HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

TomMckenny

2,285 karma · joined February 19, 2015

submissionscomments
TomMckenny··on Home is a small, engineless sailboat (2018)
That's what I thought. But I'd be just as nervous on the HMS Discovery. And yet both made it to the Cook Islands and back.

And I have to say, someone who sinlgehands a more or less home made boat across the pacific and back pretty much knows what they're doing by definition.

TomMckenny··on Raising the American Weakling (2017)
I'm not sure it's a factor but the was a fad in the '80s or so for using what are now called Hand Grippers.

I don't know how wide spread that fad was but if that was when the norms were established, it might bare considering.

TomMckenny··on Is this Paypal experience customary?
If anyone wanted a de facto software monopoly to break up, this would be a good one.
TomMckenny··on Too Many Companies Drain Value from the Economy
You mention an excess of mergers over the decades which reminds me of a new problem with the inverse: anti-trust enforcement.

It appears that anti-trust, which was rare to begin with, may now have been politicized.

For example, it's hard to understand why favoritism is shown to ISPs yet effort is put into breaking up large software companies. Especially in light of the difference in campaign contributions in 2018.

TomMckenny··on Hillbillies Need No Elegy
>If anything, Appalachian are uniquely under-represented nationally. While the region as a whole contains nearly 25 million people, WV is the only state to have two Appalacian senators. I think TN has one as well, but, overall the political power of Appalachia does not at all seem sufficient to warrant extra attention.

Technically that is 50% more senators than California with twice the population.

TomMckenny··on Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia
It's interesting that the first two seem to be more or less universally implemented through out the world. Although the neighbor level seems to be "leave each other alone including territoriality but aid in the event of emergency".

It's interesting that many of the most notorious times are when that neighborhood level breaks down: Moments of extremely intrusive totalitarianism such as the European witch trials, China's cultural revolution, cults.

It's also interesting that people seem to naturally form similar organization up to the neighbor sized groups but above that anything can happen. I'm guessing this is the result of evolving in essentially neighborhood sized groups. I suspect there is something useful to be found in this stuff.

TomMckenny··on Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia
So they will return North America to the Indians?

And antebellum mansions to the descendants of the slaves who built them?

Perhaps it is merely a _claim_ of consistency just convoluted enough that those who are advantaged by the ideology can jump on board.

TomMckenny··on Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia
>I'm not sure if this is a joke or not.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poe%27s_law

Actually I wonder where this family ideas come from. There must be some engine promulgating the bizarre notion that the only real rights are property rights and all others must derive from them or be dismissed.

TomMckenny··on Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia
I haven't read enough about it to have an opinion yet.

Does the wording in fact contradict Hustler Magazine v. Falwell? Would it outlaw satyrical images of politicians? Thus my question above.

TomMckenny··on Deepfake revenge porn distribution now a crime in Virginia
Not to defend the Virginia statute but as devils advocate, couldn't they argue that their law does not apply to parody and only protects non-public figures?

So couldn't they argue the statute would not apply to the Hustler-Falwell parody for those two reasons?

TomMckenny··on Hospitalized in Split – Intoxication
It will also benefit lower income employees and consumers who will see good wage/price changes relative to taxes.

Another possibility is a cap on drug profits declining with drug age. This will allow enough market to avoid having to guess production costs in advance and set them in stone. The drawback is incentives to efficiency. Perhaps a mixture of price cap and profit cap would hit the sweet spot.

TomMckenny··on Oregon Just Voted to Legalize Duplexes on Almost Every City Lot
Fantastic. I hope with all my heart that rezoning at least slows down price increases. It should certainly be done as widely as possible.

But in the end I think we need to keep in mind that there will need to additional aggressive legislation to even keep prices flat relative to wages let alone reduce them.

TomMckenny··on ‘Pre-bunk’ game reduces susceptibility to disinformation
You mean Assad has never conducted chemical attacks on his people? Even though Syria, Russia, Iran and youtube conspiracy theorists claim he is Innocent, the actual fact of chemical attacks it is well established. It is actually found in victims blood.

And Nayirah was invited by congress to lie in those chambers in order to give Bush justification for his war. None of those parties are news papers. In fact it was the press that ultimately exposed those lies, not a guy in his basement on youtube.

By yellow cake, I assume you are referring to the article[1] that _exposed_ Bush's lie about WMD in Iraq coming from Africa. The article that resulted in white house retaliation threatening the life of Valerie Plame.

In addition, there were a series of op-eds _opposing_ the war by Joseph C. Wilson and others. The only degree to which real journalism is guilty is the degree to which it gullibly repeated what the whitehouse said. I believe we are all aware now that the whitehouse lies profusely.

And indeed, the respectable papers report the Trump organization's meetings and deals with Russia. If this data looks like an accusation to you, I have to agree that evidence is quite damning.

So here is a counter proposal: The far right is trying to discredit and ultimately crush the free press and academia as always. One of the tools is a re-write of history so that somehow those institutions that opposed war are now blamed for it. And the hawkish right who actually did start the war is falsely portrayed as opposing it.

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2003/07/06/opinion/what-i-didn-t-fin...

TomMckenny··on “The books will stop working.”
So can I reverse any contract at anytime or is this something only large companies are allowed to do and only to consumers?
TomMckenny··on Pentagon has a laser that can identify people at a distance by their heartbeat
Even putting aside from the inevitable "misuse", I even wonder about it's intended use. For example:

>Jetson can achieve over 95% accuracy under good conditions

What does this even mean? I can see enormous incentive to avoid false negatives. But I don't see as much incentive to avoid false positives.

For example, the incentives are even less than for drug testing for which there is some semblance of legal proceeding. And yet which are still flawed.

I'm sure it's better than bombing indiscriminately. But it'd be nice to be confident that it isn't going to increase wrongful assassinations due to over confidence.

Did the test you saw attempt to show a low false positive rate too?

TomMckenny··on Show HN: A Firefox extension to leave comments on any URL
I read it to mean “allowing unrestricted comments on a web page is a bad idea”

Perhaps you read it as “allowing unrestricted comments on a web page _or anywhere else_ is a bad idea”

But that second one has never been the case. People have alway been able to post responses on their own sites with links to the original. Many places like reddit are primarily that.

I think others maybe confusing the right to free speech with a right to vandalize.

TomMckenny··on Show HN: A Firefox extension to leave comments on any URL
So if I do not add support for unlimited anonymous comments at my own expense to my website, I am engaging in Orwellian oppression?

Then allow me to comment on this repo and display those comments prominently. Because if I’m not allowed to add whatever opinion I want to the readme, I am being horribly oppressed.

TomMckenny··on Robots 'to replace up to 20M factory jobs' by 2030
Absolutely. Automation will increase net wealth.

But I do not believe everyone will quickly find an even better job when a factory closes because 1) popular perception aside, that is not what happened in the industrial revolution and 2) it is not what happened with globalization 3) it is suspiciously pleasant and easy belief for those who are least likely to be hurt. It's also a bit magical thinking.

And if wage depression from globalization has caused damaging ethnic and nationalist backlashes, it's not hard to imagine the multiplying effect that will come with reckless displacement due to automation.

Because people who have a continuing or sudden drop in quality of life due to events beyond their control are not going to blame themselves forever and are not going to be convinced by a rising GDP graph that leaves them further behind.

Great would be a society that everyone feels vested in and an economy that everyone can participate in. But it's hard to imagine any such plan being invented let alone honestly implemented in the foreseeable future. Are thousands of 50 year old factory workers going to get hired as a web designers? Are they going to work as Walmart greeters thinking "sure I lost my house but national wealth is up so I don't mind". So at the very least there needs to be more adequate social safety nets.

TomMckenny··on ‘Pre-bunk’ game reduces susceptibility to disinformation
Infowars: Clinton runs a child abuse ring from a pizza shop.

Pulitzer Prize winning news source: Clinton does not run a child abuse ring.

How does ignoring Infowars because it is intentionally lying make me less informed?

>Every comment about being skeptical about media ( especially mainstream media ) gets met with your type of comment. Makes me wonder.

Our conspiracy has been exposed! Back to Moscow comrades!

TomMckenny··on ‘Pre-bunk’ game reduces susceptibility to disinformation
The revelation that misinformation campaigns catering to preconceptions are not actually reality based is an existential threat to extremism. Any post showing that will draw them like flies.

The other popular response seems to be "the article and game are bogus". Not sure how the two are reconciled of course.

TomMckenny··on ‘Pre-bunk’ game reduces susceptibility to disinformation
I would point out that without anonymous sources, there would be no real way to hold powerful people to account.

And while problems like subtle framing are real and problematic, they are long standing and democracy has long been able to cope with them. They are no more effective now than they have been for centuries.

And they are insignificant compared to the recent effectiveness of blatant falsehood and fabrication. Often state sponsored.

TomMckenny··on Trump Signs Executive Order Compelling Disclosure of Prices in Health Care
>If one argues in favor of "free market" solutions for healthcare, then one MUST argue in favor of pricing transparency.

Indeed. And generally there is an enormous difference between "pro business" and "pro free market". In many cases they are the opposite. For example the information asymmetry you point out. Another is lack of enforcement of anti-trust.

Heaven help consumers and employees who live in the wrong one.

TomMckenny··on Aaron Peskin got his illegally merged $1.5M “monster” home
Edit: I stand corrected, the legislation will indeed harm tenements. I would suggest that arguing against legislation by showing a supporter's hypocrisy may not be the strongest approach. It is a tad fallacious after all.

Full disclosure, my incorrect original post:

Find a guy with dirt that supports protecting rent controlled units. Use that to attempt to discredit legislation that helps tenants.

If the best argument against protecting rental units is a weak Tu Quoque, then perhaps protecting duplex rentals is a good idea.

TomMckenny··on Tech journalists troubled by Assange computer intrusion charge
He's also a useful tool to undermine journalism and a free and independent press.

Even more effective than the blind defense of Khashoggi's murders and the "enemy of the people" language.

TomMckenny··on Friendly policies keep US oil and coal afloat far more than we thought (2017)
Surely no one believed that criticism of clean fuel subsidies was anymore intellectually honest than calls for a balanced budget.
TomMckenny··on Dorothea Lange’s Censored Photos of Japanese American Internment Camps (2017)
If you are habitually detaining large numbers of civilians, including children, then you are on the wrong side of history.

Somehow this point never seems to be learned

TomMckenny··on What Facebook’s new currency means for the banking system
I now have read that the Libra will have complete liquidity, will be pegged to multiple currencies and will earn interest (which goes to founding organizations).

How can all these things be true? Are they just using these terms with the same freedom they use the word "crypto-currency"?.

TomMckenny··on Hong Kong Protesters Keep Up the Pressure
The HK protesters have a specific addressable goal.
TomMckenny··on Walmart Pleads Guilty After a Decade of Bribes
A fine is simply passed on to customers or employees. If the fine is great enough, it could result in bankruptcy which harms employees and potentially customers.

Asset seizure targets the ones culpable rather than just transferring some or all of that burden. And regardless of the size of the penalty, there is no danger to third parties like employees, customers or other organizations along the supply chain.

If the above examples are inadequate, I will add civil asset forfeiture which is applied widely to crimes on the low end of the economic spectrum, even without convictions, but with great parsimony to crimes on the upper end even with conviction.

TomMckenny··on Walmart Pleads Guilty After a Decade of Bribes
Strange this is so far outside the Overton window that it can be read as a joke.

In cases involving lower valued assets, the owner is almost always punishable: his dog bites you, it's his fault. His contractor lays bad wiring that burns down your house, it's his fault. His kids misdeeds are often legally his fault. And even if he loans his car to someone who crashes into it's legally his fault.

But behind a corporate shield, nothing is ever the owners fault. The more value the company has, the less possibility any owner is to receive legally blame. Not that there's much possibility in the first place.

This remarkable and thoroughly ingrained inconsistency does consistently benefit a certain category of person.

A very practice and effective solution would be to seize some chunk of the shares/value based on the size of the crime and auction them off. The proceeds going to victims or the like and weakening or removing irresponsible investors in favor of someone else. But this option is simply unthinkable and instead there's endless debate on the CEO's culpability.

← PreviousPage 11 of 24Next →