HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

_qulr

4,776 karma · joined May 23, 2020

submissionscomments
_qulr··on A Day in the Life of Your Data [pdf]
This feels to me like Apple creating a convenient Orwellian enemy. They're not even competitors, because Apple doesn't have a social network, Facebook doesn't sell computers, and indeed Facebook is currently among the grossing apps in the iOS App Store, 30% of which Apple gets.

If Facebook was as terrible as Apple makes them out to be, why would Apple allow Facebook in their App Store and take 30% of the generated revenue? It's hypocritical for Apple to criticize Facebook. If anything, the App Store made Facebook more popular than ever, so it's a "monster" that Apple helped create.

EDIT: My perspective is that the App Store and iOS lockdown have been harmful to user privacy, and Facebook is merely a convenient enemy to distract from the harmfulness of Apple's own current business model. On the Mac, I can install Little Snitch and prevent software from phoning home to both facebook.com and apple.com. I can't do any of this on iPhone. (And indeed, Little Snitch is not even compatible with the restrictive Mac App Store rules, so it has to be distributed outside the MAS.) The iPhone platform is designed such that software like Facebook thrives, and software like Little Snitch cannot exist.

_qulr··on Businesses should try to be the best, not the biggest
> Capitalism is simply an economic system where the means of production are privately owned. Growth is not a requirement or even feature of capitalism.

The problem is that private ownership leads to the classic collective action problem, where actions that are individually rational to each private owner have consequences that are collectively irrational and make the world worse off.

This is not to say that private ownership should be abolished. But there has to at least be a heavy collective counterweight to self-interested wealth accumulation.

_qulr··on Businesses should try to be the best, not the biggest
> I think programmers in general have an overly optimistic expectation of the lifespan of their works.

I think programmers in general have an overly pessimistic expectation of the lifespan of their works. They write temporary, ugly hacks for the sake of expediency, and then 10, 20 years later the whole world is still suffering because of those "temporary" hacks.

_qulr··on Businesses should try to be the best, not the biggest
> I once worked at a company where I didn't understand why they took certain decisions. In the end, it all became very clear. My mindset from "these guys have no idea" shifted towards "wow, they are smart, I didn't get this part".

How is this story is relevant to the linked article?

_qulr··on Businesses should try to be the best, not the biggest
Is it? Earth is, or was, extremely hospitable to humans. Mars is, and will be for a very long time, extremely inhospitable to humans. If we can't even take care of the Earth, what hope is there of taking care of Mars? The more likely scenario is that greedy Martians destroy their own Martian environment very quickly and make themselves extinct. It's much easier to destroy Mars (for human life) than it is to destroy Earth.

We need to focus on sustainability, otherwise Mars will also be unsustainable.

Just wait until oxygen itself becomes a commodity, like in the film "Total Recall". Except unlike in film, there's no deus ex machina native ancient technology to suddenly make the entire atmosphere breathable.

_qulr··on Businesses should try to be the best, not the biggest
> This person is kinda suggesting that companies should have some noble higher purpose.

Not necessarily. There's nothing inherently wrong with making money. What's wrong is never being satisfied no matter how much money you make. "Growth, where it no longer serves a purpose beyond the accumulation of more growth", "endless growth", "growth unchecked". The author doesn't say that growth itself is bad. If you're a sole proprietor, it's not necessarily bad to grow and hire employees. The question is, at what point do you stop prioritizing growth and start prioritizing other things in life — happiness, love, friendship, leisure, ethics, the environment, etc. At some point there are diminishing returns to accumulating more wealth, but there's a collective insanity that says no accumulation is too much. Society celebrates the ultra-wealthy, but to me the ultra-wealthy seem more like gluttons. Would you celebrate someone who eats constantly and weighs 500 pounds? That's not healthy.

Look at Warren Buffett. Dude doesn't even know what to do with all of his money. He only knows how to accumulate, he knows nothing else. He's pledged to give away most of his fortune to the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation... which means he's delegating the spending of his wealth to someone else... after his death! Buffett literally has no idea how to spend the wealth he has accumulated. Doesn't that seem bizarre to you? Why does he keep accumulating?

Some people will claim that if you don't constantly strive for growth, then you're "complacent" and "lazy". But that's completely false, because financial wealth is only one aspect of life. If you only strive for financial growth, then you are one-dimensional; you're lazy and complacent about the non-financial aspects of your life.

_qulr··on Apple First Quarter Results
> So Mac sales are up from 2019Q4 by $1B.

Technically, up $1.7B from that quarter, but why are you comparing 2021Q1 with 2019Q4?

2021 Q1 $8.675B

2020 Q4 $9.032B

2020 Q1 $7.160B

2019 Q4 $6.991B

Clearly the uptick in Mac sales is due to the pandemic and work from home, because 2020 Q4 was prior to the release of M1 Macs, and Mac sales had been flat for several years prior.

It's difficult to determine the effect of M1 Macs on the last quarter sales, because they weren't available until mid-November and were also very supply-constrained.

_qulr··on About the security content of iOS 14.4 and iPadOS 14.4
macOS Big Sur 11.2 Release Candidate 2 was released Monday to beta testers, but 11.2 has not yet shipped to the public. iOS and macOS share a lot of code, as you can see in the security release notes for previous OS updates, so it's likely that Tuesday's iOS update has now 0dayed at least Safari Mac if not macOS too. Hopefully Mac updates are coming today.
_qulr··on Made in the USA: Socialism for the Rich. Capitalism for the Rest
> This article is completely hypocritical to be coming from Tom Friedman.

True, but I would say better late than never.

_qulr··on Brad Cox has died
> ObjC is a "child" of the 1980's when verbosity was considered a merit and a norm in programming.

It's still considered a merit by some.

_qulr··on Apple pulls the plug on user-found method to sideload iOS apps on Mac
Previous HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25807114
_qulr··on Safari 14 added WebExtensions support, so where are the extensions?
> Yeah, it's annoying that neither Google of Firefox stores have easy payments — it makes taking payments less accessible for developers. But obviously it's still possible to roll your own payments or using things like my own https://extensionpay.com

That's cool. I may look into this. Do you have a list of extensions using the service?

_qulr··on Safari 14 added WebExtensions support, so where are the extensions?
> there's nothing inherently hard about monetizing extensions

Over 95% of Chrome extensions are completely free, as in no form of payment whatsoever. This makes extensions one of the worst of all software markets. Users just expect extensions to be free.

Also, the browsers vendors themselves can make it difficult to monetize extensions. Firefox eliminated its extension store several years ago, and Google is eliminating Chrome Web Store payments next month. If anything, the Mac App Store is now the easiest place to monetize extensions IMO.

_qulr··on Safari 14 added WebExtensions support, so where are the extensions?
> It's actually not that hard to monetize browser extensions

It's actually not that hard to become a billionaire [points at some billionaires]

By the way, here are some stats on Chrome extensions: https://www.debugbear.com/blog/counting-chrome-extensions

_qulr··on Safari 14 added WebExtensions support, so where are the extensions?
> And yet, MS Office, Lightroom and others are on the App Store.

Microsoft has received special sandbox exceptions from Apple that are not available to other developers.

_qulr··on Safari 14 added WebExtensions support, so where are the extensions?
Keka: 11 years old! https://changelog.keka.io/

Bear: 1) Bear is not Mac-only: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/bear/id1016366447 2) Bear is more than 4 years old 3) Shiny Frog, the maker is Bear, is even older than that

Wipr: 1) Again, not Mac-only. In fact, Wipr started as iOS-only. https://apps.apple.com/us/app/wipr/id1030595027 2) Wipr is more than 5 years old

Darkroom: 1) Not Mac-only https://apps.apple.com/us/app/darkroom-photo-video-editor/id... 2) Darkroom is 6 years old

Amadine: 1) Not Mac-only https://apps.apple.com/us/app/amadine-vector-drawing/id13391...

_qulr··on Safari 14 added WebExtensions support, so where are the extensions?
> Apple tho wants macOS developers (and users prefer apps from people dedicated to macOS).

This is a very strange argument to make in the context of Safari Web Extensions. Safari already had its own Apple-specific app extensions API, but it seems that Apple decided this was not sufficient, so they implemented the cross-platform WebExtensions API too. Clearly Apple is trying to recruit non-Mac developers with their command-line conversion tool for existing Chrome and Firefox extensions, and automatic generation of a Mac app wrapper.

If Mac developers were sufficient for this purpose, then WebExtensions support would not have needed to be added to Safari at all.

_qulr··on Safari 14 added WebExtensions support, so where are the extensions?
> A lot of people?

Name them. This is a serious request. I'm a longtime professional Mac developer who knows a lot of other Mac developers.

> There are more Mac users (and thus app buyers)

The premise is true, but the conclusion is not necessarily true. The crap store and the iOSication of the Mac have really hurt the Mac software market.

_qulr··on Safari 14 added WebExtensions support, so where are the extensions?
> unless this is waived for these kinds of apps, I couldn’t tell when trying to dig up an answer

Mostly, no.

"You can request to have the annual Apple Developer Program membership fee waived if you’re a nonprofit organization, accredited educational institution, or government entity that will distribute only free apps on the App Store and is based in an eligible country."

"Fee waivers are not available for: Individuals and sole proprietors/single person businesses"

https://developer.apple.com/support/membership-fee-waiver/

_qulr··on When parties reverse their stance, supporters immediately switch their opinions
> There's both the clear vision of conservative values and ideals... and Donald Trump.

I've lived long enough to see the terms "liberal" and "conservative" morph multiple times. (You will too eventually, just watch carefully.) They've long since lost any connection to their origin in classical European political philosophy and have now become merely placeholders to give the pretense that the two major US political parties have some kind of consistent ideological (as opposed to financial) backing, which they don't.

There's a certain irony in Barry Goldwater being credited with launching the modern "conservative" movement in the US when Goldwater himself could be considered much more "libertarian" and was opposed to the policies and increasing influence of "conservative Christians" such as Pat Robertson.

Scratch either of the two parties and underneath you'll see a very loose coalition of differing, sometimes opposing interests, not a clear set of consistent, unwavering beliefs. It's an ongoing power struggle, and the political labels just reflect the currently dominant group in the power struggle.

_qulr··on Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features
Bring back matte screens too.

Glossy screens have been a disaster, not only ergonomically but also in terms of the never-ending "staingate" scandal of antireflective coating peeling off the screen.

_qulr··on Apple is blocking Apple Silicon Mac users from sideloading iPhone apps
> what is the actual reason?

The reason is that many developers were already selling native Mac and native iOS versions of their apps, and who opted out of providing their iOS app in the Mac App Store — because they already had a Mac app in the Mac App Store! — and then Apple comes along and without permission undercuts the developer's own product.

Note that Apple allowing this to happen actually violates Apple's developer program agreement with third-party developers. Section 6.3 of the agreement covers iOS and iPadOS apps on Mac, while section 7.6 explicitly says No Other Distribution Authorized Under This Agreement. Apple was in breach of contract!

This is not further lockdown of the Mac, because from the beginning of iPhone in 2007, Macs never even had the ability to run iOS apps. 2007 to late 2020, no iOS apps on Mac, and nobody was crying lockdown about that. Intel Macs still can't do it. Apple wasn't violating your legal rights all those years.

There is a license agreement with the third-party developer, and unless the developer has opted in to providing the app on the Mac App Store, then distribution of the app to a non-licensed device is illegal. You are free to use licensed apps however you like, but only on licensed devices. For example, you can't copy the app you bought to an unlimited number of devices, to your friends devices, etc. It has never been true that you have unlimited use of licensed apps. You can only install a Mac App Store app on up 5 Macs, no more. That's not "OS lockdown".

_qulr··on Apple is blocking Apple Silicon Mac users from sideloading iPhone apps
> What about the end user who paid good money to own a computer and run whatever he wants on it?

You paid good money to Apple. You didn't pay good money to the app developer.

iOS app prices are ridiculously low because of the crap store "race to the bottom", which fortunately didn't affect the Mac as much. This is one big reason why Things for iOS is so cheap: the market demands it, not because it's magically cheaper for a dev to make an iOS app. If you take away the Mac-level prices for Mac apps, developers like Cultured Code might go out of business, and then you won't get either version of the app.

If Mac app prices start to go as low as iOS app prices, you're going to see almost all developers completely abandon writing native Mac apps, and then Macs might as well just run iOS instead. To forestall that possibility, Mac devs might abandon their much cheaper (or even free) iOS versions to avoid getting undercut by their own products.

Paying money to Apple for a Mac doesn't automatically license you to use third-party apps. That's not how it works legally.

_qulr··on Toxic positivity does more harm than good
> The author's point seems to be that it is toxic to a person to (try to) exist in permanent state of positivity.

Yes. The article started out with the psychologist explaining how the client was looking for fake doctor's notes just to avoid going to work because the client didn't feel "totally positive" that day. That's toxic positivity, the feeling that you can't outwardly display anything less than complete cheerfulness, that you have to bottle up any problem inside and not let it out.

_qulr··on Apple removes first-party firewall exemption in macOS 11.2 beta 2
> Isn't it also tiresome when people on HN assume we know who they are from their handle

No, I don't expect people to know who I am. However, I do expect people to avoid assuming that I'm ignorant of the subject at hand. This ought to be the default approach you have toward anyone.

In this same thread, I was referred to as "My sweet summer child", as if I didn't understand software development at all. This shouldn't happen, regardless of whether you know me or not. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25771925

_qulr··on Apple removes first-party firewall exemption in macOS 11.2 beta 2
> You're assuming that changing that list is the only thing they needed to do.

No, you're assuming that I'm making that assumption. Why would you assume that?

> Most MacOS users by far probably don't care.

It's frustrating that people keep ignoring the fact that I was directly replying to this comment: "That's why Apple has the Developer and Public Beta releases for iOS/OSX so that external users can provide feedback."

If feedback during the betas does not make Apple take action, then the comment I was replying to was wrong.

Your response seems a bit ironic, though, because public backlash is exactly what caused Apple to backtrack.

_qulr··on Apple removes first-party firewall exemption in macOS 11.2 beta 2
> doesn't mean it was done as a quick and dirty implementation or that it's hastily made feature done via cutting corners.

I wasn't implying that. The ContentFilterExclusionList was already present in the first WWDC beta and could have been there internally for many months prior, who knows. I was using "hack" more in the sense of bypassing a security system. I said "It never should have existed", which is not a comment on the quality of the design of the thing that did exist.

> People forget this is not just a single feature, but part of a change to how network filtering is done (not through a third party kernel extension anymore), accompanied with new APIs.

I'm not "people". I'm well aware and haven't forgotten. I've been a professional Mac developer for 15 years. I've used the Network Extension API myself. You may remember me from such news stories as the Mac OCSP appocalypse. https://techcrunch.com/2020/11/15/apple-responds-to-gatekeep... It's incredibly tiresome when HN commenters try to "Macsplain" to me.

_qulr··on Apple removes first-party firewall exemption in macOS 11.2 beta 2
> What I'm saying is "why this took 6 months" doesn't make much sense as a question. Why wouldn't it?

For the 2nd or 3rd time in this thread, I have to remind that I was replying to a comment saying this: "That's why Apple has the Developer and Public Beta releases for iOS/OSX so that external users can provide feedback. And on this occasion just like on many other they will take action if necessary." So, maybe you should argue with that comment instead of with me?

My point was that developers filed feedback about this issue during the betas, yet Apple did not address that feedback, and thus "That's why Apple has the Developer and Public Beta releases for iOS/OSX" is not a valid point in this context.

_qulr··on Apple removes first-party firewall exemption in macOS 11.2 beta 2
> from the perspective of Apple this must've been a non-critical issue at best.

From the perspective of Apple, this wasn't even an issue at all. It "behaves as intended". https://twitter.com/david_ddw/status/1329017113709842437 So that's why Apple didn't fix it. You don't fix something that you don't think is broken.

_qulr··on Apple removes first-party firewall exemption in macOS 11.2 beta 2
> Not to mention that "removing the ContentFilterExclusionList" is a hacky fix suggestion.

You've got in backwards. The ContentFilterExclusionList was itself a hack. It never should have existed.

Some people are handwaving about a mysterious vague problem that calls for a ContentFilterExclusionList, but Little Snitch has existed for many many years on the Mac and has been able to block everything, including Apple services. There was no problem with that until Apple decided to exempt itself from getting blocked.

← PreviousPage 7 of 31Next →