HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

_qulr

4,776 karma · joined May 23, 2020

submissionscomments
_qulr··on Apple urged to root out rating scams as developer highlights enforcement failure
> Most 'reviewers' on YouTube especially are just hyping products for their own views.

That's not who I meant by the professional news media.

_qulr··on Apple asking developers to return DTK Mac mini, offers $200 credit
Apple isn't giving back anything. Participants get a $200 discount on a new M1 Mac purchase until May 31.

If the participant has already purchased an M1 Mac and doesn't need another one, then they get nothing.

And the store credit isn't given until after the DTK is returned.

_qulr··on Yellen Summons Regulators to Discuss Financial Market Volatility
> Carter has taken speaking fees

https://www.thoughtco.com/former-presidents-speaking-fees-33... Former President Jimmy Carter "seldom accepts speaking fees," The Associated Press wrote in 2002, "and when he does he typically donates the proceeds to his charitable foundation."

> Clinton runs one of the most successful charitable orgs in the world.

So does Bill Gates. So what? Clinton also made more than $100 million for himself in speaking fees.

_qulr··on Apple urged to root out rating scams as developer highlights enforcement failure
1. Online crowdsourced ratings can't be trusted anywhere. Not in the App Store, not on Amazon, etc. They're just too easy to game. The role of reviewing products was always best done by the professional news media.

2. The App Store was based entirely on the iTunes Music Store, and that's an extremely bad model for selling software. There are "bad" songs in the iTunes Music Store, but that's largely a matter of personal musical taste, and none of the songs are scams, because iTunes is not an open system where anyone can pay $99 for a "music developer" account and submit songs. The music for sale there was all written by legitimate professional musicians.

Moreover, music customers generally don't need technical support, or refunds, except maybe in the case of a mistaken purchase. The ratings and reviews for songs are mainly about taste, not evaluating whether the song "works correctly". And songs are generally quite cheap, so you're not going to lose much money buying a "bad" song.

This entire model is simply not appropriate for software. If an app doesn't work right, the customer needs technical support, and if it still doesn't work right, then the customer needs a refund. There should be exactly 0 apps in the App Store that are scams or don't work at all. Ratings and reviews are not a good way to "police" this. Every song in the iTunes Music Store "works", in the respect that it plays the expected music when you press play.

The iTunes Music Store doesn't need to be curated much by Apple, because the music is already "curated" by the record labels. Same with the TV shows and movies for sale there, "curated" by the Hollywood studios. But there's no such thing for apps, and that's why the crap store is full of scams. The record labels and movie studios have large amounts of time and money invested in each of their products. This is not true of Apple's App Store, where each app gets maybe a 20 minute review, which is almost nothing in comparison.

_qulr··on Apple urged to root out rating scams as developer highlights enforcement failure
> I expect Apple will take this very seriously.

This is not a new problem by any means. Apple has been largely ignoring it for many years, only taking action when there's bad PR like now.

_qulr··on Yellen Summons Regulators to Discuss Financial Market Volatility
> What she did was give glorified TED Talks to a group. It's a performance.

Even more reason to think that it's "selling out" and not "real" work.

_qulr··on Yellen Summons Regulators to Discuss Financial Market Volatility
> The current president often has a deep dislike of the former president and entities perceived as close to him

This is not necessarily true. The Clintons, Bushes, and Obamas are like one big happy family. Trump is the exception because he pissed off everyone, but even he used to be friendly with the Clintons.

Anyway this misses the point: in general, the system of buying political favors only works when political favors are repaid, and everyone operating in that system knows it.

_qulr··on Yellen Summons Regulators to Discuss Financial Market Volatility
> You have people complaining and asking for recusal. It's negative publicity and a hindrance to corrupt acts.

A lot better than prison though.

_qulr··on Yellen Summons Regulators to Discuss Financial Market Volatility
> Logistically, this is the stupidest way to bribe someone. There is a clear paper trail and everyone knows about it.

In other words, it's perfectly legal bribery, and thus the smartest way to bribe someone. Just like political campaign contributions.

Why risk illegal bribery when you can go the safe route, where everyone knows, but nobody goes to jail?

_qulr··on Yellen Summons Regulators to Discuss Financial Market Volatility
Exactly this. Bill Clinton's life goal wasn't to use the Presidency as a stepping stone to wealth. He just wanted to be President, and would probably still be running if there weren't term limits. But once you enter the government, you suddenly realize that people are willing to throw large sums of money at you to become "friends". Even if politicians don't start out corrupt, corruption is hard to avoid while in office.
_qulr··on Yellen Summons Regulators to Discuss Financial Market Volatility
> I don't think she's the same case as, e.g., someone who was employed by an investment bank for a long time, takes a federal position for a year or two, then goes back to working in banking.

True. Yellen clearly prefers public sector work.

However, I think there's a false dichotomy being presented. There's no inherent conflict between working in the public sector and being corrupt. The list of corrupt politicians is endless. Why not do what you love and cash in? Best of both worlds, from the corrupt politician's perspective.

_qulr··on Yellen Summons Regulators to Discuss Financial Market Volatility
> If Yellen lacked scruples, she would have gone into the private sector after leaving the Fed.

1. She did go into the private sector. She got paid for speeches. That's not a public sector job.

2. It's not mutually exclusive to enjoy public sector work while also lacking scruples. The list of corrupt politicians is endless.

_qulr··on Yellen Summons Regulators to Discuss Financial Market Volatility
She did go into the private sector. How are these paid speaking engagements not private sector?
_qulr··on Yellen Summons Regulators to Discuss Financial Market Volatility
> How much do you think it should cost to get a former president to give a talk?

That's not the right question. The question is whether ex-Presidents ought to accept these bribes. Compare the post-Presidencies of Bill Clinton and Jimmy Carter, starkly different.

> Yet obviously these celebrities aren't being tacitly bribed. What is your explanation for that?

Celebrities aren't in positions of public service, so the whole concept of a "bribe" doesn't apply.

_qulr··on Yellen Summons Regulators to Discuss Financial Market Volatility
I would consider the speaking circuit to be an industry position. A very lucrative one.
_qulr··on Yellen Summons Regulators to Discuss Financial Market Volatility
> If Yellen wanted to sell out, she would have worked in industry

What do you think Yellen is going to do 4-8 years from now?

_qulr··on Yellen Summons Regulators to Discuss Financial Market Volatility
> 700K is a pittance compared to the millions she would earn in the private sector.

We're talking about that amount of money for just a few days of "work".

> Yet people begrudge her the 220K she does earn. Treasury Secretary and Chair of the Fed would be a multi million dollar a year jobs in the private sector.

That doesn't make any sense. These jobs don't exist in the private sector.

In any case, Treasury Secretary is not a lifetime gig. At most 8 years, probably less. And then Yellen will go back to the private sector, to cash in even more. These are ongoing, transactional relationships. Think of these speaking fees as a down payment.

_qulr··on Deleting DerivedData the Right Way
You can set DerivedData to Project-relative Location with the Project Settings command in Xcode's File menu.
_qulr··on Apple watch keyboard developer put off by app store scammers
You speak as though app developers are swimming in money, but the fact is that the App Store market is very top heavy. As usual, "the 1%" are doing extremely well, but the vast majority of app developers are not making a lot of money. Apple's recent small business program is tacit acknowledgement from Apple that many developers are struggling financially and cannot afford even the 30% cut.

In comparison, the so-called "gig economy" is also extremely large, perhaps even larger in total dollars than the App Store, but that doesn't mean individual gig workers are doing well.

_qulr··on Apple watch keyboard developer put off by app store scammers
> You post screenshots of your app in progress for feedback. Scammer dupes those, rushes app into store, and when you finally launch, they "were there first" and requests your deletion on those grounds.

I seriously doubt this has ever happened in the history of the App Store.

Scammers are "lazy". The look for the easy targets. Copying an existing app is easier and more lucrative than trying to write a new app based just on some in-progress screenshots, as if scammers would even be paying attention to you before you published an app.

_qulr··on Apple watch keyboard developer put off by app store scammers
> why isn’t somebody complaining who got scammed? Don’t they want $400 back?

Many App Store customers literally do not know that they can request a refund, or how to request one. App Store does not even have a clear refund policy. You see a lot of reviews for scam apps that say "I want a refund!" They just don't know.

App Store customers assume, naturally but unfortunately mistakenly, that app developers have the power to grant refunds. They have no idea Apple itself is the sole source of refunds. You would think that Apple would put a refund link in the ratings/review area of the store, but nope.

_qulr··on A Day in the Life of Your Data [pdf]
I said: "This feels to me like Apple creating a convenient Orwellian enemy. They're not even competitors"

In other words, Apple is creating an enemy for themselves, an enemy of Apple. When in fact the two companies are not enemies in the business sense of having competing products, and indeed Apple profits directly from the In App Purchases in the Facebook app — IAP which do exist, contrary to several other false claims in these comments — and profits indirectly by having Facebook in their App Store. Facebook too has profited and become more popular by being on iPhone and the App Store.

But now Apple's App Store is under serious scrutiny, not to mention lawsuits, so Apple is looking to justify its lockdown, and "privacy" fits the bill there, despite the fact that Facebook has always been "creepy", since the beginning of the App Store and before.

The purpose of an "Orwellian" enemy is to justify the heavy-handed control of the rulers and to distract the populace from that situation. "Good thing we have Apple's strict App Store rules to protect us from evildoers like Facebook!"

_qulr··on A Day in the Life of Your Data [pdf]
> you’ve provided zero evidence for this. You claim that Apple have implied Facebook

There were dozens, maybe hundreds of news media stories yesterday stating that Apple was attacking Facebook, so it's not just me. Here are 2 examples:

https://gizmodo.com/tim-its-pronounced-facebook-1846152682

https://www.engadget.com/tim-cook-privacy-cpdp-2021-slams-fa...

Moreover, the original comment that I replied to said "Apple knows they're going toe-to-toe with Facebook", so I'm not even the first one in these comments to make the suggestion. Some commenters are acting like this all came from me, but it didn't. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25958158

_qulr··on A Day in the Life of Your Data [pdf]
> they’re probably the first name that pops into people heads when you say “abuse of peoples data”

> I don’t think Apple gives a shit about Facebook. Why the hell would they? There’s no profit in targeting them specifically.

I think you answered your own question. :-) Facebook is a convenient punching bag. Which is the point of an Orwellian enemy, who isn't actually an enemy except for the need of some enemy.

_qulr··on A Day in the Life of Your Data [pdf]
> It gets 30% of sales and in-app purchases. Facebook doesn't use either as far as I know.

Facebook does have IAP, as already discussed in other sub-comments.

> If they'd foreseen influential companies like Facebook creating APIs which were widely spread through the App Store, they'd have likely closed this door a long time ago.

It's been more than 12 years since the App Store opened. Apple didn't need perfect foreknowledge to take action long before now.

_qulr··on A Day in the Life of Your Data [pdf]
Apple kicked Parler off the App Store, and a lot of people are screaming at Apple, including powerful politicians.

In any case, part of my previous comment was noting how the decade+ of the App Store has actually contributed to and encouraged the advertised-financed "attention economy". Apple wasn't just an innocent bystander that whole time; they designed the platform and the App Store.

_qulr··on A Day in the Life of Your Data [pdf]
> Other than in direct responses to attacks by Facebook, where has Apple even used Facebook’s name?

They don't have to use the name. Everyone including the news media knew that Apple was implying Facebook.

_qulr··on A Day in the Life of Your Data [pdf]
> Given Apple's focus on privacy combined with their huge footprint in the US, Facebook may see them as an existential threat, and be using the word "competitor" to represent that.

I agree that Apple is an existential threat to Facebook, given that Apple has absolute control over software distribution on iPhone. In that sense they're competitors, but not in the standard sense of having competing products.

_qulr··on A Day in the Life of Your Data [pdf]
> I doubt it is particularly large.

Facebook is currently 43 in the list of the top grossing apps. I'm still running iTunes 12.6 which shows these lists.

_qulr··on A Day in the Life of Your Data [pdf]
Please check the App Store before you make obviously false and easily refutable assertions.
← PreviousPage 6 of 31Next →