HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

VexXtreme

1,595 karma · joined August 24, 2012

submissionscomments
VexXtreme··on Why Inequality Matters
I understand your viewpoint. It's interesting how your lack of trust for things made you become socialist, while my lack of trust for people made me develop anarcho-capitalist tendencies. I guess everyone's political philosophy tends to stem from their core personality traits. Interesting.

My issue with the concept of centralized power in the society is that it has a tendency to consolidate over time and if left unchecked, tyranny is almost inevitable. Sure, you trust your government now, but nation-states generally have a very ugly history of oppressing and even exterminating portions of their population every once in a while. I just don't believe that they can be trusted not to do it again. Not everyone is a good person, and many people in the higher rungs of power tend to have psychopathic tendencies.

So at the end of the day, you don't trust your physical assets not to betray you, but you tend to trust the society you live in. My mindset is completely opposite: I don't think that people can be trusted not to do bad things. You mentioned bitcoin, and I think this is one of the elements that it solves almost perfectly: it eliminates the need for trust, if used correctly. Strong gun rights solve the same problem, they almost completely eliminate the need for trust: I don't have to trust the society to respect my property rights, I just have to trust that most people are not crazy enough to try to get themselves shot.

I think socialism is a nice concept and I think that the idea of helping the less fortunate is commendable. The problem is that it has to rely on the coercive element (uniformed men with guns showing up at your door) if you disagree with the system.

Not to drag this out much longer; as someone who strongly believes in non-violence, self-ownership, self-governance and rejects most forms of collectivism, I can't agree with pointing guns at people in order to create a safety net for others. It defeats the spirit of charity and looks more like extortion and robbery. In my opinion, helping the less fortunate should a voluntary act that stems from one's desire to do good, rather than fear of being violated.

VexXtreme··on What we give away when we log on to a public Wi-Fi network
I see a lot of comments here presenting HSTS as some kind of silver bullet for preventing MITM attacks. While it does help, it's not impenetrable. If a website hasn't been preloaded into the STS preloaded list, then the HSTS header can be stripped on the first visit and the client will never upgrade to SSL.

The only foolproof way to make sure you're not being MITMd is to visually verify that the domain checks out and that you are indeed connected using SSL.

VexXtreme··on Why Inequality Matters
Lol no they don't. Most third world countries actually have very strong authoritarian governments where any serious dissent is highly discouraged or even impossible. And even if they have low taxes, they sure compensate for that with regular currency debasement, widespread kleptocracy and stealing wealth from their citizens on a regular basis. This free-market "gospel" is based on hard facts, not some Marxist drivel.
VexXtreme··on Why Inequality Matters
Ok, I guess we are just going to have to agree to disagree. Our respective systems of values seem to be fundamentally different, because I believe that property rights are sacrosanct and an extension of who we are.

In case you're curious how I came to that conclusion, here goes: in most cases (not involving criminal situations), private property is basically a store of our previously invested time. We spend a portion of our lives on learning skills and then applying those skills to certain ends, such as making money and acquiring property. If we assume that a human lifetime is finite, then reserving the right to redistribute private property and wealth is basically reserving the right to take the most valuable resource humans have - their time on this Earth.

So if I'm working 10 hours a day and I'm being taxed some 40% (through a combination of income, property and consumption tax), then it means I am working only 6 hours for myself and my own personal gain, and the remaining 4 hours in fact belong to someone else. Now, I apologize in advance for this loaded language, but to me, that is a form of slavery. No one has the right to demand, at gunpoint, that people give their time and person to an end that they don't care about and that doesn't directly improve their situation.

I feel very strongly about this, to the point where I left my country of birth (a European country with ridiculously high taxes), for a much better place where the taxes are much lower and more reasonable. It's a clear example of capital flight, on a smaller scale. I know my opinion is extremely unpopular in this day and age, but it is what it is. To me, strong property rights are some of the most basic human rights, no different than freedom of speech or association.

VexXtreme··on Why Inequality Matters
He seems to think that equities are some kind of sinkholes where the money simply gets tied up or disappears. He doesn't understand that the money used to buy a share has to go to the seller of the said share, who might in turn use it to consume. It's actually an incredibly common fallacy that keeps getting brought up time and again.
VexXtreme··on Why Inequality Matters
Your statement is fallacious. If governments are more efficient at creating inventions and advancing science, then according to that logic, a big government with greater power should be more efficient at advancing technological and scientific progress.

Yet, the majority of important technological and scientific inventions usually come from free-market based capitalistic societies. I don't see countries like North Korea, Russia and China making any scientific and technological breakthroughs, and I think it's easy to argue that they have very powerful governments.

Private sector has and always will drive the majority of progress. How much exactly, usually varies by era and political structure of the global society, but the fact that the free market ultimately drives innovation is indisputable.

VexXtreme··on Why Inequality Matters
You didn't answer his question whether it's ok to try to neuter the power that people derive from certain innate attributes. I.e. is it OK to make an exceptionally good looking person pay a higher tax, because there's a loose correlation between physical appearance and one's ability to secure a good future? Furthermore, doesn't everyone deserve the same shot at procreating with a good looking individual? Shouldn't we start using the power of coercion to make sure that unattractive people get to mate and have children as well? Where does it stop?
VexXtreme··on Why Inequality Matters
Looks like you're getting downvoted, even though your statement is basically correct. It's very sad that it's getting harder and harder to have a fruitful discussion here on HN. Some people are more interested in downvoting based on their immediate emotional reaction, rather than having a rational, honest discussion.

If you disagree with someone, then reply to their post and try to have civilized discourse, don't just immediately try to censor them.

VexXtreme··on The Imminent Decentralized Computing Revolution
It's only seemingly inefficient. It's basically the price you have to pay for maintaining a trustless distributed ledger.

If you were to run an organization/bank/Paypal clone that maintains a centralized ledger, it would be just as expensive (if not more), because you'd have to hire thousands of employees, compliance officers, lawyers etc. You probably see what I'm getting at.

There's always going to be a price for maintaining accurate accounting ledgers. The only questions is where those expenses are going to be pushed and whether it's going to be your payroll or your power bill.

VexXtreme··on Amazon Must Be Stopped
The workers are paid what the market is willing to pay them. If there is an inefficiency/mispricing and someone can get better compensation elsewhere (for the same skill set, presumably), then it makes sense for them to arbitrage that gap and change employers. If enough people leave Amazon, then Amazon will have to start paying people better, and ultimately, the gap will close.
VexXtreme··on Amazon Must Be Stopped
See my reply to the poster below you.
VexXtreme··on Amazon Must Be Stopped
If a monopoly spontaneously emerges out of a free market, whereby no violence or coercion was used against other participants, then that business was simply better and more efficient at giving the market what it wants. It also doubles as a price signal to others that something in their way of doing business is inefficient and wasteful (or just not as efficient as the most efficient participant).

I don't have a problem with such "monopolies", because they aren't real monopolies. As long as the market is still open to new participants, then it's not really an issue. For example, if a monopolist starts raising prices and hoarding supplies in order to artificially elevate prices, then new participants can enter the market and make money off the delta between the new prices and the old prices that made sense to the market.

VexXtreme··on Amazon Must Be Stopped
It seems as though the author has a problem with capitalism and free markets in general. Yes, let's abolish capitalism, allow some central bureau to fix prices and use its power of violence over actors who don't comply. Oh wait... it was attempted 90 years ago and it didn't work out.
VexXtreme··on Mystery Man Who Moves Japanese Markets Made More Than 1M Trades
Most Japanese day traders are ex-pachinko players, i.e. degenerate gamblers. Nothing to see here.
VexXtreme··on Smartphones Are Used To Stalk, Control Domestic Abuse Victims
Yet another reason not to jailbreak.
VexXtreme··on Seniors and the generation spending gap
You say I owe something, I say you're stealing from me.

I don't and won't pay shit. It's my property. Come and take it, but there WILL be consequences.

I don't know if you're genuinely evil or you're just one delusional latte sipping socialist hipster who thinks he can live off other people's money and labor. Sickening.

VexXtreme··on Seniors and the generation spending gap
Sorry I don't subscribe to communism. I believe in certain unalienable rights, and property ownership is one of them.
VexXtreme··on Seniors and the generation spending gap
Ok, let me present a simple scenario. Imagine the following:

Initially you're doing well in life. You're making decent money at your tech job and you eventually end up buying a pretty nice house. Things are good for a while, but at some point you get old/sick and are unable to work anymore. You are able to survive on what you have and perhaps have a fairly decent life, but it's not a lot. You like the house where you live and you consider it yours. But for some reason, the price of real estate in your neighborhood skyrockets and the government reevaluates your tax liabilities based on the new valuation of your house.

You used to have a pretty good life, but now you just can't afford the new property tax anymore and are forced to sell the property, move halfway across town and buy some dingy shack that you actually can afford.

Question: is it fair of the government to evict you from the place that you fully own and where you lived for ages, because of someone's rent-seeking behavior and based on certain factors that are completely outside of your control? Are you telling me that you wouldn't feel even a little bit upset in that kind of scenario?

edit: Also, I thought that downvoting is reserved for rude discourse and blatant violations of the HN rules, not if you disagree with someone's opinion. This place is becoming just like Reddit.

VexXtreme··on Seniors and the generation spending gap
I agree. It all comes down to your personal belief system. If I believe that theft is wrong and immoral and you disagree, then we will never be able to reach common ground.

Goodbye.

VexXtreme··on How Apple Pay works and why it matters for developers
Or that they don't subscribe to everything The Cult of Apple feeds them.

edit: getting downvoted like a champ. The Cult is strong with HN.

VexXtreme··on Seniors and the generation spending gap
It's different. If your home was previously paid for in full, then it's your private property. If I'm paying someone on a monthly basis to allow me to live in their residence, then it's obviously not mine. Asking someone to keep paying an annual tax on something that's:

1. completely theirs

2. essential to their life

is a form of feudalism and serfdom and a flagrant violation of their right to be secure in their life, possessions and property. You can try to argue this as much as you want and invoke all sorts of broken analogies, but it is what it is.

VexXtreme··on Seniors and the generation spending gap
That's correct, it's not a right, but being free from having your primary and only residence confiscated because you're unable to pay a "property tax" (usually due to a decreasing living standard) should be a right.
VexXtreme··on Stop and Seize
> we are Americans and aren't going to allow our liberties to being eroded by a bunch of fear mongering asshats

I can't count how many times I've heard this comment along the lines of "hurr durr this is Murica and no one is taking muh freedom away". No, your freedoms are already gone and it looks like you haven't woken up to it yet.

VexXtreme··on Ask HN: Palantir or Facebook?
Palantir, by far.

http://www.forbes.com/sites/andygreenberg/2011/02/09/did-sec...

VexXtreme··on EFF Asks Judge to Rule NSA Internet Backbone Spying Techniques Unconstitutional
More people get wrongfully killed every year by police officers than they do by terrorists. Why not deal with the low hanging fruit first?
VexXtreme··on Bitcoin: the Stripe perspective
The beautiful thing about bitcoin is that it's an open system, an open currency if you will, that will allow a nice app ecosystem to be built on top of it. That aspect will allow many non-technical people to interact with abstractions that hide away all the complexities (such as Stripe), but it will also allow experts and hackers to still tap into the network directly with their own wallets, nodes, private keys etc.

I think that bitcoin is currently in its early infancy when it comes to user adoption and still has a very long way to go before it reaches its potential. It's not completely off base to compare it with the way the internet was back in the early 90s.

VexXtreme··on Python is now the most popular introductory language at top U.S. universities
You know what man, FUCK YOU. You broke the layout of the discussion for everyone and it's next to impossible to follow the conversation without a ton of horizontal scrolling. Take your trolling elsewhere, it's not welcome here.
VexXtreme··on Tor users are selected and monitored by the NSA as extremists
So would this XKeyscore thing know what you're searching for if you're not logged into your Google account and you're behind SSL? Would that imply they have private keys to Google SSL certificates?
VexXtreme··on Tor exit node operator prosecuted in Austria
> Let's get real, the vast majority of Tor traffic is, shall we say, for nefarious purposes.

I don't really understand your argument here. Are you saying that Tor should be banned because the ratio of illegitimate to legitimate applications is higher than that of encryption software? I'm not putting words in your mouth, I'm just trying to understand what you're saying here.

> Safe for whom? You as an individual, perhaps. Definitely not safe for the guy running the exit node.

Well you would be the guy running an exit node on a VPS hosted by a hosting company/ISP (after all, they seem to be protected by law). Looks pretty bullet proof to me. Worst case scenario - they shut down your VPS.

VexXtreme··on Tor exit node operator prosecuted in Austria
I had to downvote and here's why:

> you're mostly helping drug dealers and child pornographers operate

You could argue the same about encryption, so should encryption be banned or deemed immoral now?

> That's why it's absolutely crazy to operate a node.

Again, you could say this for any company that builds crypto software.

> Find some other way to help if you value your freedom.

You can still operate a TOR exit node safely by anonymously getting a server paid for with a cryptocurrency. It's perfectly safe.

← PreviousPage 2 of 8Next →