HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Spyckie

295 karma · joined January 27, 2008

A college student in the Information Systems department at CMU.
submissionscomments
Spyckie··on Ask YC: Best Micropayment Solution?
This is a good question and I don't think we should kill the discussion by downplaying his choice of words.

I've looked into micropayment models before - Amazon had by far the cheapest fees compared to paypal and google if you were dealing with anything for less than $5. This was around a year ago, though, so I don't know if there is anything better that has come up since.

Spyckie··on [dead]
yeah, and I was on the second-to-last page too... great story so far.
Spyckie··on Ask News.YC: How difficult is it to break out of prevailing paradigms of the present?
You bring up a good point. I don't think anyone had the vision that we would be socializing the way we do now on social sites like Facebook. Even Mark. Z probably didn't see it until it started taking off.

The question as I see it is, can we predict the trends of the future? This divides itself into 2 questions: 1) Do we have enough knowledge/creativity to see the next waves of the future, and 2) If we saw a thousand possibilities of what would happen in the future, would we be able to pick the right one?

A different way to see it is that you are the force affecting the future - can you push your design/plan/idea far enough to make it groundbreaking?

What is interesting to me is not answering these questions, but rather, asking -

What can I do to strengthen my ability to answer 'yes' to these questions?

Spyckie··on Rethinking Recommendation Engines
Interesting... even though accuracy is generally high, the false positives weigh heavily on the experience.

How accurate can we get recommendation systems anyways? I know my friends recommend movies to me all the time and a lot of them aren't my taste - do we expect computers to outperform our close acquaintances?

Spyckie··on 10 less-than-great personality traits of entrepreneurs
Its just the other side of the same coin...
Spyckie··on The Idea About Ideas
Great post, a bit too long.

Summary -

Ideas do not fall into just good or bad.

a) Dating Julia Roberts is a good idea, but its not feasible.

b) A free email address that has no password or registration is a good idea. (read the article if you're curious)

4 types of ideas:

a) "The obvious next" - ideas that follow logically from what's currently existing.

b) "Now we're ready" - ideas that have a certain technology or other requirement before its possible.

c) "infeasible" - ideas that are good but infeasible because technology/society/whatever is required not ready (its not a 'b' idea). Also ideas that have no money making business model fall into this category.

d) luminary ideas - ideas that are unique and original not just to the thinker, but to the rest of the world too. These are rare.

In short, work off of the 'b' and 'c' ideas, since technology is moving so fast. 'a' ideas are risky because you're competing with everyone else and a lot of luck/skill is required, and 'd' is out because lets face it, no one has them. 'c' ideas quickly become 'b' ideas -

"You merely have to act on them first. Given how fast our technology advances, it's a good idea to perpetually reconsider infeasible ideas every now and then. You never know when an infeasible idea might become feasible."

Spyckie··on Ask PG: Statistics
Its because you imply (intentionally or no) that everyone who believes that some form of content control should be implemented has intentions similar to the DOD, CIA, KGB, etc.

In retrospect, ultimate control of the site belongs to pg and if fluff does start flooding the site, he could just reincarnate the site elsewhere with a different policy backend. However, there's no harm in trying to do it right the first time. :)

Spyckie··on How about this idea to save Hacker News from fluff?
How about also changing the title and url of fluff links that have been taken over by intelligent conversation?

For instance, that "programming is like sex" http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=120816 article had good discussion in the comments and the title should have been changed to "what to do about fluff".

Spyckie··on How about this idea to save Hacker News from fluff?
Maybe we should focus on the underlying users that vote up fluff, and kindly inform them of the goals of ycnews community in content rather than focus on dealing with the fluff itself?
Spyckie··on How about this idea to save Hacker News from fluff?
heh, I recently built a naive bayes analyzer that decides whether a text is from reddit or from ycnews. The assumption was that Reddit-like comments/stories were fluff and not worth reading.
Spyckie··on How about this idea to save Hacker News from fluff?
"If certain posts become popular its because people want to read them." Why is reddit's content consistently horrible to the yc community? YC is not serving all people's needs in content - its serving a particular sector of users that expect knowledge/motivation from their content-browsing rather than humor/time-wasting.

Ycnews is figuring how much they should control because the fact is that if you don't have controls, the content and user base becomes like reddit. Also, the extreme degree of control that you suggest is so ridiculous that you're doing nothing but insulting a lot of hard work that people have done to find a good balance between being super-exclusive and open to everyone.

Spyckie··on Looking for feedback on our new startup. Built in 24 hours on top of tipjoy.
Credibility and visible user activity are the 2 things I think are needed the most as of now. You need to give users more voice other than tipping in order to escalate conflict (which is the driving force of the website, right?)
Spyckie··on Programming Is Like Sex
Well, these types of threads always exist, but the real problem is that the ycnews community or the technology behind ycnews has failed to hammer it down. I'm all for democracy when the majority brings meaningful and intelligent articles to read, but in this situation I don't mind giving up equality for quality.
Spyckie··on Ask YC: do you use what you learned in school?
The most useful thing I've learned in CS is to define and keep stringent rules while programming. These can be time/space constraints, programming time constraints, keeping the code modular, readable, or reusable, etc. Define rules that make the most sense for the project you have to do and write code with these rules in mind regardless of your own personal coding preferences. All CS knowledge learned enables you to keep to these rules. Of course, good rules to follow can be 'learn as much as possible' or 'enjoy yourself', but when it comes down to building something, enjoying yourself doesn't mean you've written good code.
Spyckie··on Facebook's fail is going to be epic
I bet you Facebook has some statistical models that estimate when their user base will stop growing/start shrinking, so they probably knew at least a month ago that this would happen.
Spyckie··on News.YC statistics - community cohesion
Thanks for posting this interesting data set, but after thinking about it for some time, I don't think this data offers any insights into yc.news. The leader to user ratio is too high, which skews all the numbers so that nothing really meaningful can be extracted. It's also hard to spot any trends from the point system alone - user identity, time of post relative to other news, and the controversy of the post content can play important factors in the post's point value, and all of these don't necessarily have any correlation with the user who posted it. I think in order to figure out something about the community, someone will have to get their hands dirty and actually look at post content.
Spyckie··on PG on trolls
Creating more selective communities with stricter guidelines seems to be the wrong approach to dealing with trolls, especially based on the scenario pg lays out. As pg says, the larger a community grows, the easier it is for trolls to be accepted and the harder it is to mod (prune) the community. It seems that critical mass is just when the pruning community becomes smaller than the trolling community, and that by creating new communities with more stringent rules, you are just delaying the date (hopefully indefinitely) when trolls come in. I understand that the yc community is special, but even the comments here show that it won't work for much longer as the community grows beyond yc. To answer the question of "Will it scale?", I think its already a no.

If you've ever hung out with a lot of girls (from a guy's perspective), you can beging to understand the trolling community. 1 on 1 with a girl and you can get intellectual conversation, but the minute 3 or 4 girls get together, they start talking about clothes, guys, dramas, and all other stuff that just isn't interesting. I bet girls see it the same with guys too (5 guys together = WoW, DOTA, girls or crude jokes).

Solutions? Keep it small. This fails to keep in line with the existing goals of news.yc (advertising for existing startups, attracting smart people, etc). Another solution? Maybe try to preserve the small community feel as the site gets bigger. One way to do this would be to use user upvotes and downvotes as community boundaries for each user - ie: making their community presence only to those who rate them up, and to make their personal community those who they rate up. This is speculative at best, though.

Spyckie··on PG on trolls
Is there a way to grab a reddit comment corpus (a large set of reddit's comments)? I don't browse reddit but I think it would be a fun thing to play around with.
Spyckie··on Steve Ballmer may be the worst CEO
Its not Steve Ballmer's fault. Microsoft just has an outdated business model/infrastructure. Their business model is Enterprise software development and sales, which is a problematic model due to many reasons (slow development, piracy, open source alternatives, etc). Microsoft's approach to competition (throwing money to develop copies of other company's products) was devastating to many Enterprise level companies during that era. However, in the era of the web that approach to competition fails miserably, and its not something I'd expect the older generation (which wasn't weaned on the web) to understand. What Microsoft needs is not a new CEO - its a new business directive that combines Enterprise level software with web-based initiatives in a startup mindset. Basically, they should create a Y-combinator for themselves with the ability to "buy out" whatever people make.

Of course, I think Microsoft should have given up software development long ago and just turned into an investment firm with the money they accrued. That would have saved web developers a lot of headaches.

← PreviousPage 5 of 5