HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

TheMog

168 karma · joined July 13, 2015

Professional software engineer and engineering manager for nearly 30 years. Can't remember where the time went, but is looking forward to the next 30 years.
submissionscomments
TheMog··on Ask HN: Ever been hired through a “who's hiring” post?
Depends if you're a world class bullshitter or not :).

You've pretty much hit the nail on the head about the filters - they have some arbitrariness to them, and most people outside (and, if my experience is anything to go by, inside) HR use filters that work for them based on experience in the past. I'm not saying they are fair and unbiased (they aren't), but they work for that particular person.

I for example would perfectly OK with you emailing me (if I were hiring, which I'm not) a cover email that says something like "I have the skills you're looking for, I like the area your company is in, and I'm looking for a job that allows me to bring my dog to work and have a work/life balance". That's again specific to the hiring manager tho', I'd take refreshing honesty over someone trying to visibly BS me any day.

What a lot of people don't immediately see is that if a company is hiring, they're not looking to hire your resume - they're hiring a person (which a specific skill set) that they're going to spend 8-10h/day with. A cover email can convey more about you personally than a list of past accomplishments.

TheMog··on Ask HN: Ever been hired through a “who's hiring” post?
Data, as in carefully curated and collected? No, I don't. I admire your approach but I've never taken it this far.

What I have is interviewing lots and lots of people over a couple of decades, first contributing to hiring decisions and eventually making them myself. As developers you see patterns emerge and you start making use of them. For a halfway efficient review process you have to make a first pass over the resume submissions and whittle the pile down to a manageable size quickly, making use of patterns spotted in the past.

In that respect, my experience tells me that "no cover email at all" = "shotgunned resume to every job listing" = "not a good fit". That might not always be the case, but it's an 80/20 rule. Yes, I'll potentially overlook a couple of qualified candidates, but I'm probably already doing this after work instead of spending time with my family because I've decided to essentially circumvent the HR department.

Part of the cover letter conundrum is that if you come in through the front door (ie, the official job listing curated by HR), your resume is likely landing in some HR system and the hiring manager might not even see it. In that case, it's a total waste of effort.

If you're coming in through the "back door", say, via a post here on Hacker News, there is a good chance that your first contact is the actual hiring manager. She or he will probably at least skim your cover email.

TheMog··on Ask HN: Experience vs. Education?
I never completed my CS bachelor's degree and despite 25+ years experience as a professional developer and development manager, I still run into (usually large) companies that will immediately filter out my resume due to the lack of a degree. OTOH I have managed to get jobs that on paper required a master or PhD - it all depends on the company.

When I hire people I look for the right combination of theoretical knowledge and successful practical application of said knowledge. Personally I don't care if you got the theory part from watching videos of MIT lectures and reading books, or from a classroom.

TheMog··on Ask HN: Ever been hired through a “who's hiring” post?
I'm not sure it's confirmation bias, but if it is multiple people have had the same experience.

For the last two jobs I got by actually actively seeking out an opening rather than being contacted by a recruiter, I only send out 2-3 applications each, but with a cover email that was custom to each company.

On one occasion I had a 100% interview rate, on the second one a 66% one (1 out of the three companies had an automated screening system and I'm pretty sure I was too expensive for them).

TheMog··on Ask HN: Ever been hired through a “who's hiring” post?
Well, it works both ways.

You might send out 20 resumes. As a hiring manager - especially when using a "no filter" approach like posting on here (keep in mind that IME people posting jobs on Hacker News are more likely doing "guerilla hiring" and circumvent their HR departments) - I easily get 100+ resumes, and I don't have days to spend trawling through them. I think it was rands of randsinrepose who mentioned before that the average time an HR person or a manager gets to spend on figuring out if a deeper dive is worth it is about 30s.

So I have to filter them by something. If you as an applicant - who would like at least an interview with me -can't even put in the effort to write in a few sentences that tell me why I should look at your resume, I somehow have to assume that you'll put in similar effort after I hire you. That's not a good first impression and IMHO it counts when you're dealing with a hiring manager as opposed to an HR department.

Keep in mind I'm not asking you to write a cover novel. Put yourself in my shoes and tell me which of the resumes you'd look at if you have only limited time:

1. The one that says

"My resume attached", or fewer words to that effect

2. The one that says

"Hey, I'm applying for your job opening because I love writing web apps in Ruby on Rails with a ClojureScript front end".

TheMog··on Ask HN: Ever been hired through a “who's hiring” post?
A post from "the other side of the table" :).

The previous company I worked at, I hired two people through who's hiring posts. We pretty much tried it out for about six months as we didn't have much luck through the more traditional channels our division's HR department used. So yes, there are real positions being filled through these posts.

That said, just because it's on Hacker News and this is an informal place doesn't mean you don't need to put at least a little effort into your application. I don't think I ever received that many emails in response to a job posting that didn't even contain one complete sentence to go with the resume. I seem to remember that I received multiple emails from candidates that contained fewer than five words. The best one was the one that just contained a random link (presumably to his/her resume, but I didn't need to click on a potential phishing link that badly), no words, nothing else...

The two people who ended up getting hired (one a very junior developer, the other one a mid-level developer) wrote informal cover emails that showed signs of intelligent life at the other end of the keyboard, much like you'd expect from someone trying to apply for a job :).

TheMog··on Ask HN: Why does Google get away with such bad recruiting practices?
I've interviewed there a couple of times over the years and I was less than impressed by the process.

Doesn't stop people from applying and they seem to end up with the candidates they want, so it's probably working for them. They have to standardize on some process, this one seems to produce the desired results and with the number of candidates they get, I assume that they're not worried about false negatives, but are worried about false positives...

TheMog··on Ask HN: Why does Google get away with such bad recruiting practices?
Unless that's changed very recently, they seem to be convinced that the perceived prestige of working for Google is worth a lot and thus they can get away with paying average or below average. At least that's been my experience.
TheMog··on Ask HN: Is it possible to run your own mail server for personal use?
Good point, although that's a different rant after I found out that my ISP has an IPV6 enabled backbone but won't allegedly roll out IPV6 to their clients until late this year.
TheMog··on Ask HN: Is it possible to run your own mail server for personal use?
Being able to use a previously unused IP address is usually a good thing, pity that there are so few of those left.

ISPs definitely seem to have an impact as well, but some spamfilters at least used to automatically assign a negative score to anything originating from an IP block used by an ISP for domestic Internet connections.

TheMog··on Ask HN: Is it possible to run your own mail server for personal use?
That's a very good suggestion. I pretty much do that every time I make setup changes.
TheMog··on Ask HN: Is it possible to run your own mail server for personal use?
I've been running my own MTA for about 15 years now, so it's definitely possible without spending the majority of one's waking hours to do so.

Even when I switched mail server IPs twice over the last few years I didn't run into the issues you ran into. A large part of it depends on where you run it - if you, say, run it on your home Internet connection that's usually an immediate strike against you because of the insane number of spammers using backdoor'd PCs to do exactly that.

The only time I ran an MTA out of my home was when I was on a commercial ISP with a fixed IP address, that seemed to be good enough for most services including gmail and hotmail.

These days I run my MTA on a VPS with a reputable hosting provider and don't seem to have that many issues with outgoing mails marked as spam.

SPF and DKIM are pretty much a must these days, so that's a good starting point, as are the rest of the precautions you already too. I assume you're using your own domain, how "old" is that domain? That might also have an impact giving how many phishers and spammers register odd domains and use them for a short amount of time. I've used the same domain since about 1999 so that could make a difference.

I use postfix instead of qmail, but I've used qmail in the past. Both work well and are easier to configure than sendmail or exim IMHO. On top of that I do run amavisd/spamassassin/clamav for the incoming emails as well.

One more thing I've got set up that I didn't see in your list is that I've got TLS set up with a non-self signed certificate for both incoming and outgoing email. I suspect that this also makes a difference even if the other email server won't request a client certificate (most, if not all, won't). Certainly shows up when I send an email over to gmail.

My biggest issues these days are more with incoming email:

- You'll never get to the level of spam filtering that, say, gmail offers. To me, that's OK

- I use greylisting to weed out a lot of the spam that would normally make it through spamassassin, but unfortunately that's when you find out how many people have misconfigured servers that bounce emails when they encounter temporary failures

TheMog··on Ask HN: Interview tomorrow – How to learn whether an org is “healthy”?
I would definitely ask them to elaborate on the communcations issues.

I would also ask how they're currently handling three teams on three continents - if you as a manager are supposed to deal with all three teams and at least one of them is "needy", I wouldn't be surprised if the communications issue is that the current manager is speaking in tongues because he hasn't had more than an hour's worth of sleep a night for the past year...

TheMog··on Ask HN: Moving overseas to a 250kb/s connection, any life hacks?
If you're dealing with Unixy systems, resort to the command line and also use something like tmux or screen to preserve the session when (not if) you're getting disconnected.
TheMog··on Ask HN: What to do after failing final interviews twice?
As a lot of people have already said, even getting to an on-site with either of these companies is an accomplishment in itself. I've had on-sites at both and like you, I've been turned down. Doesn't stop Amazon from coming back to me with different job opportunities about once a year.

Keep in mind that in most cases you will not be given the real reason for rejection (mostly as a lawsuit-avoidance measure) but something vague like "not qualified" (which can mean anything starting from a wrong haircut to the interviewer bearing a grudge against your school) or "decided to go with another candidate". Heck, I've been told by an employer that they'd found an internal candidate for the position only to find out nine months later via the grapevine that the rejection happened the exact day a hiring freeze with "rightsizing" had been instituted.

You're not a loser, otherwise you wouldn't have made it in there in first place. What it means is that on this particular day, the stars didn't align for you.

TheMog··on Ask HN: When should you quit?
I'm considerably older than you (47, still a software developer because I like it) and I think you're being too harsh on yourself. You also need do do something about that burn out - that's a different point

Let's look at the "too harsh on yourself" part. So you're not the founder of a Unicorn startup that you started in your dorm room at an ivy league college. You know what that makes you? It makes you a perfectly normal person who has decided to follow your entrepreneurial instincts instead of getting the development version of a McJob. That's highly commendable.

It also may have not worked out in the way you wanted it to work out because you're not filthy rich and cruising around on a Megayacht (or whatever else your dream is). That is the case for most entrepreneurs - my first endeavour bombed so badly I ended up paying for it until about six years ago (ie, for over 10 years) after the lawsuits and and the other not fun stuff. But I also gained something extremely valuable called experience. I've since had a couple of other companies that made money, and it actually made me more valuable as an employee because I learned entrepreneurial skills that I wouldn't have otherwise.

Not being an overnight success is actually an advantage in my book - the lessons you learned are important and will massively increase your chances to succeed in the future.

One thing I've learned over time is that you need balance in your life, and you can only achieve that if you do more than one thing. To me it sounds like you've poured everything you have into a single vessel (work) and now that work didn't provide the results you expected, you're staring at emptiness because there isn't anything else.

So, first advice is to find something else you're interested in and give it some time in your life. Don't try to make it another business, but something you expressly do to counter your 100% concentration on building software. That'll help you with the burnout for the simple reason that it allows you to switch of the "tech" part of your brain.

In my case, I work on cars, I build track cars for myself and I do use them as intended. I'll never make a decent race car driver but that's not the point - it helps me balance my life, and it scratches the itch of creation and gets me away from computers. Same goes for the other things I do away from development like gardening and reading non-computing books.

BTW, you're not too old. Nobody ever is.

That said, I am toying with the idea of doing something non-software for the next 20 years or so simply because it's getting to the point for me where very few companies are willing to pay for the sort of experience and craftsmanship I can bring to the table. So I'm developing some other interests that may or may not turn into a second and third career.

TheMog··on Ask HN: How do prolific programmers go about their daily lives?
I've been coding since we considered 8 bits a luxury and I'm still at it (I'm 47 now). I do it because I enjoy it and because I'm pretty good at it, plus it affords a decent lifestyle.

There are a couple of important points I've learned along the way that might help you:

1) Some people can code productively 24/7, but those are very few and far between. For starters, they have the skill to concentrate hard for a long time and work in an environment where that is feasible. It's not feasible if the next cubicle over has a sales person in it who spends ten hours a day on the phone. Second, most of them tend to do it in bursts as it's extremely hard and draining to sustain that level of concentration and effort for hours and days on end. What you see is often the output from the bursts, but you don't see that they're then spending a fair amount of time doing different things so they can recharge their brains.

2) It's easier to do this when you're young and pull a couple of all nighters a week. This makes you a hero, especially in places that thrive on hero-based development, but you have to realize you're burning the candle at both ends. As you age and build up experience, you tend to be more productive simply because of your experience, but you're also not necessarily that willing and suited to pulling 16 hour days for extended periods of time.

3) Most importantly, your brain is a muscle. Exercising it improves its function much like exercising your body improves its function, but it also needs rest. If you look at the way top athletes train, they push themselves hard but they also allow for sufficient rest periods. It's the combination of exercise and rest that leads to the improvement. Take one or the other away and you either overextend yourself (and injure yourself) or you don't grow as much.

Yes, I read about programming and play with languages during my off time, but I try to satisfy my need to build things (which is what initially drew me into software) by working on physical things instead. Things like building/restoring a car or motorcycle, gardening, working on the honey-do list etc. Oddly enough they're not too dissimilar from programming as you still end up solving problems.

TL;DR - find a way to switch off, be it through meditation or whatever else works for you. Get enough rest and exercise the other parts of your body. Learn to recognize the signs of burning out and stop the journey before you get there.

TheMog··on Ask HN: I've constantly changed companies. Would I be considered unreliable?
It raises a bunch of red flags to hiring managers myself. In every job there are parts that are somewhere between mind-numbing and straight out boring, but that doesn't mean they don't need to get done. If you're leaving jobs after a short time because you're bored, that makes people think you're lacking the stamina that's necessary to be successful longer term.

I personally have a decade on my resume where I changed jobs quite frequently. Most of them were contract or consulting work so by the very nature of them, they were short term. Some people take issue with that, others note the fact that I had no downtime between contracts and choose to ignore the frequent changes.

I don't mind junior candidates who change jobs a few times early in their careers as I see that as them getting their bearings, but once people figured out what they want to do, I expect job tenures to lengthen or at least expect people to have a good explanation as to why they kept moving on.

You prefer to do short term consulting work over long term jobs? Fine with me. You joined a bunch of startups that ran out of money after a year? OK.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2