HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

TomMckenny

2,285 karma · joined February 19, 2015

submissionscomments
TomMckenny··on Minimizing Defection Might Be the Solution to the Tragedy of the Commons
I had always though the difference was an assertion of the speaker's values: HK protesters are cooperating to stand up for their rights vs The Phoebus cartel is colluding to the disadvantage of consumers.

But maybe there is an objective detectable difference, perhaps related to defection reluctance. It would be great if there is some additional force at play that differentiates between them.

TomMckenny··on Minimizing Defection Might Be the Solution to the Tragedy of the Commons
No doubt many specific problems could be addressed by work on the tragedy of the commons.

But at the same time, theories around a healthy market _require_ defection in order to "guarantee" competition. So in its rawest form, we have an economic system that requires a system that is known to produce some bad outcomes (climate change) in order to avoid other bad outcomes (collusion). This poses large systemic challenge indeed.

TomMckenny··on Ugly Gerry – Font created from congressional districts
In Wisconsin, the now permanent ruling party won 60% of seats with only 48.6% of the vote.

The politicized SCOTUS' 5 to 4 decision to up hold that gerrymandering was hardly a surprise:

https://www.wpr.org/us-supreme-court-ruling-effectively-ends...

TomMckenny··on How to Accomplish Big Things, Even When You Feel Small
>...Tim Ferris ...

The most regrettable thing about Tim Ferris is his popularity essentially annihilated discoverability for a great science writer with essentially the same name.

TomMckenny··on Why Lie Detector Tests Can’t Be Trusted
Those who believe clinching works also believe polygraphs work (except when clinching)

Remove the clinching illusion and you restore the polygraph illusion to that group.

TomMckenny··on The Roots of Boeing’s 737 Max Crisis: A Regulator Relaxes Its Oversight
Absolutely true. I was just dispelling the alternative history where the depression was due to over regulation and the post war boom was due to removing regulation.

And incidentally dispelling the idea that, where necessary, adequate oversight does not kill an economy.

TomMckenny··on Gödel's Ontological Proof
Very true, Anselm refers to greater, not more powerful. And is describing God entirely in the Christian tradition. But another problem is, the conclusion does not follow from the premises.

1) Imagine/conceive of the greatest possible thing. (This premise is more than true, it's a directive.) 2) Real things are greater than imaginary things. (This premise is un-controversially true.)

So we can imagine an extraordinary being omnipotent and great. And we must imagine him existing because if we imagine he does not exist, we're imagining something less great.

The problem is, in his own premise, _any_ existing being is greater than _any_ imagined being. So it's very true that a real God is greater than an imagined God. But, from premise 2, so is any physical real thing including the most humble being.

At the risk of wandering outside of my expertise, I would think this would not bother the faithful either way since I understand faith is central to the religion. I'm guessing that Anselm's argument is a "nice to have" but if it fails it does not disturb anyone. And incidentally, I hope I have not said anything offensive.

TomMckenny··on Gödel's Ontological Proof
The argument blurs two things:

1. "in order to imagine the most powerful thing possible then you must imagine it exists"

and 2. "anything which exist is more powerful than anything which is just imagined"

In the case of number 1, there is nothing requiring it to exist just how you are allowed to imagine it.

For number 2, even very simple objects will be stronger than the most powerful thing you can imagine.

To rescue the argument a third interpretation is often given: god is the most powerful thing in existence. But this provides no details and could be a very uninteresting but powerful natural phenomenon.

TomMckenny··on Gödel's Ontological Proof
>the implications of an omnipotent, omniscient being

There is nothing in the premise or conclusion about omnipotent or omniscient. Just "most powerful". If there is nothing which is omnipotent then the most powerful being is not omnipotent.

said another way: while I can (sort of) imagine omnipotentence, it does not follow that there is an omnipotent being in the same way. That is to say, there is necessarily a most powerful object in existence but there is not necessarily an omnipotent object in existence.

Indeed we can infer no attributes of this most powerful object except its power: we may just be talking about the largest black hole or something.

TomMckenny··on The Roots of Boeing’s 737 Max Crisis: A Regulator Relaxes Its Oversight
> We’ve been undergoing a 70-year long period of deregulation

This is incorrect. Deregulation only started in the late '70s. There was adequate oversight and anti-trust enforcement until then. The unusually high growth in that period was during an _expanding_ government role (and wider union membership and 90% tax rate for the extreme brackets). Since the 80s, GDP growth has slowed to low single digits with continuously rising inequality.

>In the electric industry, deregulation...

Deregulation in this area also resulted cutting of power to tens of millions as blackmail for orders of magnitude higher rates until the state stepped in again.

And while initial deregulation of airlines has had many advantages, stifling the already inadequate oversight from FAA and thinking it will produce better out comes is literally fatally flawed reasoning.

TomMckenny··on The Roots of Boeing’s 737 Max Crisis: A Regulator Relaxes Its Oversight
> the revolving door between government and industry, the influence of lobbying, lack of competition within critical American industries, deregulation

All very serious problem. But regulatory capture comes only from money in politics.

TomMckenny··on Van Allen radiation belt
using nukes to improve petroleum extraction. oh the irony.
TomMckenny··on Europe embraces rent controls, a policy that never works
>Removing rent control hurts current renters in the short term. It also removes restrictions on supply that improve the overall health of the market over a longer time horizon.

I'm just seeking proof of that. There are limitless alternative even contradictory theories. Why, other than matching preconceived world views, do we choose one over the other without evidence? In the Cambridge example 25 years have passed but there is, as you say, no additional housing and prices have risen further. Nor was there any burst of economic growth. In what way and to what end has the market become healthier?

And if it does not increase supply of new construction then it is zero sum gain. It merely benefits one group, in this case landlords and new residents, over old residents and tenants generally. And the harm done is not temporary, the increased outlay in housing is permanent regardless of who is paying it. And wealth is transferred to unproductive literal rent seeking from productive activities such as consumption, employment and businesses (who now have bigger payrolls just to pass through employees to housing).

And now, with transient population replacing a permanent one, interest in long term undertakings such as mass transit and community undertakings such as environment, homelessness or even economic stimulus also wane.

The correct solution is to add more housing which evidently is unconnected to rent control. Certainly on existing units.

TomMckenny··on Europe embraces rent controls, a policy that never works
It raised land prices by billions of dollars, it did not produce wealth or additional housing (as seen by a flat population growth). The economy did not leap forward and far from easing housing shortage, it simply raised the cost of existing stock. The only change was a spurt in home owner improvements likely financed by mortgages against increased valuation

It is indeed a fine example of how eliminating rent control does not result in new housing.

So yes, if you eliminate what rent control there is in NY (which is limited to old buildings), their value would sky rocket along with rental income and the incentive to replace them with larger buildings would disappear.

TomMckenny··on Europe embraces rent controls, a policy that never works
Indeed, NYC rent control has been weakening since the 70s.

And the annual rental increase 1970 to now is roughly double what it was 1920 to 1970. Yet for housing, 1920 to 1970 saw roughly 50% growth while 1970-now saw roughly 20%

TomMckenny··on Europe embraces rent controls, a policy that never works
On the contrary, I claim there is no causal relationship. In particular, no actual evidence that it hurts a city.

For example: on what evidence would we say NYC was hurt by rent control? Rent control started in the 1920s and was quite strong for decades, yet NYC continued to out grow dozens of potential competitor cities without it. Therefore at worst, rent control had no measurable effect on growth.

TomMckenny··on US government approves T-Mobile/Sprint merger
https://www.businessinsider.com/jared-kushner-cnn-staff-2017...

https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/business/2017/02/17/tru...

https://www.vox.com/2017/11/11/16637186/kushner-cnn-time-war...

(discussion starts with paragraph starting with "Cohn, a former president of Goldman Sachs") at https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2019/03/11/the-making-of-...

Not that I shed any tears for the failed merger (imo AT&T should be broken up further). But the corporate incentives to avoid merger blockage are radically different when anti-trust is used this way.

TomMckenny··on Europe embraces rent controls, a policy that never works
The cities listed as having rent control are Berlin, Barcelona, Amsterdam and Paris. And you can add New York. When one thinks of failed cities, these do not come to mind.

In fact, one could do worse than being more like them. And clearly rent control does not kill a city or economy or quality of life.

And actually, a list of the most miserable cities is going to be overwhelmingly rent control free.

Edit: for clarification, I am claiming there is _no_ evidence for a causal relationship between the presence or absence of rent control. Any inferred relationship is entirely conjectural and completely unsupported by evidence: cities obviously prosper perfectly well with rent control.

TomMckenny··on US government approves T-Mobile/Sprint merger
>To me this makes a lot more sense than the T-Mobile At&t merger that failed to go through.

I'm sure that's true. But public interest is not why the T-Mobile At&T merger was derailed.

TomMckenny··on How Turkey Purged Its Intellectuals
You are correct, unfortunately. There must always be a contingent that supports the autocrat or else he would not be in power. "universal" is indeed too broad a term.

And indeed, in the US there were things like the Madison Square pro-nazi rally in 1939. And just as there were pro-democracy denunciations of Pinochet that Nixon et co ignored, so too today there is denunciation of appalling autocratic behavior that will be ignored and will need to be watered down to justify to the public. Perhaps in the past too there were arguments of the form "thousands of political firings do not constitute a purge because the New York Times is X"

I am accustomed to solution oriented discussions on these topics. So while interesting from an anthropological point of view, defense and praise of autocratic behavior is a breaking distraction from finding solutions.

TomMckenny··on How Turkey Purged Its Intellectuals
There is zero possibility that anything like that will happened to Turkey just as there is zero possibility of that happening to Saudi Arabia for their journalist murdering. The current rulership of the US (and Poland for that mater) actively dislike academia and the free press.

Also, the US will need to use Turkey for whatever it plans to do to Iran. So if anything, revealing Erdogan's atrocities is annoying to the current leadership not helping.

> what we're all supposed to believe...growing disillusionment with geopolitics and its reporting in western media

Since we're talking about the NYT, I must say that at this time the US is overwhelmingly controlled by a party that condemns the media and its own free press as a lying enemy of the people. This is why the hated there grew enormously in the last few years. I understand there are similar forces in several other nations.

TomMckenny··on How Turkey Purged Its Intellectuals
It's disturbing this produced a sort of flame war.

In the not-so-distant-past, a dictator purging academics would be clearly and universally acknowledged as bad.

Somehow it's now twisted around to claim that critics of _supporters_ of a regime are actually the real "oppressors".

Interesting times.

TomMckenny··on Justice Department to Open Broad, New Antitrust Review of Big Tech Companies
The only corporations targeted are those that are not contributing to the current ruling party more than the opposition. Which is why only a tiny number of monopolies are being targeted.

So at best there will only be competition only in those areas dominated by the sliver of companies that happen to offend the current White-house. And new entrants to the field can expect the same treatment. Of course, the companies targeted for breakup may just play ball and change their campaign contribution strategy.

TomMckenny··on Why Google Poses a Serious Threat to Democracy, and How to End That Threat [pdf]
In this case there is zero such interest. It's just a focused shakedown of companies that contribute to the opposing party at an equal or greater rate than the ruling party.
TomMckenny··on Renters may get access to rogue landlord database
Post seems unpopular for some reason so here's some proof:

https://www.povertylaw.org/clearinghouse/article/blacklistin...

https://www.brickunderground.com/blog/2014/05/tenant_blackli...

https://www.mercurynews.com/2016/09/14/new-law-protects-cali...

https://www.apartmentguide.com/blog/do-property-managers-bla...

TomMckenny··on Renters may get access to rogue landlord database
Landlords already have access to a database compiled from court records of tenants who have ever sued a landlord whether they won or not. At least in the US
TomMckenny··on Many Americans who live paycheck to paycheck blame debt
I do not claim credit card debt is smarter than a mortgage. I claim it is a far smaller percentage of personal debt.

For example, reducing housing cost by a few percent would have a vastly greater effect than reducing any other source of debt by the same percent.

If a person is in debt, it's not primarily because they bought a latte, it's because housing cost are high.

So if we're looking at debt per se, then it's housing we should be looking look at.

TomMckenny··on Many Americans who live paycheck to paycheck blame debt
The article repeatedly mentions credit cards as debit but not mortgages (or rental expense). But it seems unlikely that credit cards are the biggest debt/financial-obligations people hold.
TomMckenny··on Amazon deforestation: Brazil's Bolsonaro dismisses data as 'lies'
The new crop of wannabe autocrats call every inconvenient fact a lie. They imply a vast conspiracy to undermine their "always right" supporters and the one and only leader who can fix things.

In democracies with bad leaders you might get "it needs more study" or "we can't afford it" or just silence. At worst opponents are labeled "misguided". But the new autocrats end all conversation by turning facts and those who believe them into conspiring enemies.

TomMckenny··on Equifax Is Said to Be Near $650M Settlement for Data Breach
So when will I be able to opt out of their tracking me?
← PreviousPage 9 of 24Next →