HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Veratyr

3,468 karma · joined January 16, 2013

submissionscomments
Veratyr··on Comcast is injecting 400+ lines of JavaScript into web pages
Could this legally be construed as creating a derivative work under copyright law?

As a site owner, could I prosecute Comcast for infringing on my rights by altering the content of my pages?

Veratyr··on Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System (2008) [pdf]
The content is exactly the same:

> curl 'https://www.bitcoin.com/bitcoin.pdf' | md5

d56d71ecadf2137be09d8b1d35c6c042

> curl https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf | md5

d56d71ecadf2137be09d8b1d35c6c042

Of the two organizations, .org seems far more trustworthy.

https://www.bitcoin.com/about-us: "Please keep in mind that this is a commercial website"

https://bitcoin.org/en/about-us: "Bitcoin.org was originally registered and owned by Bitcoin's first two developers, Satoshi Nakamoto and Martti Malmi. When Nakamoto left the project, he gave ownership of the domain to additional people, separate from the Bitcoin developers, to spread responsibility and prevent any one person or group from easily gaining control over the Bitcoin project."

Veratyr··on Bitcoin (BTC) is up by +22% in a single day, valued at over $14,600
Could we stop turning HN into a Bitcoin ticker? It feels like every day we get a "Bitcoin reaches $X" post and it's getting old. It's certainly not newsworthy.

If there's something concrete that _causes_ Bitcoin to move majorly, I'd be happy to see that but if I just want to watch the price, I'll look at an actual Bitcoin ticker.

Veratyr··on Student Loan Debt Is Now as Big as the U.S. Junk Bond Market
I no longer live in Australia and as long as you have this debt, you're required to file an Australian tax return. I paid it off to get rid of that hassle.

Also it used to be that voluntary payments got you a discount.

Veratyr··on Student Loan Debt Is Now as Big as the U.S. Junk Bond Market
> Another solution is to let you go to school for free and then pay a percent of all your future earnings

In Australia we have a system somewhere between this and a loan.

You go to (heavily subsidized) university, tuition is paid for by the government with an automatic interest free loan.

Once you earn above a particular (somewhat generous) threshold, your employer automatically starts taking a percentage of your income (depends on income) and pays it towards the loan.

There's no interest but the loan amount is indexed against inflation.

I graduated from one of the country's top universities with $24k AUD (~$18k USD) debt to the government and paid it all off early voluntarily. It used to be that voluntary payments got you a 5% bonus but that's gone now.

Veratyr··on Judge orders Wyoming to return $92k seized by officers
> If you are acquitted after being arrested, does that make your arrest a kidnapping?

If the officers have no reason to suspect that you actually committed a crime and arrest you solely for their own gain, then yes, it's a kidnapping.

The problem here is that there's no evidence showing that assets should be "forfeited", cops are stealing people's stuff because they can.

Veratyr··on Evolution of <img>: Gif without the GIF
This I can deal with, everyone else has been supporting this for ages. The bigger question for me is whether Apple will support AV1 like the rest of the industry or skip over it like they did with VP9.
Veratyr··on “The Orville” is on a smoother trajectory, with just a bit of turbulence
I get where you're coming from and I see that Orville is deliberately trying to be different, often in a good way but even taking later episodes into account, I think this one really stands out in a bad way.

> They SHOULD have lost the trial, and they DID, unlike TNG where everyone can quickly become an expert legal representative within 48 hours.

This isn't about becoming lawyers, this is about the otherwise shown as brilliant and logical crew throwing all their judgement out the window and making arguments like "all these other species lack the issue you're describing, that means yours does too" and making emotional appeals without looking for _any_ kind of evidence.

Look at their approaches to other problems. They're generally pretty rational and apply logic and reason.

> They argued like regular people argue, not lawyers.

But they're not regular people, they're highly trained explorers, often charged with diplomatic missions and making contact with other cultures. Plus they have a ton of science staff and a superintelligent walking computer.

They don't need to be lawyers but they _do_ need to act like they can do their jobs, at least somewhat.

