HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

WilliamDhalgren

204 karma · joined August 24, 2016

submissionscomments
WilliamDhalgren··on Donald Trump is the president-elect of the U.S.
A Croat here; I have no idea what you're talking about; Who the hell are Yugoslavians? Where does this ethnicity live?

Before the breakup of Yugoslavia, some people identified as yugoslavian, yes - as one might identify as European today, but by far the majority of population identified as being one of yugoslavia's constituent ethnicities. After the breakup of Yugoslavia, practically nobody identifies as yugoslavian today - what would be the point, since that attempt at unification seems definitively dead to history now?

I assume you meant "lumped with Serbs (as being Yugoslavian)?".

WilliamDhalgren··on The Limits of Machine Learning
I thought the point of the article wasn't that a particular approach to learning has intrinsic limits, but that underdetermination of the pattern to be learned by the available data poses fundamental limits to what any learner could hope to discover.

The example motivating the discussion in such; even a perfect learnenr would hardly have any criteria to prefer one solution to another. Guess simplicity arguments could play in this example, if they weren't so vague, but even that doesn't happen in the general case.

That has to be true, for machines and humans alike. So ofc there's motivation to think about what comes after deep learning - but this isn't it, for that too, whatever it is, would be just as hopeless in examples such as there.

WilliamDhalgren··on Why Successful Games in China Rarely Obtain the Equivalent Success in the West
> In addition, the content is usually limited to the Four Great Classical Novels because that's the only thing a Chinese layman is familiar with.

really? If true, that sounds bloody brilliant; how I wish to play some game based on "dream of the red chamber"!

What would it be; a huge, sprawling point&click intrigue adventure game with hundereds of deeply characterized NPCs maybe? Can you recommend a title? Any fangroup made english titles for it?

WilliamDhalgren··on The Doomed Mouse Utopia That Inspired the 'Rats of NIMH'
.. and zizek has used anything from Alien to Hitchcock to illustrate his concepts often enough. Hardly makes either a work of any particular philosophical depth - merely something one may illustrate notions with on a pop-cultural or introductory-educational level.
WilliamDhalgren··on Researchers achieve speech recognition milestone
So this model won't be free software??? Odd, and bummer...

Also I'm note sure an error reduction of 20% (1-6.3/7.8) is to be considered small; depends on the particular challenge really. Like, sentiment analysis only starts to get interesting above 80% on some dataset, as much can be guessed correctly in very naive ways..

Human lvl on this task is estimated to be ~4% so we have quite a lot of ground to cover still..

WilliamDhalgren··on Haskell vs. Clojure (2014)
I know barely enough haskell, passively, to dislike quite a lot of this code (like really, 3 lines on 3 places, just to case on a maybe to throw an error? w/a just calling fromMaybe or even fromJust? and manual instances??) - but, could someone more experienced suggest a saner one?
WilliamDhalgren··on Teen Creates “Sit with Us” App for Bullied Kids
We tolerate it because its normal, ie how things work out in nature unless we try to intervene, is simply the naturallistic fallacy. While in fact what happens in nature really doesn't imply anything about anything's desirability, which is what is at issue here.

Now, no doubt their responsibility is different, because their brains are different. It'd be appaling to jail a kid on charges of assault for a fight in school ofc.

However, this def does not mean that getting bullied wouldn't have similarly negative effects on the kid, as it would on the adults (easily worse, given the kid's personality is only forming).

Hence, the op was suggesting, rationally, preventing it should be just as high of a priority to the school, as it would be to the judicial apparatus in the case of adult assault.

Instead, it is just normal. And that is appaling.

WilliamDhalgren··on Someone Is Learning How to Take Down the Internet
hah, mostly very good points

IDK, for one I'm not even sure a major exchange is as deadly as here supposed (much depends on who else joins the party I guess); sure lots of land on some continents at least is badly irradiated, but a majority is not quite as bad, and most of radiation degrades quickly, some simple measures help, and besides not everyone needs to survive every year After Launch anyhow, and non-extreme radiation doses kill only statistically. Much depends on - as you say, on how much of state command structure is able to survive and organize the remains, and that could easily vary from state to state on the planet.

I lived through a minor war in my youth, with the frontline maybe 2km at its closest approach and regular shelling for IDK couple of years. It was a remarkably well-ordered affair, considering. Fact half the GDP evaporated and rest was put under direct government command for war and other logistical purposes didn't really constitute a panic collapse of societal order or anything like that, and return to some kind of (low budget) normality quite quick. Kinda remarkable in retrospect, in how badly we react to small upsets, like a high-single digit GDP loss in a recession, yet tolerate such major disasters...

If the number of people directly killed is on the order of a few hundered million, thats not a substantial part of the humankind, so it may not be too different -- to people living in places too boring to have been hit by a nuke and not too close downwind from something interesting, ofc.

Guess it becomes worse if all the players hit all the other players, and no further advances in reducing nuclear inventories are made before it hits etc.

But again, yeah, a societal collapse is certainly a kill-myself kind of event for me too, because as you say - we're never gonna rebuild if we fall to that point. I'm just more sanguine about nukes being lobbed about not necessarily causing this I guess.

WilliamDhalgren··on Pardon Snowden
Yeah, though not so much that some kind of legislation should be found that creates a balanced outcome, but that just even broad strokes of some vanilla whistleblower protection legislations are themselves reasonable and balanced, and hence should apply in the security setting too.

> There was also a massive national security compromise in the US ability to conduct surveillance.

but, but that's the whole point of the exercise, isn't it; the curtailment of mass surveillance? I mean, we're talking about a public agency; it needs to act within a clear public mandate when striving to reach its goals. It is not an end in itself, so when it oversteps its mandate, its not in fact providing any public good, but diminishing it, and so hindering it in further action on this course is in the public interest.

So sure, having the public aware that it engages in mass surveilence and bulk collection on both its citizens and non-targeted citizens of the world more generally -- is inconvenient to the agency, but is a win for the public. And consequently so are any actions third parties then take to make its life more difficult -- because really it is the rouge party here!

Something seems upside down to me in this logic where obscuring the price you pay for a public service can be permissable simply because people expect some reasonable level of that service. And hence the scandal of realizing the true cost of that service, and the public finding it too expensive can be seen as a story that has two sides, merely because any limits that public may decide to put on the price naturally cause the quality of the service to degrade. But,but if the public isn't the one that decides on the quid pro quo here, who the hell is being served here anyhow??

Surely if its the public that's served by a public agency, then a person who uncovers that the agency is costing us way way more than is known and than it claims - even under oath to the congress for christ's sake - is a desirable correction, for no decision could even be made under false information.

WilliamDhalgren··on Pardon Snowden
Wow. Fine, I'll bite: He is prosecuted for the greatest act of whistleblowing since the pentagon papers. This has enabled improvements in both privacy regulations and accelerated the deployment of strong cryptography across the Internet.

As the Berlin University puts it, he can thus be credited with "extraordinary achievements in defense of transparency, justice and freedom".

Yet despite this, his country of origin has no laws needed to protect him and any future cases of the kind. And what the hell are advesary states? Last I heard the cold war was over...

There is of course no possibility that he'd get a trial, so your morbid fantasy is just that... Again, I'm simply astonished that there are people in the US who could see this act as anything other than utter heroism.

WilliamDhalgren··on Bayer confirms $66bn Monsanto takeover
to be more precise, they can be sold but then need to be labeled. Prob used in animal feedstock, but not attractive to market for human use in that form. I presume animal feed's still a significant market, but unsure if there's significant GMO market penetration there.

Only one GMO (a bt corn I think) could be planted in the EU, and used mostly in Spain, though there's some hope the new rules will enable pro-GMO countries to plant many more in the future (approval process was generally stuck in the Council because enough countries opposed GMOs; now they can just ban them on their own territory w/o preventing pro-GMO countries from using it, and avoiding a conflict is politically attractive).

I personally see it as an ecological gain, due to productivity and so landuse improvements, something europe has basically stagnated at since these bans.

Sad to hear not much chance of improvements in the political sphere on that front..

WilliamDhalgren··on Bayer confirms $66bn Monsanto takeover
any chance this could help the perception of GMOs in Germany then?
WilliamDhalgren··on Marc Andreessen on the atomization of AI
Truly doing much with little data may simply be impossible; its not a magical black box after all, but just as ideal a learner as possible - but if small data cannot give it confidence to confirm the existence of some subtile pattern, on what grounds is even an ideal learner supposed to believe in it?

For example, no smarts would ever confirm the Higgs in the tevatron in its 10 year run even though the machine produced thousands of Higges; its a subtle signal and you just don't have the sample size to be more than 3 sigma sure there's something there (nor where exactly).

What is key, however, is being able to leverage more than just explicit training sets, like with transfer learning and unsupervised learning, as well as making algorithms scale well with more data. The latter seems promising with deep learning, the former still a research thing.

"more data beats better algorithm" is obviously false when the algorithms don't scale with data as well, as deep learning has convincingly demonstrated, being just as mediocre as anything else on small datasets, but being leaps above everything else on sufficiently large ones.

WilliamDhalgren··on Pardon Snowden
It means an extremely opaque system of checks precisely in an area of the state that is particularly succeptable to abuse. That is a real risk to national security here.

Contrary, I can see exactly zero potential for jeopardising national security by any mooderately sane law on whistleblower protection in this area.

All whistleblowing is taking things into one's own hands at the risk of persecution, and here its only more so, given the seriousness of the charges one will face if one's defense on the basis of whistleblower protection ie arguing one acted in the public interest and revealed gross abuse of power fails.

Whatever is at the discretion for the potential leaker to decide, is at that discretion regardless of legal defense opportunities a leaker may have after the fact.

It is simply ludicrous that revealing rampant abuse of power by precisely those tasked with protection of the constitutional order, and precisely at the point where such control is most needed can be a punishable offense in any democracy.

But naturally any such leak needs to be able to stand up in court and satisfy some reasonable criteria of public interest and of having revealed serious violations - nobody is suggesting blatant espionage be legalized ffs.

WilliamDhalgren··on Pardon Snowden
oh no doubt, what was done to him is atrocious and repugnant. I was only trying out an argument that politically his fate is no longer important, and it is of greater value to focus on what will protect the next Snowden better.

It's still clearly a moral imperative to help Snowden.

WilliamDhalgren··on Pardon Snowden
yeah, its what it does for the next Snowden that's most important here-- but that's why I suggested actual legal reform is necessary.

How can a pardon set a precedent? Its an act of an executive, not a court? It would be up to whoever is the president when the next Snowden occurs to grant clemence or no at their total executive discretion, no? So how's that a precedent? And how comforting it would be to the next Snowden that his life is at the whim of the current president to grant or take should he go through with a leak.

Or am I misunderstanding how the US legal system works?

I have to grant you're completely right about the political climate though. No legislative change will happen w/o a wide perception that the party at fault is the NSA here, and Snowden's action heroic and justified and hence worthy of legal protection. And a pardon would help in establishing that.

I'm really amazed how negatively he's percieved in the US apparently.

WilliamDhalgren··on Pardon Snowden
Oh I'm sure they wouldn't. But there is no risk to national security, as whistleblowing protections only apply to uncovering illegal activities, abuse and similar misconduct.

But who'd want one's security apparatus to be incentivised to follow the rules, right?

WilliamDhalgren··on Pardon Snowden
Well, from a political point of view, Snowden is just a guy, and he did what he could do already. Pardoned or shot dead, makes little difference now (well, chilling effect is certainly even worse if the latter happened tomorrow, but its bad enough as it is).

The important thing would be wistleblower protection laws changes that would protect a future Snowden from this situation.

WilliamDhalgren··on Pardon Snowden
can he do that? pardon someone that hasn't been apprehended nor trialed yet?
WilliamDhalgren··on Someone Is Learning How to Take Down the Internet
Agreed, if civilization does come tumbling down. However, as far as I could read, for it to survive a nuclear exchange is quite possible, even probable.

Blasts themselves seem relatively harmless, beyond the hundereds of millions they just outright kill that is, radiation we're just characteristically paranoid about, but can actually deal with at least in many remaining areas, and the main issue at debate is whether a nuclear winter of substantial duration would be formed or not. Which depends on the scope of the fires, so flammability of urban environments and the like. We can't pretend to know a real answer, but its certainly possible.

And then there's the issue of whether the south hemisphere could avoid that fate even in such a case, due to weather patterns, provided there's no detonations there (as there are no weapons there).

Now that doesn't seem substantially different from any large-scale warfare civilization easily survived previously, like world war II; urban devastation and millions of dead. Hardly a civilization-ending event.

WilliamDhalgren··on Someone Is Learning How to Take Down the Internet
but its only relevant in the disaster-recovery situation anyhow; should be quite decent for that use. And otherwise, you have regular Internet access, and its hardly realistic a small hacker community can do anything to replace it.
WilliamDhalgren··on Neglected Food Bubbles: The Espresso Coffee Foam
So if not espresso, what kind of coffee do Americans drink, but that's any good?

I'm just very used to italian-style espresso in the cafés and turkish at home, as that's the cultural norm around here (croatian adriatic coast; basically ex-venetian colony ;) ).

I'd like to give other styles a shot, but only provided they're worth a damn. Can't say I've been impressed by whatever the muck they serve at McDonald's is, or by home drip machines. Nor instant ofc...

WilliamDhalgren··on A Soviet scientist created tame foxes
I don't know the answer, but there was an antisemitic campaign after the war (eg 52' Night of the Murdered Poets, campaign against "rootless cosmopolitans" etc).

Shostakovich Symphony No.13 (Babi Yar) and the poem there used, Yevtushenko's Babiyy Yar was a protest of both soviet antisemitism and the government's refusal to recognise the site as a holocaust location (Jewish identity of the victims being denied; they were generalized as Soviet instead), even in the early 60s.

WilliamDhalgren··on YouTube Community goes beyond video
What's G+ like these days? Used it a few years ago, only social net I gave a serious try, and was really quite fond of it.

Circles were quite a practical way of following topics of interest, w/o having to actually communicate with anyone or disclose anything about myself to anyone (as opposed to "friending" anyone on fb, which notifies the other party as if I actually wanted any interaction with them), and there was quite a lot of say tech folks in various topics to track.

But as a topical news aggregator, there are other options, such as hackernews, reddit, various planets and desktop/console rss/atom aggregators etc, so not a real gain.

Didn't stick to it mainly cuz I'm apparently too introverted for classic friend-to-friend social networking, as I suspected; didn't really have anything to say about anything, and didn't care much to hear about the daily fluff in the lives of acquaintances either.

So what kinds of concepts/services developed and thrived on G+ since google gave up on yt integration?

WilliamDhalgren··on YouTube Community goes beyond video
Why do they need another social network? If it helps youtube users, ofc its a good move. But if its means to an end, to create a social network -- I thought their main motive for having a social net of some kind was to use vote/comment/share signals as additional data to improve search and ad placement, given that those are more informative than which link of the ones offered by search you choose to click.

But they don't need a massive social net just for that, and they have G+. Isn't that enough to do the job?

WilliamDhalgren··on YouTube Community goes beyond video
I'm apparently out of the loop; could you help me: what scandals? what happened?
WilliamDhalgren··on YouTube Community goes beyond video
very good point re blowup. Another thing is that whatever reddit is doing, still doesn't help much to clean up comments on large lightly-moderated subs. Best quality is still a matter of having an army of moderators and tight rules there, like r/science and r/askhistorians (?is that the one? its called something like that anyhow) subs.

Just like with any old primitive forum.

WilliamDhalgren··on YouTube Community goes beyond video
I like this idea, wonder how it scales! on the simple side of things, you can have something like that youtube snob browser extension, that simply hides stuff like all caps, no punctuation etc. Guess you can add more such hand-crafted features..

For something machine learning, well if it'd need to train on your preferences all the way from character-lvl to your preferences, maybe its too expensive to do it for all users.

On the other hand, if it tries to learn just a smallish matrix of general purpose features for everyone (how exactly? to predict votes? or unsupervised?), embedded in the say JSON-LD of each comment, and then just a simple shallow regression model on your history of voting conditioned on that matrix, maybe that can scale?

WilliamDhalgren··on YouTube Community goes beyond video
hmm has anyone tried such global karma that determines default comment ranking? IMHO it could work only if its on something like a logarithmic scale.

Else people that tend to create substantial on-point comments will get swamped with say funny or snarky one-liner producers even worse than now, as those are much easier to digest and, being devoid of opinion, much easier to upvote.

WilliamDhalgren··on Robots Can’t Dance – Why the singularity is greatly exaggerated (2015)
well if intelligence is recognising and extrapolating from regular patterns in your sensorium, surely the AlphaGo system is rather intelligent; even just playing against the search-less pattern subsystems on the version that beat Fan Hui (way weaker than the one we saw in the Lee Sedol match by Google's internal ELO assesment) almost any non-professionals would get crushed. So it clearly learned a great deal from both go game records, and from experience of playing.

But isn't a question of creativity rather different from the matter of intelligence? I'd love to see recommendations on papers that try to formalize creative AI systems -- but I'd expect something with less focus on exploitation and more on exploration than a goal-directed game engine. Maybe using some novelty signals or the like.

The fact that people redefine what AI whenever reached is is a valid point; but that does not mean one should lump all sistems into the same basket.

Something like a pop music composing and light novel/screenplay writing bot at least seems like a doable goal, yes, but it def isn't AlphaGo.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →