HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

TheMonarchist

64 karma · joined July 23, 2021

Someone's interests should be in line with those of the country.
submissionscomments
TheMonarchist··on Ask HN: Do All Programming Languages Have Features That No One Should Use?
> C is 50 years old -- if we hadn't learned how to do it better in that time, I'd be worried!

The better C would be C++ without the ancient baggage it keeps dragging for backward compatibility. The most recent standards have dropped some of it already.

TheMonarchist··on Ask HN: How would a programming language look if designed by non-programmer
> I think you're missing my point

I just don't object to anything but that one question.

> Word has had an outline mode since at least 1995

I haven't had Word for years so I can't check it out, but if you take WYSIWYG out of a WYSIWYG editor, what is left? Why would I use it instead of other tools you listed? I have used some of them.

TheMonarchist··on Ask HN: Life Changing Books?
https://www.soulwinning.info/bible/kjb/pce.htm looks promising
TheMonarchist··on Ask HN: Why are there so few single-letter command line utilities / tools?
Unix was created on a PDP-7. Two letters was generous considering that they had to use an electromechanical terminal. They also had only 4K words of store in the beginning so they wouldn't run out of meaningful shorthands.
TheMonarchist··on Ask HN: How would a programming language look if designed by non-programmer
> Today, people have Word and Google Docs, why do they need troff/Markdown/TeX/LaTeX/Asciidoc/org-mode/etc.?

Because what they write has structure and they don't want to be distracted by the looks.

TheMonarchist··on SF gets $1.5M to experiment with online voting, EFF others horrified
(I have been busy lately, and postponed this answer, as you also wrote that you end your part. You may consider any questions rhetorical.)

> > The point is that trying to control what others may say, see or hear is suspicious. That's what the whole paragraph is about. It would likely hurt your cause.

> I'm assuming what you're being coy about here is that the current election system hides voters' votes from them?

I meant it as related to fighting misinformation in general. Here's the context where it was used: "Yea, so unwilling they are to communicate the Scriptures to the people’s understanding in any sort, that they are not ashamed to confess that we forced them to translate it into English against their wills. This seemeth to argue a bad cause, or a bad conscience, or both. Sure we are, that it is not he that hath good gold, that is afraid to bring it to the touchstone, but he that hath the counterfeit; neither is it the true man that shunneth the light, but the malefactor, lest his deeds should be reproved; neither is it the plaindealing merchant that is unwilling to have the weights, or the meteyard, brought in place, but he that useth deceit." Papists tried to protect people from what they deemed heresy (ie. misinformation) by withholding the Bible from them and punishing whomever they apprehended of those spreading it, but that way they lost whatever credibility they still had. Of course they were wrong anyway, but I don't recall any historical cases where the users of similar tactics would have turned out to be right.

However I do believe that the ability to see that your own vote was counted would help trust the election result. That's basically the aim of my scheme.

> > If you can't win that way, your chances are slim no matter what you do. Btw, you can change a few words and get what Papists probably thought when people began reading the Bible: "The Inquisition spends millions to root out heresy, and it definitely isn't keeping up. Other problems that require millions to fix are thought to be crises, and I think we should start thinking of heresy in general as a crisis."

> This is dismissive and contributes nothing. There are core differences between the Inquisition (?) and sending texts to people telling them when and where they can vote.

I just wanted to point out how similar your description is to what it must have looked like to Papists in the 17th century.

> Your argument distills to "truth wins out" and I'm saying there's lots of good evidence to the contrary.

I do believe that truth must prevail in the end; there are no eternal lies. Truth resurfaces like a cork from the flood of lies. Nevertheless, "there is enough light for those who only desire to see, and enough obscurity for those who have a contrary disposition." Blaise Pascal. It seems to be a law of nature.

> I think you're trying to reason through this from your understanding and first principles, but a lot of things in life are non-intuitive, especially to non-experts.

Life already feels too short to learn all that I would like to, so I aim for general instead of specific knowledge. In practice I learn new things when I need to, or when they are irresistibly interesting.

> What usually happens in compulsory voting is that voters just scratch their ballots, the incidence of that is super low in Australia, it's a non-issue.

That's just what I said would happen. People scratch ballots when they don't want to support anyone and are afraid to NOT appear at the polling station. Otherwise they wouldn't bother to come or would try to at least minimise evil.

> You keep trying to make a link between totalitarianism and compulsory voting

Compulsory voting is totalitarian; everybody votes.

> (are you seriously taking issue with like, Australia being a democracy)?

Haven't there been mass protests for months? They find need to crowd the streets during a pandemic? Anyway this is digressing, for the state of democracy in Australia is mainly about the accuracy of Democracy Index, that you brought up to support compulsory voting, and "testing shows the presence, not the absence of bugs." Dijkstra. For that I find good arguments more convicting than experimental data. There are more commendable remedies to issues that compulsory voting is supposed to solve, and what cannot be solved without it isn't worth solving. Should important decisions really be made by people that wouldn't even come if they didn't have to?

> Why wouldn't every voter just do this? I'd love to get paid for the votes I was going to make anyway.

I don't doubt that, but the incentive would work only as long as payers give the tokens to use; otherwise everyone would try to get paid by looking up a token used to vote their candidate. Punishing those who try with an already cashed token would discourage also those who bring their own token, as they can't know if someone already cashed it.

> This is essentially compulsory voting but with carrots rather than sticks.

Paying voted candidates support proportional to the number of votes would also be a carrot but only for those that have a candidate they would like to support. It's the closest thing to compulsory voting that I think I could be comfortable with.

> OK to be clear [vote buying] can still be a problem in real small elections

In very small elections voters usually come to one place, where all ballots go to the same box and are counted under all eyes. The system is completely transparent without linking voters to ballots, but becomes impractical when the number of voters increases.

> I'm pretty convinced [the token system] is unworkably complicated

How would the added complexity improve the system? I'm not going to add complications just because complexity sells better.

> 1. Without a list of valid voters, you can't protect against ballot box stuffing. States build such lists through voter registration.

I think this and public records of who voted are the state of the art means to prevent ballot stuffing; the number of ballots should match the number of voters. It however won't protect against tampering with existing ballots, which my scheme aims to prevent. I'm not against them and I think they can be used together with my system.

> To prevent ballot box stuffing, a ballot secrecy system can link with the voter registration system, but that moots ballot secrecy because it links a ballot to an identity. You get to pick: ballot secrecy or no ballot box stuffing.

> The problem is there's a database that proves a vote in the big bag of votes belongs to a person.

I don't believe that linking a ballot to a voter is necessary. It is enough that a voter can recognise his own ballot; he can't prove that it is his own. The only way to prove it would be predicting its first use. Also showing such a prediction afterwards wouldn't prove it, for he could have made myriads of predictions for then available tokens and show the one that happened.

> Polls are done on either side of intimidation (and misinformation) campaigns because people want to know if their spend worked and what messages were most effective, so there's a lot of ceteris paribus happening.

Even so you know only what voters report.

> Go into this with the assumption that you're probably wrong, but you want to know exactly how

I will probably make a minimal effort proof of concept to have something concrete that can be critiqued more easily than abstract ideas.

> Given that you're probably wrong, don't make it the cornerstone of anything important

The usual no warranty clause should discourage serious use at least early on.

~~~

To sum it up, different voting systems make different trade offs. The aftermath of 2020 elections could happen in any country. If my scheme ever gets that far, I think the first country candidates for adopting it would be those, whose current systems are most similar to mine, even those where ballots are publicly available for recounting. Most problems made possible by my system would be already possible with their current system, so they should be well prepared to handle them.

TheMonarchist··on YouTube deleting comments who criticize their hiding of the dislike count
I was thinking of something like (upvotes+1) / (downvotes+1). Adding 1 to denominator is necessary to avoid division by 0. Adding it to numerator too balances it out and makes varying number of downvotes visible in spite of 0 upvotes.

Controversial posts would get a score near 1 instead of fluctuating. You would also get a rough idea of intensity as more ratios become possible when the number of votes increases.

I think it's still simple enough to be transparent to most users.

TheMonarchist··on YouTube deleting comments who criticize their hiding of the dislike count
> The difference between 102+/100- votes and 2+/0- votes is large, but invisible on this site.

I wonder whether using a ratio instead of difference would help?

TheMonarchist··on SF gets $1.5M to experiment with online voting, EFF others horrified
> Not to be snippy here but, whoever wrote the Bible clearly lived in an era before Fox News and conservative talk radio. They are anything but afraid.

The point is that trying to control what others may say, see or hear is suspicious. That's what the whole paragraph is about. It would likely hurt your cause.

> > Generally I think the most effective way to combat misinformation is spreading correct information and trusting that people can discern the truth.

> Democrats and non-partisan organizations spend millions of dollars trying this, and it definitely isn't keeping up. Other problems that require millions of dollars to fix are thought to be crises, and I think we should start thinking of misinformation in general as a crisis.

If you can't win that way, your chances are slim no matter what you do. Btw, you can change a few words and get what Papists probably thought when people began reading the Bible: "The Inquisition spends millions to root out heresy, and it definitely isn't keeping up. Other problems that require millions to fix are thought to be crises, and I think we should start thinking of heresy in general as a crisis."

> Your other counter arguments are essentially: compulsory voting doesn't fix everything. Fortunately for me, that's not my claim.

Hiding indifference and possible demand for fresh ideas is detrimental. People don't get involved in new political movements if it seems that almost everybody is content to vote the status quo. And that's what it would seems like: you need to fill ballot anyway so you try to at least pick the least evil.

> Here are the Democracy Index scores of the countries they list (I've omitted 3 micro-states and 3 cities):

Wikipedia has a criticism section on Democracy Index that reads: "Investment analyst Peter Tasker has criticised the Democracy Index for lacking transparency and accountability beyond the numbers." It may be based on gut feelings of unnamed experts. Compulsory voting may have fooled them to some extent.

Beside this I'm going to just ignore it as I never meant that the list would predict their standing in some ranking. Just that it didn't change how I view compulsory voting, but it did change my views of countries on the list (when it was new to me).

> If you believe there are organizations out there that would pay for votes, why don't you believe there are organizations that would pay people to do this?

I expect that making a fool of oneself publicly and taking the risk of the conspiracy being exposed, would cost a lot more than a vote.

> So someone exploiting this system would have to --

You seem to think of a scenario where the buyers have a list of bribed voters and tokens they should use. Such a list would be highly suspicious if discovered. I have been thinking that they would pay the voter after reporting voting by the token they gave and can verify.

> The reason people don't do it isn't because it's unverifiable, it's because it's impossible to keep secret at the scale where it would matter, and you go to jail if you try.

That reminds me of something I read from a detective: the difficulty of concealing a conspiracy increases as more people get involved. In that case vote buying isn't a problem at all.

> How do people get tokens? Don't they have to be unique? You can't just scratch a token in there because you might pick a non-unique one, tanking the whole system.

The token space should be large enough to make collisions unlikely. Recording the polling station used to cast the vote would limit the uniqueness requirement to that station, but it isn't as difficult as it sounds.

There are over 500 trillion (2*49) unique 7x7 bitmaps. Chances are that 16 million such tokens randomly generated are all unique. The number of 9x9 bitmaps is 2*81, and a trillion random ones are likely all unique.

> (or they might put identifiable information in there)

It's their choice.

> I can also imagine all kinds of extra guidance you'd have to give like "don't use the same token across multiple elections because then a corrupt mayor can see that you really do check your number" or whatever else.

People could search their own from a table of votes cast on a particular polling station without revealing which is their own. Also people that need a new token would check that nobody used their new token.

> I think this system has some serious logistics to plan out.

Right now it's just an idea.

> But more broadly, I think you wildly overestimate how much voters are able and willing to do any of this.

If you settle for ballot confidentiality, you have more options for verifying results. But if you insist on ballot secrecy - which many countries do - only the voters themselves can verify the results.

> You keep tacking on tactics voters can employ to attempt to foil corruption, effectively asking more of voters to solve a non-existent problem.

If the problem is non-existent, voters need not solve it. My scheme just aims to give them a way to solve it if they really want to.

> We already have ballot secrecy and we still have bonkers voter intimidation.

What you have is ballot confidentiality, if, as you said earlier, you have "a system that maps voters to votes".

> (it's actually almost impossible to do this)

It depends on how well they know each other.

> to suppress the votes of people who vote Democrat (way) more likely than not.

That's either based on (unreliable) polling data, or actual votes of those the intimidators failed to turn away. Those that they managed to intimidate could have voted differently.

TheMonarchist··on Constructors and evil initializers in C++
> That type achieves nothing.

The idea of taking params that can't be invalid is that validity is enforced by class invariant.

> std::sort doesn't return an instance of Sorted

It can't, because it sorts in place and therefore has no control over the sequence. Sorted constructor would sort to guarantee success.

TheMonarchist··on Constructors and evil initializers in C++
> Maybe the situation has gotten better since constexpr was introduced, though.

Since C++11? Yes.

> even something like 'this array must be sorted' encoded fully in types is going to add a lot to your program's length

  template< class Cmp, class Array> class Sorted;// The type of your parameter.
I think this could be implemented even in C++03.
TheMonarchist··on SF gets $1.5M to experiment with online voting, EFF others horrified
> It's not actually hard at all. There are two major forms of voter intimidation: the cops will lock you up, and someone will beat you up. Generally voters are made aware of these possibilities with phone calls, emails, direct mail, and police/vigilante presence at polling places. These things are easy to outlaw, in fact they're already illegal!

Those are clear cases and I would have been surprised if they had not been crimes already.

> We just need cops to enforce the laws. If you're gonna say that'll take more than money, then I'd agree with you.

As any crime it must be proved in court to convince the culprit.

> People assume this is about learning how someone voted, but you can actually just keep certain people from voting and achieve that result.

Ballot secrecy still more than halves the effects of voter intimidation. Instead of making people vote certain way, you can only keep them from voting because you don't know how they would vote. Such intimidators could actually harm their preferred candidate.

> you tell women that their husbands will find out how they voted

Admittedly this is something ballot secrecy can't fix, but neither can legislation. Married couples spend a lot of time together privately, leaving ample opportunity for intimidation with little risk of getting caught.

> Because unless you get enough people to use the token (and use it perfectly), you can fudge the margin enough to win.

Of course, but you have to fudge it in the database too to avoid detection. Also you can alter only the counts of popular tokens (such as no token) without detection. People could give a token with no intent to check it just to prevent exactly this. For that corrupt mayor can't know which tokens are really checked, so he can manipulate only the counts of popular tokens or risk getting caught.

> 2,000 people used the token, but 500 of them misremembered it, and when they went looking their vote wasn't there.

To help their memory they could keep a copy of the token with the risk of someone discovering it.

> I know your argument here is such kingpins would force voters to use new tokens and we'd detect it, but 1 no we wouldn't because we couldn't disambiguate that from population changes or people just being forgetful, and 2 tokens would either be tied to a single election or contain a voting history so you wouldn't need a new one anyway

If they allowed using an existing token, they wouldn't know whether the voter they pay used it or someone else just happened to vote as they wanted.

The effect of population changes could be detected from the records of who voted. Forgetfulness is a real confounding factor but it shouldn't vary much between elections.

> "hey my vote isn't in the system!"

They would be mostly ignored unless they would be numerous, as anyone that cares could just check whether his own vote was counted.

> I suggest starting here [1].

They point at demographic underrepresentation as grounds for compulsory voting. I think members of underrepresented groups just vote by their feet; they don't have a candidate they would vote, and compulsory voting won't give them one. It would end up being exactly the kind of facelift I would call keeping up appearance of working democracy.

There's also a list of countries with compulsory voting. I think it tells more of those countries than of compulsory voting. Also some discontinued historical cases are mentioned. In my mind those weigh far more than current adopters. It's not hard to imagine that people don't want to go through the trouble of voting if their options are "more of the same" and "even more of the same".

> this kind of misinformation is usually incorrect polling place information or time--sometimes it's more creative like "drop your ballot off at this (fake) mailbox", but that kind of thing is rare. Again this is also super illegal (the FEC exists for a reason), we just need cops to enforce the laws.

Those are again pretty obvious cases and I would have been surprised if they weren't crimes already. I suppose apprehending the perpetrators could be difficult, especially if they are foreign agents. I think you would also have to prove intent, though arguably if you are going to spread such info in writing, it would be reasonable to check that you at least got it right.

Generally I think the most effective way to combat misinformation is spreading correct information and trusting that people can discern the truth.

Sure we are, that it is not he that hath good gold, that is afraid to bring it to the touchstone, but he that hath the counterfeit. -- KJV Translators To The Reader, ¶ The unwillingness of our chief adversaries that the Scriptures should be divulged in the mother tongue, &c.

TheMonarchist··on Constructors and evil initializers in C++
The proper solution would be taking parameters that can't be invalid; it pushes validity check to the call site.
TheMonarchist··on SF gets $1.5M to experiment with online voting, EFF others horrified
> One of the (many) issues I have with cryptographic vote verification systems is that they don't prove there isn't a "second set of books" that all checks out, meanwhile we use the crooked books to determine who won.

How could you fail to use the totals indicated by the database and not get caught?

> I know these schemes are way, way more trouble than they're worth and either hinder a lot of the techniques we currently use to verify elections, or make political firestorms that make the election process even more fragile than it already is way more likely.

Don't worry; I'm not going to spend the rest of my life pushing my scheme forward. I might make a toy implementation that people can use for vanity voting with friends. It might gain traction and wider acceptance that way.

> I also strongly support compulsory voting

That reminds me of Soviet Russia and satellites that always had 90+% turnouts. I can't imagine any reason for compulsory voting beside maintaining a facade of popular support for the system. There's a difference between returning invalid ballot and not voting; in the latter case you shouldn't appear on the list of voters.

> law enforcement initiatives against voter intimidation

I think the hard part isn't agreeing that voter intimidation is bad. The hard part is specifying what constitutes voter intimidation. I doubt that legislation could root it out, and there's a working solution to it: ballot secrecy. Ballot confidentiality isn't good enough, as someone could tell voters that an inside man will check how they voted.

> and misinformation

Carefulness here is essential to avoid sliding to an Orwellian dystopy. I'm not sure what measures I would be comfortable with, and I don't wonder if legislators feel the same way.

TheMonarchist··on SF gets $1.5M to experiment with online voting, EFF others horrified
> Not everyone will use a token or remember it. If even 50% of voters do this 100% accurately, it still isn't statistically helpful.

I think this is its main weakness. Those who don't care enough to use a token would leave the token of zero effort (nothing) open for manipulations. Unless those are few, this system won't make the election more secure. It would however give those who care a way to ensure that their vote was counted, increasing public confidence in the results. For I assume that those who care enough to question the results also care enough to use a token and check it.

> It's also worth saying that if there's any problem with this system, it calls the entire election into question, even if the election itself was fine or statistically far from error.

> You might look up your vote and think "shenanigans!", and there won't be any way of looking at your original ballot to find out what happened.

The token is only needed to identify a vote, so it could be dead simple, like a bitmap that could be a grid to be painted on paper ballot. It can be just added to existing systems.

> And even if there were, you still wouldn't have any way of verifying that your vote was included in the count.

How is querying the tokens used to vote what you voted, seeing your token in the list, and checking that the tokens make up the reported total not verifying it?

> We (especially in tech) focus myopically on election fraud in the US, as though that's the thing that would undermine the legitimacy of an election.

I think it's just because it seems like something that could be solved.

> I am 100% sure that even if we implemented this system, they would still work just as hard to undermine election legitimacy.

It would be a little harder when those who care can just check that their vote was counted.

> I think we'd both like to increase the legitimacy of elections --

It seems to me that we have somewhat different aims. You have zeal for democracy and are willing to compromise ballot secrecy to verify the election result. I accept that verifying it is impossible while maintaing the secrecy, unless everyone is willing to check that his vote was counted. In practice I would be content if everyone just had that possibility, as I don't have unrealistic expectations of its popularity.

TheMonarchist··on SF gets $1.5M to experiment with online voting, EFF others horrified
> All your system tells a voter is that there's a mapping somewhere of their key to their vote. It doesn't say that vote is included in the total.

It's a database of votes and tokens used to cast them. You could also query what tokens were used to vote X and check that they make up the total. You could see the token you used on the list of Y you voted.

> Implementing and maintaining this system, as well as training administrators how to use it, would cost millions of dollars, and lead to all kinds of controversies because people don't remember their votes all that well [1].

It's one thing to remember what you voted a few days after the election, and another to remember it months later when polled, which is what [1] is about. This system is meant to increase public confidence in the election result. Wouldn't you think it worth a few millions, considering the aftermath of 2020 elections?

> It's also worth saying whether or not your vote was counted is already public record, resulting in even less relative benefit for a system like this.

You are assured that it is counted, but with this scheme you could easily check that there's a vote cast with token you used.

Btw, this system sort of exists already in countries where you write the candidate's name or number on the ballot, and ballots are publicly available for recounting; the token is your handwriting. It just isn't anonymous as someone else could also recognise it.

TheMonarchist··on SF gets $1.5M to experiment with online voting, EFF others horrified
Separation of concerns. My scheme doesn't address ballot stuffing because it can be done separately. Or how does it prohibit addressing it?
TheMonarchist··on The Truth Shall Make You Free: Catholicism and the CIA
I don't see why not.
TheMonarchist··on C Is the Greenest Programming Language
I agree in sentiment, but those results are actually pretty close to what I expected to see.

Edit: I was most surprised to see Pascal on top, but that's probably due to it being very old. Back then it had to be fast by modern standards, to be usable on contemporary machines.

TheMonarchist··on SF gets $1.5M to experiment with online voting, EFF others horrified
They would make you use an unused token for certainty, so buying a significant number of votes could be observed statistically from unusually high numbers of new tokens.
TheMonarchist··on The Truth Shall Make You Free: Catholicism and the CIA
> instead it was found that the incompetence of party officials was even greater than one could have imagined.

If the famine was indeed due to sheer incompetence, it could be argued that they were victims of the revolution that set up that incredibly incompetent government.

TheMonarchist··on SF gets $1.5M to experiment with online voting, EFF others horrified
I have been pondering a scheme where each ballot would have a field for an arbitrary token in addition to the vote. After the election voters could query a database of what ballots were cast with some token. So they could check that their vote was counted without revealing who they voted. While people are poor randomness generators, those who happened to pick a popular token would just use another one in the next election.
TheMonarchist··on The Truth Shall Make You Free: Catholicism and the CIA
You seriously link wikipedia, that simply sides with the numbers of those angered by Chick attempting to convert some of their own, as an authoritative source on Chick Tracts?

To answer your question, obviously the ultimate authority on Popery would be Popes themselves. That link serves as a quick refresher on a) why Jesuits are the butt of so many conspiracy theories b) why they are "the interesting bit of Catholicism", for most content there is somehow related to them. Albeit one could also argue that clearly they aren't the only interesting bit, for all of it isn't related to them.

Edit: There's actually a category dedicated to Jesuits, but it has surprisingly few articles, presumably because they decided to give Alberto Rivera his own category. So multiple categories treat them nevertheless.

TheMonarchist··on The Truth Shall Make You Free: Catholicism and the CIA
I'm not quite sure what exactly you want backed up (nor did I write that), but from the top of my head https://www.chick.com/information/article-listing?subject=ca... might answer your question to some extent.
TheMonarchist··on Ask HN: How many laws are there in each country?
Corruptissima re publica plurimae leges. -- Tacitus, Annals

That is, a corrupt republic needs more laws.

As I would put it: d(lawcount)/d(depravity) > 0

TheMonarchist··on [dead]
Presumably vaccines affecting babies in the womb. Can't recall concrete examples.
TheMonarchist··on The Gunpowder Plot
I'm glad to hear that all of you don't wish that the plot had succeeded.
TheMonarchist··on The Gunpowder Plot
> Royals become royals by mass murder, then oppress the people they rule over.

That way they wouldn't remain royals for long. At minimum they must keep their army loyal. One would imagine that they would prefer a good cause to fight for, so oppression must be justified to them somehow. It's easier to just avoid intentional oppression.

> In France I would have been on the side of the revolutionaries for sure. You would side with the royals (and now I notice your username)?

I guess so. Good things are easy to break but difficult to create.

TheMonarchist··on The Gunpowder Plot
Thanks! I see it now. I couldn't picture it in my mind as it is so contrary to what I know.

> an equally oppressive government (just towards a different group of people).

Could you expand on this? I contrast the then contemporary government against the reign of Bloody Mary, and it's hard to see how it could have been as bad as what Papists would surely have done.

TheMonarchist··on Unprecedented decision – deliberately coughing at someone is a criminal assault
The short description of the incident in the article makes it sound like he removed mask to catch breath and happened to cough. People must be on their toes in Canada if that's true.

How do you distinguish deliberate coughing from uncontrollable cough?

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →