HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

SpartanJ

210 karma · joined April 16, 2010

I'm a passionate software developer from Argentina. You can check my open source projects here: github.com/SpartanJ
submissionscomments
SpartanJ··on Debian developer prompted to revisit FreeBSD after 20 years
> And on Linux inotify is bound by /proc/sys/fs/inotify/max_user_watches. Six of one, half dozen the other. FreeBSD file descriptor limit is arbitrary and can be raised to INT_MAX (2 billion). That should be plenty.

Yes, on Linux you're limited to max_user_watches, and you can edit that value, just like you say with kqueue... but you need root access, so for end user applications this is not really a solution. With inotify i use one watch per-folder, with kqueue you need to do it by file ( of course you can watch the folder changes, but you need to keep a copy of the file states in that folder, and then re-stat that files to find out what file was changed, not even close to an ideal solution ). So for example in my use case with inotify i can watch 65536 folders, and with kqueue less than 10000 files ( that could be a single folder! ).

Edit: It seems that FreeBSD default a much bigger number for FDs ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9063893 ), so that should suffice a lot of use cases, that's good news for me!

SpartanJ··on Debian developer prompted to revisit FreeBSD after 20 years
This is true but not entirely accurate. The use case that he's mentioning, an application like Dropbox, that relies on a good file system watcher wouldn't be totally feasible with kqueue, since you're pretty much limited by the number of open file descriptors the OS allows to handle, if i don't remember wrong this number in FreeBSD is below 10000 by default, so it's limited for that use case. And that's also why OS X have FSEvents, because kqueue falls short for some use cases. I've worked on a multi-platform file system watcher ( https://bitbucket.org/SpartanJ/efsw ), and i must say that the kqueue implementation was by far the worst to work at. On the other side inotify is super simple and just works ( but sadly it's not recursive like FSEvents and IO Completion Ports ).
SpartanJ··on Existential Depression in Gifted Children
Yes, it's the same. Any "gifted children" can see also the "problems" in the belief system that they were raised, it's part of the conflict.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2