HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Solarsail

122 karma · joined August 29, 2013

Yet another space nut. Go by Solarspot on some other sites. http://solarspot.netlify.com/
submissionscomments
Solarsail··on The Future of Space Launch Is Near
All solid LV's haven't really been cheaper than liquids in the general case, the motors themselves tend to be quite expensive. Also, a single SRB is never sufficient, even with 0 payload a very large solid doesn't have the propellant-mass ratio to get even close to orbit. Something like Pegasus or (I think) Athena 1 were 3 stage designs. Being solid helps simplify the ground support infrastructure and launch pad, whose costs don't scale down well. With an all-solid, something like the Kodiak launch complex is feasible, an extremely simple assembly building + pad.
Solarsail··on Rosetta comet landing – live stream
I just worded it that way to point out they both have instruments on it. Sounded like what was important to point out. But yes, NASA has a couple instruments among the many ESA has on it, on an ESA mission.
Solarsail··on Rosetta comet landing – live stream
ESA has a few instruments mounted on Rosetta too. NASA's: http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/missions/microwave-instrument-for-th...

(Unless this was sarcasm)

Solarsail··on Half a decade with Go
Structural types, as opposed to nominal types?
Solarsail··on All Dressed Up for Mars and Nowhere to Go
I'm pretty sure that was Steve Squyres in the book Roving Mars, discussing Spirit and Opportunity. From memory, a heat shield can get you from escape velocity down to ~mach 3, and then supersonic parachutes can get you down to ~100mph. It's an issue because you've still got to slow down beyond that, but you can't just ignore atmospheric shielding like you could with the Moon (in response to iwwr)

I could be wrong about him saying that in Roving Mars (I can't exactly grep my paperback copy, and Google isn't helping), but I'm pretty sure it wasn't on the subject of Curiosity... I heard it in 2006 or 2007, while Curiosity was still called the Mars Science Laboratory.

Solarsail··on Police Use Department Wish List When Deciding Which Assets to Seize
Do people actually behave along these lines? Vast majority of people in most places live and die within the same region they were born in. Most people who move countries do so to follow jobs around or get new jobs. The number of people who select countries (that I've heard, at least) for political reasons is negligible. Tho I could see the argument in the extreme case. Cuba and Iraq don't exactly have sizable numbers of immigrants, with their fairly poor political reputations.
Solarsail··on “Did you mean?” Experience in Ruby
One of the early PL/1 compilers IBM wrote in the 60's did something akin to this. It was a 'premium' feature, available in one of the more expensive compilers. Where it detected any error or wrong looking code, it would correct it. There's a story floating around somewhere on the net of one guy trying to use it... (Which I can't find at the moment.)

The first time he tried to compile with it, he used a program of roughly "Hello from PL/1". When he ran it, he got a division by zero error, because his string had been turned into an arithmetic expression. With the 1 turned into an I, which was then an unitialized variable, which then defaulted to 0.

Solarsail··on Your language sucks
In the context of some other language being the origin of computing, and since the OP mentions Russian as fairly easy to work with... What if this had been Russian everywhere instead of English? If all of the terminology, POSIX, C and other language keywords had all been Russian, with the rest of the world (including English speakers) instead learning Russian as lingua franca? (Yes, deviating substantially from history for this) Would the outcome be roughly the same? Would it avoid those pitfalls of Japanese? Would it be mildly more / less convenient?
Solarsail··on All Children Are Supposed to Be Proficient. What Happened?
Only genetically unhelpable? I would sooner expect issues with teaching children who don't want to be taught than any actual ability to learn.
Solarsail··on Rhine – A Lisp on LLVM
(Sorry I didn't see your reply earlier)

Sounds like an interesting project. I didn't point ML to say that meta-languages generally or ML itself were useless. Rather, that ML is specialized in a way that wouldn't aid in writing things completely unrelated to compilers. (Tho I hadn't thought of using one in an expert system.) Say, writing relational databases, game AI's or GUI interfaces.

Solarsail··on Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling
Doesn't this assume that SpaceX will succeed at reducing launch costs? If you look at volume, I don't see what you're getting at here. Almost nobody except for maybe Ariane V is operating at capacity. Delta IV tried selling commercially for years, they've yet to have one sale. Torus (I) and Athena were never exactly booked full.

A point I believe Antonio Elias made a couple years ago (I quite him a lot...) was that the satellite market is currently quite inelastic. Both when Russian launchers became available to the west, and with cheap Chinese launchers hit the market, global launch rates didn't really increase. Clients just moved around, and pocketed the difference.

