HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

TaupeRanger

2,334 karma · joined August 28, 2016

submissionscomments
TaupeRanger··on Nintendo unveils Switch 2 ahead of June 5 launch
Is this an AI response? No, if you just look at the chart it has only gone down by about 1%, so roughly flat as I said. The link of course describes what happens during inflation, but since wages also increase in the real world, they offset inflation so real wages remained roughly flat.
TaupeRanger··on Nintendo unveils Switch 2 ahead of June 5 launch
Purchasing Power is a function of inflation and income - so it always "keeps up" with inflation. You might've been trying to say that income hasn't kept up with inflation, but that's not supported by any data. Real wages have remained roughly flat since 2021. https://www.statista.com/chart/32428/inflation-and-wage-grow...
TaupeRanger··on NotaGen: Symbolic Music Generation
Is this an AI generated response? Spending 60 seconds on Google reveals every argument to be nonsense. A simple Google search for "OpenScore" reveals a MuseScore page with only 14 scores (all of which already exist in IMLSP). So what kind of "work" you think is happening there...I haven't a clue. Searching IMLSP for popular songs reveals mostly recordings and badly photo-copied PDF scores - nothing usable in the MIDI, XML, or ABC formats.
TaupeRanger··on NotaGen: Symbolic Music Generation
Even the cherry picked examples are boring milquetoast? Maybe this is an example of "this is worst version of this technology" but I'm still skeptical of any generative system that isn't publicly available for testing.

The major issue I can foresee going forward is that the only public domain sheet music available is in the classical idiom. And people don't really care about writing new pieces in a Baroque style. It's a fun exercise, but not really relevant to modern music. The "pop music" listed in the article sounds like "Baroque-pop" presumably because that's what is in the training data. That's why a DAW style system would be more useful and welcome, although there again - what data do you train on? There aren't just millions of publicly available "EDM DAW files" laying around to train on.

TaupeRanger··on Breakthrough stroke drug heals the brain to restore movement
> Breakthrough stroke drug heals the brain to restore movement

Fixed: Pre-clinical drug that has never been tested on humans and might be worse than the current standard of care (physical therapy) gets a press release with a hyperbolic title in order to generate clicks.

TaupeRanger··on Crew-9 Returns to Earth
Do you think it's easy to be "fair" to someone who continually spouts misinformation, falsehoods, and retweets or reply-boosts such things on an almost daily basis?
TaupeRanger··on OpenAI asks White House for relief from state AI rules
No one said they "don't want it".

No one said "it's scary".

No one is "dismissing them".

It seems like you're arguing against some other person you've made up in your mind. I use these systems every single day, but if you don't understand the argument about consent and the extremely obvious difference between Python programs and humans that I already pointed out, then no one can help you. I'll keep making these arguments, because they are good ones, and they are obvious to any human being who isn't stuck in tech-bro fairy land blabbering about how human consciousness is completely identical to Python linear algebra libraries when any 6 year old child knows with certainty they are not.

> In a word, yes.

This is, frankly, embarrassing.

TaupeRanger··on OpenAI asks White House for relief from state AI rules
You "really don't understand" the difference? Do we need to spell out that these systems aren't human artists simply looking at paintings and admiring features about them? They are Python programs running linear algebra libraries, sucking in pixels from anywhere they can find them, and then being used by corporations with billion dollar valuations to increase investor/shareholder value at the expense of the people who provided the artwork to train the systems - people who, as you already know, are NOT paid for providing their work, and who never CONSENTED to having their work used for such a purpose. Now do you "understand the difference"?
TaupeRanger··on GLP-1 drugs: An economic disruptor? (2024)
Not remotely true. We have strong studies out to 10 years at this point. Given the overwhelmingly positive results at our current state, it would take a huge safety signal occurring at 12-20+ years of usage to provoke a change in recommendation, and this is exceedingly unlikely. Basically all such signals are revealed by 10 years if they exist.
TaupeRanger··on GLP-1 drugs: An economic disruptor? (2024)
What does this even mean? The results of GLP-1 meds are well studied and widely understood to be game changing and likely revolutionary. The other claims might be hyperbolic but results of the medication on individuals is not really a question at this point.
TaupeRanger··on The quiet rebellion of a little life
Yes. These types of hot takes only have force because most people don't pursue them. In a world where most people pursued a "little life", you'd see articles about the "quiet rebellion of ambition". Is either life better than the other? On what grounds? Is it not entirely dependent on the details of the life in question? Does no one understand the deep truth of the phrase "the grass is always greener"?
TaupeRanger··on The quiet rebellion of a little life
Most people agree with you until the moment they actually have to decide between further treatment and likely death. Most people simply hold on until they have no choice but to die.
TaupeRanger··on Estimates of plant CO2 uptake rise by nearly one third
no, obviously not
TaupeRanger··on Estimates of plant CO2 uptake rise by nearly one third
It isn't. Greenhouse emissions have remained roughly stagnant for over 30 years, while lung cancer deaths have dropped by 50-60 percent. Of course that's largely due to a decrease in smoking, but without any concomitant increase in mortality from "bad air", I don't see how anyone could think it's a "big deal".

Sources: https://www.epa.gov/climate-indicators/climate-change-indica... https://www.lung.org/research/trends-in-lung-disease/lung-ca...

TaupeRanger··on What is it like to be a thermostat?
Scientifically, there is a lot to learn. If we understand alternate forms of consciousness, we can potentially alter our own and open up new avenues of experience.

Your last comment strikes me as strange for someone who seems to be well read on the topic. Saying that consciousness is an ability to recall memories doesn’t really describe what it is in the natural sense. The memories themselves are composed of conscious experiences, so that definition is circular. An explanation of what consciousness is would include an explanation about why, for example, chocolate tastes the way it does, rather than like vanilla, or some other completely unknown taste. Until we can explain its character (rather than just describe it), we can’t explain what it is. It’s sort of like dark energy: we can describe the phenomenon but we haven’t fully explained what it is.

TaupeRanger··on Apple, Nvidia, Anthropic Used Swiped YouTube Videos to Train AI
Which of the factual statements do you count as an opinion?
TaupeRanger··on Apple, Nvidia, Anthropic Used Swiped YouTube Videos to Train AI
No, humans are not Python programs running linear algebra libraries, sucking in mountains of copyrighted data to use at massive scale in corporate products. The fact that this question comes up in EVERY thread about this is honestly sad.
TaupeRanger··on A landscape of consciousness: Toward a taxonomy of explanations and implications
Even then, you're still only experiencing your own, single, unitary stream of experience, you've just replaced or superimposed parts of it with signals from another nervous system. But even if you can somehow replace/superimpose the signals coming through their optic nerve, for example, into your own experience, that still doesn't answer the question of whether or not they have their own stream of experience to begin with. That is simply unknowable, outside of the reasonable assumptions we all make to avoid solipsism (but they are still assumptions at the end of the day).
TaupeRanger··on Safe Superintelligence Inc.
Trying to create "safe superintelligence" before creating anything remotely resembling or approaching "superintelligence" is like trying to create "safe Dyson sphere energy transport" before creating a Dyson Sphere. And the hubris is just a cringe inducing bonus.
TaupeRanger··on Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the human brain
Just handwavy nonsense. What counts as “observing”? Obviously the bacterial system will “observe” the memory when using it determine current behavior. If the basic definition is irrelevant, why did you post a comment outlining a claim of what consciousness is “nothing more than”? This is silly and not worth further engagement.
TaupeRanger··on Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the human brain
Bacteria cells absolutely have types of memory. And by your definition a Python program written by any random undergrad in CS 101 has consciousness.
TaupeRanger··on GPT-4o
I don't get it...I just switched to the new model on my iPhone app and it still takes several seconds to respond with pretty bland inflection. Is there some setting I'm missing?
TaupeRanger··on AlphaFold 3 predicts the structure and interactions of life's molecules
First time reading a Deep Mind PR? This is literally their modus operandi.
TaupeRanger··on AlphaFold 3 predicts the structure and interactions of life's molecules
So after 6 years of this "revolutionary technology", what we have to show for all the hype and breathless press releases is: ....another press release saying how "revolutionary" it is. Fantastic. Thanks DeepMind.
TaupeRanger··on I Know the secret to the quiet mind. I wish I'd never learned it (2021)
This is one of those areas where anecdotes can be quite valuable, because there seems to be no real downside risk to a piercing aside from the money spent and possible infection, but if there's even a .01% chance it could stop debilitating chronic pain, then sure, you might make a valid decision to try it even though there isn't a study supporting it.
TaupeRanger··on I Know the secret to the quiet mind. I wish I'd never learned it (2021)
Could be an effective placebo for sure: https://health.clevelandclinic.org/can-unconventional-pierci...
TaupeRanger··on Sora: Creating video from text
You are simply ignoring what I actually said. My criticism was directed at specific fields: name one cancer treatment or "individualized medicine" approach that has been proven to save lives or increase quality of life in the last 3-5 years. I'll wait.

The vaccines were not the result of medicine getting "better" - they just happened to have a solution for the right thing at the right time, which is fortunate (and we're lucky that it worked, because there was no guarantee of that beforehand) but if the pandemic hadn't happened, what advances would we be discussing? What advances are actually making medicine better aside from once-in-a-hundred-year worldwide emergencies?

TaupeRanger··on Sora: Creating video from text
I would be willing to bet $10,000 that the average person's life will not be changed in any significant way by this technology in the next 10 years. Will there be some VFX disruption in Hollywood and games? Sure, maybe some. It's not a cure for cancer. It's not AGI. It's not earth shattering. It is fun and interesting though.
TaupeRanger··on Sora: Creating video from text
There's no evidence to suggest what you say is true, so I would tell them to simply go to college or trade school for what they are interested in, then take a deep breath, go outside, and realize that literally nothing has changed except that a few people can create visual mockups more quickly.
TaupeRanger··on Sora: Creating video from text
> The way these models are creative is the same way humans are

We have no idea how human creativity works, but we know with certainty that it doesn't involve a Python program sucking in pixel data and outputting statistical likelihoods.

← PreviousPage 5 of 26Next →