HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

WoodenChair

8,915 karma · joined August 31, 2013

- https://davekopec.com

- https://classicproblems.com

- https://computersciencefromscratch.com

- https://x.com/davekopec

- https://github.com/davecom

I'm a computer science professor at a teaching college with a background in software development. I also build indie apps, have a few entrepreneurial ventures, write technical books, and co-host the podcast Business Books & Co. My latest programming book is "Computer Science from Scratch: Building Interpreters, Art, Emulators and ML in Python" with No Starch Press:

https://nostarch.com/computer-science-from-scratch

If you want to find out about my upcoming book, media, or software projects then join my very low volume newsletter:

https://buttondown.email/kopec

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

submissionscomments
WoodenChair··on Mac Mini G4 – The best « classic » Macintosh for retro-gaming?
I am yet to hear about 1 dying from a customer. But I can't give you a scientific answer to that and I've only been doing this since April. There's a whole community of people doing these upgrades. You can find them at https://macos9lives.com

That's where the hacked Mac OS 9 comes from and there are threads about Mac mini SSDs. There are also threads at https://68kmla.org

I would ask there.

WoodenChair··on Mac Mini G4 – The best « classic » Macintosh for retro-gaming?
This is a great comprehensive article on the "why" and there are good YouTube videos on the "how." What the article is missing that makes it even better is putting an SSD in which makes it even faster of course. You can get an untested Mac mini G4 for about $60 on eBay and the rest of the parts (SSD, PATA-mSATA adapter, RAM if less than 1 GB, power adapter, any missing screws, clock battery, etc.) will run you another $60 to make the ultimate Mac OS 9 machine. If you're comfortable taking things apart and putting them back together it's not too bad.

A quick tip: be sure to reset the PRAM with command-alt-p-r holding down during restart until you hear 3 chimes. Then while the machine is booting hold down command-alt-o-f and type "reset-nvram" and then "set-defaults" and then "reset-all" (all of this is in open firmware) before installing Mac OS 9 to make sure firmware is in its original state.

I came across this idea of SSD upgrading and installing Mac OS 9 in April 2024 and bought three broken ones to build one for my son. [0] When the first one worked, I ended up figuring, why not just finish the other two and sell them on eBay?

That led me into a hobby business. I've now cleaned, upgraded with SSDs, and sold about 70 of them. The "business" basically breaks even, so it truly is a hobby. In fact I invested so much in inventory buying 90 of them in a lot at the end of 2024 that I am negative right now. I will probably turn a slight profit in 2025. But it's fun and if you want you can buy one from me at: https://os9.shop

Sorry for the self-promotion, but very relevant!

0: https://x.com/davekopec/status/1795872492386398683

WoodenChair··on Ask HN: Books about people who did hard things
Yeah it's a great book. It definitely gets into the weeds about his family and personal life (as a comprehensive biography should). Personally, I enjoyed that stuff, but if you just want to learn about how he did hard stuff as the OP described, it may be a bit thick at 600+ pages. That said, we summarized it in discussion form on our podcast if anyone is interested: http://businessbooksandco.com/episode/7b5d6ab9/titan-the-lif...
WoodenChair··on Python Concurrency: Threads, Processes, and Asyncio Explained
> Surprising to some, this is the literal definition.

I don't think it's surprising to anyone that speaks English what the definition of concurrency in everyday language is. It is not the same as the computer science definition and that's unlikely to change anytime soon. Can anyone with permission fix the Python wiki?

WoodenChair··on Python Concurrency: Threads, Processes, and Asyncio Explained
Unfortunately this starts with a definition of concurrency quoted from the Python wiki [0] which is imprecise: "Concurrency in programming means that multiple computations happen at the same time."

Not necessarily. It means multiple computations could happen at the same time. Wikipedia has a broader definition [1]: "Concurrency refers to the ability of a system to execute multiple tasks through simultaneous execution or time-sharing (context switching), sharing resources and managing interactions."

In other words it could be at the same time or it could be context switching (quickly changing from one to another). Parallel [2] means explicitly at the same time: "Parallel computing is a type of computation in which many calculations or processes are carried out simultaneously."

0: https://wiki.python.org/moin/Concurrency

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concurrency_(computer_science)

2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_computing

WoodenChair··on The legacy of NeXT lives on in OS X (2012)
The high price was also justified by the success of WebObjects at the time, which was seen as a potential fuel for an IPO for NeXT, even though WebObjects was not what Apple was buying it for. This Computer History Museum article goes into that angle in detail: https://computerhistory.org/blog/next-steve-jobs-dot-com-ipo...
WoodenChair··on Ask HN: Does retro computing make you feel younger or older?
It's not really that the computer itself is retro, it's that people use it for retro computing because it's pretty much the fastest Mac you can get that can still run Mac OS 9 (1999). People then run games and apps from systems 1-9. So people buy this computer from 2005 to run an operating system from 1999 to run apps from 1984 to 1999.
WoodenChair··on Ask HN: Does retro computing make you feel younger or older?
I think I can speak to this a bit since I run a hobby business[0] selling restored Mac mini G4s (originally from 2005) with a hacked version of Mac OS 9 on them from Mac OS 9 Lives so that retro computer users (people still using production software for Mac OS 9) can have the fastest possible machine to run classic Mac OS. After selling more than 60 of them, my customers (from what I can tell) are largely in five categories:

- People doing this for their kids so the kids can use the software of their parent's youth (my own motivation that led me to fall into this [1])

- People doing this for work (still using old music production software for example)

- People doing this because they care about historical software (had a couple museum curators buy one)

- People who are tinkerers but want to tinker with software not hardware so they buy from me

- Retro gamers

In all of these cases I don't think it's really about feeling old or young. It's just about doing something that they perceive as better than they can achieve on a modern machine. And by "better" I mean better to them. Not objectively better. They just love those games from the 90s. Or they just think that the educational software back then was less addictive/better for their kids than the software today.

Sure, if we think about anything from our distant past it can make us feel old. But I think it's more that this hobby (or work) actually serves a purpose for these customers and they don't think along the old/young axis.

0: https://os9.shop 1: https://x.com/davekopec/status/1780032912768770448

WoodenChair··on Chocolate intake and risk of type 2 diabetes: prospective cohort studies
> Dark chocolate often has very high sugar levels.

Milk chocolate usually has higher sugar levels than dark chocolate.

WoodenChair··on Bitcoin surges past $100k for first time
> The “store of value” functionality has completely eclipsed the practical use that Bitcoin maxis were preaching back then.

Right, but that use case could be enough to see the price continue to increase. Gold is also generally used as a store of value. The average person hasn't been going into a store using gold to buy things in the US in more than 100 years. But gold's market cap (~ $17T) is still greater than Bitcoin (~$2T). So, if Bitcoin is a better store of value than gold (debatable), then the price still has plenty of room to grow.

WoodenChair··on Intel announces retirement of Pat Gelsinger
How do you know this?
WoodenChair··on $8k Suzuki from India received a 5-star crash test rating
> You don't say. And maybe it would look a little less greedy if that dividend were slightly smaller, but you guys make them sell the Ford Fiesta in the US instead?

What do you mean "you guys make them." Individual tiny shareholders have 0 ability to change what a company sells.

Also, why pick on Ford? It is one of the smallest of the "large" car manufacturers. As I mentioned in my original comment it's a fraction of the size of Toyota and Tesla in market cap. It has deliberately chosen a niche—trucks and SUVs—to survive. In my opinion, it does not have the brand, marketing, or research and development muscle to compete with Toyota, Nissan, Hyundai, or Honda in the small sedan market and rightly exited it. Few in the USA thought Ford was making good small sedans in the late 2010s compared to their rivals, hence why consumers stopped choosing them and Ford stopped selling them.

> But nobody knows, since Ford doesn't sell cars for poor people anymore, not even the cars it makes in large numbers anyway.

As is stated in this thread, across all manufacturers, the cheapest car sold today in the US is about $20K (Nissan Versa). Ford sells the Maverick pickup for $24K and the Escape SUV for $30K. It chooses not to compete at the very lowest tier of the US market and no longer manufactures any small cars like the Fiesta in the US.

Is it Ford's responsibility to compete at every segment of the market? Or is it okay that they are specializing in trucks and SUVs where they have some competitive advantage and letting other manufacturers like Nissan have the small car market?

WoodenChair··on $8k Suzuki from India received a 5-star crash test rating
> I don't want to keep funding Ford and GM shareholder greed.

As a long suffering Ford stockholder, I'd like to understand what you mean by "shareholder greed." Go look at a 30 year chart of their stock price. It's barely changed. They do have a nice dividend. The company's PE ratio is appropriate for a very very mature industrial stock. Its market cap is $43 billion. That's about 20% of Toyota and 4% of Tesla.

Who are these greedy shareholders and why are they managing to extract so little value out of the company despite being so greedy?

WoodenChair··on Show HN: I Wrote a Book on Java
Manning let me conduct an interview with Brian a few years ago for my book with them. Here is the transcript: https://freecontent.manning.com/interview-with-brian-goetz/

He was very generous with his time and there are some good insights there for aspiring developers, as well as some info about the evolution of Java which may be relevant to the more data-oriented features that have been added in recent times.

WoodenChair··on Tinygrad will be the next Linux and LLVM
> While there may be a legacy Linux running in a VM to manage all your cloud phoning spyware, the core functionality of the lifelike device is boot to neural network.

No, I do not think future devices will be "boot to neural network." Traditional algorithms still have a place. Your robot vacuum cleaner (his example) may still use A* to route plan, and Quicksort to display your cleanings in terms of most energy usage.

> Without CPUs, we can be freed from the tyranny of the halting problem.

Not sure what this means but I think it still makes sense to have a CPU directing things as in current architectures. You don't just have your neural engine, you also have your GPU, Audio system, input devices, etc. and those need a controller. Something needs to coordinate.

WoodenChair··on Working in the office 5 days/week to build company culture is a myth: PwC report
> To draw this conclusion one would have to assume that companies are measuring productivity correctly. Or that the companies are acting rationally, and we know that's never always true.

So is your argument that bad management is so endemic that every company is making a poor decision about its productivity when it orders workers back to the office? I think some companies want to do soft layoffs. And I think others actually see real benefits of working in-person.

We don't have to take such extreme positions. Doubtless some people are more productive at-home, some people are less productive at-home. And some companies are actually seeing productivity decreases when their teams are remote.

WoodenChair··on Working in the office 5 days/week to build company culture is a myth: PwC report
Are you actually going to reply to the substance of my comment or just do a Reddit like sarcastic reply? Yes, I am middle age and have worked for multiple companies. I've seen co-workers, friends, and even family abuse the opportunity to work from home. Which as I said is unfortunate because it hurts everyone who uses it wisely.

Show me or gp that there is no evidence of abuse. Anecdotally, I've seen it.

WoodenChair··on Working in the office 5 days/week to build company culture is a myth: PwC report
Anecdotally, knowing many people that work from home, there is definitely abuse of the system. And those people are ruining it for the rest of us! But it would be absurd to think that if everyone was really more productive at-home, companies would still be forcing everyone back in the office. I don't believe the conspiracies—most workplaces really do want collaboration and productivity. The only bit I'll buy is that some are doing it as a form of soft layoffs. But I find it hard to believe that every company doing this would act against its own interests in terms of productivity.
WoodenChair··on Thoughts and Observations in the Wake of Apple's 'It's Glowtime' Keynote
Yes, he’s what I’ve termed an Apple apologist: https://www.observationalhazard.com/2021/08/apple-apologetic...
WoodenChair··on The PERQ Computer
Can someone who used one comment on what GUI elements were actually in a PERQ?

I see windows and bitmap graphics in the screenshots I can find.

But I don't see menus, a desktop, standardized buttons, scroll bars, etc. In other words I don't see the hallmarks of the Xerox Star, Apple Lisa, and Macintosh. It looks influenced by the Xerox products but not as advanced.

WoodenChair··on 1M Users
Whatever you think of the site itself, this is prime HN content. A kid in high school starts a site that scales to 1,000,000 registered users while working on it during nights and weekends in college. If the founder is on here, what tech stack did you use and how long had you been programming before you built it?
WoodenChair··on AnandTech Farewell
Any other sites folks would recommend? It doesn't look to me like the sites mentioned have the same mix of stories as Anand would have covered. I'd like something that's really in the same vein.
WoodenChair··on Ask HN: Looking for kids books about famous people
My son liked this book on Thomas Edison: https://amzn.to/4cxwCJC

It takes a "misfit proves everyone wrong" angle. He was 3 though when we read it. Maybe a little basic for a 6 year old.

WoodenChair··on The Apple IIGS Megahertz Myth
> Yeah, but Apple didn’t care about WebObjects; it needed an operating system.

I never said Apple bought NeXT for WebObjects. I said that NeXT had value outside of the deal in the marketplace because WebOjects was starting to get traction.

WoodenChair··on The Apple IIGS Megahertz Myth
> No. That's what you are doing. Apple didn't buy Next for 400 million $ to get their hands on 'WebObjects'. In fact that played very little role.

I never said Apple bought NeXT for WebObjects. I said that NeXT had value outside of the deal in the marketplace because WebOjects was starting to get traction.

In fact, NeXT was planning to IPO into the .com craze on the strength of WebObjects. Here's a whole Computer History Museum article about that: https://computerhistory.org/blog/next-steve-jobs-dot-com-ipo...

WoodenChair··on The Apple IIGS Megahertz Myth
> The reality is the most proprietary software companies of that area didn't make.

You're using 20/20 hindsight instead of putting yourself in the shoes of someone in 1996. The term "open source" was not even in wide use in 1996.

But actually even with hindsight your analysis is flawed. 1996 is right at the start of the .com bubble. A company whose software (WebOjects) was being used to power real world .coms (it was even being used by large companies like UPS and Dell) almost certainly would have risen tremendously in value (even as a private company). Now, if they would have been acquired before the 2000 crash is another discussion.

WoodenChair··on The Apple IIGS Megahertz Myth
It’s about how much money did it take for them to want to sell instead of continue as an independent business. In 1996 WebObjects was starting to get traction. After a decade it seemed like there was perhaps a viable future for the company.
WoodenChair··on Intel 18A Status Update: First Chips Booting, First Customer Tape-Out in H1'25
The difference this time is that they have already shipped or are in the process of shipping products on new nodes (Intel 4, Intel 3) in a relatively short period of time whereas before the 10 nm node they were stuck on 14 nm forever. So they’re executing on new nodes.

Whether they will continue and whether it will be any good is another question but it’s hard to argue the current situation parallels 2017. There’s been demonstrated progress, government money, and new leadership.

WoodenChair··on On Front Porch Forum, politics is fair game but unkindness is prohibited
I live in Vermont and use Front Porch Forum (FPF). Here are three observations that I think are important that the article misses:

1. FPF is primarily used via email. You get an email newsletter each day with the latest posts, sometimes multiple times a day. In essence it's just many glorified local mailing lists. Email is universal and mailing lists have been around forever. But what the FPF founders did effectively is organize, manage, moderate and create mailing lists for every local neighborhood in the state and then advertise them to people. Not an easy task and not a bad idea—but it doesn't require anywhere near the infrastructure of a FB or Twitter nor offer anywhere near the features.

2. FPF has a "beg for money" business model. They charge very high advertising rates and then every few months they send out emails about how they don't have enough funding to meet their needs and ask for donations. They're a for-profit company that constantly asks for donations. They even have a donate link [0] right on the bottom of their home page. That really turns me off from them. Sometimes they use the word "subscription" but other times they call it "donations." If it was truly a subscription, they wouldn't accept one-time donations, which they do.

They seem to think of themselves as a community service and consider themselves essential to the Vermont conversation, despite also being a for-profit company. I think if they want to have a donation model and be considered critical rural communication glue they should become a non-profit and open source their software.

3. The Washington Post article's premise that important political conversations are happening on FPF I'm sure is true but I think really depends on which community you live in. This is not really one-social network, but instead thousands of mini-social networks (each little local mailing list has its own vibe). In my neighborhood the more substantive political conversations happen on the less moderated Facebook group. Nextdoor was just introduced here a couple years ago and seems to continue to be growing. I suspect over time, with its much greater feature set, it may really challenge FPF.

[0] https://frontporchforum.com/supporting-members

Overall, it's a good service. Every neighborhood should have a well-organized email list. But let's not pretend this is a Facebook competitor.

WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
Sorry to hear that. Remember your site from 15 years ago when I was an intern trying to figure out where to eat.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →