HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Taniwha

7,647 karma · joined November 25, 2013

submissionscomments
Taniwha··on Can you reverse engineer an ASIC?
In fact if you have the sky130 libraries installed (it's where I'm working) you can get a spice netlist out of it in about 10 seconds - really they should have flattened it
Taniwha··on Can you reverse engineer an ASIC?
I take it back, it's a sky130 .gds the gates are explicitly in there
Taniwha··on Can you reverse engineer an ASIC?
I'm a chip designer, back in the early 90s I visited a small silicon house who were doing some work for us, their boardroom table had been taken over by a giant sized photomicrograph of IBM's VGA chip and they had a bunch of summer hire grad students tracing wiring and matching standard cells (easier back then because we only worked in 2 layers of metal).

They weren't trying to steal IBM's design, they already had one of their own, what they wanted to know was "is there any as yet unannounced functionality in the IBM VGA chip?" they didn't want to be caught out when some unknown registers popped up. Of course it turned out there was as yet unannounced functionality - but not by IBM's design, more because of the orthogonality of the design - MODE-X was discovered and became the basis for DOOM's speed, anyone who didn't support it lost out

Taniwha··on Can you reverse engineer an ASIC?
yes, but at the transistor level .... it has no idea at that level how those transistors are arranged into gates directly
Taniwha··on Can you reverse engineer an ASIC?
It's even easier in this case because they've included the original verilog source ....
Taniwha··on The Silicon Valley Founder Meat Grinder
I think the real watershed wan't bitcoin, it was the internet bubble, before that the rule of thumb was you couldn't go public without 5 consecutive quarters of profit - you really had to build something real - suddenly you could do it on hype alone and the focus turned to that
Taniwha··on Truth is not a direction: a Tarski attack on LLM probes
Yes exactly, sure they need to know about "Pride and Prejudice" but they have no way to tell it didn't happen, nor any way to tell that all people of that age lived that way (most were dirt poor scrabbling for a living)
Taniwha··on Truth is not a direction: a Tarski attack on LLM probes
I think that one of the main problems with LLMs is that we're shoveling everything in to them, without any guidance as to what is "real"/"true"/"factual" - crazy anti-vaxxer-cooker stuff is is sitting in their along with science without any concept of scientific reality and no guidance to what is real and what is insane minds spinning on each other
Taniwha··on Hooray for the Sockets Interface
The article kind of misses out on the networking standards of the time - there were many of which TCP and IP were just one, most of the rest were either proprietary (DNA SNA BNA etc) and incompatible, or owned by telecoms who wanted to be able to charge per packet(X.25).

TCP/IP won (IMHO) because the implementation was open source, and because no one was going to make a buck by locking others out (or charging them for the right to build an implementation). Plus there was a working reference implementation available for the taking

Taniwha··on Designing an Ethernet Switch ASIC
On TinyTapeout you can add more tiles up to 16 times the size of this (at which point you likely jump to waferspace)
Taniwha··on The Computer at the Bottom of a Canal
I'm in 2 minds, I'm strongly in the RISC camp these days, I know how hard it is to build a truly performant CPU and think that simpler is better as far as ISAs go. Adding segmentation hardware into the addressing path means more clocks and makes it's harder to detect loads/stores that interfere with each other (all load/stores have to block each other until the addressing/tlb lookup has been done ie detecting aliasing ).

A true capability architecture needs separate register files for pointers and data with protections enforced when the address registers are loaded/stored, it's a step away from our models of linear address spaces that many of the languages we use today are based on. And any new CPU that requires everyone to learn a new language is probably a non-starter as a mainstream CPU

Taniwha··on The Computer at the Bottom of a Canal
It was more than 40 years ago, before I had the skills to build chips, I'm afraid I've kept nothing of that design
Taniwha··on The Computer at the Bottom of a Canal
Thing is capability machines (like this and the 432 and lots of research machines) were very much the thing at the time - cutting edge even. The research literature was full of them. I did a paper design at the time.

What ate them up was "what can you fit all on a chip with not many pins", followed by "what can you fit along with a cache on a chip with more pins", things move so much faster if everything's on the same die.

Tagged architectures are old, Burroughs mainframes had them back in the 70s along with rudimentary hardware objects (pageable even)

Taniwha··on Starlink from 1984
StarLAN was a 1Mb twisted pair networking system that was pre twisted pair ethernet
Taniwha··on Sam Neill has died
Pretty sure it's "But I LOVE what he did for the Australian flag." - he is a kiwi but that's arguably the Aussie flag with the colonial bit replaced with the local one
Taniwha··on Jellyfish Undersea Roundabout
Like Greenland,the Faroe Islands are a self-governing, autonomous territory within the Kingdom of Denmark. I'm sure this is highway funding from the mainland.
Taniwha··on Digital Deli, 1984 book by early PC hackers and enthusiasts
In context, around 1980 we bought 1.5MB of memory (core, real core, hand threaded core) for our Burroughs mainframe, we paid more than $1M (1980s) dollars for it. With 3MB our 1MHz mainframe supported 40 users.

You make do with the memory and cycles available, things get easier as the resources get less tight, it's easy to use things like garbage collection rather than doing the hard yards and managing memory yourself, or to break branch prediction by using virtual objects

Taniwha··on Book: RISC-V System-on-Chip Design
You don't really fetch 66 bytes instead of 64, what real implementations do is read cache lines (of whatever size) and hold on to 2 bytes from the previous cache line if there was 1/2 a 32-bit instruction at the end of the previous cache line (the ISA has the 16/32-bit tag in the lower byte so you know how big an instruction will be even if you've only seen half of it)
Taniwha··on Installing A/UX 1.1 like it's the 90s
It's possible that later A/UXs required booting MacOS - but when we started we got 1/2 the initial prototype production run of Mac 2s (no cases, bugs in pals, probably no standard ROMs yet)

Our standard agreement for porting Unix to new hardware (we did something like 150 different boxes, not just macs) required a minimal ROM monitor that could download code from a serial port (we could provide source), we'd take it from there, write S/A code to store data on the harddrive, download a file system, start downloading kernels into ram debugging the disk and serial drivers until we got a shell prompt ... then moving development onto the box

Taniwha··on Installing A/UX 1.1 like it's the 90s
I'm pretty sure the ROMs loaded a boot sector booter and jumped into that, it's been a long time but I'm pretty sure that's what we handed over to Apple
Taniwha··on Installing A/UX 1.1 like it's the 90s
Not really (I wrote the mouse/display drivers and kernel event queue driver for A/UX 1.x) - A/UX has it's own kernel ADB (and mouse/kbd on top of that) and display drivers, it will happily boot from hard drive, and throw up a non-mac terminal on a Mac display card without executing anything from the Mac ROMs.

The later MacOS running on A/UX ran in a single A/UX (system V) process

Taniwha··on EV Batteries Are Defying Expectations After Miles
These are NiMH cells (7V) wired in series (not parallel so matching is less of an issue) - one bad cell and the series resistance of the whole string is shot
Taniwha··on EV Batteries Are Defying Expectations After Miles
The original Prius batteries can easily have individual cells replaced (mine is 20 years old, we've replaced 2 cells) - of course Toyota want to sell you an entire battery, the wrecker will sell you a whole bunch of spares

(do this with care, an entire pack is hundreds of volts)

Taniwha··on Factories are just rooms
It's not really so much a book on how to get electronics done, more sort of an electronics specific phrase book, full of the names of things you can point at when looking for stuff in the markets.

The original was written by Bunnie Huang (a name to be sneezed at in his own right) who (I assume) grew up speaking Mandarin at home. Naomi is a local though and probably has broader local knowledge.

The original Shenzhen markets are still there (I've been going for a decade or so, they haven't changed that much), they're getting a bit crowded out by consumer electronics - I can still go and buy great tools in HQB at same places I was 10 years ago, reels of resistors at the same places, people will still sell you cut tape from part reels on the street - the big change are the electric bikes, you take your life in your hand each time you turn around :-)

Taniwha··on How H-E-B became Texas' most beloved brand (2024)
Viruses do not "fester" on flat surfaces, if they fester in anything it is cells
Taniwha··on HPV vaccine cuts risk of dying from cervical cancer before 30
This is a vaccine that does contribute to herd immunity, if enough people get it then transmission goes to 0 and it dies out, even unvaccinated people wont get it, because of the vaccine. The article says "0 cases" in the entire population, in this case the people who get vaccinated are carrying the unvaccinated
Taniwha··on America has lost its war with Iran
.... and people died, lots of people died
Taniwha··on A brief tour of the PDP-11, the most influential minicomputer of all time (2022)
Yup, as mentioned above the famous:

x: mov -(pc), -(pc)

reads an instruction from x, increments the PC to x+2, then decrements the PC back to x and reads the same instruction, then decrements it again to x-2 and writes it, then it executes from x-2 ......

Taniwha··on The time the x86 emulator team found code so bad they fixed it during emulation
there were no GPUs at that time. What we were building in the late 80s/early 90s were the first generation of Mac graphics accelerators, really just glorified blit engines, a class of things that eventually grew into what we now call GPUs as people started to push CPUs into them
Taniwha··on The time the x86 emulator team found code so bad they fixed it during emulation
Yeah those low core global system variables (including a readable/writeable 0) at fixed addresses were very much a thing, they were a bad design decision made for the original Macs with almost no memory, and made running more than one app (switcher/multifinder) a difficult transition back in the day. Someone wasn't planning ahead

I also worked on the original A/UX port for the Mac II, some hardware (like the IWM) required tiny buzzy loops, we ran into one bug where using the floppy caused ADB to freeze, but only on the release machines, not the prototypes all our engineers had, turned out there was hardware that made access to the VIA faster by pulling the clock in for 1 cycle, if you sat in a loop reading the timer in the via to measure a sector time for the IWM in too tight a loop it upped the output clock from the VIA to the ADB chip and over clocked it ....

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →