HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

_mulder_

537 karma · joined January 28, 2013

submissionscomments
_mulder_··on A Laser Message from Space
Think about it, wavelength (or frequency, they're effectively the same measurement here) determines how fast you can transmit those 1's and 0's. It's not slower, it's just that you can't transmit as much information in the same time period.

Also, laser light for Telecoms is not normally Visible, it's usually Infrared which has a wavelength shorter than Microwave radio but longer than visible light.

Another bonus fact; in a vacuum, Radio and Light waves travel at the same speed. However, when light travels down an optical fibre it is slowed down by the glass so Fibre Internet is actually slightly slower than radio.

_mulder_··on A Laser Message from Space
The big problem is getting through the Earth's Atmosphere. Space observatories are nearly exclusively located on mountains or areas with little atmospheric 'pollution'. I'd imagine even the OPALS system can only be used when it's not too cloudy/rainy.

This technology does exist on land however. Free Space Optics[1] has been around for a while but hasn't taken off in a big way because it's less reliable than sending light down a fibre cable, even though it is cheaper.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free-space_optical_communicatio...

_mulder_··on A Laser Message from Space
>you only need to worry about the Earth's atmosphere

I assume you're meaning this is the main source of attenuation (signal loss) if we assume the space between Earth and Mars is an empty vacuum. This (technically called scattering) is not the main source of loss for such a system.

Coherent just means the light is all in phase, it doesn't mean it doesn't spread out as it travels. If it didn't spread out at all, your receiver on earth would be just as wide as the laser transmitter (about the size of a coin), and you'd have to be locked on the entire time... not very practical. It looks like NASA has intentionally focussed their LASER into a wide cone for precisely this reason.

The distance from Mars would cause the beam (cone) to spread out too much, thereby reducing the power received on earth. You would have to increase your laser power on Mars to compensate for this or make the beam more directional with some focusing optics.

_mulder_··on Killing a Patient to Save His Life
Are you really suggesting a Hitleresque racial motive behind these experiments? Or just sad that black males (in that locale) have a higher incidence of homicide, and therefore more likely to be suitable for this procedure?
_mulder_··on Tell HN: audio of person who lost £15,000 to fake Microsoft calls
That could really work, especially as most frauds like this are performed using PAYG mobile SIMS, however, they're more likely to exploit it with a 'number unknown' similar to what we have today with Caller ID.

This could work really well, and be easy to implement, with a VoIP service too.

_mulder_··on This Rural Community Is Building Its Own Gigabit Internet Network
B4RN are great but they're unique, primarily because they have local access to backhaul fibre. There are some key fibre routes travelling through their area and there are existing fibres (originally used to connect local schools) that run to the nearby Lancaster University (where the CEO of B4RN used to work), and from there onto Telecity in Manchester.

Organising a fibre across some fields and your neighbours gardens is one thing, but connecting into the national fibre network can be quite another, especially for "real" remote villages where the nearest fibre point is many miles away.

Of course you then have to lease the fibre capacity too which is very expensive (£20k-40k+ a year for 10Gb backhaul) and ultimately at the operator's discretion, some operators will just not sell to customers who they see as direct competition. I seem to recall in B4RN's case they had such a clash with BT that they pretty much burnt their bridges with them for any future assistance.

This lack of existing infrastructure is why you couldn't (cost effectively) replicate B4RN in rural Wales for example, even if you had fibre to all of the houses in a village.

_mulder_··on 7 issues with email overload and ONE solution that gmail should do
You could try looking at these previous discussions:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1753080

http://blog.zeromail.com/2013/03/27/zeromail-goes-live-perso...

_mulder_··on 7 issues with email overload and ONE solution that gmail should do
This is very good advice. However, it would be great if Google could introduce a time element to filters. i.e; 'apply label 'ToRead' if email is over 5 days old and is unread and move to 'unread' folder'. Or 'mark message as 'priority' if unread after 4 hours and from dave@important.com'
_mulder_··on 7 issues with email overload and ONE solution that gmail should do
My suggestions would be:

1. Seperate work and personal - There is no need to be receiving emails from friends, Amazon or whoever when you're at work. Have a separate Inbox to process these, they will be waiting for you when you chose to look at them, not to distract you when replying to work emails.

2. Unsubscribe from everything - When was the last time you looked at or read a promotional email or weekly newsletter? If it wasn't recently (a month), then unsubscribe.

3. Manage your contacts - Do you need to be CC'd into every email? If you don't want to receive so many emails from a colleague, just email politely and say, due to the amount of emails you get, please don't CC me unless it's vitally important. This may have the added benefit of drawing their attention to what they're doing and make them reconsider who else they're CC'ing.

4. Consider separate email accounts for separate purposes - Running a businesses, a non-profit (as per OP) and you attend conferences alot? Why not have four email accounts? That way you can separate each of your 2 'jobs' and have one email for your personal friends and family, The Queen and Amazon. A separate 'public profile' account can be used to field incoming requests for help or advice or meet-ups from strangers or acquaintances that you may meet at Conferences or on your blog. These are unlikely to be high-priority but you can have a scan through at your leisure when you get the time without them interrupting your normal work flow.

However, I can't help but feel sometimes, people who receive thousands of emails it's because they actually like to receive thousands of emails because it makes them feel and look more important and popular than they perhaps are. How many of those email chains were actually started by you sending out emails to other people? Or inviting people to contact you on websites or conferences? We've all heard someone subtly boasting about coming back from holiday and having x hundred emails. All they're really saying is "look how popular I am and how much people need me". The irony of course is that, even with all of those unanswered emails, it's amazing how things just kept working as normal.

_mulder_··on (Why) I quit Hacker News (2010)
The problem with linking karma to up/down votes is that it prevents people from posting anything that is contrary to popular opinion and therefore downvoted, even if it may be well thought out or, shock horror, factually accurate too!!

The end result is an ever increasing alignment of 'group-think' where popular opinions are boosted and differing opinions are hidden.

Up/down voters just need to take a second and consider what they're voting for. If it's just because they agree, then don't. If they agree and they've learned something new, then do. If they disagree and but they think the arguments are well presented or they've learned something new, upvote.

Down voting should be reserved only for inappropriate comments, not disagreement.

_mulder_··on GCHQ spy base revealed
Your post could read word for word about any military or civil program with the ability to wield force.

Should we also scrap our space program, navy, air force, police force or even law courts?

I agree with your point, but this is just a new instance of an age old problem.

_mulder_··on [dead]
Why is this on HN frontpage? It's a reactionary protest from a customer who was has suffered inconvenience at the hands of 'the system'. Anyone who has done extensive flying in economy class will have similar experiences, or at least missing baggage.

From my experience of travel in other countries, including India, a travel delay of this nature is the norm. Perhaps the OP is holding European transport efficiency to a higher account than those of his own country?

_mulder_··on The Hobbit House (2012)
One of the big problems, at least in the overcrowded UK, is getting your hands on a suitable parcel of land in an area sympathetic to this sort of development.
_mulder_··on How did we get so busy?
In our current societal structure, longer hours = more money = more attractive mate or an easier life
_mulder_··on How the US stopped its fisheries from collapsing
I'm still disappointed however that there is not greater public awareness about the problems of over-fishing. Infact, I'd go as far as to say there is zero public awareness about where fish actual come from. It sounds silly I know, but fish is consistently touted as a healthy food and how we should eat more and more fish because it's good for you. Correct, it may be good for us, but it's simply not sustainable to eat more and more. I'm always surprised when I ask my friends where they think the fish they're eating came from and they're nearly all unaware that there even was huge problem with fish stocks. I mean come one, Pacific Bluefin tuna has declined by 96%!!! and it's a similar story for North Sea Cod.

There should be a greater focus on 'sustainable managed fisheries' vs open sea fishing, in the same way as people are aware of the difference between factory farming and free range.

also, it wouldn't hurt if everyone ate a little less fish (and meat for that matter)

_mulder_··on How taking pictures through windows can inadvertently reveal your location
Whilst this could be the case in some photographs, like reading reflected documents or personal information, the ability to see a reflected light and a photo frame which therefore narrows your location down to one of 30-40 identical hotel rooms doesn't seem like personal information to be wary off.

You're far more likely to inadvertently reveal personal information in the background of a photo of your actual hotel room that you are from looking out the window.

_mulder_··on How taking pictures through windows can inadvertently reveal your location
Isn't revealing your location the whole point of taking a picture from your hotel window and sharing it with the world on Twitter? I wouldn't be too surprised if I posted "I'm in Miami, and here's a view from my Hotel window" and someone was able to tell me the Hotel name and which side I was staying on. Infact, I'd be more surprised if someone couldn't!

The techniques used are not particularly ingenious here, especially as most of the photo's seem to depict some obvious landmarks to provide an easy point of reference, especially when given the extra information to focus on a specific location.

