HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

SoylentOrange

560 karma · joined September 20, 2016

University of Toronto alum ex-IBM, Yelp, Symantec

Current startup founder / CTO

submissionscomments
SoylentOrange··on Social Cooling (2017)
I wonder how historically true it is that people had an ability to voice unpopular opinions without social consequence.

My parents are from the Soviet Union, so that example comes to mind most readily. Obviously speech was heavily restricted and policed in that time and place; a relative was briefly thrown in jail for handing out pro-democracy leaflets in the late 80s. My wife's family is from China, another country with a history of policing speech. There is a wonderful book called "The Cowshed: Memories of the Chinese Cultural Revolution" which talks about the negative consequences of seemingly innocuous speech during the Cultural Revolution.

Lest people think I only have examples from overseas, when I was growing up here, I found that criticizing religion, even lightly, was problematic. Organized religion was something of a sacred cow until perhaps the early 2000s. I have gay friends, and coming to their support in the late 90s and early 2000s was difficult, with the majority of opposition coming from the religious community.

After 2001, criticizing the war on terror lead many public figures to be deplatformed (or canceled in modern terms). An example of this is the MSNBC host Phil Donahue [1]. Some of you may be old enough to remember the "support the troops not the war" slogan to try to get around these issues, with mixed success.

Maybe folks who are older than me can compare the attitudes now with other historical periods, but I don’t believe it’s more difficult now to vocalize an unpopular opinion than it used to be.

[1]: https://www.democracynow.org/2013/3/21/phil_donahue_on_his_2...

SoylentOrange··on Older people have become younger
FTA: longer education, better nutrition, and access to better healthcare and hygiene
SoylentOrange··on Microsoft's underwater data centre resurfaces after two years
A friend of mine wrote a paper on the effects of cosmic rays on memory errors in data centers a few years ago[1]. He also posited they had effects on hard drive reliability.

The first thing I thought of when reading this article is whether the increased shielding from the water reduced the impact of cosmic rays on the hardware.

[1]: https://www.cs.toronto.edu/~bianca/papers/ASPLOS2012.pdf

SoylentOrange··on How Big Oil Misled the Public into Believing Plastic Would Be Recycled
Question: I’ve previously read that recycling is economically viable in some EU countries (Germany, Austria, Netherlands). Some countries like Finland have figured out ways to recycle components that go into landfills in the US. How did they manage to do this?

Was it through regulation on the type of plastics that are sold to consumers? Was it through government subsidies? Through a better sorting process? Something else?

SoylentOrange··on Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index
This is very interesting. However, it doesn't appear this rule is applied consistently as Facebook is in the S&P500 and is probably the most infamous example of a multi-class share structure.
SoylentOrange··on What Satoshi Did Not Know (2015) [pdf]
This is a great read and obviously Gavin has thought a lot about some of the deep problems in Bitcoin, especially from the crypto side.

I was a bit disappointed to see that he punted* on one of the more well-known “shallow” problems: the energy consumption of Bitcoin mining, and the wasted computing power therein. The problem is much easier to understand than to solve, and I appreciate there is only so much room in the text. However I did hope he might at least acknowledge that this is among the more important technical hurdles for Bitcoin to overcome.

[*] there is a rather cheeky dismissal of Proof of Stake which obliquely addresses this issue

SoylentOrange··on Modeling a Wealth Tax
I would like to raise a different point from the many valid points already raised in this thread.

I understand this might depend on the definition of “wealth tax”, but if the founder uses the money they make in their 20s to, for example, buy a home; buy cars and other assets; invest in another company; give the money to charity... then the money remains largely intact. It is only by hoarding the wealth for 60 years that a founder would lose ~45%.

This doesn’t seem unreasonable, as people respond to incentives and will try to avoid the bad outcome by being proactive. This is akin to saying “if I have less than $1000 in my bank account, the bank will charge me a $5 fee each month. Then after just 16 years, all the money will be gone.” This is technically true, but no rational actor would actually just keep their money in the bank under these circumstances.

SoylentOrange··on I made an app that lets you split a file into horcruxes
Then what happens if one child who knows they won’t get anything, refuses to provide their piece?

BTW K of N cryptography is well known as Shamir’s Secret Sharing.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shamir%27s_Secret_Sharing

SoylentOrange··on Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing
The problem (among other things) is hyper-targeting of people who are specifically vulnerable to extreme points of view. One of my friends is an expert in tracking ads on Facebook and has found that white nationalists micro-target people who are susceptible to that ideology [1].

Similarly, they have refused to fact-check (not remove) climate science denialism, because they consider it opinion and thus exempt from their fact-checking process. [2] As you know, because of a lack of consensus on climate change, little action has been taken, causing an existential threat to everyone including yourself.

Facebook is accused of spreading “fake news” because they are in fact spreading debunked or misleading stories to a large number of their readers, who have the mistaken assumption that Facebook would prevent incorrect stories from circulating on their platform. They are accused of spreading “hate” because Facebook has long been a breeding-ground for white nationalism, the consequences of which are evident for all to see.

I applaud you for being smart and above influence, but you’re ignoring the very real effects of this policy, which have been extensively documented both in academia and in the press.

[1]: https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-46083026

[2]: https://www.wsj.com/articles/facebook-to-create-fact-checkin...

SoylentOrange··on Elevator.js – A “back to top” button that behaves like a real elevator
This is so pointless I absolutely love it
SoylentOrange··on Potential organized fraud in ACM/IEEE computer architecture conferences
One of my friends leads artifact evaluation for USENIX Sec. It's an emerging but I think valuable addition to the peer-review process in CS. There's been a growing movement, which I very much like, for improved reproducibility. Here's an example from NeurIPS: https://towardsdatascience.com/reproducible-machine-learning...

^ As you know, many areas of science have a reproducibility crisis including psychology and medicine. I hope this will go a long way towards addressing some weaknesses in peer review in CS. For myself, I try to be thorough when refereeing papers. Anecdotally I know some more busy academics farm out their reviews to their grad students.

I had a largely positive experience in grad school also thanks to my excellent advisor. Although I can say that my ~$25k/yr stipend made it difficult to live on without the additional scholarship money that I earned, and even then...

I agree with you that there absolutely needs to be more transparency in many aspects including complaints about advisors, and investigations into dishonest publishing behaviour like in this case.

SoylentOrange··on Potential organized fraud in ACM/IEEE computer architecture conferences
There’s a lot of room for improvement:

- grad student stipends are negligently low, making it difficult for students to complete their PhDs.

- many journals in CS are not open access despite the authors and reviewers not being compensated for their time. I think pre-print servers and the ability to publish work on your own website has really improved the state of CS research over the past 5 years. In the past, the official policies of many top conferences stated that a paper would not appear in the proceedings if it had been published to your website or a pre-print server. This policy has now been dropped (or is not being enforced) by almost all top CS conferences.

- it can be difficult to resolve a conflict with your advisor especially if they have tenure. Tenured professors enjoy significant faculty protection (though maybe not to the same degree as police). Often the most productive avenue for a student in this case is to quietly switch advisors. This can lead to entrenchment of toxic faculty. At my alma mater I can think of a professor who was notorious for having none of their students graduate - they all either left academia or switched advisors

It’s certainly an imperfect system and I’m sure folks can point out other flaws in the comments. There is a lot of room for reform in these and other areas. For example the lack of transparency in this case makes the entire academic community look bad for no good reason.

However I do think that folks on HN (on average) have an overly negative view of academia, some of which may not be based on an accurate understanding of its good parts. For example peer review, despite its many flaws, turns out to be very valuable. During the COVID-19 pandemic, a lot of spurious science has been published in pre-print form and on Medium, only to then be rebutted and rejected by scientific venues with a robust peer-review process.

SoylentOrange··on Potential organized fraud in ACM/IEEE computer architecture conferences
It has been confirmed that the reviewing system in question is HotCRP, which is a very battle-tested system that is unlikely to have these issues.

There is a comment from Eddie Kohler on Twitter which implies this was not a leaky endpoint problem. You can see this thread for more details: https://twitter.com/xexd/status/1222659612857401344?s=20

SoylentOrange··on Potential organized fraud in ACM/IEEE computer architecture conferences
This comment is not very helpful. Many scientists are doing their best to improve the world by publishing their research to the public. They are doing so, at least in CS, at a substantial pay cut compared to industry.

You can see the efficacy of modern science by the real and impactful discoveries in machine learning and related fields made over the last 10-15 years.

SoylentOrange··on Potential organized fraud in ACM/IEEE computer architecture conferences
Can you please explain?

In CS conferences there is generally a small pool of reviewers for a paper in a given sub-area (ex at a conference on systems some people might focus on file systems). These reviewers tend to review each others’ papers since to be a reviewer you also must be an active contributor.

I don’t see how any algorithm might detect this pattern of fraud without taking into account the merit of the papers.

SoylentOrange··on Potential organized fraud in ACM/IEEE computer architecture conferences
I have reviewed papers for these types of (but not this) conferences. It would be staggeringly abnormal.

For example, people almost never relinquish authorship credit.

SoylentOrange··on Potential organized fraud in ACM/IEEE computer architecture conferences
I believe the author of this comment is referring to industry conferences. Please note these are very different from peer-reviewed academic conferences.

In CS these academic conferences are held in many different locations, and many (most?) top researchers are not on Twitter.

SoylentOrange··on Show HN: Python package to collect normalized news from almost any website
I used to watch some of these IQ debates in college, they can be really good.

The longer format and strong moderation really lend themselves to interesting discussions, and you can learn a lot. One of my favourite debates of this format (though not IQ) is Peter Thiel vs Eric Schmidt (then executive chairman of Google) arguing about whether Google was still capable of innovation [2012]:

https://youtu.be/PsXFwy6gG_4

SoylentOrange··on Show HN: Python package to collect normalized news from almost any website
I don’t live in the US, so please take what I’m saying with a grain of salt. I imagine you are a smart and decent person on the other side of this screen.

Usually print media is considered higher quality journalism than TV media. There are numerous studies that show reading print media leads to people being more informed than just watching TV news. Whether this is correlation or causation I can’t really say.

My understanding of both Fox and MSNBC is they are entertainment programs, not so much news programs. I’m not sure it’s fair to compare those to anything in print, nor do I think it’s entirely possible.

A good news article might present both sides of a story, but try to fact-check claims by both sides, and bring in supporting evidence. That’s the key differentiating factor of quality journalism - helping bring facts to the forefront rather than let people on either side spin the facts for their purposes.

SoylentOrange··on Show HN: Python package to collect normalized news from almost any website
It’s not about presenting an opinion, it’s about moderating a debate with facts to inform the public.

A journalist’s job is to try to present the truth, not create false equivalence.

SoylentOrange··on Show HN: Python package to collect normalized news from almost any website
When I was a kid CNN used to do this: they would invite a single climate scientist and a single climate change skeptic and have them make their points on equal time. CNN would then say “who’s right? You decide.” And the program would end.

This was extremely harmful to the overall mission of informing people and created a false balance between sides which are not equally valid. Today, this is almost universally seen as a failure of journalism.

Given the lessons learned, I wouldn’t be so quick to replicate that experience with a website.

SoylentOrange··on Ask HN: Is your company sticking to on-premise servers? Why?
We are a research group at a company with 2000 or so employees. We have a few GPU machines to train models, which are utilized nearly around the clock.

AWS and co’s GPU-enabled servers are exceedingly expensive. Most of the GPU models on those machines are also very old. We pay maybe 1/3 or less to maintain these machines and train models in-house vs paying AWS.

Mind you, we use AWS for plenty of stuff...

SoylentOrange··on New York Governor announces 100% workforce reduction for non-essential services
Quote from NYTimes:

> For days, Mayor Bill de Blasio of New York City has pushed for a “shelter in place” order and the governor has repeatedly dismissed the idea, saying he would not quarantine New Yorkers in their homes.

He also spoke on a popular podcast earlier this week about DEFINITELY NOT taking this kind of action

SoylentOrange··on New York Governor announces 100% workforce reduction for non-essential services
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/20/nyregion/coronavirus-new-...
SoylentOrange··on A new Go API for Protocol Buffers
Can you explain why it's not possible to create `google.golang.org/protobuf@v1` retroactively?

Also:

> In ten years, hopefully nobody cares about the old github.com/golang/protobuf and the confusion is gone.

is the corollary that this change will cause 10 years of confusion?

SoylentOrange··on What people in tech had to say about JavaScript when it debuted in 1995 (2017)
The article conflates “popular” with “loved”. JS is popular because it’s the only* language in which it’s possible to write browser apps and extensions. The number of people using transpilers for this purpose is minimal.

In actual fact, most people try to avoid JS whenever possible, instead using TS or other languages that compile down to JS.

Saying people love JavaScript because it’s the most popular is like saying people love McDonald’s because it sells the most burgers

[*] since we don’t have Java applets or Flash apps anymore. Writing in other languages still means transpiling to JS in the end

SoylentOrange··on Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study
To combat some of the anxiety I had about people looking over my shoulder at my monitors, I bought a privacy filter for one of my screens.

It has really improved my personal feeling of being watched.

SoylentOrange··on Office noise bothers some people more than others
During my first internship when I was 20, I worked for a summer at a medium-sized packaging company to improve their aging order-handling software. Because the floor managers were on the warehouse floor almost the entire day, I took over one of their offices. That summer, I had my own office and it was incredible.

Since then, I have worked in cubicles or desks in open-plan offices.

Now, almost 10 years later, as a (small) team lead at a relatively prestigious company, I realize that I may never have my own office again in my professional career. This thought is oddly depressing.

When I really need to concentrate on a task, I take a portion of the morning and do the task at home, in my home office. I am very aware this is not something most people can do (both because I have the authority to just not come in on a given morning, and because I can afford to have a home office in my own home which is mostly silent). Many on my team do the same thing, possibly accepting that the office is a fundamentally distracting environment. I worry what effects this may have on younger team members who don't have access to a home office.

I do see the benefits of open-plan offices (for one, being at work feels less alienating), but I think we may have lost something important in the transition.

SoylentOrange··on New Hampshire Lawmaker Kills Repair Bill Because 'Cellphones Are Throwaways'
I strongly disagree. I think it would be hard to articulate why an iPhone 6s (released in 2014) which is the phone my partner has, is not usable today.

Many of my friends have phones that are currently 2-3 years old, and they work just fine.

I assume this has to do with relative income: either $1000 per year is a lot of money for you, or it’s not.

SoylentOrange··on Travel without a phone
I travel (for pleasure) a lot with my wife. I want to talk about phone uses besides the camera (which I think others in this thread have covered extensively). We have a DSLR camera, and those photos IMO are much better than what phones could take at the time.

First, when we were in Japan having a phone was invaluable for transit. We used a few apps to keep track of where each attraction was relative to the subway stops and bus routes. Otherwise we would have had to carry and constantly pull out 3-5 maps.

Second, my wife likes to sleep in and I don’t. So I’ll wander the area around the hotel in the mornings, and she texts me when she’s up so we can have breakfast together.

Third, in China it was basically impossible to get a taxi the “normal” way - everyone was using local ride hailing or taxi apps. In other countries like Vietnam, using the local apps is part of experiencing the culture (we ordered takeout on Dash, and took a ride on the back of a scooter).

Finally, I carried a kindle version of two guide books. I would not have been able to do that without my phone. They were invaluable for making backup plans (ex something was closed, or we finished somewhere early and what do we do now).

There always has to be a balance - being on your phone all the time is unhealthy. But leaving the phone behind can also make it hard to function in the modern world.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →