163 karma · joined September 28, 2024
People on HN are seriously delusional.
AI removed the need to know the syntax. Your grandma does not know JS but can one shot a React app. Great!
Software engineering is not and has never been about the syntax or one shotting apps. Software engineering is about managing complexity at a level that a layman could not. Your ideal word requires an AI that's capable of reasoning at 100k-1 million lines of code and not make ANY mistakes. All edge cases covered or clarified. If (when) that truly happens, software engineering will not be the first profession to go.
You can't seriously believe laymen will try to implement their own tax calculators.
"Factored" is doing a lot of lifting here and is borderline deceptive. Plenty of researchers have long ago pointed out that this won't scale, see M Mosca for reference.
Every single example you gave is in a hobby project territory. Relatively self-contained, maintainable by 3-4 devs max, within 1k-10k lines of code. I've been successfully using coding agents to create such projects for the past year and it's great, I love it.
However, lots of us here work on codebases that are 100x, 1000x the size of these projects you and Karpathy are talking about. Years of domain specific code. From personal experience, coding agents simply don't work at that scale the same way they do for hobby projects. Over the past year or two, I did not see any significant improvement from any of the newest models.
Building a slightly bigger hobby project is not even close to making these agents work at industrial scale.
In either case, you're primarily either a developer or a scientist/researcher. Unless you're at an early stage startup or in a principal/managerial role, chances are your time is better spent deeply focusing on one area rather than both. Either putting the system to production or doing research. A lot of the time, these tasks can be carried out in parallel -- while one person is carrying out research, the other can be improving the system.
This sounds like a vibe coding side project. And I'm sorry, but whatever he builds will most likely become tech debt that has to be rewritten at some point.
Speaking seriously, they surely meant data races, right? If so, what's preventing me from using C++ atomics to achieve the same thing?