HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Thiez

1,674 karma · joined May 4, 2016

submissionscomments
Thiez··on Israel, Hamas reach ceasefire deal to end 15 months of war in Gaza
There are land-back movements in the US. In addition, all native Americans have US citizenship. If Israel gave citizenship, equal rights, and the right of return to all those that were displaced since the 1940s and their descendents, then I imagine a one-state solution would be possible and a lasting peace could be achieved.
Thiez··on Israel, Hamas reach ceasefire deal to end 15 months of war in Gaza
It seems that they kind of did, performing false flag operations in neighbouring Arab countries to "encourage" Jews to move to Israel: https://www.middleeastmonitor.com/20230619-undeniable-proof-....
Thiez··on Israel, Hamas reach ceasefire deal to end 15 months of war in Gaza
> only if you're straight. if you're gay, the Palestinians will throw you off a building.

What building? Two thirds of them have been bombed by Israel.

> can you tell me what happens when Palestinians have unfettered access to Israel?

Palestinians lived in what is now called "Israel" for thousands of years. It seems that went just fine. It's only recently that an ethnostate has been established on their land and many of the original inhabitants ethnically cleansed or straight up murdered that hostility has risen sharply. Perhaps the ethnostate can be abolished and peace can return in the region.

Thiez··on Israel, Hamas reach ceasefire deal to end 15 months of war in Gaza
Why? I think most of us can recognize they're not necessarily good by our standards, so they're not the good guys. But they are the ones resisting a genocidal apartheid colonialist state, so they're at least better than the Israelis. So if we call Israel the bad guys, that leaves Hamas as... the guys.
Thiez··on A minimax chess engine in regular expressions
I'll happily admit that there is (to me) no reason to believe that humans can do things that a Turing machine could not, or that we are magically exempt from stuff like the halting theorem or have special insights in NP-complete problems. I am only arguing that we are unarguably more powerful than FSMs, and with some pen and paper (or perhaps an endless string of tape...) we are not as limited by our working memory size. But we are very slow.
Thiez··on A minimax chess engine in regular expressions
Humans can't see the balance at a glance, but we can still easily check the balance of arbitrarily complex nested parenthesis because we are not limited in the same way an FSM is. We're just way way way slower than a computer.
Thiez··on One way to fight loneliness: Germans call it a Stammtisch
> Personally, I have no idea what y'all are talking about. > > I enjoy seeing other people, I went sailing with a group of friends yesterday, but I absolutely enjoy spending most of my time alone.

That's wonderful that you don't have this problem at all! And that none of your friends have ever been lonely either. I sure hope this lack of personal experience won't make it hard for you to emphathize with those who do suffer from loneliness.

> How anyone can be "lonely" with 8 billion other people on the planet is just incomprehensible to me. For me the whole place is just way too full of people. I really relish my time alone.

Uhoh. Let's start with the 8 billion people nonsense. How is that relevant? One is unlikely to meet the almost 3 billion Chinese and Indians in, say, Alaska. The fact that billions of people exist somewhere else is not helpful. Doubly so because with most of those billions there is no shared language, no shared culture or experience, and generally little else to build into a meaningful connection.

I would argue that we can reasonably exclude the earth population that you are unlikely to meet on a regular basis. This filters out about 8 billion, leaving us with "only" millions for those living in or near big cities, and hundreds to thousands for those who live in the middle of nowhere.

All of this is ignoring the fact that people manage to feel lonely even in a crowd or even at a party. Ultimately loneliness is not about being alone in the literal sense but about not having (enough) meaningful connections. Having no connections in a crowd of millions only emphasizes the loneliness, it does not solve it.

> This has to be some "raised on the internet" kind of millennial phenomenon.

Dismissing the existence of elderly loneliness and spitting on a younger generation all in one sentence. Jup, kids these days, they suck right? You could really try some more empathy with people going through hard times and not dismiss their lived experiences just because it hasn't happened to you (yet).

> As a barely boomer,

Ah, there it is.

> I really miss the open spaces that weren't packed full of people.

Sure, but the US still has many places where you can walk for hours without meeting someone. Or you could move to Alaska. If that seems like a hand-wavy bullshit argument, consider what your 8 billion people argument might feel like to someone who is lonely.

Maybe next time you go sailing ask your friends if they or someone they know have ever felt lonely, and try to stop yourself from arguing an dismissing their stories. You might learn something.

Thiez··on US lawmakers tell Apple, Google to be ready to remove TikTok from stores Jan. 19
Exactly, and that's why it's so pointless to ban politics. Whatever you include in or exclude from that ban is in itself a political decision.
Thiez··on US lawmakers tell Apple, Google to be ready to remove TikTok from stores Jan. 19
> Tens of millions of teenage Americans are addicted to it is the evidence. Chinese don't allow their kids to waste all day long on stupid douyin, Americans don't have such luxuries, as tons of red necks are going to jump up and label it as anti free speech if you want something similar. As a result, you see Chinese kids spend time on STEM subjects, building toy robots and learning how to code AI stuff while American kids are all dreaming to be the most popular influencer on social media.

So it's Chinas fault that the US doesn't have the same laws restricting social media content and screentime for children? Or, if it is the red necks fault, then how does 'TikTok is spreading CCP propaganda' follow from 'US red necks oppose laws that are anti free speech'? It seems you're skipping some steps to get to that conclusion.

Thiez··on US lawmakers tell Apple, Google to be ready to remove TikTok from stores Jan. 19
You can't ban politics. Everything is politics.
Thiez··on Dear friend, you have built a Kubernetes
Your cluster consists of multiple machines ('nodes'). Upgrading is as simple as adding a new, upgraded node, then evicting everything from one of the existing nodes, then take it down. Repeat until every node is replaced.

Downtime is the same as with a deploment, so if you run at least 2 copies of everything there should be no downtime.

As for updating the images of your containers, you build them again with the newer base image, then deploy.

Thiez··on Is Chrome the New IE? (2023)
> Remember when we parsed JSON with libs written in JS?

No, when was that? Because it was always possible to `eval(jsonString)` and get the parsed result. Indeed, that was the whole point.

Thiez··on C Gibberish to English
Rust isn't so bad, is it? The example of `char ((x[3])())[5]` would translate to `[fn() -> [fn() -> u8; 5]; 3]`. It's inherently an ugly type, but I think it's easier to read than the C version.
Thiez··on Mitochondria Are Alive
Why would the fetus have any rights that are not automatically defeated by the rights of its mother if it's not a person? All anti-abortion arguments that I'm aware of start by arguing that the fetus deserves the rights of a person, and then proceed from there. Could you present a counterexample?
Thiez··on Scientists predict and witness evolution in a 30-year marine snail experiment
> Once again, evolutionists report that an organism gained abilities it basically already had. There was no, new capabilities invented in the process. So, you might want to drop that one.

Maybe you can stop with the disingenuous "evolutionists" and just call these people by their professions: biologists and geneticists.

Feeding on citrate under aerobic conditions is a new capability for the e. coli strain that the experiment started with. You can deny it all you want but that just shows the world that you're closing your eyes for what is right in front of you. If it was really such an easy ability to acquire you'd think that more than 1 of the 12 lines would have achieved it after 75k+ generations. But researching the strain that did develop the ability showed that it's a complex ability that required multiple mutations to acquire. It's not like the bacteria just activated a dormant gene that they already had.

But we can leave the e. coli behind and take another example: antibiotic resistance in bacteria and the ability to digest plastic of some bacteria. Many antibiotics (and also plastics in general) simply didn't exist before we invented them. And yet we see bacteria develop a resistance to antibiotics. And now that plastic is everywhere, some bacteria have evolved the ability to break it down. Clearly these are new and original abilities.

> Most of what I saw in the past was them claiming that without proof. What they’d usually argue are similarities. Reuse of design, or iterations, happen in intelligent design done by human engineers. We reuse and tweak all kinds of stuff, esp mechanical and software. You don’t see people arguing an unguided, chance-based process must have produced the software because of the similarities in the code. Evolutionists take quite a leap.

So you're suggesting evolution isn't true, it's actually an intelligent designer that is iterating on a design, resulting in... the development of species over time with a fossil record and existing species that looks exactly like an evolutionary tree, including physical traits, similarity in genetics... but it's definitely not evolution.

Speaking of reuse of design, in nature we actually see that something like (for example) the eye has evolved separately a bunch of times, with several variations. And miraculously these variations match the evolutionary trees for the species involved.

> You said vestigial. That’s another thing I’m skeptical of. Scientists that don’t understand our bodies have said many things were useless in the past. Then, evolutionists said they were vestigial. Later, the appendix, the spleen, “junk DNA,” etc were proven to have important uses for people even though you can live without some of them.

When I was talking about vestigial stuff I had the leg bones in some snakes in mind, that seem to VERY STRONGLY suggest that their ancestors may have had legs, and these legs have evolved away. Whales also have some bones left that again strongly suggest their ancestors once walked on land, but one could argue about whether these count as 'vestigial' since apparently some muscles are still connected to them. But regardless of vestigiality, they're clearly remains of legs.

> Vestigial organs seem to be one of those things where evolutionists don’t know why something exists, make a statement of faith that it’s vestigial, and then use the faith-based statements (existence of vestigials) to back evolution theory itself. I don’t like that methodology since they’ve been wrong so many times.

So you agree the scientific consensus updates as more information becomes available, as we see with vestigial organs losing their vestigial status when their use becomes known. And yet evolution has not been rejected by scientists. To me that sounds like the new information did not contradict evolution. Does it sound like a grand conspiracy to you?

> Same as before. There’s similarities. So, instead of designed with similarities (most likely), it must have been produced by unguided processes in hostile environments that endlessly added more capabilities starting with simple things they spontaneously formed from non-living material in a universe that accidentally formed life-preserving constants.

The origin of life is out of scope of evolution, so I don't see why you're bringing it up. Evolution would still be the leading theory about the historical and continued development of terrestrial life regardless of whether the first life arose from nonliving materials, was brought to earth by aliens, or was created by a deity from your pantheon of choice.

> Yet, even those that believe this won’t rely on such processes to design anything because they don’t work. Even evolutionary algorithms and large, language models take lots of fine-tuning in environments hand-crafted for their execution. Why would I expect anything less of the more complex designs in the universe and of life? :)

Because it's faster? Somewhere out there in the world is a tree with a branch that is perfectly shaped to be part of a hammer. But when I need a hammer I won't grow a billion trees and find the one with the best shaped branch, I'll take a slightly bigger branch and cut it in the shape I like. Here we come back to the fact that evolution takes many generation and it's essentially random, so IF you have the option of taking the role of an intelligent designer, that is often the quickest way to get stuff done.

Thiez··on Scientists predict and witness evolution in a 30-year marine snail experiment
> We’d have to see them turn into organisms that were very different from their original form or even multi-cellular. That would be closer to what evolution as origin of life says. Instead, most (all?) stay what they are with minor adaptations.

Let's take a look at the E. coli long term evolution experiment [1]! Here we see 12 initially identical populations of bacteria live through over 80k generations over a period of 36 years. During this time these isolated populations have undergone significant changes (such as becoming at least twice as large) that would surely qualify as "very different from their original form". One of the populations evolved the ability to aerobically grow on citrate. Not being able to do this is one of the defining qualities of E.coli, so it must surely qualify as becoming 'very different'.

> We’ve also observed billions of other creatures over thousands of years that didn’t turn into new insects or animals. Evolution’s predictions on a macro-level have failed over a billion times for thousands of years.

Speciation is usually a gradual process. There won't be a clear instant where yesterday there was one species and today it's suddenly two species. So in that regard there isn't a specific moment one could personally observe. And with the time between generations for animals being relatively long, we don't see much progress being made. What we do see around us is species in various stages of speciation. Here is a nice example of speciation starting for European birds [2] that is very recent.

Also I would argue that the E.coli experiment has shown speciation in a human lifetime.

> On the fossil record, evolution predicted continuous streams of changes in all directions with piles of viable, intermediate forms. We don’t see that. We do see large jumps from one type to another happening after extinctions where there’s lower populations.

Citation needed? We have lots of species living today that we can trace to shared ancestors, like how we can trace humans, chimps, and orangutans to a common ancestor. It's true that speciation happens much faster after an extinction, this makes sense because extinction events cause previously occupied ecological niches to get opened up. In a static environment the rate of change is low because most species will be in a local optimum. Everything we see appears to confirm evolution. If you think the fossil record disproves evolution you should consider if it merely disproves your understanding of evolution, which may be incorrect.

> That’s exactly what evolutionists do. These failures of the theory, both observational and historical, would have had it tossed long ago like most theories that fail that much. Instead, they keep making excuses for it or emphasizing again that it must be true.

You mean biologists? To call evolution a failed theory is absurd, it's one of the most successful theories science has produced. It's supported by the fossil record, by DNA research, by bacteria becoming resistant to antibiotics and gaining the ability to digest plastics. By vestigial organs. By the way that early fetal development for mammals all looks the same. And there are no counter examples. No species appearing out of nowhere without a historical ancestor. No species with completely incompatible biology to our own.

> That’s not science. That is like dogma driven by emotional or socio-political factors. Which also provably exist in institutions promoting it. So, it’s not science since it (a) is driven by non-scientific forces and (b) continues to fail the scientific method.

You are seeing a conspiracy where none exists. If you have a better theory than evolution I encourage you to publish, and in a decade or two we will all know you as a Nobel prize winner. Maybe share it with us here on HN, I for one would be delighted to have been one of the first to have read this new theory. I sure hope it doesn't rely on an invisible undetectable magic man steering everything.

Even if a theory is invented to supplant evolution, I guarantee it will include evolution. Just like General Relativity supplanted Newtonian Physics, turns out that they have pretty much the same results at the scales and speeds we usually find ourselves at. And just like the Earth being an oblate sphere instead of a perfect sphere. The basic idea of evolution is correct and any hypothetical future changes will be a refinement on what we already know, not a radically different thing.

1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/E._coli_long-term_evolution_... 2. https://evolution.berkeley.edu/evo-news/speciation-in-real-t...

Thiez··on Scientists predict and witness evolution in a 30-year marine snail experiment
The brilliant article you post argues against ring species, but it does so by demonstrating geographic breaks that caused... speciation. So perhaps ring species as a concept sadly aren't as much a thing as was suggested in my HS days (I suppose science moved on, thanks for updating my knowledge) but if you accept the contents of that article then you must also agree that speciation is a thing that happens.

But in the interest of considering the topic from an intellectual and academic point of view, what is your proposed alternative explanation for the huge number of species we see today, apart from evolution and speciation?

Thiez··on Scientists predict and witness evolution in a 30-year marine snail experiment
"Species" itself is a vague concept in biology. It makes sense at a HS level like "dog is a different species from elephant" but it breaks down in more complex cases, e.g. lion + tiger. Ring species are also a nice example where individuals from A breed with B so same species, B breeds with C so same species, …, but A does not breed with E so not the same species. If we exterminate the populations B, C, and D, A and E are now definitely different species, so I would argue we could observe speciation that way? But while the populations between them exist, it's more muddled.

Since evolution moves slowly there are two ways to see it in action: either you experiment with a species that reproduces very rapidly, or you look at fossil records. For the first type bacteria are usually used, but since bacteria don't have sexual reproduction a naysayer could always cast doubt on whether a new species has truly been created (are any two individual bacteria really the same species? Who can tell, short of verifying base-by-base equality of their DNA), so it won't convince someone who is determined to doubt evolution. For the fossil records we have literal mountains of evidence where the development of existing and extinct species can be observed. But I imagine you won't count that as "witnessing" it happening.

I feel like many people who doubt evolution use a standard of evidence that they don't use for any other scientific theory, and probably not for any other area in their life either. Other people have mentioned it already: plate tectonics, almost all of astronomy... we could extend it to history too. Did you witness the founding of the United States? If documented history count as proof of stuff like founding of the US, the civil war, and the first world war, then why don't fossils count as proof of evolution?

Thiez··on Code that helped end Apartheid
If you check the Bible you'll find that the Jews obtained their "homeland" through... genocide. Their deity told them to move there and kill every man, woman, child, and even the livestock already living there. They're just another invader.

Then they had a kingdom that lasted about 200 years before falling apart, we can count it as almost 500 years if you want to include the kingdom of Judah time. And now it's more than 2500 years later. Jews who can't trace a single ancestor back to the Middle East for hundreds of years can somehow claim to be indigenous to the land and "return" there. And they have the right to displace or murder the people who have been living there for generations and whose genetics show their ancestors have been in that area for hundreds or thousands of years.

Clearly this is an absurd standard of 'indigenous' that nobody in their right mind should take seriously.

As for your other claims, they are irrelevant. Whether or not Hamas uses or has used human shields is completely unrelated to whether or not it is good or righteous to commit genocide on the Palestinians (indeed, there can be NO excuse for genocide). And if using human shields is so vile that the people of the same country deserve to be slaughtered I should point out that the Israeli military has a rich history of using Palestinian civilians (including children) as human shields. And if October 7th qualifies as a holocaust, then what Israel has done in Gaza is a holocaust ten times over.

Thiez··on Christopher Columbus may have been Spanish and Jewish, documentary says
Sure. This is just Great Man theory [1] in action. It's a bit absurd, once you know about it you see it everywhere.

It's especially distasteful when it's about people who 'discovered' places, because the next step was usually the subjugation or genocide of the people already living in the discovered place. But we still celebrate the explorers as heroes.

1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_man_theory

Thiez··on Personal Names Around the World (2011)
No, because sometimes there are multiple correct ways to pronounce it in the same language / culture.
Thiez··on UK will give sovereignty of Chagos Islands to Mauritius
This all just speaks in favor of decolonialization, does it not? When decolonialisation is complete the $dictator won't be able to use it as a distraction, nor can it be a source of corruption. And apart from that it's a noble and objectively good goal in itself.
Thiez··on OpenBSD now enforcing no invalid NUL characters in shell scripts
And in case your data does contain NULs, presumably one could add a layer of base64 encoding. Not nice for the filesize, but also much less likely to upset a text editor when the script is opened (even in the absence of NUL bytes).
Thiez··on OpenBSD now enforcing no invalid NUL characters in shell scripts
This is also where Google went right with QUIC: encrypt as much as possible to show middleboxes the least possible. This combats ossification. Then again it seems likely middleboxes will just block QUIC (or UDP in general).
Thiez··on Hollywood Can't Ditch Its Teslas Fast Enough:"They're Destroying Their Leases.."
Strangely his children are all white. The continent of Africa has more genetic diversity than the rest of the world combined. Seems like he's not picking the mothers very well if he's maximising "genetic diversity" of his offspring.

I imagine you would also applaud fertility doctors who fraudulently use their own sperm and end up with 100+ children? Maybe they're winning at making a genetic impact, but it doesn't seem very admirable to me.

Thiez··on I Like Makefiles
At that point wouldn't you "just" download the source and compile locally? Since you presumably could compile stuff. Add a 'bin' folder in your home directory to your PATH and enjoy.
Thiez··on Hollywood Can't Ditch Its Teslas Fast Enough:"They're Destroying Their Leases.."
[flagged]
Thiez··on Please stop putting cookie pop-ups on your website (2022)
And 150 of the 400 "partners" will also have a pre-ticked "legitimate interest" checkbox that you have to untick separately. To me that's an automatic maximum penalty fine, but sadly there is no enforcement.
Thiez··on Independent directors of 23andMe resign from board
Can you show damages? If you can win a lawsuit here that would be great, paving the way for sueing Christians for their passive aggressive 'I'll pray for you' nonsense would be amazing.
Thiez··on We're not going to run out of new anatomy anytime soon
Perhaps the first generation would be deformed but second-gen (if they hypothetically get that far) should be much closer. You still need the mitochondrial DNA as well.
← PreviousPage 3 of 29Next →