HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Symmetry

19,477 karma · joined April 17, 2010

Robotics software/firmware engineer at Boston Dynamics working on Spot.

My blog: http://hopefullyintersting.blogspot.com/

My not-horribly-impressive github: https://github.com/aclough/ Mostly you might be interested in stealing my dotfiles.

submissionscomments
Symmetry··on The Brand Age
I think you have a different understanding of what exactly a brand is than do most people. Every profession has the right to develop its own jargon that subtly redefines common words in its own way so I'm not going to say that you're wrong about what "brand" means in any absolute way, just that you're wrong to say that pg is wrong.
Symmetry··on Dario Amodei calls OpenAI’s messaging around military deal ‘straight up lies’
Is this the first time internal communications like this have leaked from Anthropic? It'll be unfortunate if Anthropic can't have honest conversations internally going forward for fear of leaks.
Symmetry··on Claude's Cycles [pdf]
That means they're not conscious in the Global Workspace[1] sense but I think it would be going too far to say that that means they're not intelligent.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_workspace_theory

Symmetry··on Arm's Cortex X925: Reaching Desktop Performance
That might be true for the desktop, but RISC-V is wonderful from a pedagogical and research standpoint for academic uses and in the embedded world its license and "only pay for what you need" is also quite nice.
Symmetry··on Arm's Cortex X925: Reaching Desktop Performance
Yeah, the paper launch OP is talking about happened way back in May 2024.
Symmetry··on We do not think Anthropic should be designated as a supply chain risk
Anthropic's whole worry with mass surveillance was that current law is too loose in the age of AI to offer enough restraint.
Symmetry··on We do not think Anthropic should be designated as a supply chain risk
How confident are we, with OpenAI's recent very large contribution to Trump's PAC, that OpenAI wasn't working to get Anthropic designated a supply chain risk behind the scenes? I don't want to be too paranoid here but given Sam's reputation and cui bono I don't think we can really rule this out either.
Symmetry··on Hegseth gives Anthropic until Friday to back down on AI safeguards
Not just companies that we think of as defense contractors but a whole ton of corporations that do business with the federal government. They'd be treating Anthropic like it was controlled by the CCP or Revolutionary Guards.
Symmetry··on Blue light filters don't work – controlling total luminance is a better bet
The sunset and also fires. Humans have been making fires for a million years and in addition to allowing us to evolve much smaller guts they've also had time exert pressure on our behavior.
Symmetry··on Warcraft III Peon Voice Notifications for Claude Code
If you're the sort of person not to use a pre-packaged desktop environment, you can use mako as your notofication daemon and get the same effect by adding

  on-notify=exec play /usr/share/sounds/freedesktop/stereo/complete.oga
or the equivalent to your config.
Symmetry··on The RCE that AMD won't fix
Years of working in embedded computing have left me with the impression that most hardware companies are just bad at software. I think part of it is that the long cycle times of making hardware push them towards a culture of waterfall development. But years of working with the microcontroller libraries for ethernet PHYs, the bash scripts to build the kernels for SoCs, etc make me perfectly willing to believe they are incompetent with security.
Symmetry··on Data centers in space makes no sense
The formula for the equilibrium temperature for a sphere in sunlight is

    2 * pi * r^2 * L / (4 * pi * d) * (1 -a) = 4 * pi * r^2 * sigma * T^4
As you can see there are pi*r^2 on both sides of the equation, the surface area to cross section ratio of a sphere doesn't change as it gets bigger and so the equilibrium temperature doesn't change no matter how big the sphere is. (d is the distance to the Sun, nothing to do with the sphere itself).
Symmetry··on Data centers in space makes no sense
The rock in this case acts as extra thermal mass that makes it take longer to reach thermal equilibrium, but doesn't change what the ultimate thermal equilibrium is. Only the configuration of the parts of the surface that can absorb or radiate electromagnetic radiation do that. And because rock is a fairly good insulator we only really benefit from the top layer and if the sun went out we would all freeze in a week or so.
Symmetry··on Data centers in space makes no sense
Regarding 3, they're almost certainly thinking of putting these in SSO where the radiation environment isn't too much worse than you see on the ISS. If they were going to go outside the Van Allen belts it would be a different story.
Symmetry··on Data centers in space makes no sense
Space is a vacuum and yet here we are on a rock floating in space warmed by the sun and the temperate is actually pretty comfortable. Indeed, without the greenhouse effect it would be positively chilly. An important part of a thermos is that you have to use high albedo materials in the vacuum chamber or else it would lose heat too quickly to radiation.

A satellite as a whole will come to thermal equilibrium with space at a fairly reasonable temperature, the problematic part is that the properties of electricity make it easy to concentrate a good part of the incoming energy in a small area where the GPU is. Heat is harder to move than electricity and getting that heat back out to the solar panels or radiators requires either heavy heat pipes or complex coolant pumps.

Symmetry··on Data centers in space makes no sense
You take the amount of energy absorbed by the solar panels and subtract the amount they radiate. Most things in physics are linear systems that work like this.
Symmetry··on AI is a horse (2024)
It's not that each turn has a time limit but that each player has a time limit to spend across the entire game.
Symmetry··on AI is a horse (2024)
If you had a setup where the computer just did its thing and never waited for the human to provide input but the human still had an unused button they could press to get a chance to say something that might technically count as "centaur", but that isn't really what people mean by the term. It's the delay in waiting for human input that's the big disadvantage centaur setups have when the human isn't really providing any value these days.
Symmetry··on AI is a horse (2024)
After Deep Blue Garry Kapsparav proposed "Centaur Chess"[1] where teams of humans and computers would complete with each other. For about a decade a team like that was superior to either an unaided computer or an unaided AI. These days pure AI teams tend to be much stronger.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_chess

Symmetry··on Ask HN: Unemployed almost a year after graduating MIT – a rant
I feel lucky that in 2008 I could go into the Military Industrial Complex and work in places where I could be confident the results wouldn't be things I'd find objectionable. That seems like a much tougher prospect in 2026.
Symmetry··on How AI labs are solving the power problem
I had been under the mistaken impression that the turbines in airplanes were more different from the turbines in power plants than they actually are.
Symmetry··on How AI labs are solving the power problem
I found Boom's pivot much less confusing after this article.
Symmetry··on Liskell – Haskell Semantics with Lisp Syntax [pdf]
The venerable master Qc Na was walking with his student, Anton. Hoping to prompt the master into a discussion, Anton said "Master, I have heard that objects are a very good thing - is this true?" Qc Na looked pityingly at his student and replied, "Foolish pupil - objects are merely a poor man's closures."

Chastised, Anton took his leave from his master and returned to his cell, intent on studying closures. He carefully read the entire "Lambda: The Ultimate..." series of papers and its cousins, and implemented a small Scheme interpreter with a closure-based object system. He learned much, and looked forward to informing his master of his progress.

On his next walk with Qc Na, Anton attempted to impress his master by saying Master, I have diligently studied the matter, and now understand that objects are truly a poor man's closures." Qc Na responded by hitting Anton with his stick, saying "When will you learn? Closures are a poor man's object."

At that moment, Anton became enlightened.

Symmetry··on Economics of Orbital vs. Terrestrial Data Centers
It's very important in this case to specify which orbit the satellite is going to be in. If you're in LEO like the international space station you spend all day inside the Van Allen Belt protected from all those charged particles that the sun is pumping out. You're still lacking the atmosphere's protection from cosmic rays but that's not a huge dosage.

If you go out to MEO then suddenly you're outside that protective magnetic shield and you have to deal with charged particles smashing into you and you want a large mass of water or wax shielding if you don't have radiation tolerant electronics.

SSO, a low earth orbit whose plane is perpendicular to the direction of the sun so it gets constant sunlight, is harsher than normal LEO orbits because it passes over the poles where the protection from the Earth's magnetic field is weakest, but it's still a lot better than higher orbits. This is probably where you want a datacenter to get constant sunlight and as much protection as possible.

Symmetry··on CRISPR fungus: Protein-packed, sustainable, and tastes like meat
I'll be the first to cheer if we get rid of industrial agriculture but there's an awful lot of land in the world that doesn't receive enough rain for farming but which is still fine grazing land and when used for grazing still supports most of its original ecology. And there's a lot of damaged, blemished, etc produce that pigs are happy to eat but which can't be sold in a supermarket.

I'd like to see meat consumption to something like half to a quarter of its current level rather than eliminate it outright.

Symmetry··on Horses: AI progress is steady. Human equivalence is sudden
We certainly can't expect that with LLMs now but neither could compiler users back in the 1970s. I do agree that we probably won't ever have them generating code without more back and forth where the LLM complains that its instructions were ambiguous and then testing afterwards.
Symmetry··on Horses: AI progress is steady. Human equivalence is sudden
> Are you ok with having a codebase that is effectively a black box?

When was the last time you looked at the machine code your compiler was giving you? For me, doing embedded development on an architecture without a mature compiler the answer is last Friday but I expect that the vast majority of readers here never look at their machine code. We have abstraction layers that we've come to trust because they work in practice. To do our work we're dependent on the companies that develop our compilers where we can at least see the output, but also companies that make our CPUs which we couldn't debug without a huge amount of specialized equipment. So I expect that mostly people will be ok with it.

Symmetry··on The C++ standard for the F-35 Fighter Jet [video]
The rule of thumb I use is to only have one return after modifying state that will persist outside the function call.
Symmetry··on Covid-19 mRNA Vaccination and 4-Year All-Cause Mortality
For vaccines like the measles vaccine where it can entirely stop the spread in a vaccinated population this can be true until enough people think this way that measles starts spreading in your vicinity.

But with Covid-19 vaccination wasn't able to eliminate its spread so it mostly is about protecting yourself rather than protecting others.

Symmetry··on Nimony (Nim 3.0) Design Principles
Specifically, C comes form a world where allowing for machines that didn't use 2's compliment (or 8 bit bytes) was an active concern.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →