HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Thiez

1,674 karma · joined May 4, 2016

submissionscomments
Thiez··on The Internet Archive has lost its appeal in Hachette vs. Internet Archive
Copyright infringement is not, nor has it ever been, theft. Why would you push that absurd publisher propaganda?
Thiez··on Federal appeals court finds geofence warrants “categorically” unconstitutional
I'll admit to disliking the color of your curtains and they'll find the jerrycan for my lawnmower and suddenly I'm the prime suspect for arson. Sorry neighbour I'm not talking to the cops, hope you have insurance.
Thiez··on Can we stop the decline of monarch butterflies and other pollinators?
Wouldn't these hypothetical ticks only be a problem for him if he wants to walk through your barkyard? Never mind that ticks can and do live in short grass just fine...
Thiez··on Enum class improvements for C++17, C++20 and C++23
One of those cases happens accidentally all the time (in more complex variants than the motivating example you responded to), the other never happens except on purpose. It's like complaining guard rails are pointless because people being launched with catapults might still fly over them and plunge to their deaths.
Thiez··on Trump injured but ‘fine’ after attempted assassination at rally
We should probably kill the people advocating genocide and the use of nuclear weapons first.
Thiez··on A landscape of consciousness: Toward a taxonomy of explanations and implications
That seems unlikely, as neural networks don't all develop exactly the same. There is some natural variance which brain regions perform which function. E.g. Broca's area (very important for speech) only 'usually' lies on your left hemisphere. We know from experiments that stimulating certain areas of the brain produces certain (predictable) feelings, but to stimulate the brain in such a way to transfer an exact thought or a specific vision would seem impossible without a very detailed scan of the source and destination brain, and a complex remapping in between. And some experiences may not be transferable if the target doesn't hawe the required circuitry.
Thiez··on A landscape of consciousness: Toward a taxonomy of explanations and implications
That's a nice story but does it make any testable predictions? Because it appears to introduce many new concepts that would be measurable with particle physics, yet mysteriously have never been observed. And if these magic soul particles don't interact with matter in measurable ways, how do you know their size?
Thiez··on Analyzing my electricity consumption
So rich people? So they can save money while people who can't afford a battery cannot. I guess it's like this for most cost-saving investments, but doing it this way hardly contributes to a more fair society.
Thiez··on Panama Papers: Court acquits all 28 charged with money laundering
I'm not in or from the US either. It's a common rule though.

The word of a burglar alone hopefully isn't enough for a conviction anywhere, but it should be sufficient for a warrant in sane jurisdictions.

Thiez··on Panama Papers: Court acquits all 28 charged with money laundering
Generally evidence gathered by the authorities may not be tainted, to discourage the police from breaking the law to gather evidence. This restriction does not usually apply to evidence collected by private citizens.

In other words, if a burglar finds the dead bodies in your cellar, that evidence is admissable.

Thiez··on Formal methods: Just good engineering practice?
Exactly. In practice you always want each loop iteration to perform some action that brings you closer to some desired end state. That loop invariant + some notion of getting closer to the end is usually the proof you need to prove termination. A loop where you don't have these things is almost certainly a bug.

The vast majority of loops iterate over some finite collection of elements and are thus guaranteed to terminate. Tricky cases are stuff like "I will repeat this operation until the output stops changing".

Thiez··on Memory-safe, clean implementation of classic Posix "BC" calculator
Adding UTF-8 support in 2024 is hardly second system syndrome. Note that these re-implementations generally try to be compatible with the original rather than starting with a completely new vision, another sign that we're not suffering from SSS here.
Thiez··on Most life on Earth is dormant, after pulling an 'emergency brake'
Large groups of people in society already hate immigrants. What makes you think they would welcome useless old and sick people from long ago? They're like immigrants, but worse!

Face reality: when you've been on ice long enough that your friends and immediate family are dead, nobody wants you anymore. You will never be defrosted, and if you're lucky at some point your remains will be given a burial. It's more likely you'll be unceremoniously cremated like medical waste.

Thiez··on API Shouldn't Redirect HTTP to HTTPS
Denial of service by blocking API keys is really your happy case when someone malevolent has your API keys.
Thiez··on ICJ orders Israel to stop military operation in Rafah
Both of those cases involve the dissolution of the state holding the veto power. While dissolving the UK would be hilarious, I imagine they would veto it.
Thiez··on ICC prosecutor seeks arrest warrants against Sinwar and Netanyahu for war crimes
So they'll be eating this rice raw, then? Raw uncooked rice with a nice cup of seawater to quench their thirst.
Thiez··on Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the human brain
Science is based on the hypothesis that stuff that worked yesterday will work the same way tomorrow, and it tries to discover the rules that govern the stuff. There is nothing religious about it. It's a safe assumption to make; if there are no rules or the rules can change in arbitrary ways, science should be able to detect that, too. We've seen enormous scientific progress throughout human history, and based on this history I think it's safe to say that it's the best way to learn about our world that we've discovered.
Thiez··on Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the human brain
There's always 'reports' of people being able to do these magical things that cannot be explained through modern science. And yet challenges such as these https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_prizes_for_evidence_... never seem to have winners. It seems that these abilities inherently come with the luck of never having financial problems that could me resolved with a generous cash prize.
Thiez··on Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the human brain
It's no coincidence that Frank has his own beer brand: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huyghe_Brewery, so that we may commune with him.
Thiez··on Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the human brain
There is nothing religiously fanatical about seeing that everything in science appears to be explained by our laws of physics, and concluding that human consciousness probably is, too. In our history we've seen time and time again that humans will believe in magic and higher powers and every single time it's turned out to be just physics, just biology, just chemistry...

And here we have something mysterious and poorly understood (and poorly defined...): consciousness. And again as always the quacks line up with their magic to explain it all. Higher dimensions! Quantum effects! We're all in the matrix and only our minds are real! Even though we can clearly see that so many mental processes can be influenced with drugs, with hormones, with magnetic fields, or with a scalpel. Everything points to yet another physical thing that we'll hopefully understand and explain soon.

Thiez··on Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the human brain
And 200 years ago only living being could fly, but now we have machines that can fly higher and faster than any bird, even to Mars. But back then you could have said flight requires a living being because that's all we've ever seen.

A hundred years ago computers didn't exist and now they've been beating us at chess for some time. That you haven't seen a conscious computer yet in no way proves that it's not possible is principle.

Thiez··on Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the human brain
But since we can't yet define consciousness, how do you know the AGI is just 'faking it' instead of being the real deal? What are human brains but a bunch of neurons pretending to be a person?
Thiez··on Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the human brain
Where did GP use this view to argue for the abolishment of the criminal justice system?
Thiez··on Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the human brain
Why? Why can't the world be a cruel and indifferent place? Take for example the babies that had to be left behind by hospital staff in one of the Gaza hospitals when it was occupied by the IOF and when the doctors could come back a few weeks later they found the rotting corpses of these babies who had been left to starve, alone and afraid, by the Israeli soldiers.

If you were one of these newborns and somehow con-cious and you had to choose between 'I have been left here to die' and 'Mommy loves me and is coming soon', would you reject the former as obviously false since it's incompatible with health, sanity, and humanity?

I think so easily dismissing the cruelty and insanity of the world is in itself inhumane.

Thiez··on Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the human brain
So then bacteria have souls? And computers will never have one since they're not biological. But also there doesn't seem to be a relationship between souls and consciousness, so they are irrelevant.
Thiez··on Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the human brain
Humans aren't better at solving NP-hard problems so I don't really see the connection with consciousness here.
Thiez··on Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the human brain
Why?
Thiez··on Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the human brain
I always think of this comic when people try to mix quantum mechanics and consciousness https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/the-talk-3 . You have to show an actual relation here, you can't just connect these two concepts on the basis that they're both complex.
Thiez··on Born to run? Endurance running may have evolved to help humans chase down prey
The world already has quite enough evolutionary "just so" stories. Our ancestors lived in trees, which presumably is safe from most predators, and standing upright isn't much of an advantage. Gathering would have been off the ground (no advantage to standing) or from bushes / trees (where climbing is better than standing).

Most African predators (such as the many big cats, but also some crocodiles) easily outrun humans, we are in no way evolved to outrun them. They will sneak up and then do a short sprint. Remember we're not running a marathon against them - we're playing tag and when they tag you, you lose. We're almost certainly not evolved to run to avoid predators.

Thiez··on Born to run? Endurance running may have evolved to help humans chase down prey
Humans were quite good at preserving food before the invention of refrigeration, e.g. through drying and smoking for meat.
← PreviousPage 4 of 29Next →