HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

YeGoblynQueenne

24,944 karma · joined September 26, 2015

This a common question on this board:

What is reasoning?

In computer science and AI when we say "reasoning" we mean that we have a theory and we can derive the consequences of the theory by application of some inference procedure.

A theory is a set of facts and rules about some environment of interest: the real world, mathematics, language, etc. Facts are things we know (or assume) to be true: they can be direct observations, or implied, guesses. Rules are conditionally true and so most easily understood as implications: if we know some facts are true we can conclude that some other facts must also be true. An inference procedure is some system of rules, separate from the theory, that tells us how we can combine the rules and facts of the theory to squeeze out new facts, or new rules.

There are three types of reasoning, what we may call modes of inference: deduction, induction and abduction. Informally, deduction means that we start with a set of rules and derive new unobserved facts, implied by the rules; induction means that we start with a set of rules and some observations and derive new rules that imply the observations; and abduction means that we start with some rules and some observations and derive new unobserved facts that imply the observations.

It's easier to understand all this with examples.

One example of deductive reasoning is planning, or automated planning and scheduling, a field of classical AI research. Planning is the "model-based approach to autonomous behaviour", according to the textbook on planning by Geffner and Bonnet. An autonomous agent starts with a "model" that describes the environment in which the agent is to operate as a set of entities with discrete states, and a set of actions that the agent can take to change those states. The agent is given a goal, an instance of its model, and it must find a sequence of actions, that we call a "plan", to take the entities in the model from their current state to the state in the goal. This is usually achieved by casting the planning problem as pathfinding over a graph with a search algorithm like A*. Here, the agent's model is a theory, the search algorithm is the inference procedure, and the plan is a consequence of the theory. Deductive reasoning can be sound, as long as the facts and rules in the theory are correct: from correct premises we can deduce correct conclusions. We know of sound deductive inference rules, e.g. A*, and Resolution, used in automated theorem proving and SAT-Solving, are sound.

The classic example of inductive reasoning is inferring the colour of swans. Most swans are white (apparently) so if we have only seen white swans we have no reason to believe there are any other colours: we are forced to infer that all swans are white. We may only be disabused of our fallacy if we happen to observe a swan that is not white, e.g. a black swan. But who is to say when such a magnificent creature will grace us with its presence, outside of Tchaikovsky's ballets? Induction is thus revealed to be unsound: even given true premises we can still arrive at the wrong conclusions. Another example is the scientific method: imagine an idealised scientist, perfectly spherical, in a frictionless vacuum. She starts with a scientific theory, then goes out into the world and makes new observations about a phenomenon not described by her theory. She constructs a hypothesis to extend her theory so as to explain the new observations. The hypothesis is a set of rules, where the premises are the consequences of the rules in her initial theory. Then, being an idealised scientist, she goes looking for new observations to refute her hypothesis. Science only gives us the tools to know when we're wrong.

Abductive reasoning is the mode of inference exemplified by Sherlock Holmes. We can imagine Sherlock and Watson standing outside a tavern in London, watching as a gentleman of interest steps out of the tavern with egg on his lapel. "Ah, my dear Watson, what can we conclude from this observation?". "Why my dear Holmes, we can conclude that the man had eggs for breakfast". Holmes and Watson can arrive at this conclusion, about a fact that they have not directly observed, because they have a theory with a rule that says "if one eats eggs, one may get some on one's lapels". Working backwards from this rule, and their observation of egg on the man's lapels, they can guess that he had eggs even if they didn't directly observe him doing so. Abduction is also unsound: the man may have swapped coats with an accomplice, who was the one who had eggs for breakfast instead.

And now you know what "reasoning" means. So the next time someone asks: "what is reasoning?", you can let them know and turn the discussion to more interesting, more productive directions.

submissionscomments
YeGoblynQueenne··on I flagged two research papers for fake authors and both were accepted as orals
That's right. At least there's reporting in the lay press which can cause a scandal and that may finally convince Cambridge to do something, although I'm not holding my breath.
YeGoblynQueenne··on Gemini Robotics 2 brings whole body intelligence to robots
At this point the bitter lesson has become a meaningless shibboleth. It seems very few people have actually read the original article:

The Bitter Lesson Rich Sutton March 13, 2019

http://www.incompleteideas.net/IncIdeas/BitterLesson.html

And even fewer are aware of the author's follow up on what his article says about the current trend in AI:

Silicon Valley Doesn't Understand The Bitter Lesson – Richard Sutton

https://youtu.be/QMGy6WY2hlM?si=0aOmgKiPfGEEXoK9

YeGoblynQueenne··on Gemini Robotics 2 brings whole body intelligence to robots
Yeah, look carefully at that demo of tying the garbage bag strings: it's done in a very peculiar style that suggests a very specific, very precise, "algorithm" taught in an imitation learning session, which has no chance to transfer to other tasks, or even other garbage bag strings.

