HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

WoodenChair

8,915 karma · joined August 31, 2013

- https://davekopec.com

- https://classicproblems.com

- https://computersciencefromscratch.com

- https://x.com/davekopec

- https://github.com/davecom

I'm a computer science professor at a teaching college with a background in software development. I also build indie apps, have a few entrepreneurial ventures, write technical books, and co-host the podcast Business Books & Co. My latest programming book is "Computer Science from Scratch: Building Interpreters, Art, Emulators and ML in Python" with No Starch Press:

https://nostarch.com/computer-science-from-scratch

If you want to find out about my upcoming book, media, or software projects then join my very low volume newsletter:

https://buttondown.email/kopec

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

submissionscomments
WoodenChair··on Intel to lay off 15,000 employees
He's been in the job roughly 3.5 years. A turnaround that involves building multibillion dollar fab facilities takes longer than that. Many of the problems he is currently dealing with are still leftovers from the prior decade+ of mismanagement. I judge him on two things:

- Whether they execute successfully on the five nodes in four years

- Whether foundry is the right strategy and they successfully lure high profile customers with the opportunity to grow foundry into something that rivals TSMC and Samsung

We will know the answers to both of these by next year. But change horses now when neither question is answered yet? No, I wouldn't do that. Especially after the prior decade of constant CEO turbulence.

WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
Author here—seems they noticed that people were unhappy. Just got this email from Yelp (August 1, 2024):

> Earlier this month, we sent you an email about your Yelp Fusion API usage. That email gave developers until July 23rd to contact us if they want to continue using Yelp’s data for use in their app. We realize you might need more time and are extending your free access for an additional 90 days starting today. Your access should be available now.

> We’re sorry for any inconvenience or frustration this abbreviated transition might have caused. Please respond to this email or contact us at api@yelp.com if you have any questions.

WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
Exactly, we're not. We're closing our products. They are perfectly welcome to charge too high a price for us. They just should've communicated it better.
WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
There should have been an email months ago saying they were converting their API to be paid. Not a 4-day threat to shutoff your API key or pay-up. As I mentioned in my post, I was not aware that they were converting to a paid program and had received no prior emails.
WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
> I'd say, no you had no shared customers.

Person pays for my app. That was a customer.

Person who paid for my app also later uses the Yelp website via a link for a specific review from my app. Also a customer.

Therefore shared customers.

> Sure you had some kind of informal permission at first.

I don't know why you would define it as informal. They had an official review process for deciding what apps to grant higher daily API limits. My app went through that review process 10 years ago including considering its functionality, screenshots, and I believe I even sent them a prototype back then. We had a few emails back and forth to confirm my intentions to only develop for the Mac and what I was building.

I'm sure that got lost in the corporate shuffle over 10 years but I clearly had their permission to build the app and in fact given the relatively high API limit they gave (25000 per day versus the free at that time 10 years ago I think being 1000 per month), arguably blessing.

WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
No, it's $10 per thousand on average (you get 1,000 calls per day) with a $299/month minimum commitment by my reading.
WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
Yes, for sure. Some people explain it away as "well if you buy Wrangler jeans from Walmart and there's something wrong with them you ask Walmart for a refund." So if you buy X's app from Apple you ask Apple for a refund. That kind of makes sense. But if Wrangler does a recall, they have a way of getting that across to their customers.
WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
It seems to be mostly a US phenomenon. As I pointed out in the post almost all of Restaurants sales were to the US. The directory is very up-to-date with active reviews everywhere that I've travelled in this country.
WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
The prices in the deck they shared with me are on slide 3 if anyone is interested: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Cb_8laDpxZdfwJPtYBmibZgvLZ8...

They never answered my question about the discrepancy between these prices and the prices on their website. Both would be too high to make Restaurants low sales sustainable.

That said, I'll say again that they were perfectly in their right to start charging for their API. They just should not have done so with 4-days notice and with such a threatening email.

WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
Author here. I actually discovered something in their terms of use today while looking up something else that someone had asked me in this thread:

"2. CHANGES Yelp reserves the right to modify the API Agreement at any time. If Yelp reasonably determines that a modification may materially and adversely impact You, Yelp will provide email notice to you using the email address you provided during registration no less than ten (10) days prior to the material adverse modification taking affect. IF YOU DO NOT WISH TO BE BOUND TO ANY NEW OR MODIFIED TERMS, YOU MUST TERMINATE THE API AGREEMENT BY CEASING USE OF THE API WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS OF RECEIPT OF SUCH NOTICE."