Solarsail··on Al-Jazari
Would that be a bad thing? Unless you're referring to the current 'golden age' ending, wouldn't it be a good thing if modern day achievements are still that well regarded 5 centuries from now?

(I suppose you could say that the current phase of western civilization falling, eventually, would be a bad thing. But isn't it inevitable that any single civilization will end, eventually?)

Solarsail··on Rhine – A Lisp on LLVM
ML? I believe the genesis of 'Meta Language' and 'Standard Meta Language' was language design being done by people who wrote nothing but experimental compilers. Not sure how often they were bootstrapping, but it would be a similar issue.
Solarsail··on Galileo satellites experience orbital injection anomaly on Soyuz launch
Oops... Edit 2, since I can't edit this anymore. R7 has not flown over 3500 flights in 60 years, it's flown ~1600 flights. 749 on the model retired in 2011. http://astronautix.com/lvs/soya511u.htm
Solarsail··on Galileo satellites experience orbital injection anomaly on Soyuz launch
Proton aside, Soyuz is singly the most reliable launch vehicle on the market, since the retirement of the US Shuttle and ULA Delta II. It has both the longest track record of anything out there, if you look at the entire R7 family, of over 3500 flights. It also has a success rate of over 98% over the past thirty years. The Delta II reached a similar ratio, but over only 140 flights. Also, the Soyuz is one of only three vehicles that Arianspace is able to launch from French Guiana.

Edit: I should probably note, Delta II isn't completely retired yet. So the two are sorta kinda still tied. I've been a Delta II fan for a while, but they're down to selling off stockpiled hardware. Prices kinda went through the roof with the GPS contract going to EELVs. It's a shame, since it's the end of a fairly good track record. But we still have Soyuz.

Solarsail··on Marijuana Law Mayhem Splits U.S. In Two as Travelers Get Busted
Odd that you would pick those two countries as your examples. Both are federations comprised of a number of separate sovereign governments. Or, for that matter, the United States of Mexico shares that trait of its name with America. (An actual counterexample would be France, a unitary state.)

The Constitution of Canada far more clearly lays out what is and is not the role of the Federal and Provincial governments than the US 10'th amendment does for states rights. Canadian provinces, then, are sovereign themselves (tho not independent). The federal government can't decide it doesn't like an Ontario law and block it any more than it could an American law.

The States of the United States then sound far less like united, sovereign states than the members of some federations without United in their names.

Solarsail··on Vancouver tech surges as U.S. immigration reform idles
Only if immigrants are merely settling empty land. As long as they want to start out as part of society, they'll need jobs, housing and regular infrastructure. My own region is growing nearly as fast as housing can be built. More than 50% of everyone in some cities like Toronto have been in the country for less than 5 years, at any given moment. (Often starting out there, and moving to other parts of Canada later. Still limited by the population capacity of Toronto)
Solarsail··on Firefly Space Systems
I'm not so sure the economics works so well for reusables. Flying a reuseable LV requires (as far as anybody's managed, we'll see with SpaceX) far more work than just fuel & go. Typically you'd need a lot of maintenance work and repairs between each flight, not to mention the added complexity to the vehicle required for recovery. That's largely why the Shuttle wound up pushing a billion per launch, instead of the $10 million initially targeted, or the $110 million marginal cost of a launch.
Solarsail··on Firefly Space Systems
Many people have suggested as much. The issue then is finding a large enough volume of customers / missions to make use of frequent flights. I've also heard (tho I don't have a link ready) that past 50 - 100 flights per year on a given vehicle, some more exotic methods of flight into orbit (that have been impractical to date) become cost effective compared to expendables. Not a few studies have suggested reusable chemical rockets are cheaper than expendables, if you can fit at least 50 flights a year on them. I once read that number as around 70 a year for the Shuttle (possibly from Antonio Elias, maybe someone else). If you can manage hundreds, some of the really nifty / whacky launch concepts might become viable, like cannon launch, laser launch etc. etc.

http://www.fourmilab.ch/documents/rocketaday.html

(I think Antonio Elias, on NSF made the argument that Kistler's now defunct K1 (COTS contract, along side SpaceX) rocket would have been viable at nearly the lowest possible launch rate for a reuseable, far sooner than the Shuttle.)

Solarsail··on Firefly Space Systems
For Oribital's Pegasus, about 25% (solid fuel) engines, and 25% support labour [1].

http://www.mitre.org/sites/default/files/pdf/kane_mls.pdf Page 7 (Rest of that paper is also an awesome read about the problem space. Although it was from relatively early in Falcon 1 development... Pegasus has gone from alone in its class, to having competition, back to being alone).

Solarsail··on MIT at center of political power play over campus fusion reactor
Maybe I'm being pessimistic, but those companies will go bust before they get any hardware off the ground. They won't want to spend $20 billion USD over a quarter of a century before making a dime in revenue. SpaceDev wanted to do that. Now they're a parts supplier.

(To be truly pessimistic...) Nor will NASA or any other governmental agency ever make use of asteroid resources. That'd be too useful. Instead they'll spend 400 years doing political stunts and in-space handshakes. In 400 years time, we'll all have uploaded ourselves into The Cloud and gone exploring simulated galaxies. The real moon will be empty, save for some smiley faces carved in it from Earth with lasers.

(To address the actual topic at hand, I think long-term research isn't getting done on either side.)

Solarsail··on HippyVM
From memory (I think one of the dev's comments on HHVM or Hippy a while back) Hippy started after HHVM was already underway. Hippy was mostly a proof of concept, to see if PyPy would be a viable strategy for a PHP runtime. HipHop was more so the logical followup to HipHop... I think being forked from the HipHop interpreter they were using for development.
Solarsail··on Opal: Ruby to JavaScript Compiler
Couldn't you translate source given the ability to translate behaviour? If some behaviour in language X can be simulated by a state machine in Y, then you could just emit said state machine as the translation of the behaviour, give its output to the next state machine, etc. And gradually build up the behaviour of a program in X, but using a bunch of generated code in Y instead of just an interpreter. In other terms, if an interpreter for / simulation of X may be expressed in Y, then for each bytecode / AST node in X you could just inline the bytecode handling you would use in Y into the compiled output.
Solarsail··on Tail Calls, Optimization, and ES6
Well, Java does have TCO already, just depending on the JVM you're using. J9 supports it, just not HotSpot.

http://stackmonthly.com/2010/9/tail-call-optimization

Solarsail··on Protecting Net Neutrality and the Open Internet
Metering is used in Canada. Many have criticized the policy as backwards, unfair, and hampering creativity compared to other countries. http://www.theglobeandmail.com/technology/tech-news/a-metere...

Tho I do agree that, at a first glance, it seems to have extremely good correlation with the cost of the service provided.

Solarsail··on Why Python is Slow: Looking Under the Hood
Notably, tho, Both SBCL and Clojure have optional types. So the number of indirections necessary is already substantially reduced, as per the GP. For this to be the case in practice, tho, requires that type annotations actually be commonly used in both lisps.

A more interesting counter example would be LuaJIT, since it has to support completely dynamic code with a fair bit of monkey patching going on. But that is more of a showcase for tracing JITs being fairly powerful (for hard to predict code bases) than that indirections are cheap.

Solarsail··on Why Python is Slow: Looking Under the Hood
Apologies if you've already read this, but this paper was absolutely enlightening for me on what a more performant Python would look like: http://julialang.org/images/julia-dynamic-2012-tr.pdf especially section 2 on language design, which discusses how it's actually different.

(And yes, I know I'm just adding to the people plugging Julia here) Among other things, Julia actually avoids forms of dynamism that are in practice rarely employed by programs in dynamic languages. Existing code is immutable, but new code may always be generated if different behaviour is desired.

I'm not entirely sure if I could accurately say Julia allows one to trade between efficiency and dynamism when each is desired, but it does appear to be a much better balanced approach than is normal.

Solarsail··on A new book compiles knowledge necessary for society to recover after disaster
If it's literal bits etched into stone, wouldn't it still be digital (the way sections of a disk platter having a particular polarity is digital)? Analog would be etching the resultant data in graphical form into the rock. I'm not sure what to call ASCII art carved into rock, tho.
Solarsail··on ‘~’ is being removed from Rust
French Canadian keyboards are fairly different from European French keyboards:

French Canadian: http://www3.uakron.edu/modlang/french/images/kbd4.gif

European French: http://www.fentek-ind.com/images/frenchkeytop.gif

Solarsail··on The JavaScript Problem
Aren't these two equivalent statements? Liberty to do any particular thing, ever, increases the ability to do something wrong. And so requires more caution. That doesn't stop restrictions that would alleviate said caution from being overbearing themselves. (Maybe they aren't always overbearing, either way...)
← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →