HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

TomMckenny

2,285 karma · joined February 19, 2015

submissionscomments
TomMckenny··on Jeff Bezos's phone 'hacked by Saudi crown prince'
Of course, the nation that the Saudi's rely on for aid and military hardware could pressure them. But that would require some minimal commitment to human rights and a free press. And no personal desire to silence criticism from the WaPo by it's president.
TomMckenny··on Glenn Greenwald Charged with Cybercrimes in Brazil
We've entered an era where hounding and intimidating journalists is considered a legitimate political position. So they probably really are genuine far right users, Brazilian and otherwise, swept up by the reality distorting extremism of the day.

And their influence will continue to expand so long as they are able to shout down, spam and vandalize venues that might have been used to find solutions.

TomMckenny··on Aussie firefighters save world's only groves of prehistoric Wollemi pines
In-spite of our self confidence, our knowledge of biology and ecology is just the tiniest beginning. Letting organisms and genes disappear is insanely reckless.

An analogy would be an illiterate dark age monk wondering if he should let random Greek and Roman books burn in his fireplace.

TomMckenny··on Education and Men without Work
Benefits are much more generous and much easier to get in countries with much higher worker participation. And they have the same video games in other countries too.

And marriage does not cause entry in the workforce, participation in the workforce is what makes marriage partners more interested.

Reduction in benefits has not and is no increasing work participation. There was not spike in worker participation in the 90s when massive "reform" was undertaken. There is no increased work force participation from the cut backs being done now or in recent years. Yet loosening of work safety regulations would certainly be expected to increase disabilities for manual laborers. So the best conclusion is that the supposed cheaters aren't.

Also, if those not participating in the work force are merely enjoying life on theses supposed benefits, one would not expect the already high and ever increasing suicide rate in this sector.

The author's ideology entails denying calls for higher wages by diverting what is clearly a demand/wage problem[1] into a culture war issue.

[1] I'm guessing the author is a fan of Adam Smith where lack of participation is _always_ caused by under pricing. Apparently the author is willing to accept pretty thin evidence to drop Smith when that theory might benefit labor.

TomMckenny··on A game theorist breaks down the effects of inequality
>...immoral...

There is no morality involved. The assertion is only that's it's more _productive_ to distribute resources this way. Productivity might be a multiplier but can not be innately good itself.

TomMckenny··on Think Debtors Prisons Are a Thing of the Past? Not in Mississippi
These people had no wage garnishment, instead they were sentenced to forced labor. Why the difference? Because they are poor.

And the line between civil and criminal is often drawn in a peculiar way: Repeat copyright violation enough and somehow it's criminal not civil, but systematically fail to pay artists their royalties it remains civil forever. Embezzling $1000 is criminal, keeping $1000 out of an employee paycheck is a civil.

TomMckenny··on Think Debtors Prisons Are a Thing of the Past? Not in Mississippi
The "except as a punishment for crime" in the 13th amendment was not in the first drafts. But less progressive minded forces got in the final version with the obvious intent of using it[1]. And it has certainly gotten a lot of use in spite of occasional whack-a-mole attempts to moderate it.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thirteenth_Amendment_to_the_Un...

TomMckenny··on A Man Who’s Spending $1B to Own Every Pop Song
That 90% does not live on IP, they live by offering medical care, police service, education, roads, reservoirs and aqueducts. By transporting those farm goods, inventing new tractors and efficiently managing all these things.

And while pop songs artists may deserve compensation, society does not crucially depend on someone collecting royalties for generations after the guy's death.

On the farmer analogy (and inspired by the recent .org tld acquisition), if one really wanted to extract rents, simply acquire the land they work on and set them all to sharecropping.

TomMckenny··on A Man Who’s Spending $1B to Own Every Pop Song
Seems that's the way society ended up being structured. Perhaps we will all end up selling houses to each other and no one will have to make anything at all!

I swear, even the Aztecs had a less destructive system.

TomMckenny··on Blackout Bug: Boeing 737 cockpit screens go blank if lands on specific runways
A Ukrainian airline but it occurred in Tehran, Iran a few hours after the missile attack. It was taking off, not landing.
TomMckenny··on Why are we using black box models in AI when we don’t need to? (2019)
>No amount of white-boxing or model transparency will get around this trilemma. The sooner the industry comes to grips with it and learns to explicitly wield it when required, the better.

Agreed. The optima of multiple criterion will essentially never intersect.

But for Amazon, there is no evidence the tool was accurately selecting the best candidates. They themselves never said it was. After all, altering word choices in a trivial way dramatically affects ranking. On the points you mention, why should we assume their data was relevant or their fitness function even doing what they thought? If they were naive enough, they could just be building something that predicts what the staff of an e-commerce monopoly in a parallel universe will look like.

The most likely story is that they failed at what they were doing. Part of that failure happened to be controversial and so got unwanted attention. I would guess there were quite a few incredible correlations the tool "discovered" that did not get to press.

At any rate, their recommendation engine is more important and has been worked on longer yet it is conspicuously flawed. When their recommendation tool inspires awe then maybe we could take their recruiting engine seriously enough to imagine it has found deep socio-psychological-genetic secrets.

TomMckenny··on Why are we using black box models in AI when we don’t need to? (2019)
If an algorithm is clearly sorting on irrelevant criterion, especially a black box algorithm, we normally assume it's a bug. It's not reasonable to reverse that, assume the code is incapable of being mistaken and say that obviously irrelevant criterion are somehow correct in an unknown way.

Amazon's problem is a bug, they even describe it's nature. And given how flawed their recommendation algorithms are, it's especially unreasonable to assume this one is infallible.

So that linked Reuters does not show a failure to find bias, if anything it shows a design error.

TomMckenny··on Porn site to pay $12.7M to women who didn't know videos would be posted
I think you are saying that we should treat the accused as just that: innocent until proven guilty. Which is a very good policy. Especially since this industry sees a lot of attacks on the grounds of of "immorality"

But in this case we have moved beyond merely accused. We have a completed verdict in a real trail. And although the judicial system has flaws, in this case the weaker parties actually won against the more powerful. And in several instances too.

So I think it's reasonable people feel quite confident that the verdict was correct and that the good guys won here.

TomMckenny··on Philosophy as a public service
Competition for resources is only one human behavior. In nature, it is carefully balanced not to disrupt the stability of the well functioning community that all primates must have at all times to survive.

Being social animals, another more critical instinct is the need to cooperate. Indeed, eliminating cooperation from a human group will extinguish it faster than eliminating competition (assuming it's even possible). And when people have a choice in the matter, pecking order is based on amount of support the higher up people provide to the group, not the leaders ability to serve himself: people do not knowingly and freely back someone who has no interest in backing them.

Also instinctive is the sense of fairness[1] Of course those with an abundance of resources might want to convince others that this instinct is unnatural or somehow harmful. But it is clearly a well established instinct over a wide range of mammals and exists for a reason.

And while the meaning of life varies greatly from person to person, I suspect that a life lived solely to maximize one's own resources will be as comfortable as it feels meaningless. I image evolution has made it that way. At least so people will have children but also to work fairly with others. Otherwise we would have wandered completely alone in the jungles and been eaten out of existence by Pliocene tigers.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=meiU6TxysCg&feature=youtu.be...

TomMckenny··on Do Not Trust Journalists – A Mormon Example
I think his followers maybe (accidentally?) dissembling: He only became president of the Quorum six years _after_ the iron curtain fell. And Mormons account for well less than 0.1% of Eastern Europeans. So to say he had something to do with it is another reason to be suspicious of those saying wanting to change his obituary.
TomMckenny··on Finnish PM Marin calls for 4-day-week and 6-hours working day in the country
Keynes conjectured reduced workload (or the equivalent: ever rising compensation) would be the natural consequence of increased productivity. What went wrong seems to come from at least two things he did not expect.

Firstly, rather than continuing the trend of increasing political power in the early post war period, the productive classes, including employees, have lost political power relative to the ownership classes and thus control of resource allocation decisions.

Secondly, outside tech and a few other vibrant sectors, capital sits idles or is used unproductively (for example in real-estate speculation) or even to destroy wealth (for example through expanded rent seeking). This is relevant because in these cases the increased wealth from increased productivity is just wasted rather than being used productively or at least spent on quality of life.

It's nice to see that somewhere, a few people are trying to address that first issue.

TomMckenny··on Alcohol and social bonding in humans (2018)
What I'm wondering is whether our attitude toward alcohol poisoning is like that toward "hot" peppers and herbs. I understand that those last two repel broad groups of animals. So perhaps being tipsy is something other animals despise while we tolerate and even welcome it.

_if_ that is the case then it opens up carbohydrates to us that other animals pass up. Maybe it's even testable in a lab.

TomMckenny··on Alcohol and social bonding in humans (2018)
I'm going to guess that human tolerance of alcohol has some evolutionary advantage. In addition to being a social lubricant, which seems to be critical to the species, I can imagine it's previous value was that it let us eat not-so-fresh fruit that the other beasties couldn't.
TomMckenny··on Do Not Trust Journalists – A Mormon Example
Watson's bigotry was not a key feature of his legacy. It was confined to some comments that would hardly directly impact anyone. And he resigned after it.

Contrasted with his discoveries that will benefit all humanity forever. To a reasonable person, this is obviously more defining than his ineffectual coarse statements at the end of his career.

Conversely, Monson was the leader of a relatively small religious group which he worked to benefit in roughly the standard manner.

But he also used his considerable power to directly lobby and negatively affect thousands of people far outside his own religion. He certainly did not resign over this but worked continuously and unapologetic.

So as you say, it'd be pretty ridiculous to portray Watson's core legacy was bigotry. But clearly reasonable people can disagree about Monson's legacy. Especially those who were directly affected.

Rather than a scientist, I think a better comparison would be other religious or maybe political leaders. Elsewhere I point out complaints about Jefferson Davis' historic portrayal. Another might be Saint Louis of France. Or Pope Gregory VII, reformer and which hunter. (For that matter even the city of Salem Mass is still defined by its lunacy 300 years ago.) Trump's obituary will either list the impeachment first or not, either at length or not. Either way someone will _call_ it biased but that doesn't mean it is.

TomMckenny··on Do Not Trust Journalists – A Mormon Example
>The author's point is that the obituary only mentioned recent events, ignoring the rest of his career.

But that isn't true: it is the _blogger_ who is shifting the facts to mold opinions

In addition to has lobbying against lgbt and women, the article covers his birth, earliest job, naval career, university degree with honors, wife children and business. It mentions his 1950 bishop appointment, his visits to service men in the Korean war, his 1963 promotion, his presidency, and the expansion of the church under his leadership.

The article even literally says "he embraced humanitarian causes with Christian, Jewish and Muslim groups supporting homeless shelters, food banks, nursing homes and disaster relief efforts in the United States and abroad."

When the blogger claims it only discusses recent events, he is, at best, mistaken. Of course it does not emphasizes or order them in the way the blogger wants which is not surprising in that he would like his religious leader portrayed more positively. Other people, on the other hand are not interested in having articles honed to conform to the desires of a religious group.

Luckily, he has a church run paper he can read and the rest of us have a less religious centered source. Which is exactly how it is supposed to be. What is less clear is why the Deseret News (and other rightist papers) receive so little pressure to change, while the NYT receives a continuous stream of denunciation even from the highest government leaders.

But, as you say, absolutely no-one has to read a particular news paper, that is part of a free press. The other part is that the press be free from government interference.

TomMckenny··on Do Not Trust Journalists – A Mormon Example
Of course rather than taking a bloggers opinion of bias as fact, one could actually read the piece and see for oneself whether it is as outrageously biased as is claimed.

Unfortunately, no doubt due to some oversight on the part of the blogger, the link to the original, rather than being with the top image, is actually pretty buried so here it is.

https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/03/obituaries/thomas-monson-...

TomMckenny··on Drones flying nighttime patterns over NE Colorado leave law enforcement stumped
I know neither farming nor IR technology so let me ask: is there really publicly available technology that allows a person to identify a crop at a few hundred feet at those speeds in the dark from a drone?
TomMckenny··on Do Not Trust Journalists – A Mormon Example
But what constitutes the most salient points is a matter of opinion. Which explains the considerable length of the NYT obituary[1] In such a lengthy piece, which omitted items could the blogger think were more important than the boy scout lobbing? Because that did affect quite a few thousand lives.

Of course to those who don't think gay's have a legitimate claim to rights, emphasizing discrimination is just a political attack on an otherwise good guy. Just as Fifty years ago bringing up a "good" man's discrimination against African American would be called politically liberal bias. Just as a hundred years before that the legality of Mormonism was merely a political topic, completely unimportant when describing the overall charter of a man.

Those who feel that lgbt people _do_ have these rights will obviously think those who act against those rights are crucially defined by that opposition.

For contrast, consider an extremely philanthropic atheist had worked hard to keep Mormons out of the boy scouts. Should the NYT down play that or would it shameless biased and political to mention it?

It turns out, the NYT wrote a lengthy obituary covering Monson's acts and including boy scout lobbing. And since that last is of extreme interest to millions of people, it certainly qualifies as important enough to be in a paper.

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/03/obituaries/thomas-monson-...

TomMckenny··on Do Not Trust Journalists – A Mormon Example
Also in press freedom and other civil liberties it is easily comparable to European countries, which is fantastic.

There are some social issues where the US remains conservative like attitudes toward nudity and sex as well as religiosity and church attendance and child punishment. There are more displays of nationalism like school children daily saying the pledge etc. More significant issues include the death penalty and mass incarceration. But in fiscal issues, the US is much more conservatives. Even the party on the "left" houses Bloomberg, Bezos and Soros.

Consumer protection is unimaginably weak by European standards as are protections for employees. All the "liberal" media outlets have a center-right market focus. The WSJ is well to the right of Bloomberg Media and the Economist which themselves are firmly free market. Calls for nationalization of industries that Europeans long ago switched to non-profit are unheard of in the States.

Even universal healthcare, which is universally supported by European parties and much of the third world is a non-starter for Republicans and under endless debate by Democrats. Government sponsored housing is no longer even discussed and structures are even demolished. Likewise support for adequate pensions as well as food and housing for the indigent: "Welfare reform" which was a reduction in the social safety net, was embraced by B Clinton who is considered by many in the US to be an extreme liberal.

TomMckenny··on Do Not Trust Journalists – A Mormon Example
There are certainly some who do this, notably News Corp[1]. And the huge presence of that organization gives the impression that all others are this way too.

But it simply isn't true of respectable publications. People don't go to journalism school thinking "I'm going to devote my life to hiding facts". If they do, they don't graduate. And papers aren't interested in hiring people that are going to create an endless stream of retractions. Likewise, any outlet that doesn't issues retractions is highly suspect. So reporters at respectable paper really are trying to find the truth.

Indeed, this whole thread is not about facts but about a person's opinion about the tone of an article. And, quite frankly, a blog post that is lying about the article when he says it only mentions negative aspects of Monson's life[2] Which is probably why the lead image is not actually linked to the NYT article.

Papers often print things people don't want to be true, or say them in ways that offend certain groups. But to rely on a gut feeling or general annoyance or selected anecdotes to decide that a paper is lying would be an error.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jane_Akre

[2]https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/03/obituaries/thomas-monson-...

TomMckenny··on Do Not Trust Journalists – A Mormon Example
The NYT article _is_ comprehensive, covering most of what the blogger says it lacked. Which is probably why he did not actually link to it.

https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/03/obituaries/thomas-monson-...

TomMckenny··on Do Not Trust Journalists – A Mormon Example
That information is in the NYT article too. Which is probably why the blogger did not actually link to it.

https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/03/obituaries/thomas-monson-...

TomMckenny··on Do Not Trust Journalists – A Mormon Example
Unfortunately, this is just saying the US is more liberal than most 3rd world countries which is not very flattering.
TomMckenny··on Do Not Trust Journalists – A Mormon Example
Exactly. The other force at work is rising religious-nationalism which makes it increasingly difficult for the press to speak ill of powerful people.
TomMckenny··on Do Not Trust Journalists – A Mormon Example
> Journalists focus on the most attention grabbing tidbit

In this case, the NYT's title was "Thomas Monson, President of the Mormon Church, Dies at 90" But the blog's title is "Do Not Trust Journalism"

>they double down on their position

But what the reported on Monson is true! They did not add flattering points the way the church wanted because this is how a free-press in a non-theocracy works!

← PreviousPage 5 of 24Next →