever said that there is no such thing as climate change, as your statement seems to imply? Or, do they just question the details of how the evidence is presented and emphasized, the tradeoffs in the proposed responses, and the perverse incentives involved?

Snargorf··on India's Plan to Bring Digital Banking to 1.2B People
I take it this plan is going to be executed by the 2% of Indian programming graduates who are employable.
Snargorf··on Business in Africa: 1.2B opportunities
It's a shame the West abandoned Africa to the warlords and tribal supremacists.

Think of what Africans could've accomplished with consistent, basic decent governance from the top, over the last ~50 years. Hong Kong, anyone?

The road to hell is paved with good intentions. White guilt is a staggeringly destructive impulse. It makes me sad.

Snargorf··on What It’s Like to ‘Wake Up’ from Autism After Magnetic Stimulation
I find a lot of irony in this comment.
Snargorf··on The Swedish Number – Talk with a Random Swede
Who said anything about anyone 'caricaturing' people of Arabic origin? They spoke the language. That is not by itself a 'caricature'.

Moreover, blackface was done to be funny (you know, like an actual caricature). This is done to make a political point.

If it was Americans answering a phone line like this with an exaggerated Texas accent, you wouldn't bat an eye. That's how we know you're driven by white guilt.

Snargorf··on What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to other people?
If there was no other source of clothing, you'd be willing to spend crab money.

In fact, this was the case during the industrial revolution. A pair of pants would cost a full week's wages. This is why people back then owned like 2 to 4 outfits.

It's amazing how many people just can't comprehend how the world can realign so different things become 'normal'. Like, "nobody would ever pay that for clothes". What, you think they'd go naked if there was no alternative?

Snargorf··on What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to other people?
Compared to what they could make in another job, they make a lot wherever they are.

e.g. here it's hundreds per hour for a girl who would barely beat minimum wage otherwise.

$5 in South Asia is mostly mythical, but even where it would be true, that's a large multiple over what they could make otherwise.

Snargorf··on What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to other people?
>What you forget is that some jobs just cannot pay enough to make it worth for non-impoverished people.

Of course they can pay enough. Just not when there is competition from other farms using illegal immigrant labor.

You know as well as I that if all illegal immigrant labor simply disappeared, the American farming industry would not just shut down and leave everyone to starve. They'd pay as much as they needed to hire Americans, and consumers would pay as much as needed to sustain that.

Snargorf··on The Swedish Number – Talk with a Random Swede
Or maybe it's a form of harmless-but-pointed civil disobedience by people who don't want their society to merge with those of the Middle East.
Snargorf··on What if the problem of poverty is that it’s profitable to other people?
Sure they would. People will do almost any job, if they're paid enough.

This is why military contractors in war zones, Arctic crab fishermen, and prostitutes make a lot of money.

This is econ 101; supply and demand. You know it too. You're (presumably) not impoverished, but you'd work in diamond extraction or a clothing sweatshop, if you were paid enough.

Snargorf··on Should Living in an Apartment for 34 Years Give You the Right to Stay There?
No. Next question?
Snargorf··on Tantrums as Status Symbols (2005)
It's not just tantrums. It's a huge variety of status-reinforcing behaviours which symbolically or actually make the lower-status person uncomfortable in favour of the higher-status person.

Even something like having an entrepreneur stand and present in front of a group of seated money men. They sit in judgement of him, they are comfy and he stands, they relax and he works and struggles to please them.

Or, when bosses make weird symbolic work demands that don't actually make sense. Sometimes there's the idea that they're just looking out for the product and are wrong about something, but there's also often an element of 'I sense some disturbance in the status hierarchy so I'm going to make you do this task we both know is useless just because I say so to remind you that I can'.

Or 'I'm going to be unreasonable to demonstrate that I can'.

Or 'I'm not going to give this question the think-time it really needs; to demonstrate my superior value I'll save myself five minutes while costing you two days to remind everyone that I'm above you'.

A lot of this is subconscious. The people with the power don't always do it intentionally, thinking "I'm going to signal status today." It's just what feels good and intuitive to them, so they execute these status-signalling behaviours without conscious intent.

Snargorf··on Slack raises $200M at $3.8B valuation for business messaging
I believe you're being honest, but what about in two years? Four years? Six years? Anything can change in that time span, including your sales model.

Not that this is a dig against you or Asana; it's just that this is how the world works.

Snargorf··on The First Muslims in England
Indeed. In fact, basically all Muslim country north or west of Saudi Arabia were Christian for centuries before being conquered by Muslim invasions. Syria, Israel, Jordan, Egypt, Algeria, Morocco, Balkans, Turkey - all Christian before the armies of Islam came in 632-1683.

It's an interesting piece of history that not a lot of people realize.

That's why all these places have/had Christian communities. They're the leftover conquered people who were too stubborn to convert of leave under the abuse of their Muslim rulers. It's not like a bunch of Christians have ever immigrated into any Muslim country - lol!

Snargorf··on Make elites compete: Why the 1% earn so much and what to do about it
The analysis is broken by the focus on the top 1%. They should be looking at the top 0.1%, or smaller.

It's absurd to put together hedge fund managers making $30 million a year with the established doctor who works two blocks from your house making $250k. These are entirely different phenomena.

You can see it by the section where they realize, shockingly, that the most common workplace among the 1% is the doctor's office. Well, duh. That's what makes it so clear that the 1% is much too broad of a target.

When people (innumerately) rage against the 1%, they're not thinking of real estate agents and local doctors and lawyers and dentists and university or hospital administrators. But that's who the 1% is.

Snargorf··on I Love the U.N., but It Is Failing
You're so close to a breakthrough here.

If everything the UN does is self-serving bureaucratic garbage designed to maintain and expand the bureaucracy itself...

And the bureaucrats behind the IPCC gain authority and money when their reports are more alarmist...

And, every year, their reports become more alarmist...

And, every year, the IPCC bureaucrats gain authority and money...

Maybe... maybe the IPCC reports aren't a shining jewel of perfect Science that has somehow arisen from the bureaucratic cesspool of UN corruption?

Personally I find it pretty hard to believe that an organization that is so shot through with politics and corruption could somehow have one perfectly uncorrupted part. And, even more, that this part is one of its highest-status sub-bureaucracies. Something to consider, anyway.

Maybe the invariant in your argument shouldn't be an invariant. That's all I'm really saying. This article could refute your belief, rather than your belief refuting the article.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2