HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ZachPruckowski

1,432 karma · joined July 29, 2008

submissionscomments
ZachPruckowski··on How My School and District Failed its Students
In a private school, that's probably a decent solution. Generally, people willing to send their kids to a private school are probably the parents who (a) put a premium on their kid's education and (b) make their children behave at least somewhat civilly most of the time. That cuts out a lot of the problem cases of children who face no consequences at home and who have no incentive to learn. Private schools also get to select on competence in many cases. You're not going to have someone who's reading on a 4th grade level in your senior English class, as happens at public schools. And you can refuse hard discipline cases and/or expel them, which they can't do in public schools.

In that environment, a teacher should be able to control the students. But you can't expect a system that works in those conditions to work in non-optimal conditions.

ZachPruckowski··on How My School and District Failed its Students
It's not even that hard. It's not like we need them to check their kids' homework and go over it with them (though that'd be great). It's a mindset issue. If you can instill in your kids that learning is important and getting good grades is crucial and respecting parents and teachers is non-negotiable, that's like half the battle right there.

I'm not saying that all children should mindlessly obey whatever they're told by authority figures, but I think we can all get together on "shut up while the teacher is talking"

ZachPruckowski··on How My School and District Failed its Students
OK, but if teachers and administrators can't do more than write nasty notes in files and make kids sit in the corner, and we can't expect parents to discipline their kids, then any sort of educational reform targeted at those kids is basically trying to push a string.

This idea that a teacher can stand up in front of the class and say something so inspiring that it magically makes the goof-offs and the slackers want to be A+ students is great for a Hollywood movie, but completely unrealistic. On a 1-on-1 basis, sure that's probably possible if you're really good, and really can take the time. But if teachers had the power to inspire and move those troublemakers en masse with the power of their words without taking half their class time, then they wouldn't be teachers, they'd be world-class salespeople or winning politicians.

ZachPruckowski··on How My School and District Failed its Students
I blame the parental situation, for two reasons. First of all, if my parents got a message on their voicemail (and schools have parents' phone numbers) or on my report card comments saying so much as "Zach can be slightly disruptive sometimes", then they'd darn well make me behave myself. Which brings us to the second reason - a lot of parents seem unwilling to lay down the law and make their children respect their authority even slightly. I'm not suggesting we go back to beating kids with switches or anything, but I think there's a fundamental link between whether or not you make kids eat their vegetables and whether or not they'll listen to the teacher.

Now I'm sure there are a lot of mitigating factors on the parental side, in terms of having to work long hours to put food on the table, but in the end, discipline and respect begin at home.

ZachPruckowski··on "You've angered the hive"
What about chain of evidence? Who's to say that the hacker didn't change details of the report between downloading it and publishing it? "This is a report from a security expert" sounds quite a bit better in court than "This is a report that another hacker claims is an unaltered copy he nicked from a security expert".
ZachPruckowski··on Canadians Just Became World's Biggest Internet Losers.
>"The parent sits at 38 points while being almost entirely wrong."

Do you have any evidence that he's wrong, an argument why he's wrong, or even a different assertion of the facts?

This has actually been a fairly fact-filled, low-whine conversation, with reason-filled arguments. It's a topic (proper regulation of state-granted monopolies) that goes back hundreds of years (to American Colonial times, at least). The fact is, you need a monopoly on last mile connections because it's not feasible to let 3-4 ISPs run last-mile connections, even if it could be made profitable. To prevent the company with that monopoly from owning the whole telecommunications industry (at least in that region), governments sometimes force them to lease those lines to competitors at agreed-upon rates, so that those competitors can keep the monopoly (in this case, Bell) in check. But Canada's change has let Bell impose restrictions on those competitors' plans, so that those competitors can't offer better plans (at least in terms of cost/GB), which basically circumvents the whole reason to make Bell let competitors lease the lines.

ZachPruckowski··on How the FBI raided Anonymous
Well, if they're snooping your net traffic, then you don't have to say anything on those forums or sites, simply hitting them on port 80 more than a handful of times is probably sufficient. They're trying to differentiate "guy who got botted" from "guy who's doing this manually", and even visiting those sites is probably differentiation enough to establish the probable cause or reasonable suspicion they need for a search warrant.
ZachPruckowski··on How the FBI raided Anonymous
For a law enforcement agency to investigate the Wikileaks would require Wikileaks to turn over their server access logs, including every visitor to the site for the period of time in question. They would be basically finished in terms of getting dissidents to visit the site or hand over information if they're seen as turning over any sort of visitor-identifying info to any sort of law enforcement agency.
ZachPruckowski··on Rethinking 99 weeks of unemployment
>"endless leisure and procreation"

I think you mean REcreation here, but I guess it could go either way.

ZachPruckowski··on Rethinking 99 weeks of unemployment
Except that we're not having a capital shortage, we're having a demand shortage. There's plenty of money to be lent out, but there's no demand for it. So it really is the case that that money being spent is better than that money being saved.
ZachPruckowski··on Rethinking 99 weeks of unemployment
Either some of those training times are unrealistic, or there are broadly different definitions of competence. I'm extremely skeptical that ANYONE can learn enough about video editing in 2 weeks to become a professional editor. Or "go from zero computer knowledge to being a Microsoft Certified Systems Engineer or a Cisco network engineer" - I'm not sure we have the same understanding of the general public's computer knowledge. There's a bit difference between "Harvard non-nerd" and the average unemployed person in terms of learning aptitude and in terms of computer familiarity.

Not to mention that with lots of people from Tier 1 schools having a hard time finding jobs, it's not like the recession is a result of not enough people having college degrees. I mean, training never hurts, but the issue we're facing isn't a skills-to-opportunities mismatch, it's just a total lack of available jobs in all sectors.

ZachPruckowski··on Rethinking 99 weeks of unemployment
Either some of those training times are unrealistic, or there are broadly different definitions of competence. I'm extremely skeptical that ANYONE can learn enough about video editing in 2 weeks to become a professional editor. Or "go from zero computer knowledge to being a Microsoft Certified Systems Engineer or a Cisco network engineer" - I'm not sure we have the same understanding of the general public's computer knowledge. There's a bit difference between "Harvard non-nerd" and the average unemployed person in terms of learning aptitude and in terms of computer familiarity.

Not to mention that with lots of people from Tier 1 schools having a hard time finding jobs, it's not like the recession is a result of not enough people having college degrees. I mean, training never hurts, but the issue we're facing isn't a skills-to-opportunities mismatch, it's just a total lack of available jobs in all sectors.

ZachPruckowski··on Poll: What is your personal annual income?
These sorts of polls probably attract people who rarely post. The sort of guy looking at this site and reading it and saying either "I wish I had their guts" or "I'm getting ready to take the plunge". They're probably guys with a few years of experience under their belts, so they're probably making more than entry-level pukes like me or founders living on Ramen.

By which I mean that it's probably your second guess ("there's fewer founders than expected")

ZachPruckowski··on Poll: What is your personal annual income?
Not all metros are NYC/DC/SF level cost though. Even among the 1m+ people metros, my $45k would buy a middle-class life in Houston, Phoenix, Philadelphia, San Antonio, and Dallas. Not a fabulous one, but I'd certainly have no issues living there as a bachelor. Probably harder to make ends meet as a family man, but most Dads don't have entry level positions. Maybe my wife would have to work part-time, but it wouldn't be unmanageable. And that's assuming I don't get another raise[1] in my life.

My point is that in most of the country, anyone in the top 4 buckets (which is to say $50k+) is in pretty solid shape.

[1] - By which I mean a performance or experience related raise, promotion, or new job. Obviously that would require small raises to keep up with inflation.

ZachPruckowski··on Poll: What is your personal annual income?
Yeah. I mean, even on the low-end of it, my $45k salary is low but manageable in DC (it's starter salary), meager in NY/SF, but basically enough to raise a family in the other 95% of the country.
ZachPruckowski··on The Ethics of Publishing Cease-and-Desist Letters
Why does it matter who the letter was directed to? The recipient of the letter was the one who published it, and Volokh quoted from it (or reprinted it) for commentary purposes. It's not like he snatched it out of the ether en-route or something.
ZachPruckowski··on Qwiki Epitomizes the Current Startup Bubble
If this were 1990 or you didn't know about Google, then a simple web directory connecting you to various sites would be very impressive.
ZachPruckowski··on The GPL is a License, Not a Contract
No, you need systems in place to make sure you don't commit copyright infringement. But if you do commit copyright infringement, there are solutions other than opening up your code, such as buying a license from the guy you copied from or removing the infringing code.
ZachPruckowski··on The GPL is a License, Not a Contract
>"But developers don't always protect the best interests of the company."

Then you should either hire better developers, manage them better, or get some sort of "my employees are shit" insurance (which I doubt exists).

ZachPruckowski··on The GPL is a License, Not a Contract
>"Any developer on your staff could look at something on line and derive some code from it, and drop it into your codebase"

Well that's what's so crucial about having solid Best Practices and hiring good developers. If you hire people who break the rules (deliberately or accidentally, with your knowledge or without), then there's your problem. The GPL has nothing to do with that scenario, it's you hiring people who can't toe the line.

ZachPruckowski··on Sean Parker: "The Social Network" is a complete work of fiction
>"A bus full of hot girls arriving to be used for sex"

At my college the freshmen girls walked more than mile to get to frat houses or apartment parties thrown by older and frequently wealthier students, knowing full well that their hosts weren't giving that beer away as charity. Once you get to "girls in real life are willing go to parties to drink and possibly hook up with guys", it's a short step to going out of their way to party with the more privileged guys.

>The hero hacks one site in one night when drunk and in 2 hours it crashes the network

It was built in one day. It took slightly longer to propagate and get shut-down, but its method of propagation (email lists), massive traffic (though not network-crushingly so), and the end result (Ad board) were accurate. It shouldn't be surprising that the movie compressed the timeline - after all, there's over a year of story told in 2 hours.

ZachPruckowski··on Techies don't understand what business Apple is in
>Yeah, pat yourself on the back, you're smart.

Not just me, everyone who regularly posts on a niche board about programming and entrepreneurship. Maybe my original statement was hyperbole, but it's not crazy to say that people who voluntarily seek out conversations on the value of OOP are more tech literate than the average. Similarly, if we were on a website catering towards people trying out for minor-league baseball teams, the audience would mostly be in the top 5% in terms of athleticism.

And for the record, I'm probably the dumbest guy here, and I freely admit it.

>Never used EBay, never bought anything from Amazon and I also Google for URLs from time to time ... pretty sweat if you can't remember the exact string.

You're trying to misread me here. There are people for whom "order tickets online" is a major accomplishment, akin to cleaning out the garage. Once, a ReadWriteWeb article[1] overtook Facebook in the Google search for "facebook login" (w/o quotes). It resulted in thousands of people commenting on the article trying to log into facebook. I'm not saying "can't tell RWW and Facebook apart" is average, but I am saying that that's a rare occurrence.

>Apple's products are not idiot proof.

Of course not. But the flipside of the file structure and CLI on an iPhone being locked away is that users can't accidentally do something to their System directory. And locked-down, reviewed applications means fewer compatibility issues and fewer misbehaving apps slowing things down.

[1] - http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/facebook_wants_to_be_yo...

ZachPruckowski··on Techies don't understand what business Apple is in
Yeah, I'm not saying high-end tech-savvy users never did anything for Apple (I bought my Macs for largely the reasons you describe), but when Apple makes commercials, they're not advertising "the most usable Unix-compatible OS in the world", they're advertising "it makes web and media and lifestyle stuff really easy".
ZachPruckowski··on Techies don't understand what business Apple is in
I said "the average user", not "all Mac users". It's the same thing with PCs - the 90% of people who aren't experts or ninjas or developers are web-itunes-facebook-email people. You may not know many of them, but that's a result of your professional and social circles.

Apple doesn't sell millions of computers every quarter to Rails developers, it sells them to 90%-ers. Sure, some developers buy them, but they're not the main market.

ZachPruckowski··on Techies don't understand what business Apple is in
They definitely sell experience. The average user mostly wants[1] (1) email, (2) Facebook, (3) iTunes, (4) web surfing, and they don't really care about how the box on their desk gets their emails, whether it's open source or closed source, locked down or modifiable, or even if it's electronic or just really fast carrier pigeons.

Like the article said, the average user wants toast, not a toaster.

[1] - it's starting to look like we can add internet video to this list.

ZachPruckowski··on Techies don't understand what business Apple is in
No, they don't become stupid. But their view of the uses of computers changes. Everyone reading this post is in the top 5% in terms of computer skill. The majority of the friends of everyone reading this post are in the top 25% in terms of computer skill. It gives a very warped perspective of the "average computer user". You know that guy who's still getting the hang of EBay and Amazon and who Googles URLs instead of typing them? He's the average computer user[1]. Which means half of all computer users are less capable than him.

For instance, consider the sentence "Angry Birds is lots of fun - you should get it from their website, they take paypal"[2]. To HNers that's incredibly straightforward and simple - (1) Google "Angry Birds", (2) make sure it's a legit site, (3) look for the "Buy" button, (4) check out, (5) enter your paypal information, and (6) install the game. To me (and most HNers, I'd imagine), the hardest part of that is "what was my PayPal password again?", but to the average computer user, that's a confusing 30 minutes, part of which will be spent on an ornithology site. It's for that average user that things like the Mac App Store and locked-down phones were designed.

The point of this long, meandering post is that the reason techies have issues analyzing Apple's strategy is because they mis-over-estimate the skill of the average computer user, for the totally understandable reason that they're surrounded by people with well-above-average computer skills.

[1] - Probably hyperbole, but not by much. [2] - I've actually never played Angry Birds.

ZachPruckowski··on Facebook Billionaire Eduardo Saverin Leads Qwiki’s $8 Million Round
I suspect most people will find Qwiki cool for the novelty, but when it comes down to brass tacks and actually trying to learn something, I think Wikipedia's going to win out for everyone over the age of 13.
ZachPruckowski··on The polynomial algorithm for 3-SAT problem (or P=NP)
Don't forget that changing out algorithms is a time-consuming process. It's not a 10 second fix, it's a technical challenge and a bureaucratic nightmare. I mean, it takes a week's worth of meetings to restock the condiments in the mess hall in some of these places. So you wind up in a situation where it takes a year or more to implement this stuff once you have the ideal solution selected, and selecting the replacement solution takes another year or more. So even if it's not projected to be an issue for 5 years, you have to start the replacement process right away.
ZachPruckowski··on What Hollywood Execs Privately Say About Netflix
Honestly, I think Netflix and Hulu result in me watching more TV. If I miss an episode or two of a show, that starts the slide into quitting the show. But if the show's on Hulu, I can stay caught up, and then go back to watching it live.

Similarly, I wouldn't want to jump into a show halfway through Season 3. It'd be confusing and too much work. And I'm not going to buy two seasons worth of DVDs because the current commercials look cool. So if I can get those back seasons on Netflix then I can become a loyal viewer.

ZachPruckowski··on What Hollywood Execs Privately Say About Netflix
Yeah, I've long thought it's a great idea that circumvents a lot of the weaknesses of tightly-constrained TV storytelling.

The problem is the economics. It seems people tend to respond negatively to production values below a certain standard. Cable productions run about $2M/episode, which translates to roughly $3M/hour or $50K/minute. Even if you can cut that by 20%, you still need to make a serious amount of money, and that's a lot of $2.10 iTunes purchases or $0.xy (I don't know what that number is, but it's got to be smaller than a dollar) Netflix streams that you've got to get in order to break even. And that's for the production values of "White Collar" or "Leverage", not "LOST" or "Rome"

On top of that, you have the business costs. You've got to pay the overhead costs, and you've got to pay development costs. Half the new shows that get a slot on TV fail, and getting one slot filled requires shooting 2-3 pilot episodes at a couple million a pop. In addition to expansion, you've got to replace your shows every few years, since (a) even the best shows get stale after a while and (b) costs go up every year.

← PreviousPage 7 of 16Next →