And people who needed to use the road to get somewhere are automatically "pro-china"? And they deserved to be attacked?
Can you even believe yourself? Honestly?
78 karma · joined August 2, 2011
And people who needed to use the road to get somewhere are automatically "pro-china"? And they deserved to be attacked?
Can you even believe yourself? Honestly?
I didn't discard anything, I never said kidnappings are OK.
Neither are your violence and destruction. Stop justifying your own evil with China's.
But these are still exceptional cases, the vast majority of HK people have no reason to fear the same fate.
> The extradition law that sparked these protests was a formalisation/legalisation of a decade long string of kidnappings with increasing frequency and visibility.
Where are the reports to back up this "a decade long string of kidnappings"? Or are there just the same three cases?
Where's the evidence China was behind the extradition law?
In any case, the extradition law has been officially (announced to be) withdrawn. Stop using it to justify the continuing and escalating violence and destruction.
Even Cantonese speaking local HKers, who tried to remove roadblocks (so their vehicles could pass) set up by the protesters, were regularly attacked.
They kidnapped one person, as far as I know. I agree they crossed the line there, and there's no excuse for that. But that's an exception, not the norm.
> They have said they were not behind the Extradition Law, and yet they force our government's hand.
Where's the evidence they are behind that? How are they forcing the HK government's hand?
> They have said HKers have freedom, and yet they call us terrorists and cockroaches for exercising it.
You have the freedom to peaceful demonstrations an protests, not violence or destruction. And the CCP most certainly did not call you cockroaches, some angry mainlanders maybe, but not the CCP.
(EDIT: downvoters, please use the truth to argue your side, instead of downvoting me to try to suppress it.)
By all means let's hold the Heaviside to the same high safety standard as other aircrafts, but not higher.
I still use it in a VM to this day.
Directly from the article:
> And when Mao founded the People’s Republic of China in 1949, he and Zhou Enlai decided not to seize Hong Kong—which the British at the time expected
The other side of the story is that China could've easily seized HK from the beginning, and the people of HK would've been under the direct rule of China, and never gotten any of the freedom and autonomy they enjoy today.
That doesn't seem to be true in this particular case, since said suspect is still enjoying his freedom in HK. An extradition treaty to cover the case seems like a reasonable initiative.
> Mainland Area of China, a communist dictatorship where laws are at the whims of party members.
I agree that's a valid concern, and that the proposed law didn't include adequate protection for HK citizens. And I support the initial peaceful protests against that law. What I cannot support however, are the ongoing and escalating violence from some of those protesters, before and especially after, the announcement of withdrawal of that law.
Prior to the handover, the executive head of HK had been the governor, appointed by the British government.
The big corporations will probably always win the battle of new and shiny. But free software can win the battle of UX, if we stop chasing the tail of the fashion de jour of UI design from big corporations.
Image how much more free software could do for users it we didn't waste all our efforts trying to match the looks of the big corp. software.
For me, software that do more, is more cool.
To expand on whoevercares' comment, recently someone committed a crime in Taiwan and fled to Hong Kong. To close this loophole and prevent HK from becoming a safe haven for criminals, the Chief Executive of HK proposed a new law to facilitate extradition of these crime suspects from HK to various jurisdictions in the region, including Taiwan and mainland China.
The proposed law even explicitly stated that it's not applicably to crimes political in nature. But some HK people were nevertheless concerned that it might be abused by China to target political dissidents taking refuge in HK.
So they have taken to the streets to protest that law. As a result, the law was quickly suspended before it had a chance to pass, and a few weeks ago the HK Chief Executive officially announced the withdrawal of the law.
However, despite the concession from the HK government, the protesters pressed on, demanding four more concessions from the government, chief among them universal suffrage, or the direct election of the HK Chief Executive, who up to this point have been nominated from a narrow pool of Beijing-approved candidates, then voted on by a committee.
It's not entirely clear that China even had anything to do with the proposal of the law which started this ordeal. But the protesters have shrewdly painted a picture, to great effect, of big bad China stomping on the poor helpless people of HK.
(EDIT: spelling, wording)
The chief executive publicly announced the withdrawal of the bill. It's as good as done, technicalities notwithstanding.
> these are people who’s freedom and independent judiciary made them an attractive spot for foreign investment in the first place.
What's your point? They had been that attractive spot for foreign investment before the expansion of rights.
> With democracy,
You seem to think democracy is this panacea that heals all ills. I have a magical bridge in Brooklyn you will surely be interested in.
> such a pointless bill as the extradition bill
The bill was proposed as a direct response to someone committing a crime in Taiwan and fleeing to Hong Kong. See the point there?
> And, a democracy has checks and balances to investigate police departments for excessive violence and corruption,
I admit that Hong Kong is not a full democracy, but Hong Kong already has all these things, and they work remarkable well, in fact much better than in most countries one might consider full democracies. Again, one would have to be really blinded by ideology to not see that.
> I can publish a full page ad in every US newspaper calling for the US to drop all charges against Snowden and have absolutely no repercussions from the US government. I can’t do that in China calling for the release of Gui.
But you can do that in Hong Kong. There you have it, one country, two systems, it's alive and well.
Thank you!
> Sadly, these protests are more likely to bring the dictatorship closer.
That's my fear as well. I'm all for peaceful protests, but I'm afraid the violent protesters are signing the death wish of freedom in Hong Kong.
> Then you have the simple fact that China is not a democracy, it's an oppressive surveillance one-party state.
(I'll ignore the "oppressive surveillance" you snuck in there, as that's not an exclusive to China, and many democracies are much further along in that regard.)
And that makes China automatically bad...how? China has on balance done less evil and more good than most of the democracies of the world. Can we be honest with ourselves and keep an open mind?
> All of the democratic world has a certain moral obligation to either attempt to transform or to oppose China.
China certainly should be kept in check by fellow world powers. But let's not get carried away with mindless ideology and dogma.
All you came up with is the extradition bill, and that, again, has been withdrawn.
My apologies if it came out wrong.
That narrative is never supported by the facts, and the extradition treaty has been withdrawn. You keep saying it does not make it true.
> the British also made large scale election reforms
After the signing of the Sino-British Joint Declaration. It's like agreeing to sell your company, then doubling the salary of every employee before handing over the company to the new owner. It's reckless, irresponsible, but sadly, very effective. Like I said, a ploy you'd willing fall for, even though you know it's a ploy.
> We've waited quite a while now in Sweden for the release of our countryman, the CCP can lend some faith to their insistince that they support "one country, two systems" by releasing him.
While I agree the CCP crossed the line in the case of Mr. Gui, and I sincerely hope for his release as much as you do, it by no means indicate the unraveling of one country, two systems. Just like the exile of Edward Snowden by no means indicate the unraveling of freedom of speech in the US.
Know your history. How had the British treated the Hong Kong people throughout its history as a colony? How has China treated the Hong Kong people? Honestly?
(EDIT: Honestly, people?)
You should try to enjoy it too. It gets lonely sometimes :)
It was suspended almost immediately after initial protests.
> self destructive bill
That's a stretch. Personally I believe Ms. Lam proposed it out of good faith. It was too naive perhaps, and did not include adequate protection for Hong Kong citizens. It never would have survived the legco anyway, never mind the protests.
Regarding one country, two systems. The Chinese government, to its credit, has largely kept its end of the bargain and allowed Hong Kong to govern itself, aside from making sure that the chief executive isn't actively anti-Beijing. Hong Kong people had never enjoyed as much freedom and autonomy as they do today, not under British rule, not ever. Some people are just too blinded by ideology to see that.
(EDIT: I stand corrected, if reports of his continuing detention in mainland China are true. His is certainly a curious, unfortunately, and extreme case. It does not take away from the fact that Hong Kong still has a functioning judiciary system independent from mainland China, and the vast vast majority of Hong Kong citizens have no reason to fear the same fate.)
The extradition treaty has officially been withdrawn as a result of the protests.
That alone should tell you that Hong Kong has been able to maintain substantial autonomy from the central Chinese government.
People look down on Trump and ridicule him endlessly when he spews bullshit about things he knows nothing about. But if you spew bullshit about China, you get lots of upvotes.
And if you dare to speak the truth and the nuances about the situation in Hong Kong, you get downvoted to oblivion.
EDIT: Case in point, downvoters! Go ahead, show me you know something about China and Hong Kong.
That alone should tell you that Hong Kong has been able to maintain substantial autonomy from the central Chinese government.
Just like the UK could influence HK matters when it was a British colony, China can influence HK matters now that it's a Chinese special administrative region.
Control? Not so much.
Really? How exactly is it being implemented?
EDIT: Down-voters, can you answer the question? Or are you just going to try to bury it with down-votes?
That's a very poor analogy. Hong Kong citizens already enjoy the benefit of an independent legal system and don't have to live like mainland citizens.
> They sure as hell didn't choose to lose their rights to a fair trial and freedom of expression either.
They sure didn't. And they sure haven't lost those rights.