_mulder_··on Why engineers make great CEOs
Which explains why there are more Engineers in the 'top 50 Companies'; because most of the biggest, and most valuable companies, are Engineering based in some way, either by manufacturing a product (Cars, Planes, Computers), applying Engineering (Mining, Metal, Oil) or reliant on technology to perform their business (Telecoms, Internet).

The big exceptions would be Finance, Logistics, Business Consultancy or Conglomerates.

_mulder_··on The Case Against ISP Tolls
>Comcast is selling access to the Internet are they not?

There's the rub. As a cable company, Comcast are not just selling internet access, they're also selling access to TV and Movies, infact historically this is all they sold and they're still stuck in this mindset. Netflix threaten to disrupt this lucrative business.

Everyone knows cable make money from bundling a whole bunch of rubbish channels together with a handful of high quality channels and charging a lot for it. As soon as someone (Netflix) offers to let you just watch the good stuff, for less dollar, Comcast's profit line is going to take a hit. It's no coincidence that it's Netflix who has to pay extra whilst the non-threatening Google/YouTube/Facebook/Porn get past without hassle.

_mulder_··on Why is asbestos still killing people?
I don't know why you have been down-voted. You are correct, and most of the replies to the contrary are along the lines of "I knew someone who worked in an Asbestos-heavy-industrial environment and they died from it so therefore it's all dangerous."

For most members of the public, our interaction with Asbestos will be from it's use as a building material for roofs, insulation or pipes. The risk only increases if it is heavily disturbed, usually due to building work or demolition.

_mulder_··on The Telephone Tower in Stockholm circa 1890s
I'd imagine all but the first two were taken in the later part of it's life as there are not many cables!
_mulder_··on Whatever’s Best For The People, That’s What We Do
This is an interesting concept. Are there any relevant studies/articles of this in practice, beyond the Anecdotal?
_mulder_··on We Built a Hacker News for Biotech
Yes the keyboard navigation is great, I didn't notice it at first.

Whilst I agree with danso's comment below, that there is too much to look at on harlembiospace.com vs. HN, I think a hybrid between the two would be great.

HN list layout with keyboard navigation!

Infact, if someone could build that into my Chrome HackerNews Extension suite I would be very happy!

_mulder_··on Bill and Melinda Gates Aren’t Leaving Their Kids Billions
"Hi Mum, I earned $125k a month working at the local Food Bank...again! Can I have my $625k now please?"
_mulder_··on Popcorn Time Is So Good at Movie Piracy, It’s Scary
Here's a better link http://www.submarinecablemap.com/
_mulder_··on Exist
Micro-analysing ones life in this manner is wrong and counter productive on so many levels.

Knowing how many tracks you listen to a day is interesting trivia only.

Knowing how long you sleep for each night could be useful, but only if you have a problem with sleep and know, scientifically, what you're looking for. If you're consistently missing out on sleep and feeling ill as a result, you shouldn't need exist.io to tell you this. And if you're not feeling unwell or having sleep problems, then you shouldn't need exist.io to tell you this either.

Knowing the number of steps you take is also irrelevant unless it's part of some very slow burn exercise regime you're on, in which case you'd presumably count them anyway. If you're doing normal exercise, steps and heart-rate may be of interest, but only during the exercise period.

In short, knowing all of this info about yourself is not helpful. When it lacks greater context and, unless you know how to interpret it, is just a source of confusion and anxiety. At best, it's novel trivia.

_mulder_··on American Aqueduct: The Great California Water Saga
I don't know about you, but here on Planet Earth I only have 24 hours in my day. I'm happy to spend 10-15 mins reading an original article on something I currently know nothing about, but not an hour dedicated to it. FYI, I am a heavy reader, hence why I'd sooner spend my time reading something I enjoy (like a book!).
_mulder_··on Dual-lens smartphone cameras are coming
I imagine the 3D would be fairly limited because the lenses are so close together. Would this be the case?
_mulder_··on American Aqueduct: The Great California Water Saga
Personally, I was quite interested in it, I spent 10 minutes reading it before I realised how long the article was. Clearly others are interested too, as it's on HN. But who actually read it all the way through? Did you?
_mulder_··on American Aqueduct: The Great California Water Saga
Be honest, did anyone read the entire article?

I don't like this trend of writing incredibly long articles. It's as if the length alone somehow makes it more intellectual or credible, or perhaps just makes the author look good.

An approx calculation, assuming reading speed of 250wpm, means a 12,000+ word article, like this, will take nearly 1 hour to read.

← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →