HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

TomMckenny

2,285 karma · joined February 19, 2015

submissionscomments
TomMckenny··on US edits National Stockpile website after Kushner claims it’s not for states
I wonder how long it will take for this thread to be buried by people as eager to cover for the regime's ineptitude as Kushner is.
TomMckenny··on Private Equity Wants in on the Bailout? Spare Me
For want of an equally familiar term, "trickle down" is all I had. Apologies if it is critical sounding.

The crisis will end with sky high unemployment, no consumer saving but massively increased personal debt. To raise the deficit solely so companies can make twice as many widgets with half the employees would be the worst possible response. And even this assumes supply side policies do what they claim.

TomMckenny··on Private Equity Wants in on the Bailout? Spare Me
These two options for saving the economy: corporate bailout vs social safety net essentially correspond with belief in trickle down vs Keynesian stimulus. Stated even more bluntly, it is essentially whether you believe customers or assets are most important for business.

It is why the current path begins to resemble 1929 where consumer buying power spiraled downward. If the social isolation period ends with millions of consumers cashless, and in debt then there will be no one for businesses to sell to. In this cases, businesses would have to use any bailout money to employ people unnecessarily for the months it would take until consumers have spare cash: The months of paychecks it will take for them to pay outstanding mortgage payments, back rent, personal loans, credit cards etc plus interest on those. Bailing out consumers/employees avoids this convolution, does not assume that business will act in this uncharacteristic money losing way and, avoids extra expense/risk since consumer loans are higher interest rates/risk than government borrowing.

Furthermore, the trend away from brick and mortar toward online consumption may be enormously sped up by this social isolation period. In this case, many of the businesses bailed out will never fully recover. Consumer spending power is a much better way for the market to evolve than a government guessing which companies are will be viable at the end of this.

TomMckenny··on The Collective Body: Russian experiments in life after death
This will sound odd to the vast majority but there are some who view the whole idea of their personal immortality as awful and the drive to obtain it incomprehensible. Even if it were in some harp filled cloud borne paradise let alone in the real word. To some, permanent existence seems unspeakably nightmarish.
TomMckenny··on The Opium of the Intellectuals
The title contains the words "Marxism" and "intellectual". There are far too many anti-intellectual cold-warriors here that have access to the down vote to have a reasonable conversation on what is really just a philosophic opinion on the matter.

So this thread innately ends up being troll bait.

TomMckenny··on FCC will require phone carriers to authenticate calls by June 2021 [pdf]
The very first sentence of the communications act of 1934 says the FCC exists to regulate communication by wire, congress need not pass a law granting it[1]. And what wording could the new law possibly use that is more explicit than the existing "for the purpose of regulating interstate and foreign commerce in communication by wire"

It's inexplicable that the same party that claims the act establishing the FCC is more limited than the wording states while the federal arbitration act is continuously expanded to cover cases that neither the authors nor previous courts ever tolerated.

[1]https://transition.fcc.gov/Reports/1934new.pdf

TomMckenny··on How do you know if you’re living through the death of an empire?
It need not be theoretical connections to the ancient past. Consider a people who's beliefs get further and further from reality and who's society can't manage to maintain, let alone build, what it used to like roads and bridges. Such a place is in deep trouble almost by definition. And even more oddly, not due to lead pipes or barbarians but purely from social-political causes.

And if we're talking about the US, the world will continue on with it as a 3rd tier power just as it did outside of Rome. Either the Europeans will get their act together or China will dominate with a capital centered dictatorship as the standard.

TomMckenny··on The internet should be a public utility
As you point out, competition is better than monopoly because it provides a surplus that advantages consumers. But some things we do not want a surplus of, for example river dams. Other things can not be competitive even in principle like surface streets. Likewise as was discovered with mass transit and utilities in the last century in a world that did it's absolute best to be laissez faire.

So there are some rare cases where there must be monopolies and if you must have a monopoly, it is better to have one controlled by a democratic government than a self interested clique. At least then there is some possibility of working in the public interest on price and innovation.

That ISPs must always be a monopoly seems unlikely to me. But if it's politically impossible to break them up, then nationalizing them is still far better than the current situation.

TomMckenny··on Ask HN: Is HN a ‘healthy online community’? I’m doing a case study for a class
> Why is strong moderation part of a healthy online community

Membership criterion is central to maintaining the competency level of the members. And competency on the topic (along with intellectual honesty) is the single most, perhaps only, important component to a useful discussion: It would be insanely destructive for the New England Journal of Medicine to publish every single thing it ever received with equal weight in massive weekly tomes.

Moderation acts as competency monitoring to a degree.

The problem with literal membership is that it precludes autodidacts, people new to the field and people who can't be bothered with a complicated process for joining. Thus unrestricted membership with moderation. And indeed on reddit, the highest quality subreddit, /r/science, is the one most aggressively moderated

For fact based, purpose driven venues, if you believe you were censored because of your opinion, you should not have posted an opinion in the first place. That's certainly how it works in the workplace which is how some people need to use the web.

There can be unlimited venues where partially informed people post their opinions, maybe we can call them "healthy" or not. But some people want to work on problems that actually do require knowledge and should not have to have their discussions constantly vandalized. A "functional" venue one might say.

TomMckenny··on Coronavirus patients start to overwhelm US hospitals
In principle that makes perfect sense. And it is important to note that there is another choice other than the two we are given: the one the Europeans have chosen: employee protection/compensation along with any corporate bailouts.

If for political reasons we refuse the European approach then the concern is not that fatality counts and epidemiologist will be balanced by economist but that epidemiologist and economists will be balanced by lobbyists.

As if to underscore this point, the order for 80,000 ventilators[1] was stopped yesterday on grounds that it was too expensive[2]. The cost at 1 billion is equivalent to 1/4 to 1/12 of 1% of the total F-35 order at 428 to 1196 billion [3] And the f-35 order is already controversial to begin with.

[1] https://twitter.com/realdonaldtrump/status/12417326813664829...

[2] https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/26/us/politics/coronavirus-v...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Martin_F-35_Lightning...

TomMckenny··on Wavve: making $76k a month turning podcasts into videos
He has actually made something rather rent seeking so there is no reason to think this is zero-sum-gain.

Beyond that, his lifetime income, even assuming zero business expenses and a hyper optimistic business lifetime, is not remotely enough to guide a government. It's no even enough to buy a decent apartment building.

This income level is closer to the $1000 a month person than the Koch brothers by several decimal places. And the difference between how he got what he has vs theirs is like the difference between a faucet and a drain.

TomMckenny··on Coronavirus patients start to overwhelm US hospitals
But trends in suicide including economic causes are handled by epidemiology[1]

It is great that attention is now being paid to this subject. Although the overall suicide rate has continued to _rise_ in spite of 11 years of a rising DOW, the suicide rate among those approaching retirement has risen significantly in the last decades. From past trends we know this is directly related to social security[2]. I sincerely hope the attention continues and solutions are pursued and deeply hope that, as some think, it is not a cynical ploy.

Likewise, I hope the sudden concern for food security among the vulnerable poor continues.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epidemiology_of_suicide

[2] https://books.google.com/books?id=ESSEHA5TyoIC&pg=PA360&lpg=...

TomMckenny··on Coronavirus patients start to overwhelm US hospitals
Judging from the comments, explaining the severity of the epidemic is now politically charged.

Epidemiologists and the medical field have made it clear we are _under_ reacting. But apparently some politicians want to down play the problem and their obfuscation is echoed in every corner of the web with great zeal and again drowning out reality.

It's like the climate change denial phenomenon but at high speed.

TomMckenny··on About that Hydroxychloroquine for Covid-19 trial
Even before he was president, his calls for infrastructure were praised by democrats. And many on the left praised his calls for tariffs.

But after leading chants to lock up political rivals and repeatedly calling the free press the "enemy of the people"[1], there is indeed nothing any politician from any party with any agenda could ever do to become normalized by democratically minded people.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enemy_of_the_people#Marxist%E2...

TomMckenny··on About that Hydroxychloroquine for Covid-19 trial
Like supporters of Oberan, Erdogan, Bolsonaro, Modi, Putin, Duterte and Maduro, any damning direct quotes will always be claimed to mean something else entirely.

The larger issue is that the leader's supporters know what he is and his relationship to the truth. They know when he looses the popular vote, has consistent majority disapproval and acts with dubious legality. These things don't mater. If fact, that he can retain power in spite of these things is considered a virtue.

They elected him because of single minded ruthlessness and willingness to break laws to permanently eradicate liberalism and the viability of opposing parties. The mere promise of this is so thrilling to them that any action the leader takes is defended or obfuscated unwaveringly even when the defenders don't fully believe or aren't really comfortable with it themselves.

TomMckenny··on Why Don’t We Use Chemical Weapons Anymore?
>Are you really pretending the US, Britain, Soviet Union, etc didn't freely violate the "rules of war" also

No but The US and UK are far less notorious and so are not as good examples.

> Also, the nazis aren't a nation

Given the foulness of the topic but limited space, I wanted to emphasize the enormous difference between the Germans and Japanese of today vs 80 years ago. In retrospect, I should have written Tojo instead of Japan even though he is not a country either.

TomMckenny··on Why Don’t We Use Chemical Weapons Anymore?
Another point of evidence that the author probably omitted out of politeness are the nations that freely violated rules of war yet did not make (much) use of chemical weapons: the nazis on the eastern front and wwii japan.

Also another technology banned because it don't work is the hollow point bullet.

Apparently killing a solider outright is not as destructive as driving him long term onto the medical system. This is also one of the reasons caliber has generally been dropped over time. The 1950s move to the 223 round is pretty explicit on this.

TomMckenny··on About that Hydroxychloroquine for Covid-19 trial
>You're just witnessing the old joke IRL: If Trump could walk on water, the Left would complain that he can't swim.

The skepticism is due to false claims like "anybody that wants can get a test" [1]

But as you say, maybe they shouldn't blame Trump since he says it's not his responsibility [2]

Anyway, why do any treatment if the virus is a hoax[3], hype[4] and fake news[5]

Or at worst, it is only one person coming from China and is totally under control [6]

Certainly the president is not concerned at all about the White-house [7]

And all this must be true because has has known it was a pandemic all along [8]

[1] https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefings-statements/remarks-pres...

[2] https://youtu.be/NezEbDx4B9A?t=102

[3] https://youtu.be/NezEbDx4B9A?t=57

[4] https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/12369751966423900...

[5] https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/12370045091566428...

[6] https://www.cnbc.com/2020/01/22/trump-on-coronavirus-from-ch...

[7] https://youtu.be/NezEbDx4B9A?t=78

[8] https://youtu.be/NezEbDx4B9A?t=109

TomMckenny··on Covid-19 in Hungary: Viktor Orbán pursues dictatorial powers
Beyond campaign financing, the US also has gerrymandering, voter suppression and disproportionate voting like the electoral college. And fixing those things will make the nation better serve it's people by making it more democratic.

Comparing these dictatorships to each other is not meaningful, we would need to compare dictatorship to democracy. Tudor England was better off than medieval England: not a very high bar. For one thing religious executions still happened and there are certainly no written troves of commoners praising the new age.

Elizabethan England was certainly inferior to the Italian renaissance republics of the period. And its people worse of than the latter democratic UK. It is less of a leap forward than 5th century Athens or even 19th century UK. The nearest semi-democracy in time and space would be recently independent Holland which had more freedom and growth: it is even where the American Pilgrims initially fled to. Even among dictatorships, Elizabeth I is not that great: equally despotic Spain had more power, technology and culture, Arab and Asian nations had longer life spans, more sanitation and higher literacy.

To compare democracy vs dictatorship you'd need to countries similar in culture and era. Like North and South Korea.

TomMckenny··on Covid-19 in Hungary: Viktor Orbán pursues dictatorial powers
It was just a mater of time until that group decided stock values exceeded the value of life and epidemic mitigation.

Note also the assumption in "unemployment = death": there will be no social safety net to prevent it.

TomMckenny··on Covid-19 in Hungary: Viktor Orbán pursues dictatorial powers
A dictator has the reverse mechanism. He must spend all his effort and distribute resources to stay in power which means not benefiting the people. If he did not then he would not be the one to rise to or stay dictator.

A democratic leader must please the public which could mean lying to them or being a moron __but__ will also mean working to help them (the more educated the public, the less the lies work) So your chances are always better with democracy.

TomMckenny··on Spain's hospital IT systems under “massive attack” (in Spanish)
There are powerful, influential people down-playing the seriousness of the epidemic while they unload stock. Pointlessly murder a few people by puncturing ambulance tires or profitably contribute statistically to the death of millions, there seem to be some deeply evil people around.
TomMckenny··on Shall We Play a Market Timing Game? (2018)
Yes, it simulates the hypothesis that future markets are unknowable. Which would indeed be begging the question. Unless of course you find that whenever you apply technical trading to a Monte Carlo market, you get the same results as applied to real market history. Then you show that the signals technical trading uses are not actually predictive.

At any rate, if the market trends upward and trading is close to random (regardless of what the trader believes) then being out of the market occasionally will always be bad statistically. If there are vast numbers of traders all actually acting randomly then some will out preform others and some tiny number might out preform the market. In fact, if you have the data, you can plot the performance of every trader against the market average and actually measure how far from random the average trader is.

Maybe price to earnings ratio "should" relate to stock price. But in actuality stock price is determined by what people are willing to pay for it obviously. To the degree that people are buying and selling _not_ based on P/E, say for example they are doing so somewhat randomly, then the P/E won't reflect accurately the stock price: it won't be predictive.

These hulking paragraphs is what the demo is basically saying.

TomMckenny··on Amazon raises overtime pay for warehouse workers
The administration would certainly order employees back to work under the Taft–Hartley Act under threat of imprisonment. While it resists ordering companies to produce critically need medical supplies on ideological grounds[1], there can be no doubt that it would not miss an opportunity to damage labor organizations.

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/20/us/politics/trump-coronav...

TomMckenny··on Hyperland (1990) [video]
Technology can been something better. But we decided to make these thing rather than something else. Or we created a system that preferred these thing over something else.

So I can not blame technology for what is clearly a human/social priority problem.

TomMckenny··on NASA to launch 247 petabytes of data into AWS, but forgot about egress costs
Judging from the random yet inexplicable 42 cent bill on a free account I set up years ago, I'd say their memory is positively unbelievable.
TomMckenny··on GM’s CEO Offers to Make Ventilators in WWII-Style Mobilization
There are a couple possible re-thinkings. The disturbing one is where it is noticed that we are essentially sacrificing a bit of the economy to reduce fatalities. So next time it is decided that company valuations are worth the extra deaths[1]

I submit that rethinking needs to be started early rather than late so the discussion isn't dominated by euphemisms for some very dark path.

[1] As we know, social isolation is to spread out the pace of acute cases so as not to overwhelm hospitals. But it obviously slows the economy considerably. The alternative would be to not to isolate, keeping businesses wide open and allow the medical system to be overwhelmed with its accompanying higher mortality rate.

TomMckenny··on For Years WallStreet Spent More on Buybacks Than It Earned-Now They Want Bailout
It's remarkable that the same parties who denounce any government participation in markets will be using that government to decide which companies to prop up. No doubt with lobbyist's advice.

The irony is there is a way to do this _and_ use a little market force: dump the money on to consumers and let them rather than lobbyists decide what is worth keeping afloat. I imagine in that case, cruise lines would be lower priority.

TomMckenny··on Stay home except for essential needs
True, the draft is not an ideal example. None the less, the court is hardly infallible: for example, it is odd that congress can not constitutionally require medical insurance but can institute taxes and even prohibit the consumption of anything deemed to be an intoxicant.

Or for more specific examples, given, Gore v Bush, when exactly does the court have standing to intervene in a presidential election? Given DC v. Heller in 2008, what does the word "militia" mean now? Why, to everyone's surprise, did maritime law suddenly limit punitive damages with Exxon vs Baker (2008)? Why did the court narrowly reverse 200 years of convention and the near universal understating of speech with Citizens United?

TomMckenny··on Stay home except for essential needs
The government can compel you to take up arms and risk death on a battle field. I think you'll find the constitution is entirely up to the whims of the courts which makes it far less absolute than one imagines.
← PreviousPage 3 of 24Next →