So, the 4-days would have violated their original notification terms of use anyway. I think they realized this after the fact of sending all of us the threatening emails and this is why they ultimately closed my API key after 10-days as described in my original post.

Anyway, just an interesting aside that the poorly written, inaccurate original email that I shared in my original post was even inaccurate to their own policies.

WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
On the Yelp developer site you have an app profile where there is the name and description of the app. There is also a separate field for the URL of the app website, which I did have filled in. So, they have that at a minimum. If they didn't retain the records of the screenshots/communications that led to the original approval and raise of the API daily limit then that is poor recording keeping but understandable in a corporate environment after 10 years.
WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
Right, they never answered my questions about the discrepancy between that and the pricing deck they specifically sent me for my app. See slide 3 with a $229 per month base price: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Cb_8laDpxZdfwJPtYBmibZgvLZ8...

The economics of Restaurants actually mean it wouldn't be profitable either way though. That's how low the sales are.

They're welcome to start charging for their API whatever they want, but they should give more than 4-days (Friday->Monday, 1 business day) notice.

WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
Yelp has an API dashboard where you can see how many API calls have been made. I can tell you it was never exceeding 200 calls per day and often below 100.
WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
Yes, definitely based on other people in this thread getting the same letter. It was an inaccurate and threatening form letter bizarrely sent from a personal email address of a Yelp employee with another personal email address CCed.
WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
I sold 467 copies over 10 years for less than $5 per copy. It's about $2000 in revenue. Surely not a good use of my time. But I liked the app and so did its few users. We should build things we want to use ourselves right? I think it was a much nicer and faster frontend to the Yelp restaurant directory than the Yelp website.

Your other question about the cost is answered in the blog post and in several other comments I have left in this thread. In short, when I started the app 10 years ago there was no paid API (perhaps there was some kind of "enterprise" version but I'm not sure). The point of my post is how poorly they handled the transition from free->paid.

WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
> Either way. they should've had the cost of the API in their budget.

There was no cost to the API ten years ago. I submitted a prototype of my app to their developer program, described its functionality and exchanged a few emails back and forth with someone in developer relations. They specifically approved it and decided how many API calls to give me. A paid API didn't exist back then to my knowledge (perhaps there was some kind of enterprise API but I don't know?). The point of the post is how badly Yelp handled the transition from free to paid. They are perfectly in their right to transition to paid. But they should've handled the emails and transition better.

As mentioned in the post I developed the app on a whim. But after 10 years, it had a few users, although not many. They and I should have received more than a few days notice from Yelp that the API was going to become unsustainable (see my comments elsewhere in this thread).

WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
Oh thank you for that clarification. That's very interesting, but of course it is not worth it to me to pursue for the reasons mentioned in the post and the comments here on HN.
WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
Thank you. It's actually just a couple users who have posted multiple negative comments in this thread like gp. Not sure what nerve my blog post hit with them but they are free to not like it! It seems like they're more upset about my blog post than I am about the actual situation.
WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
> Developing an app to use someone's free API is not an exchange of consideration.

I would never pursue anything further over this app that had about $2,000 of revenue over 10 years. That said, for the record there was consideration.

I had to go through an official approval process that required providing evidence of the app's functionality and a few emails back and forth. I think I actually sent them a prototype of it. And based on that process they decided how many daily API calls to give me. A normal free user did not receive 25,000 API calls per day. I believe if you didn't go through approval back then you got something like 1,000 per month. So there was a consideration process on their part and a determination to green light my use case.

WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
> He did get through to the sales rep. The responses are directly in the article. The sales rep responded within hours and showed him how to sign up for the free trial option to extend the free usage period longer while he decided.

> What more would you want the rep to do?

Not send a threatening, inaccurate email with a 4-day (1 business day Friday->Monday) deadline in the first place?

Also for the record, this was not a sales manager. This was someone in "growth" that sent the email. I guess maybe that just means "sales."

WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
> I don't understand. Are you saying that even if it did make financial sense, you would have voluntarily shut the app down in protest of the 4-day notice period? Even though the sales rep pointed you toward the free trial option to continue using the API beyond the 4 days while you decided?

An app that sold 467 copies over 10 years at less than $5 a copy is not worth the trouble of dealing with a company that gives you Friday->Monday ultimatums. Obviously, if it were a big source of my income I would have to seriously consider it. But luckily, it's not. I discussed this in the "Development Ends" section of the post. Here is the pricing deck they sent me: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Cb_8laDpxZdfwJPtYBmibZgvLZ8...

It seems to indicate a $229 base monthly price on the third slide for my use case.

> I know you're angry and want us all to be angry at Yelp too, but I have a difficult time believing that anyone would choose to destroy a profitable application out of protest just to stick it to the company.

I'm sorry you're reading so much anger in my post. I thought my blog post was pretty balanced. The worst I called them is "quite rude" (I think it's hard to read their emails otherwise) and spent the first half of it describing my app. I never expressed much emotion in my post, and frankly as mentioned above it really doesn't matter in the scheme of things for my life. What I do want is Yelp to change the way it treats developers. Perhaps if someone there reads this it will cause a tiny reflection on their part. I also hope the experience here expressed in the "Lessons Learned" section of the post is useful to other indie developers.

WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
> So I know we're supposed to be angry about the 4 days thing. It's not good, obviously. However, I don't think it actually changes the situation at all if he wasn't going to sign up anyway.

As I said in the post and comments here if it made financial sense and they gave me a more reasonable deadline with a less threatening email I would be willing to pay for the API. In this case it didn't make financial sense, so you're right at the current API prices it wouldn't make sense even with 6 months-notice.

That said, 6-months (your suggested time period) is a much better grace period for our shared users (users of Restaurants who use it as a frontend and continue to read more reviews at Yelp.com) and much more likely to make me convert to a paid API customer if it had made financial sense.

WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
> If you don't want to deal with the slightest inconvenience don't run a business and don't take money from customers. You owe it to your users to care at least a bit.

I did care "at least a bit" which is why I kept updating the app for 10-years despite it not making almost any money. How many indie apps survive that long? But based on the pricing they quoted me it would be a money-losing venture to continue (see slide 3 base monthly fee $229 from the deck they sent me): https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Cb_8laDpxZdfwJPtYBmibZgvLZ8...

And we have to decide what we work on when we are just one person. If it's money-losing and they don't treat you well it might not make sense to keep doing it.

That said, as I expressed in the blog post I do feel really bad for any of the users that bought the app and I want all of them to get a refund from Apple as explained in the post. They can use these directions: https://support.apple.com/en-us/118223

WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
> Btw, I'm pretty sure what happened was that this conversion was planned and carried out, but nobody was assigned the responsibility to tell developers. It was clearly done last minute using the most convenient form.

Right, the biggest thing is a failure of communication. There should have been emails months ago, not 4-days (1 business day Friday->Monday) before.

WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
Thanks—yeah I actually think they mostly just didn't read the whole post since I addressed this in detail in the last two bold sections "Development Ends" and "Lessons Learned."
WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
Yes, this was surely somewhat tied to employee turnover and poor record keeping. But I was almost certainly not one of the "biggest API users."

The thing is, regardless of the turnover or situation, 4-days (actually 1-business day Friday->Monday) is not a reasonable timeframe to threaten to shutoff someone's API key who hasn't violated any terms of service. They have the right to do it, but it doesn't make you want to work with them in the future.

WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
Thank you. Yup that was the main thing people liked about it. It was really fast and had no ads.
WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
I did respond with the required information and they still shut down my access (10-days post though, not 4-days in the end). But regardless, no, I don't think sending you a request on a Friday for information due on a Monday or shutting down all of your access is reasonable. As I mentioned in my post, what if I had been on vacation? 1-business day or shut you down is just not a reasonable time frame to make anyone want to work with you in the future.
WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
Right I don't mean legally. I mean in terms of making people want to continue to work with them.
WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
It's just not worth it. I have a full-time job and many other projects and apps I am supporting. I don't want to work with a company that provides long-term API users 4-days notice about a major change and threatens to cut you off in that time period. As you saw in the blog post I did write back to them and did not get any kind of response indicating flexibility (did you read my whole post?).

Also, the money is very very low stakes. This app sells dozens of copies a year. Not hundreds or thousands. It's just not worth it financially. It sold 467 copies over 10 years. People who used it loved it, but it's not a money maker.

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →