HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

TameAntelope

5,096 karma · joined July 12, 2020

thetameantelope@gmail.com
submissionscomments
TameAntelope··on No evidence for nudging after adjusting for publication bias
Isn't this just one specific analysis using a very narrow definition of "nudge", one that doesn't even begin to encompass the work being done at those "300 "research" departments"?

Further, isn't this using the same data from the original meta analysis that did find "of small to medium size" effect[0]?

Why would this, alone, undo decades of research and clear, bright-line conclusions such as the ones cited in my sibling comments? In other words, why is this letter the final word on the topic of "nudge", to you, and not the original meta-analysis? Sounds like you think everyone should pack it up and go home, all because of one letter using an alternative set of definitions and analysis.

Just seems like an overreaction on your part, especially given how vocal and... you-sounding (for lack of a better term) the "anti-nudge" crowd often is.

To take a wider view, a comment like yours is a more malicious form of nerd-sniping[1], especially on HN. Claim to have relevant credentials, voice a contrarian-but-popular-here opinion, and make a wild conclusion to give those reading it a feeling of "inside baseball."

[0] https://www.pnas.org/doi/full/10.1073/pnas.2107346118#sec-3

[1] https://xkcd.com/356/

TameAntelope··on A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter
> Here’s the thing: I’m a stinker. Even at my jolliest, if someone figuratively shoulder-checks me, I’m probably going to make so many mountains out of this molehill that I will adjust the topography of the United States significantly.

I’m sorry, but this is your real problem, not Twitter banning you. This is called “pride” and is historically recognized as one of the largest “problem creators” as far as emotions go.

The author writes like this is some kind of noble trait, but is in reality very probably the source of many of the author’s negative experiences.

There is a clear path to getting unbanned from Twitter, but the author refuses to take it. Shame.

TameAntelope··on Cheap junk flooding Amazon has brand names like MOFFBUZW
Is there an opportunity to create a marketplace that does meaningful validation and testing of the items on it, such that when you buy a product, you can be guaranteed to be getting the real thing?

What could a competitor do to attack Amazon here?

TameAntelope··on Prostitution and Spam Killed Craigslist
Well yeah, it’s probably against the FB ToS to create a burner account, so it sounds like they correctly detected an account that wasn’t legitimate.
TameAntelope··on Tell HN: You can't hire because you don't post salary ranges
Hm, I know you're getting a lot of responses to this, but just to throw my view onto the pile: what I "enjoy" doing (golf, video games, playing with my dogs, traveling with my wife, etc.) is not something anyone will pay me for.

What I'm willing to do, however, is a whole bunch of stuff, as long as that "stuff" gives me a better ability to do those things that do make me happy, and a primary driver of my ability to do the things I like is how much money I have.

Happiness doesn't really factor into it, because as I said, the items at the top of the list of things that make me happy are nonstarters from an income perspective.

It's delusional, as an employer, to think your job is to make the people who work for you "happy" in some objective sense.

Nobody would be there if you weren't paying them, you need very badly to remind yourself of that.

TameAntelope··on Software development topics I've changed my mind on after 6 years in dev
After 15 years, I no longer judge past coding decisions, and I think you can save yourself a lot of grief by not waiting as long as I did to realize this.

You don’t know the constraints the previous person was under, so you can’t possibly know what you really would have done or what “should” have been done.

I mention this because there’s still a tone of, “there is approximately one right way to code” in this article, and I really doubt that.

Make good choices now, but don’t be harsh to the folks who came before you.

TameAntelope··on Ask HN: What can you realistically manufacture in your garage?
Eh, I was thinking more like, "Build us a web portal for viewing the status of <random thing> and requesting more <random thing>." than, "Run guns for us cheaply."
TameAntelope··on Ask HN: What can you realistically manufacture in your garage?
You're not the first person I've heard this from; when you say "many are now posting lists of open contracts you can bid on" where are they posting these things? https://sam.gov/content/home is what my cursory Googling found, is this what you mean, or is there some other, more relevant site involved?
TameAntelope··on Ask HN: Is Anonymity Possible in 2022?
What are you trying to avoid? Generic fear is debilitating; you need to identify, very specifically, what your threat model is, and address that.

Just coming up with horrible "what if?" scenarios seems counterproductive and paranoid.

TameAntelope··on How “let it fail” leads to simpler code
Handle errors you should.

Don’t handle errors that aren’t relevant to your specific code.

TameAntelope··on How “let it fail” leads to simpler code
What you're describing are "known" states; the idea behind "let it fail" is that you shouldn't write code that exhaustively handles every single potential outcome, just the ones that are part of your code's path in general use.

Definitely write code to handle network issues. Don't write code to handle random bitflips, ways to handle garbage coming back from the service you're connecting to, or try to handle OOM errors. Just let those fail.

Do not catch everything you can. That's the whole point of "let it fail". An app crashing is totally fine and expected behavior, in a lot of cases (of course if it's not fine, e.g. someone dies, don't do that but if you're working on that kind of software and taking advice from me, you're super duper screwed).

TameAntelope··on Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her consent
Meh, virtue displays that still help people are fine by me.

I don't think this really helped anyone, but "dehumanizing" is an overreaction, IMO. "Mildly annoying" is probably the more accurate term.

TameAntelope··on Tell HN: Upwork has an impersonation problem
Consider that not all of us mind sharing their CVs to the world. The potential for harm is quite low, and there are meaningful upsides.
TameAntelope··on Tell HN: Upwork has an impersonation problem
I would be thinking very hard about all the ways I could prove, definitively, that I could not be the person doing this to others.
TameAntelope··on Gamedevs not baking in monetization are “fucking idiots”, says Unity CEO
I think he says "the biggest fucking idiots" in the way some of us say, "aren't thinking of all the angles".

If folks are getting wrapped up in the insult, they're not reading his tone correctly. He says it lovingly, and even if you disagree with that kind of tone, it's disingenuous to say he's literally calling these people "fucking idiots".

TameAntelope··on Show HN: Inflation-adjusted stock charts – Total Real Returns
No, "education" as a concept does not mean either of those things.
TameAntelope··on Manhattan rents cross $5k threshold for first time
It's as cruel as life. Pretending like there aren't any negative learned behaviors that cause vicious cycles from poverty is naive. When all you know is suffering, the human mind has to come up with some justification for it, some reason it's "worth" continuing on. Nobility is often that conjured reason.

Have you really never met anyone who's oddly proud of how hard they work, despite how little they earn? I grew up around these people, this view was more common than drug use, more common than gambling, almost consensus that the poor folks were the real heroes of the story.

"Stuck" is indeed the right word, but no they won't get "unstuck"; their lives will just get worse and worse. Like I said, there's just so much lower we can go here, people don't even realize where the bottom is.

TameAntelope··on Show HN: I built an app for when I talk too much in online meetings
Depending on how you did it, you could be quite “aggressive”!

“Dave, found the perfect app for you!” is aggressive. “Wow I might start using this app!” Is better.

TameAntelope··on Manhattan rents cross $5k threshold for first time
> no one is going to commute 90 minutes for a minimum wage job when there are plenty of jobs available elsewhere.

They absolutely will, this concern has never really made sense to me. Poverty is like a badge of honor for many folks, and the harder one works for the lower the pay ends up being a little game some folks like to engage in, almost as a self flagellation; "I suffer therefore I'm noble."

Just look at some of the most oppressive places in the world, and how people continue to opt into that abject horror because it's a path to marginally help themselves or others they care about. NYC is nowhere near approaching the levels of, say, Qatar, in how it treats its workers, and a 90 minute commute each way wouldn't do much to push NYC closer to Qatar on that particular front.

You think we're at the bottom? No, we can go so much lower. So very much lower...

TameAntelope··on Show HN: Inflation-adjusted stock charts – Total Real Returns
Do my research, you say?

Like, find a company in the S&P 500[0] that is not an American company? A company named, oh I dunno, Linde plc, which trades as $LIN and was founded in Germany[1] and currently has its headquarters in the UK?

So on the technical merits, what I said was correct, the S&P 500 does indeed have non-US stocks. Further, on the general thrust of my point, that the S&P 500 has exposure to international markets, that also holds true, something like 71% US and 29% international based on some cursory research [2].

But please, continue to lecture me on my ignorance. :)

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_S%26P_500_companies

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linde_plc

[2] https://www.spglobal.com/en/research-insights/articles/daily...

TameAntelope··on Show HN: Inflation-adjusted stock charts – Total Real Returns
Who said anything about blind or tradition? That seems like stuff you injected into this convo, not me.

I trust institutions who have a strong track record of predictiveness and desirable outcomes. Vanguard has both in spades, and has earned their authority. If they stop accurately predicting future behavior and/or stop producing desirable outcomes, that will change their authority on matters of investing.

Not trusting predictiveness and desirable outcomes seems prone to bias. If your alternative is that you only trust yourself, that seems like both a paranoid and privileged outlook, given how much time and how many resources you'd need to expend to gain even half of the knowledge Vanguard as an institution has about operating as an investment advisor.

TameAntelope··on GoDaddy locks out derivatives of Chrome
All the way back to their Danica Patrick days they’ve been more focused on the bottom of the market (non technical users who don’t know better) than in providing a good product.
TameAntelope··on Show HN: Inflation-adjusted stock charts – Total Real Returns
No, it very much is not. It's literally how all education works, for example.
TameAntelope··on NYC releases PSA for what to do in case of nuclear attack
That is neither smart nor safe, given your need as a human to eat and drink clean food, which requires coordination with others.
TameAntelope··on Show HN: Inflation-adjusted stock charts – Total Real Returns
So Vanguard (venerated investment institution for 50 years) is wrong and you (random HN commenter) are right?

Sure, okay.

TameAntelope··on Show HN: Inflation-adjusted stock charts – Total Real Returns
Not according to Vanguard[0] (the link is for VFIAX but that's just the admiral fund), the quote I gave was from Vanguard's own description of the fund's composition.

You can take it up with Vanguard why they describe the fund as I've quoted[1].

[0] https://investor.vanguard.com/investment-products/mutual-fun...

[1] https://support.vanguard.com/

TameAntelope··on Show HN: Inflation-adjusted stock charts – Total Real Returns
> Portfolio emphasizing U.S. and foreign large- and mid-capitalization value stocks.

VFINX is not composed exclusively of US stocks.

TameAntelope··on Thoughts on the potato diet
When the choices are, “anonymous person on HN” and “one of the most respected institutions for public health education on the planet”, I’m going to tend towards the latter, thanks.
TameAntelope··on Choosing a New Comment Policy
It is by far the best option for someone as easily triggered as the author to ignore trolls entirely, as his own article suggests.

The narcissistic tendencies he’s indulged here are toxic as hell, both to him and to whatever community he’s trying to foster in his comments, far more damaging than any troll might be.

Just let it go! This is so damaging to the fabric of your community, you’re literally killing the very thing you want to support by not just letting it go.

Write no more of it, think no more of it, just move on.

TameAntelope··on Choosing a New Comment Policy
Honestly, this reaction demonstrates pretty clearly that he’s not strong enough to deal with any of this, as the by far best way to deal with a troll is to ignore them.

This self indulgent out-loud, “this is why we can’t have nice things” contemplation is just fishing for sympathy, when what he should be getting is direct feedback to either move on or to enact any changes without feeding the troll (i.e. silently).

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →