HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

TheBrokenRail

744 karma · joined December 9, 2020

submissionscomments
TheBrokenRail··on Tech journalism doesn’t know what to do with Mastodon
> Mastodon starts off by explaining how federates instances work and then gives you a list of popular ones to choose from.

This is kind of terrible.

Now instead of just putting in your emails you have to make an impactful choice that won't be terribly easy to reverse. Now you have to check which instances have sane moderation, which instances actually have funding so they won't just die on you, which instances are fast or slow, which instances have blocked which other instances, and all the other inevitable petty drama between them. And again, this is compared to just putting in your email and not thinking about it.

And this isn't even inherent to federation either! Matrix has an officially-endorsed default homeserver for people who just want to create an account (most people). You don't have to understand federation to use Matrix, it's available if you want it, but you could live without understanding any of it. This causes Matrix to have a much better on-boarding experience.

TheBrokenRail··on Kickstarter shuts down campaign for Unstable Diffusion amid changing guidelines
I'm not saying that AI should have rights. I'm saying it's silly to call it "theft" when an AI does it, but "learning" and "inspiration" when a human does the same thing.
TheBrokenRail··on Kickstarter shuts down campaign for Unstable Diffusion amid changing guidelines
> The thing to remember is AI literally copies the originals. While it mashes them together in a way that makes the lines hard to see that is in fact what it is doing.

As another commenter already pointed out, this is literally not possible. The model size for Stable Diffusion isn't nearly big enough to contain all its training data. Understanding the concepts (at least on some abstract level) of the artwork it's trained on is the only possible way a 6 GB[0] model can be based on such a massive data-set.

In conclusion, the important thing to remember is that AI does not just copy and paste the originals. It's simply not possible.

[0]: https://huggingface.co/stabilityai/stable-diffusion-2-1/tree...

TheBrokenRail··on Kickstarter shuts down campaign for Unstable Diffusion amid changing guidelines
> Humans as a race have created art from literally nothing.

No, they didn't? Humans don't have any magic creative juices that allow them to come up with ideas out of thin air, that's silly. Ideas are created from our brain using our past experiences and knowledge, why do you think some of our earliest art is of animals?

Also, I'm not sure comparing artists to horse-drawn carriages is the best analogy to support your argument, considering horse-drawn carriages are almost nonexistent nowadays. I'd argue a better analogy would be something like chess or any other game. When computers beat humans at chess, nobody changed the rules of chess to make computers perform worse. People just acknowledged that computers were better.

TheBrokenRail··on Kickstarter shuts down campaign for Unstable Diffusion amid changing guidelines
> AI art is about putting together the work that artists have done in a way that isn't technically theft (well it might be the law is very slow about reacting to this thing and you can't go after someone for copyright violation as a class action lawsuit)

How do you think humans learn art? Humans aren't magic, they learn to make art by looking at and being inspired by other art, and I'd bet quite a lot of that art is copyrighted. AIs are just doing the same thing but way faster, and I don't see any issue with that. (Same with GitHub Copilot for that matter.)

TheBrokenRail··on HelloSilicon – An introduction to assembly on Apple Silicon Macs
So what's the difference between ARM and Apple Silicon?

It's a little odd seeing it treated as its own unique architecture (for instance with people specifically porting software or writing guides about Apple Silicon rather than ARM in general) when it's just ARM64. Which already has a lot of stuff already ported to it and is quite extensively documented.

Am I missing something? Did Apple do something crazy non-standard when making their chips which make them behave differently?

TheBrokenRail··on Epic Games to pay $520M to resolve FTC allegations
Yeah, Google thinks I'm 31 years older than I actually am.
TheBrokenRail··on Epic Games to pay $520M to resolve FTC allegations
When we get into situations like this, you do have to question if the law requiring it is just plain silly.
TheBrokenRail··on I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years, but now only have a few days left
I feel like I'm missing something, what did the medical system actually do wrong? I feel like I'm missing an intermediary paragraph talking about high fees or uncompassionate doctors or something similar.
TheBrokenRail··on A self-updating list of the most current useragents
To me, that just sounds like an pretty good argument to improve feature detection. Freezing user-agents and improving feature-detection aren't mutually-exclusive.
TheBrokenRail··on Getting started with nmap
> The Nmap Scripting Engine (NSE) allows you to use, and share various scripts. The scripts are written in Lua.

Stuff like this is why I can't take people who argue against systemd because of the Unix philosophy seriously.

The idea of this mythical program which does exactly one thing is just that, mythical. Yeah, modularity is important, but these programs are also made for real people who'd rather just use a command flag than figure out how to chain 50 different programs together in a brittle Rube Goldberg machine to get the result they want. Just look at how many command flags GNU ls has!

The Unix philosophy is a good one, but I'd rather judge program's based on their actual usability.

TheBrokenRail··on A self-updating list of the most current useragents
Can we please just freeze the user-agent string all browsers use? (I'd prefer if we could remove it, but we all know that isn't ever happening due to all the old websites.) It's silly that it's almost 2023 and web browsers are still sending legacy-infested nonsense like "(KHTML, like Gecko)" and websites actually change behavior based on it! We have proper APIs for feature detection nowadays, websites shouldn't need to change behavior based on the browser anymore.
TheBrokenRail··on Is Are we kidding ourselves that anything is original? [video]
I thought this was interesting regarding the conversation whether AI was stealing when it's trained on copyrighted code/art, despite humans also learning from (or being inspired by) copyrighted code/art.

Also I now see I made a typo when shortening the title.

TheBrokenRail··on Ask HN: If I get locked out of everything, please try to help me
This is the issue with companies forcing 2FA on people. I don't see why it's so controversial that people should be able to make their own security decisions on their own accounts.

Yes, I know 2FA is more secure, but sometimes, I just don't care that much.

TheBrokenRail··on Introducing passkeys in Chrome
This all seems really cool, but right now I'm just dreading when some site inevitably start forcing you to use it out of some misplaced desire to protect the user from themselves.

It's my account, it should be my choice whether to make the security/convenience tradeoff. Sometimes I just want to use a plain password, stick it in my web browser, and forget about it.

TheBrokenRail··on Incident affecting Google Ad Manager
It's always weird when something like part of Google goes down. I just don't expect it because of how massive Google is and how much money they put into their site running reliably. I guess it's interesting to be reminded that Google can go down just like any other website, it's just a really big one.
TheBrokenRail··on Why I'm less than infinitely hostile to cryptocurrency
I came into this article expecting to disagree with it... but the author actually makes a lot of good points. It's nice to see an acknowledgment that crypto is simultaneously useful (and actually pretty cool) but also not a magic solution to all the world's problems. (It does get a bit annoying hearing "we're going to reinvent the wheel BUT WITH CRYPTO!" for the 10th time.)

This was pretty well encapsulated in two paragraphs:

> In the same way, everything about the crypto economy is worse than the regular economy. The only excuse is that it’s decentralized. This means you can use it for all of those cool things - sending remittances, circumventing corrupt banking systems, resisting authoritarian governments - that are hard to do with regular money. Of course subjecting yourself to a difficult constraint is going to be harder than not doing that!

> If nothing’s wrong with your country’s financial or political system, then you don’t need crypto. If you use crypto anyway, it will be worse than your regular financial system, because it’s trading off many things you need (efficiency, speed, safety, the good kinds of regulation) for something you don’t need (avoiding the bad kinds of regulation).

I still think NFTs are silly though.

TheBrokenRail··on Apple introduces end-to-end encryption for backups
Everyone uses Google Play because it's convenient. But as a notable example, Fortnite refused to use Google Play for a while precisely because of that 30% fee, and it worked out pretty well for them. Eventually they gave in and put Fortnite on Google Play. Although Google kicked them off later (they pushed an update which allowed users to bypass Google's 30% cut using their own payment system) so it's back to direct download from the website.
TheBrokenRail··on Apple introduces end-to-end encryption for backups
Apple has a lot of things going for it, but let's not pretend they're perfect and anyone who doesn't use their products is unreasonable.

iOS still doesn't allow you to sideload without shenanigans (requiring your to not only have a Mac, but also have it resign any custom apps every week is beyond unreasonable). Some people don't care about that, but I do and not being able to do so is 100% a dealbreaker for me.

Not using Apple because you disagree with their decisions does not make one intentionally "going out of their way to swim up river." It just makes one a normal person who doesn't want to use, what it to them, an inferior product.

> the don't care to scan your pictures with AI 20 different ways

This is especially ironic as another post on the HN front-page today is about Apple giving up on their plan to scan iCloud photos for CSAN after months of pushback.

TheBrokenRail··on Samsung’s Android app-signing key has leaked, is being used to sign malware
Apple doing what they do is the main reason I will never buy an iPhone. It's my phone and I should be able to install whatever I want on it.
TheBrokenRail··on Samsung’s Android app-signing key has leaked, is being used to sign malware
While it's obviously bad that people are making malware with this key, I do wonder if there could be a silver lining. Samsung and Google lock a lot of cool permissions behind system apps. I wonder if you could use this key to sign you own apps (or make modified versions of existing system apps) and get the benefits of rooting without actually rooting (especially on devises that don't allow unlocking the bootloader)?
TheBrokenRail··on Fosshost Is Shutting Down
> there is a single executive who cannot be held accountable

I mean, they can be held accountable. That's what law enforcement is for, to hold these people and firms accountable.

TheBrokenRail··on Fosshost Is Shutting Down
Having a mental health crisis should not mean that you're free of consequences. It's not like random people are driving up to their house to harass them, they're reporting them to a regulatory body who will investigate themselves and prosecute if needed. And if they are having a mental health crisis, they should be able to plea insanity.

All is this is compounded by the fact that, at least according to another commenter, they're head of operations at another company.

If someone in control of a lot of money with duties to other just vanishes (and according to other commenters, they do have legal duties in the UK), they should face consequences. People didn't donate to Fosshost so one person can disappear and take their money with them.

TheBrokenRail··on Fosshost Is Shutting Down
Yeah, GitHub definitely has its issues. But I can be fairly certain that GitHub's CEO isn't going to suddenly go AWOL and have GitHub lose all funding.
TheBrokenRail··on Advent of Code 2022 is nigh
I'm excited to try again this year! Last year, I only got 7 days done before getting distracted because of how crazy December is.
TheBrokenRail··on Forgejo – Launching a Fork of Gitea
While the seeming lack of communication from the Gitea owners (see the Gitea open letter) is a bit worrying, it does seem a bit premature to fork and potentially fragment the community before they've actually done anything.
TheBrokenRail··on Compiler Errors for Humans (2015)
While those are funny, I'd hate using a compiler that actually gave me error messages like that.
TheBrokenRail··on IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up
> Only if the server has been boosted enough to allow for it. Boosts = paying money.

This just isn't true.

I'm on a server which has never been boosted and I can scroll back all the way to the server's creation with no limits.

TheBrokenRail··on IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up
This just isn't true.

I'm on a server which has never been boosted and I can scroll back all the way to the server's creation with no limits.

TheBrokenRail··on IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up
> For limited definitions of 'preserves' if you aren't a paying user.

What do you mean by this? I don't pay for Discord and I have never had any issues scrolling as far back as I want to.

> Not really, you can't tell who pinged you half the time (and this is a common complaint from most everyone in a discord server with 70+K members.)

Personally I have notifications disabled so I can't comment on that, but both the web client and the Android app have a specific view to list all past pings or replies.

> Limited ones unless you get a bot to add in granularity (such as duration of moderation action.) I can think of a few HTTP chat sites from the late 90s that had better moderation for all users (and a reverse-ignore feature, which seems to have just disappeared from everyone's collective memory.)

While limited, they are there by default and pretty convenient. And they're getting better.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →