HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

VictorPath

403 karma · joined June 19, 2021

submissionscomments
VictorPath··on Finland’s education system is failing. Should we look to Asia?
Sahlgren (not Shalgren) is an ideologue with an axe to grind. Finland has gotten good PISA scores for a while and still gets them, he sits figures fir his purposes. Also Chinese PISA scores come from top schools in Beijing, whereas Finland tests more broadly, so the comparisons don't hold any how.
VictorPath··on Ask HN: Location based pay is killing my motivation, how do others handle it?
Google "super exploitation".
VictorPath··on Backsliding on free expression around the world needs to end
> Since he took office in 2000, Putin has been eroding the space for public debate in Russia. He moved from dismantling independent media

Right, Russia bans independent media, while those in the free EU can go read https://www.rt.com ... oh yaa, the EU blocks that web site.

VictorPath··on Will I Ever See the $36MM Oberlin College Owes Me?
IT People used to talk on Usenet, then a bunch of young free software guys started Slashdot, which took VC and corporatized, then a seed fund started this web site. The medium determines the message and this board is filled with white, upper middle class born people doing tech finance. Not much of a surprise the front page comes down on the side of the white against the black 95% of the time.
VictorPath··on Snowden: US asked British spy agency to stop Guardian publishing revelations
> national security information

The word national security used to mean protecting a country just invaded, then moved to troops on the border looking like they'll invade. Now you've stretched it to the government doing mass surveillance on its citizens (and storing it forever). During COINTELPRO, Hoover and his secret political police in the FBI spied on and worked to anonymously disrupt feminist groups and other political organizations, and this is just a continuation of that - set up in secret incidentally. I don't see how some elite trying to set up a police state to exert political control has anything to do with national security. Luckily the FBI raided Trump recently, so Republican wariness may have them go back to that old idea of a Republican secretary of state that "gentlemen do not read each others' mail".

VictorPath··on Mikhail Gorbachev has died
> The West has embraced Russia's democracy right after the fall of the iron curtain.

Right like Clinton and the US congress cheering Yeltsin bombing Russia's elected parliament.

VictorPath··on Mikhail Gorbachev has died
What do you mean, like when Clinton and the US Congress cheered Yeltsin bombing Russia's elected parliament (Duma). Then Yeltsin appointed Putin and here we are. The US has positioned Russia exactly where it wants it - it has positioned the Ukraine exactly where it wants it too.
VictorPath··on Heavily Armed Russian Navy Ships Sailing Between Britain and Ireland
The US is actively seizing another sovereign nation's territory, it is seizing Guantanamo in Cuba, which Cuba has requested the US leave for decades.
VictorPath··on Heavily Armed Russian Navy Ships Sailing Between Britain and Ireland
The article could also mention that Britain has a heavily armed presence in the six counties of north Ireland, which colluded with and armed loyalist death squads, when it wasn't locking up the native population in concentration camps during internment, shooting dead unarmed protesters in the street when Irish men and women marched through the street protesting internment. This is not a possible threat to Ireland but a threat against Ireland which already was enacted, and Britain seized six counties from Ireland.

The British empire has now turned its attention from Ireland to Russia and has been sending weapons abroad in order to kill Russians. So Russian warships sailing past Britain is natural enough.

I hope they do fire on Britain in order to not only stop the weaponry killing Russians, but to weaken Britain so the Irish can be free of Britain's military occupation.

VictorPath··on Heavily Armed Russian Navy Ships Sailing Between Britain and Ireland
The US Navy sailed guided missle cruisers along and just outside Chinese waters Sunday. The headline in that case neglected to proffer that they were "heavily armed", I guess the objective news only mentions that if they're Russian ships, not peace-seeking ships from the west.

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/us-navy-vessels-aircraf...

VictorPath··on The sudden silencing of Guantanamo's artists
> the people held at Guantanamo are responsible for killing humans via cowardly terrorists attacks, either indirectly or directly.

The people held at Guantanamo Bay are not considered POWs by the US, nor have they been given a trial. They're held in violation of even US law. The US has let some go saying they picked up the wrong person. Who determined they are responsible for what you say they are responsible for? Even the US doesn't agree as they say they picked up some in error and let them go.

On top of this - for over half a century the country of Cuba has demanded the US withdraw its military base from Cuban territory. As US presidents piously intoned about Russian troops in Donetsk, that a sovereign nation wants US troops out of its territory is considered so unimportant it is practically unknown.

VictorPath··on The sudden silencing of Guantanamo's artists
> the perperators will get to live lavish lives off the proceeds of their artwork once released

The US has released some people from Guantanamo, saying they picked up the wrong person. Of course such things happen when people are imprisoned without trial, which is against even US law. They have never been given a trial, nor are they considered POWs, and some have been released when the US realized they got the wrong person, yet you piously and sanctimoniously desire to punish them even beyond the illegal punishment they've been meted.

VictorPath··on Hammer and Tickle (2006)
> Why such a long queue?”...“Well,” sighs Marx, “Sometimes we’re out of oil, sometimes we don’t have

I've been immersed in shortages for the past two years (try to go buy a car for MSRP), why some UK paper is writing about some far away, long ago shortage I don't know (well actually I do know).

VictorPath··on The Student Loan Giveaway Is Much Bigger Than You Think
If the US can afford to send $40 billion in weapons to Ukraine, it can afford some help to people going to college.

The government subsidizing a more educated US workforce is a "giveaway", but you don't hear that word applied to the tens of billions Lockheed Martin and Ukraine get from the US taxpayer.

VictorPath··on What to read to understand how economists think
For modern topics, read the Monthly Review ( https://monthlyreview.org ).

This article on the 2008 financial crisis has lots of interesting references to government data. Then you can see if you reach the same conclusions as the authors.

https://monthlyreview.org/2008/12/01/financial-implosion-and...

VictorPath··on “I survived the TCP transition” (2013)
In thanks for his decades of work getting the Internet going, Postel spent the months before he died getting trashed by anonymous government officials in the Washington Post and elsewhere.
VictorPath··on Philip K. Dick’s dystopia
> a surveillance society run by engineers would feel like to its inhabitants with a nauseating accuracy that did not become fully apparent until the rise of the modern tech surveillance complex.

Dick used to write letters to the FBI in the 1970s urging them to investigate fellow science fiction writers like Thomas Disch or professors like Fredrick Jameson. He was a participant in (delusionaly?) ratting people out to the secret police. I'll leave it to others to forecast a dystopia, he seems to forecast a dystopia he is trying to build.

VictorPath··on What Beirut was like before the war (2019)
> Here in India, British barely spent money on education, or industrialising the country.

It's beyond even that. The English spent the nineteenth century deindustrializing India - textiles, steel etc.

VictorPath··on What Beirut was like before the war (2019)
> He'd been in power since 1941

Does that include when he had fled to Italy in 1953? The reports were he had little desire to go back to Iran, and the CIA and SIS met trying to figure out how to get him to go back to Iran

> the Iranian military were ones who ultimately removed him

That's how it usually happens, the military elements with contact with foreign powers are usually who do in the local nationalists.

VictorPath··on What Beirut was like before the war (2019)
> Egypt and Iran are similar

Mossadegh wanted a secular independent Iran, England empowered the mullahs and worked for decades to destroy the secular left in Iran (along with the US). Eventually even the mullahs and bazaari turned against western colonialism.

The west also worked against Nasser's secular pan-Arab socialism, including the French/English invasion of the Suez.

VictorPath··on Study finds link between 'forever chemicals' in cookware and liver cancer
> he'll go through your science and find your errors and get a colleague he can deny knowing to publish that. Chomsky did this to the Piraha linguist.

"Go through your science and find your errors" is science. Commendations to Chomsky for advancing science in this instance.

VictorPath··on Themes in academic literature: prejudice and social justice
> Studies show test prep makes very little difference

Your cited studies show a 10-37 average increase, which means some prep improves half the preppers even more.

> Also, “hundreds of dollars” as a one time expense per kid isn’t unaffordable even for poor people.

Saying this shows how out of touch you are. Speaking of New York, the recent under-10 chess championship was won by a refugee in a homeless shelter. Yes, hundreds of dollars is out of range for his family.

> The selective admissions schools in NYC are full of poor Asian immigrants

Middle class in Asia can be poor in New York City.

VictorPath··on Work, Work, Work – So a Few Can Be Rich
> whining

We workers are bombarded consistently with whining about estate taxes, carry interest and that sort of thing. Actually the recent senate bill was held up over the fight over carried interest, a fight which was won by the funds.

However when the workers who create all the wealth press for their interests, it is "whining".

Insofar as the afterwards, to quote Malcolm X "anywhere is better than here".

VictorPath··on Work, Work, Work – So a Few Can Be Rich
> tak(x)ing away any raise and disposable income your employer gave you

An employer does not give a raise and disposable income to a worker. The worker is the creator of wealth, and the heirs collecting dividend profits are who are being given to. Your confusion about the directionality of created wealth within the relations of production is the whole point of the article.

VictorPath··on Work, Work, Work – So a Few Can Be Rich
In 1985, FARC entered a peace process and began working electorally and non-violently. The right never went for this and despite the government agreeing to a peace settlement, the right slaughtered political candidates, trade union leaders, etc. So eventually FARC reformed and began its armed campaign again. Something to think about for complaints about FARC "terrorism" from 1985 on. Actually they began doing so well that the US began having to bankroll the Colombian military with Plan Colombia (not a new thing, Kennedy was doing the same thing on a smaller scale).
VictorPath··on Work, Work, Work – So a Few Can Be Rich
This is a strawman argument. It is a diversion. It is not about billionaires and their wealth.

It is about the expropriation of a worker's surplus labor time by the heirs. It is about control of all the worker's work time (surplus and non-surplus) by the heirs.

VictorPath··on Work, Work, Work – So a Few Can Be Rich
> uhh. The article appears to suggest that we change who controls our labor...

> #1 - we do, we can quit anytime we want and find another place to work for.

We change who controls our labor by making those who control our labor us, the workers creating wealth, not the heirs who own companies and expropriate our surplus labor time via dividend profit checks.

The idea that a worker controls his own labor seems to be the one idea that is alien to your prescription.

VictorPath··on Archaeologists rebury ‘first-of-its-kind’ Roman villa
Iraq? From 1958 to 2003 Iraq preserved its cultural heritage fine. Then the UK invaded and the Iraq museum treasures were lost. The UK of course blames this on the Iraqis. The country is thrown into turmoil, to a tut-tut by upper middle class white westerners about how the Arabs aren't preserving their cultural heritage. This is why Arabs fighting against colonialism and imperialism fly planes into the Pentagon.
VictorPath··on Archaeologists rebury ‘first-of-its-kind’ Roman villa
Destroyed like the English banning the Irish language in schools in trying to destroy the Irish language?

Insofar as radical Islamists, the English sided with and supported radical Islamists in Iran against Mossadegh and then against the secular left under the Shah. The English supported Mujahideen in Afghanistan. Watch Lawrence of Arabia, they do it and celebrate it. The English saving secular socialist pan-Arab nationalism against radical Islamists? Please.

The real destruction of artifacts was the destruction of Iraq Museum during the UK's unprovoked invasion of that country. Which they of course blamed on Iraqis. These people are transparent.

VictorPath··on Apple warns suppliers to follow China rules on 'Taiwan' labeling
This is correct. The US does not recognize Taiwan as an independent country. The Taiwanese government doesn't recognize itself as a separate country from mainland China. I guess some people want Apple to have some US ultra-jingoist Opium Wars attitude to China that the US (aside from perhaps Pelosi) does not.
← PreviousPage 3 of 13Next →