HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

TomMckenny

2,285 karma · joined February 19, 2015

submissionscomments
TomMckenny··on Man who stockpiled hand sanitizer donates it all ahead of investigation
True, I put the point bluntly.

If the market produces bad outcomes for years on end, which it in some narrow cases it does, do we 1) keep with it regardless or 2) do something else.

I think you will find there are quite a few people who will choose #1

TomMckenny··on Man who stockpiled hand sanitizer donates it all ahead of investigation
Food, water distribution, internet, building construction are all things people produce and must be paid for to exist and out of fairness. Land ownership is and always has been an arbitrary claim inevitably traceable to a murdered Indian or the equivalent on other continents.
TomMckenny··on Man who stockpiled hand sanitizer donates it all ahead of investigation
There also seem to be differences in underlying assumptions: whether humans exist to serve markets or whether markets exist only because they happen benefit humanity. And a similar question for property itself.
TomMckenny··on Italy and South Korea virus outbreaks reveal disparity in deaths and tactics
City or village, you'll need one where store clerks don't come in to work when sick due to lack of sick days and no one avoids testing and doctors for lack of insurance.
TomMckenny··on Ask HN: Was the Y2K crisis real?
Don't even get me started on "epicenter"
TomMckenny··on Richard Rorty in Tehran
The term "post-modern" has become immensely overloaded so is hard to use clearly. Obviously, the notion that "everything is relative" is even self contradictory but is not what is meant when the term is used seriously.

It is the idea that some values are absolute and can be forced on other that was originally being objected to. Some historical cases are obvious others are still ambiguous. Thus a debate is interesting.

Likewise, inside our society we have crucial rights justified as being "endowed by our creator". We would need to justify these values on something stronger than a particular theology to explain their universality. So again, discussion is worthwhile. I believe raising this point is what caused a ruckus in Iran.

But yes, the term "post-modern" has made it's way into pop culture and is so widely used it is often hard to figure out what the speaker means by it. Better would be specifically referencing "Rorty's ideas" which I am certain you would find coherent and very intriguing. Rorty was most definitely not in Iran to say "theology is as good as democracy".

TomMckenny··on China Uighurs 'moved into factory forced labour' for foreign brands
Unfortunately, the cheapest legal product will dominate almost any market. Slave made products are de-facto legal on the world market so the market takes advantage of that.

And not to diminish the horror of China's practice here, but I imagine they would call these slave factories "penal servitude"

TomMckenny··on The boss who put everyone on 70K
You can not even buy a house built on the 1950s on 70k a year. And while most quality claims (which usually lack actual numbers) certainly look subjective, the quality of a dirt lot or vial of insulin has obviously not changed while their adjusted inflation price has sky rocketed.

At any rate, the claim that "stuff" is more expensive because it is better implies that decades of technical improvements have resulted in no efficiency gains. At best, it implies the value per man hour has essentially remained flat. And since the option of buying lower priced versions of items has dispersed, we can never know if the higher quality item is fairly priced.

TomMckenny··on Disney blocks John Oliver’s new episode critical of India’s PM Modi
This is a government using implicit, extra legal threats to silence it's critics. As opposed to mass pro-democracy, human rights moments to counter pro-regime propaganda. People used to be able to tell the difference. For example, that's why apartheid ended.
TomMckenny··on Amazon let a fraudster keep my Sony A74 IV and refunded him
Thief's last name is just an initial.

I say "thief" because that's how it looks to me. But how can I or Amazon be confident given the evidence I've only just read about?

What would help is posting up front a list of evidence that would convince Amazon in case of a dispute. If Amazon does not provide this then perhaps a third party could figure it out and post it.

TomMckenny··on Did the early internet activists blow it?
As you say, the problem is not 8chan or "the daily stormer" for that matter. But it _is_ Facebook. Anything goes sites like 8chan have so much reality free and bizarre content that they have only the tiniest impact. Yet they provide insight into those mindsets and their trends.

But Facebook and Twitter inject extremely harmful falsehoods into reams of fluff and corporate posts. This gives them far more legitimacy, weight and exposure than they would otherwise have. And since those two have made agitating posts part of their business model, regardless of historic levels of societal harm, the problem is not fixed.

I would be appalled if anything I built were used to do such harm, I would use every ounce of my being to stop it. If necessary I would shut the whole thing down rather than have my name remembered forever as such a facilitator. Obviously Zuckerberg has a different mindset and is clearly no Alfred Nobel.

TomMckenny··on Back to the Future
Most likey we've done all the low hanging fruit: supersonic flight is categorically more difficult than subsonic yet is a diminishing return given that so much time is just spent preparing for the flight. And, Peter's opinion not withstanding, it is impossible to communicate faster than light which is where we are.

But if we have become decadent, it hardly surprising in a society where opinion is give more weight than facts and people are not even willing to preserve their democracy.

TomMckenny··on Ask HN: What’s the most important modern simple invention?
The cargo container: it has changed the entire planet culturally, economically and geopolitically. It would be hard to count the percentage of every day objects most people use world wide that owe their availability or existence to that standardized metal box.
TomMckenny··on Environmental lawyer who won a judgment against Chevron lost everything
That is a good question. I wonder if maybe no judgement has even been entered, just the contempt ruling.

And if so, could this trick could be used to prevent an appeal and keep him under arrest indefinitely?

IANAL obviously, but very curious.

TomMckenny··on No City Hates Its Landlords Like Berlin Does
I was listing barriers namely debt and market research. The market research barrier is solved in such a way that it produces a de-facto cartel.

But indeed, "Never" is to strong a term. "Typically in the US" would be more correct.

in 2000, the average US rent was $600 and the vacancy rate was 7.8%

in 2018, the average US rent was $1400 and the vacancy rate was 7.5%

I can not list every city in the country that has lost population but I can start with two: As I mention elsewhere, Flint Michigan has lost some 20% of it's population since 2000 and rent has still risen. And searching California for cities with declining population (there are not many) the first I found, Citrus Heights CA, has had a net drop in population in the last 20yers yet rent has increased four fold.

At any rate, the down votes make it clear this information is not welcome here.

TomMckenny··on No City Hates Its Landlords Like Berlin Does
The barriers include psychological refusal and debt on the building. But the main barrier, at least for residential property, is researching competing prices. This is solved by using a service. The same service all land lords use.

This is why there are no examples of any towns where rent is less than it was decade ago regardless of population decline. It is why there are rising numbers of working homeless in towns with rising vacancies.

It is the chief mechanism driving ever increasing rental profits which is probably why merely mentioning the existence of the service, its ubiquitous use and success draws such silent ire. Silent because of course anyone can just google for the service. It also does not match the standard narrative which no doubt annoys people in inarticulable ways.

Likelihood is a real measurable quantity with a real number attached. You can obtain it by counting the defection rate: the number who lower their rent. This number is observably zero.

TomMckenny··on No City Hates Its Landlords Like Berlin Does
This theory is simply not correct, the market is broken. Even flint Michigan has lost 1/5 of it's population since 2000 and rent has still risen. Just show me some towns where the market works.

The use of that software has exactly the same outcome as a cartel but, understandably, few people want to acknowledge that even to themselves.

TomMckenny··on No City Hates Its Landlords Like Berlin Does
Prices are set by the Property Management Software SaaS that all landlords use. So it is a Cartel. That is why prices rise even in places where population drops and vacancies rise.

This can't be a surprise, vast swathes of the economy have fallen into virtual monopoly over that last few decades.

By the way, I think we can extrapolate candidate Bloomberg's (non)position on the housing issue here.

TomMckenny··on You have a set amount of “weirdness points” – spend them wisely (2014)
I think the article's claim is that bigotry against appearances is so strong that it uses up people's ability to keep an open mind on any other topic of discussion. Which is to say, we live in a world at the moment where when someone meets a transgender person, much of the time the only challenging topics they can think about are transgender related: for example they will have trouble concentrating on arguments concerning cryogenics.

Not to say this is a good or fair thing. But if true, it is a data point to keep in mind and maybe even fix.

So the suggested remedy concerning appearances, has to be re-thought in some cases.

TomMckenny··on Higher social class predicts increased unethical behavior (2012)
True, one should always avoid the word "always". But given that the world just saw a Senate trial of a nations highest ranking member occur with no witness and no evidence allowed, the claim remains pretty strong.
TomMckenny··on Children as young as 9 locked up by Indian Police for speech violation
Many people calling for free speech are undisturbed by a leader that calls the press "the enemy of the people" and leads rally where the press is screamed at and intimidated and where chants to lock up political opponents are common.
TomMckenny··on Higher social class predicts increased unethical behavior (2012)
Since higher position in a social structure always means better treatment by the judicial system, it should be expected that the reduced deterrent would result in more bad behavior.
TomMckenny··on Ask HN: How do we stop the polarization/toxicicity filling the web?
>silencing everyone who disagrees with you

That is not remotely what is being suggested.

Toxicity is when a site devoted to people mourning a synagogue massacre is overwhelmed by spamming neo-nazis.

Toxicity is annihilating a site's function: a site where climate scientists discuss findings needs to be free of an flood of spam from climate change deniers and paid petroleum sock puppets. Such a site exists for people to do their job not waste every day repeating the same basic information available elsewhere easier to people who came intentionally to disrupt.

TomMckenny··on Ask HN: How do we stop the polarization/toxicicity filling the web?
Does free speech include yelling down other speakers? In the physical world this rarely happens. But spamming and vandalizing an intelligent conversation with sock-puppets and intentionally disingenuous posts is trivial and universal on the web.

Consider a parallel phenomenon: I notice there is outrage among gamers when cheating happens. But ironically cheating in conversation causes less active outrage. Both of these behaviors happen easily on the web but are difficult in real life. Maybe because conversation destroying behavior is less well understood or more stealthy. Maybe because it's so unimaginable in real life, people aren't used to dealing with it. Whatever the cause it's absurd that for games the problem is solved more zealously than in conversations that have serious impact.

TomMckenny··on How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost?
It would also be interesting to know how many dollars per man hour.
TomMckenny··on Hackers acting in Turkey's interests believed to be behind recent cyberattacks
Could be the whole thing is faked by an other country. Could be all the logs were misread. Could be the west trying to make Erdogan look bad, or a plot by Gulen or maybe UFOS.

But more likely is a regime spewing conspiracy theories so the people can no longer tell truth from fiction.

TomMckenny··on Hackers acting in Turkey's interests believed to be behind recent cyberattacks
Reading the article, it seems the conclusion was inferred from the fact that Cyprus, Greece, Albania and Turkish Masons were targets. That those targets are not a good way to steal but are all disliked by the current regime. That several western analysts concluded they were government sponsored and that the attacks were quite complex.
TomMckenny··on Why did we wait so long for the cotton gin? (2017)
This effect can not be over stated. Plantation owners never invented the cotton gin in spite of the vast numbers of them and decades of cotton raising.

I suspect there were additional social issues at play as well. For example, plantation owners, being at the top of the social hierarchy have less incentive to invent. Also that tier typically views tinkering and mechanics as lower status and so would avoid it on principle: prestige was based on land size and number of other people owned. Certainly not number of new ideas.

TomMckenny··on How housing became the world’s biggest asset class
I can't claim expertise comparing particular funds. But for example, hasn't Vanguard's Real Estate EFT outperformed the S&P 500 by a wide margin?

And beside serious investors, for the typical individual, a home loan allows them to leverage funds that are unimaginably beyond what they could raise for investment with vastly more safety. Not that I suggest it would be better if half the population could and did buy stocks on unlimited margin or the like.

I just want to point out that even on this one particular issue, we gradually made policy and decided and made it such that one kind of loan is vital and the other insanely too risky. That at this point, this is so ingrained that it's hard to imagine any alternative. But I suggest we should probably try.

TomMckenny··on How housing became the world’s biggest asset class
It will not crash. There maybe a temporary double digit dip in prices described in hyperbolic "end of the world crash" terms to demand government intervention to prop up prices. But without large social-economic change, land/housing prices will quickly recover and continue to outpace wage growth and many other productive investments.

We have shifted to an economy that increasingly favors rent seeking in every field and land is quintessentially that. Even without that trend, land reform meets enormous resistance under any circumstances but given that shift, even more so now.

Note that we know people will endure housing conditions seen everywhere at all time up until the 20th century, and unless the people hurt[1] by this do something remarkably effective, that state of affairs is guaranteed to return: there is no invisible hand guaranteeing even one family per room let alone per unit.

[1] disproportionately wage earners and the young but also all paying rent and mortgage interest.

← PreviousPage 4 of 24Next →