As usual with robot tech demos: WYSIWYG.

YeGoblynQueenne··on Gemini Robotics 2 brings whole body intelligence to robots
Sounds great if you want to research, what DeepMind wants you to research; but that's not great if you want to go down the untrodden path where all the true innovation has the (very slim) chance to happen.
YeGoblynQueenne··on Gemini Robotics 2 brings whole body intelligence to robots
No, the above is absolutely exactly true. Robots folding clothes and tying shoelaces etc is nothing but a tech demo at this point.

It's difficult to grok this because if you watch a human folding a t-shirt, you can reliably predict that the same human will fold a different t-shirt just as well, and in fact be perfectly capable of folding a wide variety of other clothes items as well. Not so for robots. With robots, what you see is precisely what you get. If you see a robot folding a t-shirt, all that means is that that particular robot can fold that particular t-shirt. The state of the art today is that the same robot cannot be expected to be able to fold a different t-shirt.

For example, see this article about Mobile ALOHA at Google. There's a passage where the visiting, awe-struck, journalist asks whether the robot he's just seen tying up a pair of shoelaces can tie up his own shoe.

“If I gave it my shoe,” I ventured, “would it just totally fail?”

“We could try,” Tompson said. I removed my right sneaker, with apologies to anyone forced to handle it. Tompson gamely placed it on the table, while Driess reloaded the policy.

“To set expectations,” Driess said, “this is a task that is thought of as being impossible.”

Tompson eyed his new experimental subject with some trepidation. “Very short shoelaces,” he said.

The policy booted up, and the claws set to work. This time, they poked at the shoelace without getting a grip. “Do you give consent for your shoe to be destroyed?” Driess joked, as the hands grabbed at the tongue. Tompson let them try for a few more seconds before hitting the Failure pedal.

https://archive.ph/CiJJG#selection-1887.0-1915.291

(Original: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2024/12/02/a-revolution-i...)

As to ACT-2 which basically uses the same techniques as ALOHA (imitation learning) far as I can tell, that's a commercial product and the information they give on their site is difficult to parse. E.g. they say they have 99.1% ±0.3 success rate, 778 successful folds and 9 garment types which is low enough to engender some trust they're not trying to inflate their numbers, but they don't say whether they trained on the garments used in evaluation or not. Chances are they did, because that's the current limit of the technology, i.e. if the garment being folded is unseen (as opposed to the environment, which they tout) then performance is basically random. So either ACT-2 have a major breakthrough that is a few leaps and bounds away from the current state of the art, or you've just watched a tech demo.

The fact that they only advertise "9 garment types" though is a big hint: they have the same problem with generalisation as everybody else at this point in time.

YeGoblynQueenne··on Gemini Robotics 2 brings whole body intelligence to robots
I think that's not a bad point but it ignores the different safety standards that most people accept when it comes to a) driving and b) their toddlers. Like a household appliance that kills 20-40k toddlers every year would be a major scandal, but it's OK for automobiles.
YeGoblynQueenne··on Gemini Robotics 2 brings whole body intelligence to robots
I don't think that there's any inherent difficulty to do with physical bodies, it's just that the learning techniques used by the big labs, that is to say, various forms of Reinforcement Learning, don't transfer to the real world. Because in the real world if you try stuff at random until you figure out the right policy, you end up destroying too many robot bodies. Imitation learning that went wild a couple years ago with ALOHA looks like a great way to get around this on paper, but then you realise that you have to train your robot for hours on every single task you want it to perform and it still won't generalise even between similar tasks. The sim-2-real gap also remains a big obstacle and you can't just train in simulation and transfer to the real world seamlessly; and then the seams end up being more like chasms.

Then there's the problem of generalisation. RL is insane in figuring out the dynamics of any arbitrary environment you drop it in at any time. Unfortunately once you have a policy trained in one environment (or one task) you have to train again for the next environment (or task) you want to deal with. The number of different environments, situations or tasks in the real world ends up being overwhelmingly large.

So for example DeepMind has been trying for ever to train various robots to do stuff like grasp arbitrary objects by training in the real world or in simulation and still grasping is an unsolved problem, in the general case; and in fact in most cases.

With LLMs it was different in that there was a www of text to train on and the stakes are lower because there's no sim-2-real gap and there's no need to deal with the real world, in training or deployment, it's just text on a screen. That's very hard to replicate in robotics.

There are major breakthroughs still to be made and they aren't currently even on the horizon. And no, I don't have the answer with my super secrete robotic AGI homebrew project either, just saying :P

YeGoblynQueenne··on AI's top startups are barely publishing their research
>> That said I'm unclear how safe direct exposure to the pigment itself is (such as when suspended in a liquid for painting). There's not a lot of data available that I could find, and of course due to having a unique crystalline structure it won't necessarily have the same properties as the component products, however cobalt(II) oxide itself is extremely hazardous which is at least cause to be cautious.

The consensus is that artists' colours are hazardous waste that needs safe disposal. You can find instructions how to do that in many arts supplies' sellers sites and the like, for example one I've used:

https://www.jacksonsart.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/...

The comment about not licking your brushes is a reference to the common practice of licking them in the wargaming miniatures painting community (you know, Warhammer and all that). You can find videos of influencers explicitly telling you that the best way to shape the tip of your brush or remove excess water is to lick it. For example:

https://youtu.be/BXMhwPAee4U?si=WM-FXuxDtToNpkm4&t=129

If you ask for a rationale it's usually that wargaming and generally hobbyist paints are non-toxic, but the truth is that hobby paint manufacturers never list their paints' ingredients so there is no way to know. And of course there's different degrees of toxicity, not everything needs to be cobalt(II) oxide-level toxic to hurt you if you consume "large enough" quantities of it; the question is what that "large enough" means and without knowing the substance, there's no way to know.

So: don't lick your brushes.

YeGoblynQueenne··on AI's top startups are barely publishing their research
Not always. AFAICT my papers have often been reviewed by people I have never met and who have expertise that overlaps with, but does not fully match, mine, and I couldn't possibly contact those people out of the blue to ask for feedback, particularly because I'd never get the chance to meet them outside of peer review (they wouldn't be in the same conferences as me etc). And that's a good thing because that way I get a sort of "outsider looking in" view.

I've sure given and taken informal feedback in the past from people I know and that's great but peer review also makes the whole process more formal and less sloppy; at least sometimes and depending on the venue and to my experience.

YeGoblynQueenne··on I flagged two research papers for fake authors and both were accepted as orals
For me at that point it's OK to give the paper a quick read, write a few words on what it's about and whether the paper looks well written and so on, explain it's outside my area of expertise and give a weak accept with low confidence.

So basically leave it up to the Area Chair. It still helps them a bit that you give the paper a quick once over and flag it up if it's somehow complete crap. The problem is that I'm probably missing the chance to review papers I'd be really interested in and that I could help to improve.

I guess it's a bit ridiculous that AI conferences in particular can't find a systematic way to route papers to subject matter experts. I guess the usual system with area and sub-area keywords is overwhelmed by the extreme increase in numbers. This year AAAI made link to my Google Scholar and DBLP, link my top five papers, and add some more info about my subject to my profile; and they still failed to rate the papers that were really relevant as most relevant. At least the bidding pool was a bit smaller this time so I guess they're trying to work something out.

Meanwhile submission numbers are exploding and I fear all the conferences can do is try to play catch up.

YeGoblynQueenne··on I flagged two research papers for fake authors and both were accepted as orals
What is your area? I publish in AI (mainly IJCAI/AAAI, MLJ and some smaller conferences) and had one of my rejected papers copy/pasted into a new submission to a different conference without my consent. When I asked for the copy to be retracted a new paper was written, also based on my paper, to replace the copy of my paper without telling the conference. When I complained to the conference the new paper was sent to the reviewers of the first copy (which had been accepted before the new paper was written) with a note "explaining" a mistake had been made and then the new paper was also accepted to the conference. I reported all this to the integrity team at the host institution and there was an informal investigation which found that there had been "some level plagiarism" (sic) but it was only poor academic practice, not misconduct and there would be no disciplinary consequences. Right now we're at the point where I'm waiting for Springer, who publish the conference proceedings, to also sweep it all under the rug and let me know that publishing a copy of a copy of my paper meets their high scholarly standards.

Plagiarism brings a slap on the wrist unless the case is very high profile, like the example posted by azan_20 in the sibling where the plagiarising academic had many accolades and a big reputation. If the target or source of plagiarism is not famous it's like stealing bikes.

And of course if you're a senior academic being accused of misconduct by a less senior academic you can LOL about it because it's all a big joke and the less senior academic is the one who'll get a hit to their reputation for making a fuss and rocking the boat.

YeGoblynQueenne··on AI-generated, Lean-verified proof of Collatz conjecture exploits Lean kernel bug
The plot thickens! It seems the researcher who posted the "proof" of the Collatz conjecture was aware of the Lean bug; or maybe he wasn't. He's currently being coy about it and it's hard to say if he's trying to save face or genuinely intended to cause a stir for whatever reason:

https://leanprover.zulipchat.com/#narrow/channel/270676-lean...

YeGoblynQueenne··on AI's top startups are barely publishing their research
Tier 1 journals have high standards (that's why they're tier 1) and they also have hundreds of submissions every cycle. It's common to have a paper rejected. On the upside you get your work seen by some of the most experienced researchers in AI, who are also specialists in your paper's subject. For example, here's the editorial board of the Journal of Machine Learning Research:

https://jmlr.org/editorial-board.html

Scroll down where it says "JMLR Editorial board of reviewers" and where you can find the names of reviewers and their areas of expetise.

The advice you get from such reviewers, even if your paper is rejected, is an invaluable tool to help you improve your work and its presentation. You eventually learn to not be sore about it and iterate until your work gets accepted.

Of course nobody's forcing you to publish, especially in a journal (in AI and CS conference proceedings tend to have much quicker turn around times and you naturally get more feedback if you get to present at a conference) but the alternative is to sit alone in your room hacking away at your code until you discover the perpetual motion machine.

YeGoblynQueenne··on AI's top startups are barely publishing their research
>> To your dye example, yttrium indium manganese blue was the first commercially viable inorganic blue pigment discovered in ~200 years, is the only known environmentally safe one, and was openly published in the literature. It's also under an exclusive license.

Gee, I wonder what was wrong with the previous blue pigments and why it was so important to have this one under an exclusive license.

Cobalt blue is a blue pigment made by sintering cobalt(II) oxide with aluminium(III) oxide (alumina) at 1200 °C. Chemically, cobalt blue pigment is cobalt(II) oxide-aluminium oxide, or cobalt(II) aluminate, CoAl2O4. Cobalt blue is lighter and less intense than the (iron-cyanide based) pigment Prussian blue.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cobalt_blue

Oh right.

P.S. Don't lick your brushes.

YeGoblynQueenne··on Unitree As2-W
So now we have a robot that walks a bit longer and... does nothing else? What's the point?
YeGoblynQueenne··on Unitree As2-W
A bigger and beefier machine will also be much less nimble. The whole point of this robot is that it can travel at speed over rough terrain but that's in large part enabled by its light weight. If you eliminate that, it's just a wimpy quadruped. Nobody's going to "scale" that up, they'll just use a bigger platform, forget about rolling downhill, and get it over with.

There's already plenty of systems like that, e.g. Ukraine's TW 12.7 [1] or even the MAUL used in rescue missions [2].

What is the niche targeted by Unitree with this robot? What are they selling, exactly; and to whom?

It's worth asking those questions if one wants to go beyond the excitement of watching a cool demo, and towards understanding the state of the art in robotics. Lots of cool videos of robots doing all sorts of impressive stuff around, but those are heavily edited and carefully curated to show what the vendor wants to show. The question is how much of that ends up in use in real-world situations, from homes, to roads to battlefields. The answer usually is: very little.

_____________________

[1] https://theconversation.com/ukraines-killer-robots-show-how-...

[2] https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2025/11/17/robot-coff...

YeGoblynQueenne··on Unitree As2-W
Excuse me what?
YeGoblynQueenne··on Unitree As2-W
There are so many places wheels can't go and legs can. For example, most rough terrain is right out of the question for anyone using a wheelchair. There are all-terrain wheelchairs that can go over some rough terrain but you just can't move across the same range of terrains with wheels that you can with legs. Even Mars rovers have to carefully avoid areas of e.g. deep sand where they can get stuck etc (and they still get stuck occasionally like Spirit†). Hence also all the specialised wheel designs like tank treads.

If it were possible to make legged robots with the same fine motor control and dexterity as human legs, let alone four-legged animals' legs, we'd be way ahead of where we are right now in mobile robotics. We can't.

YeGoblynQueenne··on Unitree As2-W
Or five. One on each leg and one ON THE FACE!

And then a tiny little one on the bum like a cutesy tail <3

YeGoblynQueenne··on Unitree As2-W
Guys, guys:

>> High Payload:

>> Static 150 kg;

>> Continuous walking payload approx. 16 kg

And on top of that:

>> Long Endurance:

>> Unloaded 3h+ (>33 km);

>> Loaded > 2h (>16 km)

16 kgs for two hours max is not "extremely valuable to any military". It's hardly even valuable to a leisure camper. You might be able to get this to carry some of your stuff if you go on a short hike, but if you were thinking of going camping and having it carry your camping gear, you can forget about it.

YeGoblynQueenne··on Unitree As2-W
Not this robot. You can see that none of the videos where the robot is careering downhill or rolling fast over rough terrain shows it carrying any load at all. Since those are the best-of, carefully curated videos, painstakingly chosen to show off the system's capabilities at its best you can rest assured that the robot can't manoeuvre like shown in the videos with any load at all.

There's a video where it's going uphill over uneven terrain with a load at a much slower pace, which is the same as what Big Dog could do 21 years ago, and another one where it's shown rolling up a smooth, grassy slope while loaded, which is pretty meh.

And that's just carrying a load. Now, you want it to carry an assault rifle and fire it? Like, at enemy targets? And hit them?

You will need to wait for a couple of major breakthroughs in robotics and AI still, I'm afraid.

YeGoblynQueenne··on Future euro banknote design proposals
Wow, I had to dig this deep down the thread to find a comment that doesn't sound grumpy and offended. It's just banknotes. Honestly.
YeGoblynQueenne··on Future euro banknote design proposals
It's "Marie Curie". Marrie Currie invented the curry.
YeGoblynQueenne··on Future euro banknote design proposals
Btw, I'd probably go for Design J; because it's upright and because birds.
YeGoblynQueenne··on Future euro banknote design proposals
OK, is there any place where they name the people and the birds? I can recognise the following people:

5 Euro - La Callas

10 Euro - Beethoven

20 Euro - Marie Curie

50 Euro - Cervantes

100 Euro - Da Vinci

200 Euro - ???

I'm sure I know who the 200 Euro person is but I can't name her.

I'm sad I can't recognise any of the birds with any certainty at all. Fortunately their names are listed in Design B. In fact, so are some of their characteristics like size, weight, wingspan etc, so maybe you can use the banknotes to play some kind of bird card game of sorts.

YeGoblynQueenne··on I regret migrating to Codeberg
>> I'm literally seeing companies being pitched with B2B products written by people who had never written a program before, even as a hobby!

Can you post some links to examples of such companies? It sounds really bad but I don't want to really believe it until I can see it with mine own eyes.

YeGoblynQueenne··on I regret migrating to Codeberg
>> There are a lot of projects coming out now where someone feels like they've made a cool thing but it breaks on the first edge case and is entirely unmaintainable. Many are built on wrong principles because the prompt authors aren't savvy and don't know better.

It would be nice to have concrete examples of that kind of project.

YeGoblynQueenne··on Claude Fable produced a counterexample to the Jacobian Conjecture
Why do people on this site always barge in when someone is having an argument and move the goalposts? That's not at all what the OP said.

Besides which you have no idea whether that's how the Jacobian conjecture counterexample was verified. Nobody does because no details were released.

YeGoblynQueenne··on Claude Fable produced a counterexample to the Jacobian Conjecture
Sorry, that's just egregious abuse of terminology. Either you're pruning the branches of a tree (or other graph, potentially) when you're doing a tree search, or you don't do pruning. Specifically advice taking (if that's what you mean) is not pruning.
YeGoblynQueenne··on Claude Fable produced a counterexample to the Jacobian Conjecture
Checking, it how? I mean can you describe the mechanism? How does an LLM "check" that something is (or isn't) a counterexample? Does that involve pattern matching, formal verification or model checking, some other approach?
← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →