HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

SoylentOrange

560 karma · joined September 20, 2016

University of Toronto alum ex-IBM, Yelp, Symantec

Current startup founder / CTO

submissionscomments
SoylentOrange··on Anti-intellectualism in American Life
You are 100% right.

However I was trying to respond to the parent commenter’s point about mediocrity. I was trying to craft a simple metric which would speak to mediocrity. It’s an imperfect metric for sure.

SoylentOrange··on Anti-intellectualism in American Life
I’m not sure this is accurate, if attempting to compare US political figures with those of other countries. I don’t know if there is hard data on this, but I would bet the US Congress has proportionally just as many graduates of top universities as any other legislative body in the world.

If anyone wants to crunch the numbers, I would be excited to see the percentage of US Congresspeople with serious educational attainments vs Japanese, French, German, Canadian, or any other similar body.

SoylentOrange··on Ask HN: How Do You Read?
Sorry OP to hijack your thread

I skimmed through the comments and folks have said they read slowly, but also say they average about a book a week. Is that really true? How many books would you say you finish on average per year?

I read quite quickly but I average about a book every 2 weeks because of other commitments (consistently ~25 per year)

SoylentOrange··on The Paxos Algorithm, or How to Win a Turing Award
My advisor’s advisor worked with Lamport, and my advisor’s thesis was in distributed consensus in file systems. My advisor worked heavily on a lot of the Paxos follow up work. He told me that Paxos is actually so complicated that only Lamport really understands it.

He said that after the original paper came out, everyone was trying to simplify it, but no one was successful. He said almost any implementation he saw (in those early years) contained serious errors.

It’s a truly remarkable thing.

SoylentOrange··on Cryptic, allusive messages from Hong Kong's wealthiest tycoon
To the Chinese native speakers here on HN: how clear would the message have been to you, if you didn’t read the explanation on this website?
SoylentOrange··on Cryptic, allusive messages from Hong Kong's wealthiest tycoon
I’ve heard it in at least one other context: to mean “inheritor” or anointed successor. Here is a quote from Gore Vidal:

‘I have been asked whether I wish to nominate a successor, an inheritor, a dauphin or delfino. I have decided to name Christopher Hitchens.'

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/books/9443914/How-Christ...

I’ve seen other examples in this style. Maybe folks in comments can point out more.

SoylentOrange··on India Shut Down Kashmir’s Internet Access
While I understand where you’re coming from, I don’t agree with this sentiment.

Imagine saying this about electricity or gasoline. Modern cities would be completely shut down without these resources, and we should treat the Internet in the same way - as a vital resource that we simply accept as present except in the most egregious or catastrophic circumstances.

SoylentOrange··on Is Google evil? (2017)
I’m genuinely interested, can you provide a source for this?

My understanding of companies is they have always been exploitative. Any large company from the gilded age is a good example (now almost a century ago).

Further back, the companies of the industrial revolution were legendary for their amorality. Another example I’m familiar with is coal companies in Scotland before WWI.

SoylentOrange··on The Lonely Work of Moderating Hacker News
Big thanks to dang and sctb. You’re doing an impossible job, and doing it as well as two humans can. As others have said, this makes HN the best forum left on the Internet.

I want you to know your efforts aren’t wasted or invisible to me. I am very appreciative of the tough work you both do.

SoylentOrange··on Glass discs that can store 360TB and remain intact for billions of years (2016)
Thanks for the answer. Can the durability of the fused quartz be compared to the durability of this storage format though?

(from a more detailed article [1])

> The information encoding is realised in five dimensions: the size and orientation in addition to the three dimensional position of these nanostructures.

Is the idea that these nanostructures are themselves hyper-resilient? Or would a significant impact alter them so as to render them unreadable?

[1]: https://www.southampton.ac.uk/news/2016/02/5d-data-storage-u...

SoylentOrange··on Glass discs that can store 360TB and remain intact for billions of years (2016)
I have a question for anyone here who understands how this works: is the glass from the article resilient to physical shocks like falling/shaking/heat/other mechanical stress?

Documents that are meant to last a long time used to be written on vellum because it is a very physically durable material. I understand that this glass method beats existing digital storage methods for resilience, but does it best traditional analog/legacy techniques?

SoylentOrange··on The decline of the family has unleashed an epidemic of loneliness
I have a serious question for you, curious on your answer.

Can men “have it all”? Is “having it all” different for men than women?

My experience is that men are able to “have it all” often at the cost of their spouse making sacrifices to stay at home, with the implicit idea that this is the way things are meant to be.

If both people in a relationship try to “have it all”, some sacrifices do have to be made (speaking from experience), but I am not sad about these choices since trade offs are an inevitable part of life :)

SoylentOrange··on Moscow Publishes Photocopies of Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact, Secret Protocols
As someone who grew up in Russia and went to school in Russia in the 90s and early 2000s, this is not true.

I would be curious what your sources are, if any.

Just because there is limited freedom of the press in Russia doesn’t mean it’s a Stalinist dystopia.

SoylentOrange··on Show HN: Civilization 6 Timeline Visualizer
After trying to get better at Civ6 (Civilization 6, a turn-based strategy game), I found no good way to really analyze my games. Since I couldn't find anything, I built it myself. I present to you (tadadada) a Civ6 timeline visualizer.

https://boompig.github.io/civ6-timeline/

You can read more about how it works here: https://boompig.github.io/civ6-timeline/about.html

Here are some example games from my own playthroughs:

- https://boompig.github.io/civ6-timeline/?hash=1kVvkd7_w8Y_vU...

- https://boompig.github.io/civ6-timeline/?hash=cIxA-pgYSCbafu...

If you play GatheringStorm, let me know how it handles those files. I haven't played the new extension yet so I'm not sure.

SoylentOrange··on A Gentle Introduction to Attribute-Based Encryption
I'm the author and can answer any follow-on questions here.
SoylentOrange··on State of Python in 2018
I don’t know if it will, but I agree with the author of [1] that it should. Python should aim to be faster in its next iteration, as it is increasingly being used for long running computational tasks like science experiments. I would go further and argue for direct integration of numpy into the language to achieve faster performance.

I don’t have any inside track knowledge on plans for Py4.

EDIT: see PEP 523

[1]: https://hackernoon.com/4-things-i-want-to-see-in-python-4-0-...

SoylentOrange··on State of Python in 2018
I'm the author and I'm happy to answer any questions about this post.
SoylentOrange··on The peer review industry: implausible and outrageous
Open access, as is mentioned in the article, is both important and difficult to achieve. As a PhD student or associate professor, you work on a strict schedule to publish or perish. The only acceptable publication venues are the 4-6 respectable journals in your field. You have no time or power to push for open access.

Only large research institutions like (I’m familiar only with the CS research community) MSR, Google Research, Facebook Research, ... as well as already tenured professors can really force the issue.

I work at a smaller industrial research lab. We try to push for open access whenever we publish, but publishing in non open access journals is important to maintaining our perceived prestige, which in turn is important in hiring (especially when we poach from academia).

I publish pretty regularly and try to be selective, but ultimately the push has to come from an institutional level such as universities or large industrial research labs to say “we will only publish in open access journals”. This is especially true in the US where EU style legislation is a long way off.

SoylentOrange··on Ask HN: What open source project, in your opinion, has the highest code quality?
I like the design philosophy behind BoringSSL:

https://boringssl.googlesource.com/boringssl

If some portion of the library is overly complex, look into the use case and delete it wherever possible. It maintains a long-term bound on code complexity, which I quite like.

Edit: a nice explanation on the design philosophy here https://www.imperialviolet.org/2015/10/17/boringssl.html

SoylentOrange··on State of JavaScript 2018 Survey
Thanks for the suggestion. These sites are usually for quick and dirty prototypes within my company and won’t live very long. They usually have a little client side functionality because that’s what users expect.

I’ll definitely check out Vue.js

SoylentOrange··on State of JavaScript 2018 Survey
Great survey, very excited to see the results.

The option of complexity really spoke to me. If you’re building a small one-off website, then you want something short of a framework like React, but something more modern than Jquery (manage state, reactive style programming). What can you use?

I feel modern client side JavaScript assumes you’re working on a large, long lived site that you plan to maintain. There’s no equivalent of “I just want to create something quickly for use by about 100-1000 people for a few weeks”

SoylentOrange··on How IntelliFilter Enables Fast, In-Depth Analysis of Endpoint Activity
Disclaimer: I work with the author of this post. I can answer any questions about the technical content.
SoylentOrange··on Nation’s top three most expensive places for renters: all in Bay Area
The study talks about a 2-bedroom apartment on a single, minimum-wage income. There is no discussion of dual incomes or roommates. The idea is for a single family to live in the 2-bedroom
SoylentOrange··on Nation’s top three most expensive places for renters: all in Bay Area
I have two nitpicks with the study:

1. It uses a two-bedroom home as a baseline instead of a one-bedroom. While I understand that may be interesting for historical reasons, it's not a practical metric for modern considerations. If we want to talk about housing affordability, it's more honest to discuss one-bedroom apartments for single earners. We could also talk about two-bedroom apartments for dual-income earners.

2. The 30% pre-tax rent metric doesn't make sense to me at all. Why would that be invariant across income levels, and across states, given both graduated taxation and the vast differences in both income tax and sales tax across different states? In California, 30% pre-tax works might work out to more than 40-45% post-tax, depending on your income, and the remainder doesn't translate well to purchasing power given varying state sales taxes.

I'm not saying that affordable housing is not a problem, because it clearly is. Just that, to address the problem honestly, we need to use better metrics to figure out what a fair solution is.

SoylentOrange··on Massive Breach in Panera Bread
Hey, I work at Symantec Research Labs. If you still have not been able to get this looked at by someone from Denny's, I can probably have the right people take a look.

e-mail me at daniel_kats [at] symantec [dot] com

EDIT: please do not post your method publicly. That is a bad idea.

SoylentOrange··on Where are all the films about poor Americans?
Some recent examples:

- Florida project

- 3 billboards outside Ebbing Missouri

- La La Land (to a degree)

- Manchester by the Sea

- Straight Outta Compton

- Creed

2015 and more recent, set in the USA, nominated for awards at Oscars, protagonist is poor

SoylentOrange··on A Year of Tech Solidarity
I feel like tech workers are already highly engaged, just very selectively with the causes that matter to the tech world. A good example of this is EFF. EFF has a huge presence both in the community and at every industry event I've ever been to. Most tech people I know donate to them.

There is also the FSF, numerous hacker camps and conferences aimed at women (Grace Hopper Celebration, etc).

I'm very skeptical on the need for a broad coalition of tech professionals.

SoylentOrange··on Reasonable Person Principle
In Canada, a lot of law is based on the "Reasonable Person Test". See http://criminalnotebook.ca/index.php/Reasonable_Person_Test
SoylentOrange··on The Fantastic World of Professor Tolkien (1956)
This review is scarily wrong in its understanding of Tolkien's works. First, LotR does not refer to the One Ring, but to the master of the ring. Second, Balrogs are not "dreadful spirit of the underworld" but are Maia, basically corrupted angels. Third, Orcs are not "a new kind of goblin", but are tortured and enslaved elves. And they're not new; they've been around since the First Age. Fourth "Aragorn returns from the battle and by healing earns his place as King". No. That is not why he is the King, it just fulfills the prophecy. He is King because he was descended from Isildur, not because he has magic healing powers.

If you're going to review something, at least get the facts right.

← PreviousPage 4 of 4