> I agree with your assessment, but suspect that the aloofness was intentional

I agree with you too that it was intentional but I really don't think it made sense. Am I really supposed to expect that the crew I saw in episode 3 is the same crew I saw in the other episodes?

I could believe it if they showed that the admiralty was so disappointed in their performance that they made them undergo additional training between episodes 3 and 4 but that wasn't the case.

> Totally cool if you don't, but if you keep watching you might enjoy it more if you associate the cringeworthy moments with the writers telling you to think about the scene more. At least it worked for me.

I've kept watching it and I've mostly liked it but that episode just really stood out to me as bad.

Veratyr··on “The Orville” is on a smoother trajectory, with just a bit of turbulence
You basically summed up my experience with episode 3 as well, but I finished the episode and decided to give it one more chance.

Episode 4 is a better episode to judge it on I think so I'd encourage you to give it one last chance.

3 has definitely been the worst so far and I'm not a fan of 9 (though it has some character development) but I haven't regretted watching the rest.

At this point I feel like it's basically Star Trek made more accessible to the kind of person who can't sit through Inner Light or "Shaka, where the walls fell". Tone down the moralising and philosophy (it's not entirely gone but it's definitely reduced), throw in some crude humour and you've got something that much of the US TV audience could actually watch, while still being somewhat like Star Trek to those who want it.

Veratyr··on “The Orville” is on a smoother trajectory, with just a bit of turbulence
My main problem is that, driven by emotion, the crew attempted to make a _logical_ argument, substantially based on fallacy ("these other species don't have this attribute you claim you have, so you mustn't either"). Their ultimate argument was, in the end, a pretty solid one, based on real evidence, however they didn't seem to bother looking for evidence until the very end, when all other avenues were exhausted. It wasn't a rational way to behave and I don't think this would have ever happened in TNG (did it? An episode doesn't come to mind).

In TNG, Data would also have found the whole thing very confusing and grounded the crew somewhat. Isaac was notably absent in this episode.

The ending was interesting and I think this episode could have been _much_ better if the rest of it was handled better but the irrational behaviour of the crew was so bad it broke the suspension of disbelief for me.

I may be naïve to think I can do better but I'd do it something like this:

- Crew asks, in a great deal of detail, what exactly the aliens believe the problem is and why they believe it's there

- Aliens respond with their concerns and that they are primarily based on custom/legend and there is no modern evidence

- Crew asks if it would be possible to gather evidence

- Aliens say no

- Crew tries to justify their search for evidence with the arguments presented in the episode as it was originally written

- Aliens rightly point out that those arguments are invalid, continue to say no

- Crew gathers evidence on their own, sneaking around and maybe getting in a bit of diplomatic trouble

- Crew finds evidence, makes argument

- Argument is overruled, episode keeps its nice ending

Veratyr··on “The Orville” is on a smoother trajectory, with just a bit of turbulence
As someone who was in a similar situation:

- I'd skip episode 3. Maybe come back to it later. It's the episode that nearly put me off the series. I think 4 is a fairer episode to judge it by.

- It's not a parody of Star Trek and it's not meant to be one. It's more like Seth MacFarlane really wanted to run a Star Trek show and couldn't, so made something about as close as he could while still appeasing the networks with some crude humour thrown in.

It's not as good as TNG but it's definitely an okay Star Trek at this point. They've toned down the stupid humour and premises from where it started.

Veratyr··on “The Orville” is on a smoother trajectory, with just a bit of turbulence
Odd, that was the episode that just about made me drop the series.

The crew of the Orville was driven by emotion, barely took any time to consider the aliens' point of view, didn't seek any evidence for either side's position and argued their point primarily with logical fallacies ("look, these problems don't exist in other species, so clearly they can't exist in yours").

I don't think this episode could have worked in TNG because the episode would boil down to:

"Picard: What evidence do you have to support your beliefs?"

"Aliens: Uhh, why do we need evidence, clearly it is this way?"

"Picard: Let's find some evidence"

It had its upsides for sure but it's definitely not comparable to TNG.

Veratyr··on “The Orville” is on a smoother trajectory, with just a bit of turbulence
It's definitely got more of a Star Trek feel now but early on it was pretty bad. "About a Girl" just about made me drop it.

Without spoiling it too much, a crew member on the Orville had a family dispute that boiled down to alien ethics/culture vs. human ethics/culture. While I feel crews of the earlier actual Star Trek series would have approached the problem with more empathy, understanding and logic, the (mostly human) crew of the Orville were purely driven by emotion and tried to argue their position in ways that made zero logical sense.

It's been much better since then though. These days it feels like Star Trek with a little less philosophy and some poor jokes thrown in to appease the network.

Veratyr··on German government wants ‘backdoor’ access to every digital device: report
> That's condescendent

Really? In the wake of the GFC, which bills would _you_ have voted for and why?

> and openly anti-democratic

No, it's realistic. Lawmakers needs to make decisions on a _huge_ variety of issues and people with full time jobs simply _cannot_ become familiar enough with all these issues to make an educated decision about which option is in their best interests.

Unless you're suggesting people stop working, I don't think there's anything we can do.

> to me it seems there are too many laws anyway, so let's make it easier

How? The only way I can see is to make the language required to write them less precise, which opens them for more interpretation by the judicial branch. Are you okay with putting more of the country in the hands of the courts?

> No prejudice? no law. Less freedom for the People? no law.

Guarantees like this are the purpose of the constitution. I don't think "Less freedom for the People" is viable anyhow as laws inherently reduce freedom.

> if representative democracies were working on those issues

There are representative democracies that don't have the issues we see in others. Representative democracy isn't the problem. Things like electoral systems and corruption are the bigger problems.

> America once was a flaming wreck... then a great country emerged.

Not coincidentally, the "great country" (as a non-American living in America, I find this hilarious) was a representative democracy.

Veratyr··on Detailed Financial Histories Exposed for Thousands
Not everything you do is futile. Refraining from distributing your data is very effective.
Veratyr··on German government wants ‘backdoor’ access to every digital device: report
The theoretical advantage of representative democracy is that the average voter doesn't have the time or knowledge to make decisions on the vast majority of issues, while an elected representative can spend 100% of their time ensuring they make the decision that benefits their constituents.

That, plus it's actually _really_ hard to write a law.

I agree that representative democracies as we see them implemented have serious issues but I don't think it's viable to replace it with direct democracy, digital or not. Imagine if America was a direct democracy, the country would be a flaming wreck by now.

Veratyr··on Drone Maker D.J.I. May Be Sending Data to China, U.S. Officials Say
Sure but the US also has a very broad definition of "reasonable", where just about any kind of information you share through or with a business is a "business record" and doesn't require a warrant.

Not to mention the blanket surveillance, use of Stingrays without a warrant and near total lack of privacy law.

The US might not be as _bad_ as China but it's still far from _good_.

Veratyr··on A Map Showing How Much Time It Takes English-Speakers to Learn Foreign Languages
Why did you link to this page, which is little more than blogspam wrapped around the original source: https://www.reddit.com/r/MapPorn/comments/7dith2/language_di...
Veratyr··on Auto increment is a terrible idea
> all it takes to know your user count is to create an account

Also, this is only the case if your raw user IDs are visible. You only need a very basic encryption scheme to hide them. It can be as simple as taking two large prime numbers and sending (uid + x) % y to the user.

Veratyr··on Ask HN: What age do you expect to be able to retire?
If I were working in a field that required an able body I might agree with you but I'm not performing manual labour, society would get just as much value from me overall if I had my retirement now and spent my 40s and 50s writing code instead.

It's already silly that I'm spending my 20s and 30s writing code.

Plus the code I write doesn't do anything for society's survival. We could just about switch the entire tech industry to maintenance mode, cut jobs by 90% and society would get along just fine, as long as we figure out a way to distribute necessities like food and housing without money.

The same can be said about an enormous chunk of the workforce. We're forced to work for survival but the jobs we perform aren't truly necessary, they're ultimately derived from an illogical and unsustainable obsession with growth.

Most of society doesn't _need_ to be working at all and society would get along just fine if it wanted. It just doesn't want to.

Veratyr··on Keeping Time with Amazon Time Sync Service
Yep, you can buy a Neo-6M with breakout board and antenna for $5 and hook it up to a Raspberry Pi without much trouble.

Software can be fiddly but I found this guide to be helpful: http://www.satsignal.eu/ntp/Raspberry-Pi-NTP.html

Hell, you can hook it up to a NodeMCU as well: https://blog.squix.org/2016/05/esp8266-peripherals-ublox-gps...

Bam, $10 wifi enabled GPS.

Veratyr··on Ask HN: What age do you expect to be able to retire?
As soon as I can! I think it's insane that I'm spending my most able-bodied years sitting behind a desk writing code all day instead of with my wife or (not yet conceived) children.
Veratyr··on Keeping Time with Amazon Time Sync Service
The datacenter I use does: http://www.he.net/adm/ntp.html
Veratyr··on Ask HN: What age do you expect to be able to retire?
In theory, if I wished, I could retire right now. My wife is Russian, houses are very cheap in her area and I've managed to save a good portion of my bay area income over the past few years.

Realistically though, more like 40 (another 17 years). I generally save about half my income, which over the next 17 years should build to >$1M, which is enough to buy a house outright in a nice area with a few hundred thousand left over to spend on living expenses.

> What are some common mistakes software engineers make that prevent them from getting their sooner?

Living and working in the bay area, spending their money. If you work at MicroGoogleBookZon, you can usually transfer to a region with a lower cost of living without much of a salary hit and save that money. Even if you stay in the bay area, you can drastically reduce the cost of living by increasing your commute or living with others. It's less pleasant but you don't have to do it as long.

Also, you don't have to retire to the same place you save your money in. You can work and save in Seattle, then retire to say rural Minnesota. If you're happy with that, you can retire much earlier.

Veratyr··on Ask HN: What age do you expect to be able to retire?
I recognized this story from the "made in the USA" thread (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15794202) and thought your story a little curious so thought I'd look into it a little more (i.e. Google your name).

Assuming this is you: https://peterburk.github.io/

"Political issues have caused me to wander around the world looking for a country willing to simply give me a visa."

What are these nebulous "political issues"? Why do you think wandering around the world is likely to result in a visa?

You say in your bio: "Where am I from? To the English, England. To the Swiss, Switzerland. To the French, France." You also claim to have lived in France most of your life, which would entitle you to French citizenship should you wish it.

You should be able to live and work in the UK, Switzerland or pretty much anywhere in the EU. What exactly is preventing you from doing so?

> If I am lucky to get a visa to a Western country, then I might earn more.

Again, do you not have English, Swiss or French citizenship? Can't you work in most of Europe?

It sounds like you should be work in most western countries and derive a western income without any problems.

Veratyr··on Plex’s DVR Now Auto-Removes Commercials from Your Recordings
Yeah, that's a limitation of Roku, the older ones don't support HEVC.
Veratyr··on Plex’s DVR Now Auto-Removes Commercials from Your Recordings
Dunno if it's an option but the NVIDIA Shield TV can either direct play pretty much anything with Kodi or it can act as a low power Plex server with a hardware video encoder.
Veratyr··on A guide to great things still made in the U.S.A
Oh, you're stateless? In that case you should be able to get in to many countries on a humanitarian/refugee visa right?
Veratyr··on A guide to great things still made in the U.S.A
> It's been a long, difficult, wandering struggle to find a country willing to accept me for 3 years so I can get enough work experience.

Your home country?

> Work experience requirements are a veiled age limit. This is persecution of younger generations.

Hardly. It just means that someone has to have demonstrated their ability, not just acquired a piece of paper.

Veratyr··on A guide to great things still made in the U.S.A
OP is asking for a moral/ethical argument though, not an emotional one. Saving your son's life is emotionally justified but unlikely morally and certainly not ethically.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →