HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Thiez

1,674 karma · joined May 4, 2016

submissionscomments
Thiez··on John Searle has died
Not all of physics is relevant to a brain simulation. For example, humans appear equally conscious in free fall or in an accelerating vehicle, so a simulation can probably safely ignore the effects of gravity without affecting the outcome. We also know that at body temperature (so about 310K) there is a lot of noise, so we can rule out subtle quantum effects. There is also noise from head movement, pressure changes due to blood flow, slight changes in the chemicals present (homeostasis is not perfect). We won't be simulating at the level of individual molecules or lower.

To me it seems highly likely that our knowledge of physics is more than sufficient for simulating the brain, what is lacking is knowledge of biology and the computational power.

Thiez··on ChatControl: EU wants to scan all private messages, even in encrypted apps
Perhaps they meant the police as the men with guns doing the stopping, and the states monopoly on violence. I for one wholeheartedly support the police enforcing gun control laws and dealing with armed criminals.
Thiez··on New study shows plants and animals emit a visible light that expires at death
It would be wild because it would be wrong. We acknowledge someone who has suffered brain death to be truly dead, even if their body can be kept alive (and presumably shining!) for weeks and weeks through modern medicine. If this light is a side effect of biochemical processes then presumably someone who is decapitated will also continue to shine for minutes.

The fading of the light would be sufficient but not necessary for someone to be considered dead, so it would make a poor definition.

Thiez··on How can I influence others without manipulating them?
The difference between legality and morality is extremely relevant and it's absurd to just gloss over it. Many things we now consider immoral were perfectly legal, like slavery or the holocaust. Law should be based on morality, morality does not and should not defer to the law.
Thiez··on New study shows plants and animals emit a visible light that expires at death
If humans could detect this light then we could see living things in otherwise complete darkness. But we cannot. So it stands to reason that these photons do not explain "auras", and "It's just your imagination" remains the best explanation for auras. Perhaps they are based on simple after-images: if you stare at something long enough the color detecting cells in your eyes get tired and you start seeing weird visual effects that seem to match how people describe "auras".
Thiez··on Israel's strike on Hamas leaders in Qatar shatters Gulf's faith in US protection
That is not an accurate estimate, that is the number of bodies that they have managed to count. If people are stuck under rubble or are otherwise "lost" without leaving an identifiable body then they don't go into the official count. And as you can imagine the ability of Palestinian authorities to count bodies is significantly diminished since Israel has destroyed so much infrastructure. We'll only learn of the true number when this genocide finally ends. And then we'll all be shocked and surprised and can join the German civilians after WO2 in saying "Wir haben es nicht gewusst".
Thiez··on Ireland will not participate in Eurovision if Israel takes part
If you google the Haavara agreement and their little celebratory coin (star of David on one side, swastika on the other) you'll find that the literal nazi government supported Jewish migration to Palestine. Of course Israel technically didn't exist back then.

There are also plenty of evangelicals who want Israel to exist so that biblical prophecies are fulfilled and Jesus returns and takes them all to heaven. Of course non-Christians (like for instance the Jews) will all die and burn in hell for all eternity in this scenario.

So I challenge your point. I think antisemites are as likely to support Israel as they are to oppose it.

Thiez··on Microsoft is officially sending employees back to the office
So they are seriously saying that Google developers on average went from about 70 PRs per year to less than 10 PRs per year when working from home? That seems such an absurdly large decrease that it's hard to believe.
Thiez··on Microsoft is officially sending employees back to the office
What is a CL? What are "significant revisions pushed in comparable products" and what does it measure?
Thiez··on Microsoft is officially sending employees back to the office
Why do we rely on the managers suspicion if there is actual evidence? Why is the evidence not shared?
Thiez··on 'Reading crisis' prompts Denmark to end 25% tax on books
I fully agree with you that forced "literature" lessons suck the fun out of reading. As someone who had to go through it in the Netherlands I've sworn off Dutch authors in response, and haven't read Dutch literature for over 2 decades.
Thiez··on "None of These Books Are Obscene": Judge Strikes Down Much of FL's Book Ban Bill
Your country did gleefully kill millions of innocent brown people in response to 9/11, it's just that they mostly lived in the middle east. You've apparently dehumanized them to the point where their deaths just… slipped your mind.
Thiez··on Abusing Entra OAuth for fun and access to internal Microsoft applications
Because the protection that the VPN provides decreases the risk of having bugs to the point where they won't get prioritized, ever.
Thiez··on I tried living on IPv6 for a day
That and poor support from cloud vendors. Looking at you, Azure. How is IPv6 not enabled for everything by default? It boggles the mind.
Thiez··on VPN use surges in UK as new online safety rules kick in
Surely you see the difference between ordinary citizens buying online and spending money abroad while on holiday and big foreign companies taking their billions of profits out of the country?
Thiez··on The borrowchecker is what I like the least about Rust
You can also do something like:

    fn xy_mut(&mut self) -> (&mut f64, &mut f64) {
        let &mut Point { ref mut x, ref mut y } = self;
        (x,y)
    }
The fact of the matter is that doing mutable getters in Rust is a bit inconvenient at times. There are various workarounds.
Thiez··on LIGO detects most massive black hole merger to date
It cannot. The event horizon by definition prevents mass and energy from leaving (ignoring the exception of Hawking radiation here). I'm assuming your "black hole droplet" would be a tiny black hole? But if you could remove a little chunk from the black hole then you've effectively taken mass out of it, which is impossible.

It is even the case that once two black holes have overlapping event horizons (so they "touch" in a way) they can't stop touching. So two black holes can zip past one another at a small distance, but if they high-five they can't stop merging.

Thiez··on LIGO detects most massive black hole merger to date
No mass escapes. It is purely gravitational waves that are emitted. There is no sneak peek behind the event horizon curtain during a black-hole merger.
Thiez··on LIGO detects most massive black hole merger to date
The energy is emitted as gravitational waves which is probably tricky to convert into usable energy and you probably can't attend more than one in your life unless you have faster-than-light travel. You're much better off visiting a supernova.

But in general it's better to have a steady and stable source of power, rather than one enormous burst of energy that you have to spend on something instantly.

Thiez··on Why is the Rust compiler so slow?
This explanation gets repeated over and over again in discussions about the speed of the Rust compiler, but apart from rare pathological cases, the majority of time in a release build is not spent doing compile-time checks, but in LLVM. Rust has zero-cost abstractions, but the zero-cost refers to runtime, sadly there's a lot of junk generated at compile-time that LLVM has to work to remove. Which is does, very well, but at cost of slower compilation.
Thiez··on Hacker News now runs on top of Common Lisp
Slashdot allowed you to configure scoring, so you could assign 0 or even negative points to 'funny'.
Thiez··on Good-bye core types; Hello Go as we know and love it
C# has great generics and originally shipped without them, so it has been done before.
Thiez··on How often are children genetically unrelated to their presumed fathers?
This 'random kid' stuff is absurd. The child is five or older. For all these years you have been calling it 'my son' or 'my daughter', and it has been calling you 'papa' or 'dad'. You've changed its diapers, sang it to sleep, fed it, clothed it, played with it, taught it words, hugged it after a bad dream. You are its world.

If after all that time it turns out to be not genetically yours I'm sure that hurts. Probably hurts a lot, if it's a betrayal by your partner.

But to pretend that it is in any way the same thing as the government assigning you 'a completely random child' is an absurd hyperbole. Five+ years is a decently long time to be (or think to be) someones father, but for the child that is literally its whole life.

So tell me, if it turns out after 5 years your child isn't biologically yours, you would just abandon it? It's been a nice few years but now it's over, leave to buy cigaretes and never return? And you think remaining its father is the un-manly thing to do? That sounds completely insane to me.

Thiez··on How often are children genetically unrelated to their presumed fathers?
At least if you turn out to be the father you can put the issue to rest. If not, you can pursue parallel construction somehow.
Thiez··on Tesla sales dropped 60% in Germany
I'm sure we can conclude Elon is a fascist based on his words and actions alone, without resorting to numerology.
Thiez··on How does Ada's memory safety compare against Rust?
And people like C in spite of the segfaults. It's the same disliked thing, Rust just moves it to compile time instead of production. Which many people prefer, since it avoids security issues, data loss, and mysterious crashes.
Thiez··on Brain Hyperconnectivity in Children with Autism and Its Links to Social Deficits (2013)
It's not rocket science. What is the purpose of the interview? For the company, to find out if you are a good fit for them. The questions must be interpreted in that context.

That you need money is not interesting information to them, that will be true for (almost?) all other applicants too. So when they ask: 'why do you want this job?' they mean 'why do you want THIS job?' so they actually do literally say word-for-word what they mean. So you answer with stuff like why you might like the job, or why it is a good career step for you, or why your skills make you a good fit.

Thiez··on CDC: Unpublished manuscripts mentioning certain topics must be pulled or revised
> Your sex is defined only by the gamete size you produce.

So you have no sex until puberty? After menopause women stop being women? Infertile people also have no sex? What about euneuchs and people who have their ovaries removed?

Your definition seems to create more problems than it solves. It creates billions of new sexless humans.

Thiez··on Understanding gRPC, OpenAPI and REST and when to use them in API design (2020)
It certainly does not. Sure it can crawl links, but the browser doesn't understand the meaning of the pages, nor can it intelligently fill out forms. It is the user that can hopefully divine how to interact with the pages you serve their browser.

Most APIs however are intended to be consumed by another service, not by a human manually interpreting the responses and picking the next action from a set of action links. HATEOS is mostly pointless.

Thiez··on Israel, Hamas reach ceasefire deal to end 15 months of war in Gaza
What an absurd thing to say. You could say the same of any oppressor and/or colonizer in history. "Well at least they're doing something useful with the land, the people that are being crushed under their boots are just screaming angrily and acting aggressive. All the oppressed are good for is slave labor and dieing." Lucky many people around the world have evolved their morality beyond 'might makes right'.
← PreviousPage 2 of 29Next →