346 karma · joined March 21, 2024
The fact that the suspense change made it this far shows how the react team has lost focus. Now more than ever, the ecosystem is really primed for a competing framework to dethrone react. I say this as someone that has invested a lot into using react.
Did we all forget about books?
At the root of it, the author is arguing that everyone needs to reach for common tools to patch together feature-packed solutions for a narrow set of customers. This somehow translates into it being cheaper to build and more appealing to customers. The problems I see:
1) Stuffing a bunch of third party services together to make a product is great for a startup looking to launch quickly, but in practice it is usually horrible long term. Quality integration between your features becomes difficult, and you will often sacrifice the UX as a result.
2) Outsourcing everything makes you a thin wrapper. Talk about commoditization.
3) The author seems to assume that the brand is the business, not the underlying product. That doesn't even hold for hamburgers, let alone specialized software verticals.
4) In an era of software being dumped on the market in droves, the solution is not to dump into the market even faster. I can tell you as someone coming from the medical side of things that people try doing this to us all of the time, and it's just endless heaps of garbage software. People would be smart to take the time to really think through our problems in the fine details where they matter. I know that doesn't mix well with a VC-backed growth at all costs model, but frankly that's not my problem.
The article feels like it was written by an MBA, not an engineer.
People on HN complain how a substantial amount of the comments are negative. I give my honest opinion, as a doctor, knowing full well how hard it is to not only clear the hurdles to get to where they are at, but I also appreciate that it is a worthwhile endeavor. In an era where half of the people in tech are wasting their lives optimizing SEO and to sell more ads for useless crap, these people are out there making tangible improvements in people's lives.
There are many studies which evaluate things that seem obvious. These are necessary to support less obvious conclusions in other studies. If your paper is going to make the claim that IL10 upregulation in children as a consequence of environmental stimuli is linked to some disease process, one of the critiques will be if you can even establish that IL10 upregulation reliably occurs. If your paper can cite a well-performed study evaluating that prior, it strengthens the conclusions of your own study.
We call these screening tests.
> doctor can say "ok, you had this result from an unverified lab, let's do a more thorough test and see what we find"
The more likely scenario is that this is the 10th patient this week presenting for suspected cancer based on an at home administration kit with a low specificity (under ideal conditions), and it turns out it's not. Conducting such tests indiscriminately (voluntary and self administered) is going to waste a ton of doctor time that we don't have.
> The public need to be educated that these tests are a lower cost "pre-test"
Anything that requires education of the public about anything is unfortunately a losing battle.
> we are given an FIT test for colon cancer when we turn 50. This test is 79% accurate. This is a simple at home test, no doctors involved
This can work with a structured protocol. The problem is that at least in the US, we will have direct to consumer labs chasing next quarter's revenue numbers, so everyone will be shown commercials and be grabbing them off of shelves to avoid seeing expensive doctors that they don't trust. It's a recipe for a lot of unnecessary anxiety and time wasted.
Talking in absolutes like this doesn't help the rest of your point. There are plenty of situations where a single result is sufficient to trigger a whirlwind of treatment decisions.
> More importantly, such results can help offer hard evidence to pressure one's physician to investigate a particular complaint, which can be difficult to convey or to convince the physician it's real. Physicians are often dismissive of things that they do not understand, or of certain classes of patients
If you've ever been sitting on the other side of a consult you would recognize that this statement isn't all that accurate of a characterization. As much as people like to believe they are outsmarting navel-gazing doctors, the reality is that with sufficient time and adequate resources most of these "complex issues" can be diagnosed and treated. The problem lies in that most providers have a 15 minute window to determine if the patient is part of the boring 80%, or if the patient's problem will require time you don't have. Until provider shortages are solved, that will be how it works in order to do the most good on the whole. Berating and pressuring them will just contribute to the burnout that in turn contributes to shortages. The source of the problem is above them.
Medical problems are highly contextual, so you are not going to get much valuable information at the level of what a doctor is thinking from the first page of Google. That doesn't mean it isn't a simple within our area of expertise.
Try getting it to properly select crystalloids with proper additives for a patient with a given history and lab results and watch in horror as it confidently gives instructions that would kill the patient.
What is even more irritating is that I had gpt4 debate me on things that it was completely wrong about and it was only when I responded with a stern rebuke that it hit me with the usual "Apologies for the misunderstanding..."
Almost nobody uses explicit typing in yaml.
The fact you need features like folding strings or chomp characters is a symptom that yaml is trying to work around limitations that shouldn't be there to begin with.
That said, the hyphen still looks bad and the name is an abortion pill in the US.
Taking a child's phone away is not abuse. It should be expected and desired by parents wanting their child to actually learn in school. Unfortunately we have normalized suspicion towards teachers to such a toxic level that they are now powerless to enforce a learning environment, and it has resulted in a mass exodus of talented people from teaching.
The whole culture around teaching needs a hard reset.