HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

VK538FY

105 karma · joined August 8, 2018

submissionscomments
VK538FY··on Archive of medieval books and manuscripts discovered in Romanian church
Very interesting. I was not aware of this part of Portuguese history. Thank you.
VK538FY··on US Treasuries Blacklisted by the German State of Baden-Württemberg
It's also an open secret at this point that American atomic gravity bombs are stored in bases in Italy, Belgium, UK and Germany. The current Polish government doesn't seem to be opposed to doing the same in Poland. Plans to maintain the American nuclear umbrella may still involve Germany regardless of Poland's decisions.
VK538FY··on US Treasuries Blacklisted by the German State of Baden-Württemberg
Really? I was under the impression that Poland wanted the US to establish permanent bases on its territory and that they would make most of the American presence in Germany superfluous. (The Russians do not like this at all and the outcome of the current conflict may affect the PL-US cooperation. But that's not really the point here.) Maybe someone can correct me but I understood that the base in Ramstein is the only American base in Germany that is hard to replace because of a favourable position to communicate with satellites and provide nearly instantaneous communication between multiple theatres. Hard for me to say if 1'000 km east in Poland is less favourable.
VK538FY··on US Treasuries Blacklisted by the German State of Baden-Württemberg
And the madness of WWII was in no small way related to the oddly inequitable treaty of Versailles formulated to reflect French and British demands.
VK538FY··on Archive of medieval books and manuscripts discovered in Romanian church
The French revolution took place at the end of the 18th century and I'm sure that a lot of churches in Paris (or any French city) were demolished in a big FU to God. I can't recall something similar having taken place in Portugal at the time. Or anywhere else.
VK538FY··on An auto CEO came close to saying the right thing about heavy EV batteries
I don't have the statistics at hand but I remember a study about road degradation based on vehicle type. The difference between industrial vehicles and passenger vehicles (including pickup trucks) was enormously skewed so that industrial vehicles were responsible for 80% of the degradation, Pareto-like. Meaning that heavier passenger vehicles might not make a difference.
VK538FY··on How to survive a car crash
Essentially the problem when one respects sensible security distances. Others just move in. Even when you want to roll faster on say a 2 lane motorway but can't without compromising that distance.
VK538FY··on Leaving China
Thank you for your comment with relevant citations. The dominant version of the story in western circles is too often accepted uncritically. There are many other elements to consider. Same for many stories regarding China.
VK538FY··on Reversing UK mobile rail tickets
The relatively high fees on French autoroutes are offset by the good quality, yes. But the principal objection may be the way in which said autoroutes were privatized after being built with public money, no?
VK538FY··on Globalization is dead and no one is listening
That's a bit disingenuous regarding Russia. It's true that hydrocarbons are the lion's share but take a look at this list for example.

https://tradingeconomics.com/russia/exports

I'm often surprised by what I learn of the Russian economy, especially over the past year.

- Nobles gases used for the production of semiconductors are produced in large part by Russia. I've seen and forgotten some other examples where I said to myself 'huh, I didn't know that was made in Russia... ooops'.

- Russia produces significantly more cereals than Ukraine. Worth mentioning, since it comes up frequently.

- Hydrocarbons are the biggest combined export but the relative amount and the very low cost of production are impressive, downright advantageous.

- Russia's GDP is often understated (see nominal vs PPP basis), making its true economic size comparable to that of Germany while far less dependant on services.

- Russia has an enormous appetite for imports (luxury goods and consumer electronics come to mind) but it's worth noting that shelves are far from empty and the Russian agricultural and food transformation industries have really stepped up their game in the past 10 or so years.

There's a lot of condescension towards the Russian economy that is propelled by western 'Russia experts' who frankly aren't very smart or honest. Downright dangerous if you ask me, since western politicians may very well base their decisions on incomplete or incorrect information.

VK538FY··on Is Germany attractive enough for qualified workers?
Good point. The Aussiedler represent some big numbers, are foreign born, but can loosely be considered German. I've known a lot and while not entirely representative, the criteria were loose: only adoptive father of German ancestry, last person really German and to speak German was mummy's oma, etc. Of course when you're being beat up by the locals in some ex soviet republic because you're not really one of them either, well, you do what you have to do. What surprises me are the numbers of Spanish, Italians, Poles, Hungarians. Anecdotally I would have expected bigger numbers. Germany has emptied such countries of their qualified workers in recent years.
VK538FY··on The strange case of Britain’s demise
Sure, I won't argue semantics. I and many others don't want a democracy that relegates us to an anachronistic minority.
VK538FY··on The strange case of Britain’s demise
In the case of my small example: I am the rural vote so I don't see our collective force as tyranny of course. As long as basic rights are respected. Ours is a case of a region with specific identity and interests not shared by the single metropole so a purely proportional result is not ideal from our perspective. But I understand your point.
VK538FY··on The strange case of Britain’s demise
I appreciate your suggestions but would really need to see some simulations to digest the potential effects. Not that my opinion counts for much but it's always good to suggest alternatives when one criticizes. That said, the duopoly isn't always so bad historically. Many cases of individual candidates who broke party lines or walked the fine line. It depends to a great degree on party discipline or the lack thereof.
VK538FY··on Is Germany attractive enough for qualified workers?
Germany is half-half.

Open to immigrants because a/ its economy is an electromagnet that needs foreign talent and b/ its post war doctrine makes it imagine itself as America but with better beer. Foolish but true.

Closed to immigrants because it is the clearest ethnostate in western Europe (I don't make this up, my political science professors taught that) and its culture is borderline neurotic.

In general, it's the last place where I imagine locals running after brown people with pitchforks because most Germans aren't apes. They are however quite particular and have other ways of making the piece that sticks out, feel unwelcome. Immigrants from Germany's closest neighbours have trouble integrating there. French, Scandinavians, Slavs, even the Dutch.

Just be aware.

VK538FY··on The strange case of Britain’s demise
I understand your point. 'First past the post' may not be ideal for your country. For other countries, it is appreciated despite its inconveniences. Example: Québec. We inherited 'first past the post' from England. The results are obvious: small parties with significant numbers of voters in many ridings don't end up in parliament. But Québec is a rural province with only one city worthy of the name, Montréal, almost half the population of the province. That city has a demography very different to the rest of the province. In a proportional system, the will of the big city would simply sweep away the rural regions that don't have the same weight. People have learnt to accept 'first past the post' and any change would upset the balance that exists today.
VK538FY··on SMIC reaches 7nm without access to western equipment and technologies
I will read the white paper to which you link because it looks interesting and it's important to obtain information from the source. (Can't digest it before I respond to you here.)

I have read about the positive aspects of the Chinese system of representation and the iterative improvements that it's intended to introduce. Definitely some things to learn from that approach.

Still, I can't go so far as to call it direct democracy and it's not just semantics or my reference to the Swiss system. Here is my reasoning. The Chinese government (central, provincial or local) is known for some heavy handed tactics that just wouldn't pass in a direct democracy where the people is sovereign.

Example: China's anti-coronavirus measures. (I am not arguing for or against but the case illustrates the mechanism.) I see no evidence that a large majority of Chinese citizens support those measures. In Switzerland, it was clear that the majority supporting measures was razor thin and this led to significant compromises. Primarily because there would have been more and more democratic initiatives seeking to limit government action and some would be successful. Neighbouring countries with less direct democracy do not feel this pressure and do not move so quickly.

VK538FY··on SMIC reaches 7nm without access to western equipment and technologies
I'd encourage you to study the difference between (a) the Chinese political system and (b) the Chinese model for international co-operation.

The first is hard for me to accept, as a Westerner attached to direct democracy, but I recognize its accomplishments and try to look through the fog of propaganda.

The second is a an alternative to the Western, 'rules-based', neo-liberal and neo-colonial order. You're likely to see a large part of the world supportive of this alternative. It also leaves plenty of space for human rights and democracy in partner countries, since national sovereignty and multipolarity are amongst its guiding principals.

VK538FY··on Why there's no 'Dijon' in Dijon mustard
I go to Italy every few months and buy a few bottles of generic balsamico for cooking. Cost about 1.20 EUR per 700 mL bottle at Coop. No caramel or funny ingredients. Surely not aged like the expensive stuff but it performs its job well in my kitchen.
VK538FY··on Why there's no 'Dijon' in Dijon mustard
If I understand correctly: Grey-Poupon started in Dijon and the Reitzel brothers in Switzerland first imported it. Then they started to make it in Aigle (Vaud), Switzerland, and the French company kind of disappeared. Not sure, but Grey-Poupon is probably still made in Aigle.
VK538FY··on Eyewitnesses describe brutal beatings by HK police
A semi-secret war? Surely a very mysterious war, at least to me because conventional reasoning does not allow me to understand why western governments encouraged putches that destroyed stable governments (imperfect but far, far superior to the alternative) and subsequently armed 'moderate' groups whose morbid ideology differed little from the ideology that we're all supposed to combat ('...right?').

Unfortunately, our press doesn't ask the hard questions. No one is held accountable for the death and destruction that these policies have created. So western governments go on and try to apply the magic formula again. I believe that they are doing the same in HK.

VK538FY··on Eyewitnesses describe brutal beatings by HK police
To clarify.

A free press writes what it likes and the act of writing a newspaper article of any sort is not an act of 'foreign intervention'. We probably agree on that.

I have a problem with the fairly homogeneous discourse that I observe in the western press about certain subjects that prepare the domestic public opinion for political and armed intervention in other countries. I know that it's happening because I remember the day when I could read a lot more opposing opions in the newspapers of my language.

But preparing the domestic public opinion for intervention is not intervention itself. I am resolutely opposed to the intervention that is desired by the powers that be.

VK538FY··on Eyewitnesses describe brutal beatings by HK police
I agree partially. The limits of 'acceptable' foreign intervention are not black and white. My feeling, based on what I observe, is that western intelligence services are all over this. Foreign intervention in Syria and Lybia started quietly enough alright through unofficial meetings with opposition groups. It's obvious that many Hongkongese are legitimately concerned about their political and economic future. Foreign money and promises at just the right moment can be wielded to manipulate people that are more or less well intentioned initially.
VK538FY··on Eyewitnesses describe brutal beatings by HK police
Yes, I think that that is the case, based on the following elements.

1. Contacts between US consular staff and HK opposition leaders.

2. Funding by the US 'National Endowment for Democracy' of several Hong Kong groups.

3. My observations of the western media coverage of the events in the province of Xianjiang.

4. My observations of the similarities between the events in Hong Kong and other 'colour revolutions' that have the fingerprints of Washington all over them.

VK538FY··on Eyewitnesses describe brutal beatings by HK police
I'm probably a bigger fan of self-determination than you: if the people of HK, Catalonia or California wish to follow their own road, I support them, but they need to work that out on their own. When those movements are even partly the product of foreign intervention and are given uncritical coverage in the western press, that is a giant warning sign. We've been there before many times yet we never learn.
VK538FY··on Europe Built a System to Fight Russian Meddling. It’s Struggling
The people of whom you speak would need to be gifted communicators. I'm sure that there are some smart, well informed and well intentioned people on Hacker News that could argue for realistic, multipolar solutions.

That said, it's an anglophone site for IT professionals. I feel that most political discussions are steered in the direction of 'good thinking' progressivism and neo-conservative interventionism. It's the majority demographic where many of those people live.

VK538FY··on Europe Built a System to Fight Russian Meddling. It’s Struggling
Sure, but the guy to whom we are responding suggests implicitely that some hypothetical political meddling is an act of war that requires a war-like response -- twice with an identical comment, in fact. I don't think that I am poorly interpreting what he says. Both the US and Russia have meddled in other countries' politics but I will bet real money that the meddling of the US has ended in greater disaster that that of post-Soviet Russia. So move through the dimensions as you will -- this guy wants to let the missiles fly. Troll or completely barking mad, black or white.
VK538FY··on Europe Built a System to Fight Russian Meddling. It’s Struggling
I believe that the grandparent poster could be qualified as rather 'hawkish'. I hope truly that cooler heads are at the helm of international politics.
VK538FY··on Europe Built a System to Fight Russian Meddling. It’s Struggling
Responding to myself since I first wanted to note the irony of the submitted article. Now I'll talk about this.

First, the US has many times interferred in Russian elections. I will not mention the interference in those of Russia's neighbours, Russia's allies, or others. So understand me when I find it absolutely impossible to be shocked by the allegations of Russian interference in the US since at least 2016. Brussels is an ally of the US, submitted to the NATO and therefore the US by treaty, and has done similar.

Second, no concrete evidence has been produced that this Russian interference in the US elections went beyond some tens of thousands of dollars of adverts in social media. The fingerprints of Russian troll farms are speculation. To believe some of the commentors here, if someone writes in an online forum that the EU is bad or we need to improve relations with Russia, then it's a Russian troll farm. Well I'm not from a Russian troll farm and I'll say (a) that the economic and political model of the EU has brought suffering and servitude to many of its members and (b) that it is imperative that western countries improve their relations with Russia rather than blindly following the irrational and bellicose positions of the US and NATO.

VK538FY··on Europe Built a System to Fight Russian Meddling. It’s Struggling
In the country in which I live, what I fear the most is Brussels meddling in the democractic process. Although an immigrant, I have become very attached to the institutions and culture of my host country. Every move closer to the EU, of which we are not a member, menaces those institutions. Yet Brussels has no problem financing NGOs, articles, 'economic research' etc. that want just that. Some are known, yet for others, the source is quite opaque.
← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →