HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

TomMckenny

2,285 karma · joined February 19, 2015

submissionscomments
TomMckenny··on Foreign purchases of American homes plunge as Chinese buyers flee the market
>Land has value

Then consider the "value" of an empty lot, the archetype of land in itself. Its _price_ is based solely on the the _value_ that those near it produce. A high productivity region increases the value of neighboring empty lots. The lots themselves have produced nothing and whatever price they command is solely a drain on the productive part of the economy.

>Is a grocery store milking you for food you buy?

Value added by building or improving a resource like food or a structure is fundamentally different and obviously needs to be compensated and encouraged. But profit from an unchanged property is entirely a zero-sum gain moving wealth from productive parts of an economy to unproductive.

TomMckenny··on Foreign purchases of American homes plunge as Chinese buyers flee the market
All democracies allow personal property but this does not extend to land. In fact, all democracies have always put controls on land ownership and treatment of tenants. Even the US itself taxed land before income.

The only places with no protections were medieval societies and their resultant immense inequality.

TomMckenny··on Foreign purchases of American homes plunge as Chinese buyers flee the market
The equilibrium market price will displace owner-residents because the return on a property that is bought and rented is always greater than one which is bought and lived in (ie not rented).

There was very little urban home ownership until twentieth century incentives and regulation directly changed that. Efforts made by people like FDR, William Beveridge and influenced by Keynes who would all be called vociferously denounced as socialist today.

So unless we want to return to that historic lack of home ownership, those are the kinds of policies needed. This because the eventual outcome of an uncontrolled hosing market is as problematic as an uncontrolled market is to climate.

TomMckenny··on My Journey from Free Market Ideologue, Part 5: Commercial Development
The article explicitly warns of that sort of confirmation bias.

In particular, it points out that the free market had already failed the people in the community. The remedy, essentially government financial incentives to business, was the only thing that made enterprise possible. But since the whole system innately runs at a loss for the comunity, a harsh future reckoning arises.

So it points to a possible deep flaw in our economic system and underling assumptions that simple theories obviously do not explain.

After all, one should believe the simplest working explanation, but certainly no simpler. The complete confidence in completely unfettered markets is apparently overly simplistic. Likewise, some forms of business incentives are counter productive.

TomMckenny··on Trump signals scrutiny of Google's ties with China after Thiel comments
Clearly Trump's party is crucially different than John McCain's. It's unimaginable that McCain would keep kids in cages, call the press "enemy of the people", lead chants to lock up political opponents, undermine NATO, or encourage hostile powers to assist his candidacy. I may not be a conservative, but whatever else may be said of the old McCain-Regan-Rockefeller party, they would certainly never, ever engage in any of these obscene activities.

And I entirely agree, the US does have some considerable advantages:

- the "blood and soil" ideology is very alien (though not unprecedented as seen by the first, more obvious, "America first" movement [1] and later by John Birch)

- it's had 240 years of voting and some notion of civil-personal rights

- there's nice separation of powers. (Although it's becoming apparent that a president with >33% of the Senate can exercise almost unlimited authority.)

But these advantages are not automated, people have to use and defend them. The judiciary is especially delicate, it's been the first thing targeted by the other neo-autocrats.

Also there is a possibility of over confidence in these institutions ("it can't happen here"). And there's an unfortunate dose of denial ("he did not mean that literally"). And inexperience (modern Germans know exactly what the AfD is and how dangerous it is)

But absolutely, the future is not written yet and certainly I too am never going to be shut up.

By the way, the Bannon influence is so obvious (and 1930's obsessed) that you see Trump threatening opponents with half understood ideas of a paramilitary somehow made out of "bikers and police"[2]

[1] https://vimeo.com/237489146 [2] https://thehill.com/homenews/administration/434110-trump-sug...

TomMckenny··on Trump signals scrutiny of Google's ties with China after Thiel comments
>Do you believe the ends justify the means?

In the colloquial sense of that phrase, certainly not. Any honest calculation about the ends includes _all_ events that cause it. That necessarily includes the costs of the means.

> If you do, we are not talking about anything other than straight civil war.

I don't believe that is possible under any circumstances. The pattern being followed in the US is not at all unique. It is essentially identical to several other nations which are going or have gone down this path. There was never more than a broken window and burning trash can or two. (which of course are always portrayed as world ending violence justifying yet more authoritarian behavior)

In the end, either the public notices the situation in time and somehow gets enough ballots counted that they return the country to sanity (enough ballots to overcome gerrymandering, the electoral college, the unbalanced senate, systematic disfranchisement and foreign interference)

Or the country follows the same path that Hungary and Poland are on now, towards a hyper nationalistic, xenophobic kleptocracy. Essentially the same choice soon to be faced by several other western countries (and India and Turkey btw).

TomMckenny··on Trump signals scrutiny of Google's ties with China after Thiel comments
We don't need 30 duplicate lines across country for competition so we don't need them for the last mile. And quite a few municipalities do allow multiple wires. But even so ISPs don't invade each others territory. The over-regulation stories, among others, are simply untruths promulgated to provide plausible pro-monopoly sentiment.

If the US wants something that works, then just do something that works. For example [1]

At any rate, the ISP arguments are well known. And are about as moot as appeals to a free market or the public good. In the current environment, no amount of evidence concerning monopolies will change policy that is fundamentally based solely on political favoritism and retribution.

[1]https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2010/03/uk-regulators-of...

TomMckenny··on Trump signals scrutiny of Google's ties with China after Thiel comments
The monopolies' _claim_ of benevolence is irrelevant. Nor does it mater what anonymous voices on HN said. I at least have the limited option of using Bing and DuckDuckGo for search. But I have no choice for ISPs.

Demanding a free market in America did not use to be controversial. But for two years now, under a sea of double think, it's just used as cover for political cronyism and contribution shakedowns.

TomMckenny··on Trump signals scrutiny of Google's ties with China after Thiel comments
They managed the amazing feat of being both anti-free market and anti-social-safety at the same time.

Perhaps a big-tent pro-democracy, pro-rule of law party will emerge as a counter weight somehow.

TomMckenny··on Trump signals scrutiny of Google's ties with China after Thiel comments
So yes, the "anti-trust" talk is politically motivated? And proudly so because the employees have "pledged allegiance to the left"?

Strangely, there seems to be a very large number of people who decry google's information "monopoly" because of the blogs and youtube(!) videos they found while googling. A group that, given their power in government, is certainly not being oppressed.

And as a side note, I use no Alphabet product and obviously run an ad blocker. You'll find there are a great many technologists that do so. So, while there are certainly issues, the monopoly talk is obviously intentional hyperbole promulgated for political reasons.

As compared to, say ISPs which actually are monopolies. Or even Sinclair broadcasting which actually does control all media in some regions. But those genuine monopolies are not objectionable because they align politically with the party in power.

This pattern does correspond with some political systems but certainly not democratic, rule-of-law forms.

TomMckenny··on Trump signals scrutiny of Google's ties with China after Thiel comments
Are all statements true until proven otherwise?

He spoke, with no substantiation, at a conservative conference denouncing a contributor to the democratic party.

Not only is that venue suspicious but any real counter intelligence conversation is done discretely. So perhaps the burden of proof is actually on him. And perhaps the requirements for such are rather high. And if anything, his actions strongly discount rather than support his claim.

TomMckenny··on Trump signals scrutiny of Google's ties with China after Thiel comments
Perhaps because if it were really a tech anti-trust summit, ISPs would be the chief topic. Or at least discussed somewhere. So a better description is tech contribution shake down.
TomMckenny··on Why did we wait so long for the bicycle?
>In light of this, I think the deepest explanation is in general economic and cultural factors.

Indeed, with enough people with enough spare wealth, you can have significant progress even when technology remains flat.

There is an immense difference between the Greek dark age and classical Athens, but not technologically. And intellectually curious people can figure out how to fly just using paper.[1]

Apparently, the first iteration of the bike in the early 1800s was a briefly popular toy: the very epitome of unguided discovery is play. Only later was it made practical by inventors working from that exiting idea.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Montgolfier_brothers

TomMckenny··on Court rules against Oracle in Pentagon 'war cloud' litigation
>Sen. Marco Rubio (R-Fla.) on Thursday sent a letter to President Trump’s national security adviser, John Bolton, asking the White House to delay the contract over concerns the procurement process has been unfair and biased toward Amazon.

A pork barrel military may not be a good idea. One that punishes political critics might even be worse.

TomMckenny··on Seattle Faces Backlash After Easing on Crimes Involving Mental Illness
Because homelessness aggravates a controllable condition into an uncontrolled one. Treatment should be provided but it's not going to do much good if the patient is just going to live on the street.

You'll find the number of homeless with mental health problems corresponds with the total number of homeless which corresponds directly with housing prices. So until there is a major effort to drive those prices down, this problem will worsen, as it has for a generation now.

And of course Sinclair broadcasting is pushing to lock up the poor rather than do that.

TomMckenny··on Brain activity can be used to measure how well you understand a concept
I don't see where they accounted for those who incorrectly believe they understand the topic vs those who actually understand.

Unless they are claiming the process either:

1) detects how the brain correctly models Newtonian physics vs incorrectly.

or

2) detects accurate knowledge from incorrect. I can't imagine this lol rich assertion would be the actual claim. But the title does vaguely imply it.

TomMckenny··on Libra, 2 Weeks In
> It’s not possible to be truly permissionless

Exactly, it certainly appears the claims can't all be true. This is a bit disturbing from a company with a questionable track record.

TomMckenny··on Libra, 2 Weeks In
Assuming they wanted to prevent large transactions, how will they? Is Facebook planing to be solely responsible for clearing every transaction?

Because the article literally says they plan "gradually transitioning to a permissionless state" and "Facebook will not control the network".

And, not that this is their plan anyway, but how could they prevent Libra's from crossing borders if it is permissionless?

And even if there were a limit on transfers somehow. A limit, by the way, on an automated system that presumably will involve large sellers with large volume. A limit which the word "permissionless" makes impossible. How will they prevent multiple wallets?

For laundering generally: you buy a thing with cash or the like from an incurious seller and sell it again. To grease the wheels, you could buy at over market value and sell under. Realestate is very popular, even driving up urban prices. But Persian rugs work just as well[1]. It's not currency change that is interesting but the erasing the origin of the purchasers money and replacing it with a legitimate origin: the sale of a condo.

[1] https://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/paul-manafort-and-t...

TomMckenny··on Libra, 2 Weeks In
It certainly intends to circumvent financial controls from democratic institutions. As if someone read parts of a dystopian SciFi novel as a how to manual. So it's certainly anti-democratic.

But technically it lacks the ethnic hatred, anti-intellectualism and gleeful blood-lust of fascism.

TomMckenny··on Libra, 2 Weeks In
https://www.wired.com/story/if-trump-is-laundering-russian-m...

Of course that only describes one "hypothetical" case but the mechanism is the same everywhere and for all pass through commodities.

This reference in context has the virtue of being slightly humorous IMO.

TomMckenny··on Libra, 2 Weeks In
>Why would anyone want to use Libra?

Money laundering. You'd no longer need to buy a condo in New York to get your rubles into dollars.

TomMckenny··on Bitcoin mining on an Apollo Guidance Computer
Indeed, the author found a project both hilarious and difficult.

Also funny is the implication that the astronauts would have had to be careful of malware in addition to the occasional unaccounted for floating bolt.

TomMckenny··on Employee activism in tech stops short of organizing unions
>Everyone who works for a company is an employee of the company, with a wage (or an hourly rate), and potentially some equity as well. Every employee should be considering how to make the company more profitable, which could be by accelerating a development schedule, over delivering in a new feature/performance, or hiring and retaining key talent.

Absolutely. And in a sufficiently abusive environment, none of that will happen. It is a terrible thing when executive staff destroy a company by creating a toxic environment. But employees would rather be improving the orginization since they need the company to survive and everyone would rather work with smart people than someone they have to carry.

But I know of cases where employee pressure in tech has slowed AI use in warfare and stopped physical abuse toward workers. I hear theory about it being bad but where has it made things worse?

>The wages of these employees is not set by the company. It is set by the market

If that were true then negotiating would be irrelevant. And previous salary would not be the primary determiner of your next offer. And there would not be formulaic pay raise percentages that rewards those people who changes jobs frequently over those who say on and so are in fact more valuable but less savvy.

More than that, labor prices have as much to do with housing prices as anything else (from which extra expense neither employer nor employee benefits). That is not the tech market.

So skill availability is only tangentially related to compensation. The market favors a set of behaviors other than technical skill such as negotiation and job hopping. And ironically for the job hopper, who is selected _for_ by this system, would have minimum interest in the companies success.

>Companies incorporate for the legal liability protection, for the ability to issue shares, for the ability to file taxes as a separate entity, etc.

Being incorporated has nothing to do with analogy. Or even to being called a company. It has to do with some communication being acceptable while other similar communication is not. It's also a specific description of the friction that emerges anywhere only a subset of people decide the allocation of revenue to the whole group including themselves. In this case, in a work place.

Which becomes more suspicious when the opposition to full participation in decision making is on moral grounds or is followed by implicit threats rather than showing how the arrangement is best for everyone.

TomMckenny··on Employee activism in tech stops short of organizing unions
I agree that there is nuance and details that make it more useful in some cases than others. Conversely, unions can assist a companies survival. There are cases where even the teamsters(!) agreed to pay cuts to save businesses. And of course it can occasionally go wrong and there can be incompetence just like everything else in this world. But there are some widely held beliefs that demonize unions more than should be.

For example[1], empirically the presence of a union does not correlates with a bad workplace or failing business because the bulk of last half of the twentieth century saw widespread union membership yet was dominated by enormous growth in both production and quality of life along side high job satisfaction. While the last 40 years with declining union membership has seen slower GDP growth and in some cases quality of life reversal. So unions can't be causing the problem.

And the Us vs Them attitude is certainly close to catastrophic. But people aren't going to go through the effort, stress and risk of forming a union unless there are already some never addressed grievances in the first place. The antagonism would have to precede the talk of unionizing not be caused by the appearance of the union. And after the fact, there is at least some small chance of discussing, explaining and solving the problems. But I too would bail long before it got that broken. But for tight labor markets, with few and poorly run industries, this choice doesn't exists.

[1]in western countries and Japan

TomMckenny··on Employee activism in tech stops short of organizing unions
I believe the following is being referred to:

Inside a company, the management/owners regularly talk together about how to minimize the cost of employees, including compensation. But employees talking together about maximizing their compensation is considered scandalous, harmful or even unethical. The practice is even given special names "organizing" and "unionizing" and is certainly considered unusual.

Corporations acting together are not analogous to a union because, legal fictions aside, corporations are not people.

But the activities of humans working together inside a cooperation to maximize some benefit, say a promotion or higher personal profit buy cutting employee costs vs a group of employees seeking a pay increases, seems a credible analogy.

TomMckenny··on A Government Guide to Keeping Insulin Unaffordable
If campaign contributions are called free speech and legislators are happy making laws blatantly favoring contributors, you're going to have a pretty tight loop.
TomMckenny··on English speakers should learn math instead of a second language
The author makes a good point of course.

But I'd add that, for native English speakers writing to a broad audience, they should spend a little time learning how non-native speakers use and understand the language.

A few changes in word choice, sentences structure and idioms can make informal communication significantly clearer.

TomMckenny··on Boeing loses big order for 737 Max aircraft
Regulatory agencies that actually work for the public interest would be a good start.
TomMckenny··on The No-Algorithms Follow-Up
Social media algorithms have produced the worst results recently. But some outlets like tabloids and AM radio have long embraced outraged hyperbole and blatant falsehood to attract audiences.

Possibly any motivation beyond a desire to inform damages the message at least a little. And sometimes annihilates factuality completely.

I would conjecture this is because facts are often subtle, ambiguous, complex or contradict preconceived notions. So choosing between reality vs entertainment/outrage portrayed as reality, people tend to prefer the latter. So anyone maximizing for numbers will be drawn into the latter too. Maybe this is the human bug referred to in the article.

So current algorithms that maximize engagement are obviously catastrophically bad and any curation has to be better. But there may yet be undiscovered (likely non trivial) algorithms that promote calm reality. They just might be less profitable. As newspapers are less profitable.

TomMckenny··on In Hong Kong, one protester pulls off his mask and defines a movement
It is a magnificent thing to see people defend their civil rights. And it is the rational ting too: given the implications of the extradition bill, a few days on the street will seem a tiny price to pay.

And indeed, given ever growing intrusion into HK by the main land and ever increasing biometric surveillance technology, once on film, I doubt the surgical masks will provide anonymity for all the decades these folks will live.

← PreviousPage 10 of 24Next →