HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

TheSwordsman

1,839 karma · joined June 12, 2012

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/theckman; my proof: https://keybase.io/theckman/sigs/sdBoJTtBwPcwi1tpmyge7iA4vooZ1ZmTK_huiHJGylc ]
submissionscomments
TheSwordsman··on Gitlab cancels plan on tracking user behavior on GitLab.com
Telemetry is necessary to be able to observe the system, and look for adverse impact. You should be more thoughtful to the people supporting the tools you use, because without telemetry they do a bad job keeping it working for you.
TheSwordsman··on Go Module Mirror and Checksum Database Launched
I'm not sure a solution that solves 100% of the problems, with minimal to no side effects, is a poor solution.
TheSwordsman··on Ask HN: What do you do on an Android phone that cannot be done on an iPhone?
Google Voice native integration with the system dialer. When I click a phone number on a webpage or in a text, I can dial it from my Google Voice number. It doesn't seem as seamless on iOS.
TheSwordsman··on Go 1.13: xerrors
+1 on all of this. I really prefer that https://github.com/pkg/errors is outside of the standard library so I don't need to use the fmt.Errorf abomination.
TheSwordsman··on Mozilla is giving up on their IRC server
If the full conversation is retained what's the functional difference?
TheSwordsman··on Mozilla is giving up on their IRC server
Downside is that it's additional infrastructure that someone now needs to be on-call to support and pay for.

This is the main reason we aren't considering leaving Slack.

TheSwordsman··on Mozilla is giving up on their IRC server
Because Slack's product assumes you have an HR department, and that's an HR issue.
TheSwordsman··on Mozilla is giving up on their IRC server
I have another thread I commented on where I discuss Discord very briefly. Most times I used Discord I'm hella annoyed, Slack just has me slightly frustrated sometimes. To each their own, but the Discord UX doesn't do it for me.

That said, watching them migrate voice servers seamlessly between regions is fucking impressive, though. Kudos to them on that.

TheSwordsman··on Mozilla is giving up on their IRC server
Seeing that the context menu that comes up has about 20 items, I can't personally agree.

Overall I hate using Discord and wish it was more like Slack in some ways. Better yet, take me back to the days of TeamSpeak when my Voice Chats had a Text Chat implicitly alongside it.

TheSwordsman··on Mozilla is giving up on their IRC server
It is to me personally, as I use it to find answers to questions I don't know the answer to. At a minimum, I can point them to someone who had a similar problem in case they solved it.
TheSwordsman··on Mozilla is giving up on their IRC server
I've myself set to Offline permanently on Slack to try and deflect some of that. It seems to have worked for the most part.
TheSwordsman··on Mozilla is giving up on their IRC server
I think we need to be explicit, Slack isn't always conducive to the needs of open communities. Some of its features are extremely friendly to users, like having the possibility of full message history retention and mobile apps. But the former does require you be paid, and the latter is also possible with other solutions.
TheSwordsman··on Mozilla is giving up on their IRC server
I think if you make it clear the channel is logged it's the best you can do, since they can choose to partake in the conversation or not. No forcing function. The downside comes when you've a Netsplit and you lose one side of the conversation.

It does surprise me that some people are supporters of open source, but aren't supporters of open and transparent communication. Seems like a miss.

TheSwordsman··on Mozilla is giving up on their IRC server
Get your session key that's embedded in the HTML body after you log in. Be careful with this key since it has no expiry and can impersonate you as if you were connected via the default client, including undocumented API access. Find some application that can connect to the Slack RTM API and provide a chat TUI, using the session key you extracted.

I know there are a few out there, but can't personally recommend one.

TheSwordsman··on Mozilla is giving up on their IRC server
I use Discord all the time; it's a mess. Its permissions model is complex and hard to reason about, obvious UX decisions in Slack that make for a good experience aren't present in Discord. Like being able to click on someone's name and go to the dedicated DM view for them.

Discord is the one thing I dislike more than Slack, even if their backend tech is fucking stellar.

TheSwordsman··on Mozilla is giving up on their IRC server
More than you'd imagine. Someone may be strongly against a feature, library, or tool and their presence in a channel focused on that thing may not be ideal.
TheSwordsman··on Mozilla is giving up on their IRC server
As I mentioned, in our community we have some deal with Slack so that we are paid (up to a point) and have full message history retention. Search can also go through all of those messages too. This is extremely valuable, and is a selling point for Slack if you can somehow get on to a paid plan without breaking the bank.

But in my experience, many don't use the search anyhow. :P

I'll admit, I don't know the full details of the relationship we have with Slack as I'm just an admin and not an owner. It is paid for by someone, but I don't know how much we're paying per head or of it's a flat rate.

TheSwordsman··on Mozilla is giving up on their IRC server
Well, in general you can also ignore people on IRC, you can ban people from channels, and some IRCds support restricted DM permissions which require a user to share channels with you and be _validated_ to message you.

We don't have these sorts of controls in Slack because it's built to support companies with Human Resource departments. Communities like ours don't give the Slack shareholders value.

So in some ways it's worse than IRC.

TheSwordsman··on Mozilla is giving up on their IRC server
As I understand it, to support things like timed bans your only options are undocumented APIs which can change at any point in time. So while some things are documented and possible, not everything is and that's not the level of support we need.
TheSwordsman··on Mozilla is giving up on their IRC server
As an admin helping out the Go Slack workspace, which is about to cross 39,500 registered users, they would be ill-advised to go with Slack if moderation is one of their goals. Full disclosure: our Workspakce does have some sort of agreement with Slack, so our space isn't a free space (we have full history), and even then we aren't able to get them to provide support around moderation of users.

There is no mechanism to ignore a user, mute a user, or temporarily suspend a user if they need a timeout. The first two are completely impossible, while the latter today is manual / mostly possible using undocumented APIs and mechanizing of HTTP requests. Users reporting spam is done by them sending a message to an admin, or in the admin channel, and requires someone to manually intervene and moderate the message. So we effectively need to aim for follow-the-sun moderator coverage, which is a bit painful.

In terms of usability and accessibility, some of the things Slack does (e.g., threads) are not super-inclusive or accessible to users who use screen readers. Today, based on feedback I've gotten, IRC is still superior for users who rely on screen readers due to some form of visual impairment.

Whichever product they go with, it'd be nice if they provided an authenticated IRC gateway which would allow this class of user to have a better experience using the platform as they could use one of the text-based IRC clients that has served them well.

For everyone who is saying they hope Slack isn't the choice, I'm fairly confident with these issues today they won't pursue Slack. If anyone from Mozilla, or any other org, would like to discuss some of the challenges we've had using Slack as an open community I'm more than happy to schedule time. I'd like to help you provide the best experience and community for your users.

TheSwordsman··on Binder – Turn a Git repo into a collection of interactive notebooks
So, did this site get slashdotted? Getting connection refused errors.
TheSwordsman··on California’s Monarch Butterfly Population Hits Record Low
We are so fucked...
TheSwordsman··on Icecast: Open Source multimedia streaming
Wow, going to n10as website is an experience...
TheSwordsman··on SpaceX to lay off 10% of Workforce
What's the current SpaceX attrition rate like, and how does that change across different organizations? It could be a response to their attempt to gain additional funding, and something they heard or agreed to for said funding. Speculation, but wouldn't surprise me.
TheSwordsman··on [security] Go 1.11.3 and Go 1.10.6 are released
Be aware of this regression with 1.11.3: https://github.com/golang/go/issues/29241
TheSwordsman··on Ask HN: How should a programming language accommodate disabled programmers?
At GopherCon 2018 Julia Ferraioli gave a talk titled "Writing Accessible Go". She's challenged with some vision impairment, and shares some of her struggles in trying to be a programmer with those challenges. Of course it's contextually about Go, but I think what she talks about applies to current languages and those to come in the future.

- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cVaDY0ChvOQ

TheSwordsman··on Chicago95 Linux Theme
Can't unsee the terrible letter 'J'.
TheSwordsman··on Google CA Root Inclusion Request
This URL 404s.
TheSwordsman··on The vgo proposal is accepted. Now what?
The concerns haven't been addressed. Sam's latest comment for context:

- https://github.com/golang/go/issues/24301#issuecomment-39254...

TheSwordsman··on The vgo proposal is accepted. Now what?
I wish it was as simple as that. Instead it's that that Russ Cox is fundamentally against SAT solvers, and has opted take this alternative approach instead. I think they would have been better off iterating on the things that have worked for other languages and tools, and arguably a SAT solver is one of them.
← PreviousPage 3 of 8Next →