2,285 karma · joined February 19, 2015
While Monson is obviously not Jeff Davis, his opposition to the rights of a minority hurt an awful lot of people.
And 180,000 saints agree (the author and Mormoms generally refer to themselves as saints). But it is still an _opinion_ by a group who are so opposed to gay rights, they continue to oppose a pro-equality supreme court decision that included four conservative justices. Presumably the many millions of "non-saints" this discrimination works against in daily life have an opposite _opinion_ about this issues' importance.
The blogger, also accuses the NYT of being click bait. The NYT's title was "Thomas Monson, President of the Mormon Church, Dies at 90". The blogger titles his post "Do Not Trust Journalism" stretching what is an accurate report whose topic ordering he does not like, to imply every story in the NYT and indeed all journalism is deceitful. For example, Reuters had the same title.
I too could become an obscure blogger with religio-emotionally shaped opinions and clickbait titles if I posted a one side response article titled "Mormons Oppose Free Press". Such a story would be as unworthy of serious attention as this one.
But instead, this story is taken seriously. An indication of how far down the anti-press, anti-reality, pro-religious-nationalism rabbit hole we have fallen. A result of a trend where tales from the most obscure parts of the web are sought out to match the readers preconceived opinions and then taken as complete gospel over all else regardless of implausibility or internal inconsistency.
Religions and certain secular leaders and their followers often dislike the press and much of literature, it will never be too hard to find someone somewhere claiming things they don't like are deception and thus presumably "evil". For example in Italy at this same period, you will find outraged denunciation of press "lying" criticism of Padre Pio.
Conversely, it would be nice to talk with clear headed people about a solution to the rise of religious-nationalism including its war on the press rather than debating obscure right wing blog's cry of "Lügenpresse". Just as it's nice to talk to informed people about climate without repeatedly facing a stream of deniers.
Ultimately I image many will decide that truth is between these two: that reality lays halfway between the uncomfortable facts they learn and the things that they wish were true.
Is the movement so narcissistic that the very existence of the people already living there is not even noticed? Is this hypothetical country a place where you ruthlessly steal from the original people to make a state where private property is the only right? Because "bleak" is the exact word that describes the lives of the millions of people who don't even show up on libertarian radar.
And "hypothetical"is the right word because there were taxes and regulation form America's earliest beginnings. And, fortunately, it protected more rights than just property. Indeed, the founding fathers intentionally _removed_ the word "property" from the original phrase "life liberty and the pursuit of property"
If there are any analogies to North America, it would either be the Puritans who had shockingly strict ideological requirements on their members or plantation owners who lived by laws completely different than their slaves. Because we know these libertarian colonists are not going to be building their own log cabins or personally work "their" land. Startups are those bootstrapped farms and self built log cabins. Likewise space exploration. But colonialism, when it isn't simply theft, is rent seeking and always at best zero-sum-gain.
>not let the plot of a video game limit our social innovation
"Bioshock" is apparently a necessary comparison because its plot is clearly more accurately known North American history evidently.
But it's hard to imagine space technology would advance faster if NASA and JPL suddenly ceased to exist. It's even harder to imagine space tech would be anywhere near as far along as it is now if they had never existed in the first place. Besides that, the Apollo program supported almost the entire semiconductor and even transistor industry for a decade. Our world today would be unrecognizably more primitive with out that.
And while "useful" military applications gave us the V2, and then the space race to build suborbital missiles capable of carrying nuclear payloads, the "socialist" non military NASA projects involve less city destruction or risk of nuclear annihilation. A future orbital arms race will presumably move some land based missiles into orbit and cut down crucial retaliation decision time to seconds. "Useful" though it may be, military expansion would be the kind of development best avoided
So China did not fall behind because of Zheng He, it fell behind _inspite_ of him. It fell behind because an overly restrictive, incurious, overly frugal leadership prematurely _stopped_ exploration, both government and private. A similar thing happen to Japan without ever having a costly initial government expedition.
Conversely, Norse exploration failed even though it which was low cost, benefit driven and not central subsidized. Overall, Europe was lucky in that it was so balkanized that a few countries were bound to send/allow ships into the unknown. "Lucky" also was that a gold filled North American blocked Columbus on what would have been a suicide trip across Pacific + Atlantic. Which trip, incidentally, was government funded.
And, when the grand-parent says that "some people are in denial" about problems with medical, housing and other costs and problems. Apparently they're not just in conspiracy theory denial but even seek to prevent the merest mentioning of these issues.
When it's done by a foreign government, it's an act of aggression. When it's done internally, it's an expression of camping financing.
Like brain cancer vs skin cancer I suppose.
The fact that arbitration actually exists is because there is a disconnect between price and wealth generated solely by information differential.
And beyond an exchange, that, merely because their parent's opportunity cost differs greatly, raising one infant is in fact vastly more valuable than another essentially identical infant.
I would suggest that price is not identical to value, it's just that the market is usually the best way to determine a value.
Even if you qualify, there is limit to how total many section 8s are given out. So there is a waiting list of several years, during which time you must still qualify.
You can not just sign up on that waiting list. There are small windows open at random a few days a year when they will accept names.
No leasor is required to accept section 8 people and very few do. So even if you get a section 8 voucher, you still need a lot of luck to find a place.
Thus the streets are paved with homeless.
And it is difficult to identify the motivation behind every piece of legislation but the Roosevelt administration, Beveridge, LBJ and others often acted with the clear intent of creating greater equality. And, as I think you point out, did things that would have been impossible before the wars.
If it favors incumbents then it is not favoring any particular ideology since the incumbent can be any.
If you want to address the staying power of incumbents, arbitrarily favoring opponents who happen to have the most wealth is not the way to do it. It will just consistently favor political movements that money approves of.
So you are "damned [by the pro-money-in-politics-group] if you do, damned [by the no-money-in-politics-group] if you don't"
"Is Hillary a bad person?" asks an opinion and has no objectively wrong answer.
"Did Hillary run a child abuse ring from a pizza parlor?" is objectively either true or false regardless of how many people believe it.
Relativism may have started with the intent of pointing out this distinction (eg the 19th century firm belief that "Primitive societies are bad") before being over generalized.
But more interesting, given much of the thread has somehow become an anti-press tirade, is how easy it has been for the new style autocrats to reuse the cry "Lügenpress!" just by translating it.
And while it is becoming increasingly unfashionable to say so; there is such a thing as truth, it is knowable and, there are conscientious people who follow facts wherever they lead and report them.
edit: or half a year's wage for a laborer, equivalent to aprox £9,000 today.
Those ratios seem to have changed: apparently the benefits of greater efficiency in mining, cattle raising etc. have not be evenly distributed.
Likewise, discussions of wealth inequality are becoming conflated with income inequality.
Yet the professional class has only marginal voting power and comparatively little to contribute to political funding, so it's not surprising that the astute ones are concerned.
In how many uses cases is anything other than perceived brightness relevant?
Increased costs to provide something the consumer doesn't want is exactly the kind of thing competition is likely to reduce.
The market doesn't always work but it's also very hard to determine what is wrong and how to fix it. If market equilibrium leads to destroying the ozone, it's easy. But if the market means fewer lumens per dollar (or even per joule), that is less obviously bad.
If we believe in the "market place of ideas" where validity and accuracy are the sole determiners of success then none should have artificial support. So all ads should be banned. If an idea fails in this market place, then it is reasonable to assume it is a bad idea. Leveraging it is just as bad when done by Soviet approved posters or Exxon paid for ads.
The echo chamber is an example where paid ads will actually _worsen_ the situation: Ads are aimed at target audiences driving them into more extremes by seeing exaggerated or false statement they would not have seen if there were no ads. Also, those echo chambers backed by moneyed interests will thrive and expand while those not money backed will fade. So instead of at least having some hope of uneasy balance between two extremes, you get head long plunge into just one of them.
Since the risk of burnout from frustration is real, if you value your career, you will need to leave such places quickly until you find one that can utilize you maximally.