HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

_verandaguy

1,714 karma · joined June 4, 2018

Alt account of `verandaguy` for use from other computers.

Python developer for web systems with interests in concurrent programming.

    -----BEGIN RSA PRIVATE KEY-----
    4
    -----END RSA PRIVATE KEY-----
submissionscomments
_verandaguy··on AI-assisted cognition endangers human development?
While I agree with your rebuke of the GP, Socrates was materially wrong about writing (or at least, about the ability to persist information beyond any single human lifetime).

Cumulatively, knowledge work (including, in particular, curating knowledge) is exceptionally energy intensive from an evolutionary standpoint. It does pay dividends, clearly, but to get compounding effects from it, being able to efficiently pass down big corpora of facts, ideas, processes, etc., is an absolute necessity.

Writing systems are the fundamental way through which we can do this. They worked for us for millennia, and we eventually built upon them to develop encodings used today to store information remarkably densely.

_verandaguy··on France to ditch Windows for Linux to reduce reliance on US tech
It doesn't help that Microsoft seems to be doing everything in its power to alienate Windows users.
_verandaguy··on OpenAI backs Illinois bill that would limit when AI labs can be held liable

    > context exhausition attack
Can you give a high-level overview of how this AV works? I'm a bit of an infosec geek but I generally dislike LLMs, so I haven't done a terribly good job of keeping up with that side of the industry, but this seems particularly interesting.
_verandaguy··on EmDash – A spiritual successor to WordPress that solves plugin security
These april fools jokes keep getting lazier every year.
_verandaguy··on Claude Code's source code has been leaked via a map file in their NPM registry
To clarify: this is the terminal's scrollback buffer vs one managed by the application in the alternate screen.

When I scroll up in nvim, it will keep the editor frame in place (that's the top bar and bottom bar showing things like open buffers, git status, the scratch buffer or whatever it's called), but the file contents will scroll by because nvim at that point has exclusive ownership of the entire screen and can do anything with it, including repainting parts of it in response to motions or a mouse scrolling (if your terminal supports emitting mouse events).

This is in contrast to the `rmcup` "normal" terminal mode where it will scroll back in the terminal's history.

The best analogue I have for that last one is to use tmux with nvim open, and have a tmux visual selection going. You can scroll up and out of nvim, and keep scrolling to whatever was executed before neovim, and when you get out of tmux visual mode it'll snap back down to the bottom of your scrollback buffer, nvim (nominally) taking up the entire pane like nothing happened; but we can probably agree that outside of a few narrow use cases, this isn't a very desirable way to manage scrolling in a terminal.

_verandaguy··on Claude Code's source code has been leaked via a map file in their NPM registry
The other part (which IMO is more consequential) is that once the LLM application quits or otherwise drops out of the alternate screen, that conversation is lost forever.

With the usual terminal mode, that history can outlive the Claude application, and considering many people keep their terminals running for days or sometimes even weeks at a time, that means having the convo in your scrollback buffer for a while.

_verandaguy··on Claude Code's source code has been leaked via a map file in their NPM registry
I've actually heard a plausible theory about the TUI being janky, that being that they avoid use of the alternate screen feature of ANSI (and onwards) terminals.

The theory states that Anthropic avoids using the alternate screen (which gives consuming applications access to a clear buffer with no shell prompt that they can do what they want with and drop at their leisure) because the alternate screen has no scrollback buffer.

So for example, terminal-based editors -- neovim, emacs, nano -- all use the alternate screen because not fighting for ownership of the screen with the shell is a clear benefit over having scrollback.

The calculus is different when you have an LLM that you have a conversational history with, and while you can't bolt scrollback onto the alternate screen (easily), you can kinda bolt an alternate screen-like behaviour onto a regular terminal screen.

I don't personally use LLMs if I can avoid it, so I don't know how janky this thing is, really, but having had to recently deal with ANSI terminal alternate screen bullshit, I think this explanation's plausible.

_verandaguy··on Welcome to FastMCP

    > FastMCP is the standard framework for building MCP applications
Standardized by whom?

In an era where technology exists that can lend the appearance of legitimacy to just about anyone, that kind of statement needs to be qualified.

_verandaguy··on Snowflake AI Escapes Sandbox and Executes Malware
"The sandbox isn't so bad, if the criticism you have is that it totally fails at doing the one thing a sandbox is supposed to do."
_verandaguy··on Have a fucking website
I haven't in a very long time, over a decade at this point.

A few friends and I have a small handful of self-hosted services that we all run on a VPN between our places with stuff like a recipe sharing app, etc., but the number of people with access to that is single digits.

In terms of "hosting anything," I still have my own homelab, and my self-hosting will be limited to this sort of stuff for the foreseeable. A cluster of limited-scope apps that helps me and a handful of friends keep in touch after moving out of our hometown, beyond just chatting in Signal groups.

I won't be putting up my own public website (or portfolio, or whatever; be it hosted on my own infra or not).

_verandaguy··on Have a fucking website
My two cents: I'd love to have a site. I've been involved with web technologies since the early/mid 2000s, when I built my first site in elementary school.

I've picked up hobbies since then that lend themselves well to sharing online, but right now, with the amount of LLM-related scraping happening, I have no intention at all of hosting anything I've made by hand, be it code, photos, recipes, etc.

These bots make their own ground rules -- "just put up this special robots.txt thing" -- and then ignore them, requiring tools like Anubis to be created, maintained, and kept constantly up to date, and for what? So the plagiarism machine can plagiarise more? Copyright courts have apparently just checked out on this, so I'm not at all confident they'll do anything about this.

To be clear: my ego isn't so huge that I want my name plastered everywhere, on everything I've ever touched. I believe strongly in the principle of not getting your shit scraped online and then churned out into something that these LLM companies can (eventually? presumably?) profit off of (or at least turn into investment, in the short-term). These companies have done terrible things to the state of public discourse and I do what I can to avoid feeding the beast.

_verandaguy··on Have a fucking website
It's not the conjugations that scare most people, it's the declensions (ok, well, at least anglophones).
_verandaguy··on UK MPs give ministers powers to restrict Internet for under 18s
To be clear: this is civil action by a family, not the position of the Government of Canada.
_verandaguy··on Open Camera is a FOSS Camera App for Android
What's a rare pepe and how does it support the project?
_verandaguy··on Wikipedia was in read-only mode following mass admin account compromise

    > Based on the fact user scripts are globally disabled now I'm guessing this was a vector.
Disabled at which level?

Browsers still allow for user scripts via tools like TamperMonkey and GreaseMonkey, and that's not enforceable (and arguably, not even trivially visible) to sites, including Wikipedia.

As I say that out loud, I figure there's a separate ecosystem of Wikipedia-specific user scripts, but arguably the same problem exists.

_verandaguy··on New accounts on HN more likely to use em-dashes
Same here, but it'll be a cold day in hell before you see me using the dreaded double-period-bang..!
_verandaguy··on Show HN: AI Timeline – 171 LLMs from Transformer (2017) to GPT-5.3 (2026)
This is ignoring ML which has existed for decades.

Neural networks, computer vision, sentiment analysis, all of these and more have provided an unspeakable amount of value over the years.

_verandaguy··on PayPal discloses data breach that exposed user info for 6 months
This isn't the argument against traditional payment systems you seem to think it is.

There's a reason most people in well-banked countries use plastic over cash these days, convenience and consumer protection are it; and even with cash, the barrier to entry for fraud is higher since at some point that cash will come into contact with the banking world, and will have to be accounted for. If your cash flow is suspicious enough, it'll be audited.

_verandaguy··on PayPal discloses data breach that exposed user info for 6 months
These are often undesirable features for SMEs that need to be accountable for a variety of reasons, including KYC regulations; besides, while blockchains provide protocol-level security, they fail in two ways that do matter to consumers:

- They provide no meaningful consumer protections (since this necessarily requires an authority, which blockchains may not have)

- They don't protect at all against meatspace vulnerabilities like scams and other deception-based attacks, which are by far the more common issue in banking. This is exacerbated by the lack of consumer protections.

(To be clear: don't read my comment as being in support of PayPal. They have abused user trust for a while, and I haven't had an account there in over a year -- fuck 'em.)

_verandaguy··on California's new bill requires DOJ-approved 3D printers that report themselves
This is coming from California, a distinctly capitalist state, and refers to a list published by the US Federal Department of Justice, which reports to a distinctly capitalist (or... at a minimum, a distinctly non-communist) administration.

It also doesn't get in the way of the US's (already extraordinarily loose) firearms sale and acquisition doctrine which regularly costs innocent lives with the pretext of resisting a tyrannical government (which, it appears, people aren't actually that interested in doing now that one's in power).

_verandaguy··on Microsoft says bug causes Copilot to summarize confidential emails
Words have multiple meanings depending on context, and here it's at best ambiguous. In the context of security incidents, logging, auditing, etc., "advisory" is often used as a severity level (and one of the lower ones at that).

So, yes, technically, it's de-facto advisory to publish this information, but assigning "advisory" as a severity tag here is questionable.

_verandaguy··on Airfoil (2024)
It's been said before, but this prediction isn't amazing, imo.

I look forward to Bartosz's articles because they're rock-solid sources of information and the visualizations are both easy-to-understand and surprisingly light on performance. It's all shockingly digestible.

Honestly, as popular science writing goes, this is art as far as I'm concerned, and art is best when it comes from a place of passion and conviction, something AI will never be able to reproduce.

_verandaguy··on Apple introduces new AirTag with longer range and improved findability
I use the terms interchangeably when it comes to batteries; I do use battery disposal bins, but I don't have any faith that the actual process behind the scenes is much less impactful for the environment.

It's like when I learned that many paper recycling programs end up combining paper with regular garbage, or finding out that plastic recycling is comically ineffective in its outcomes.

_verandaguy··on Apple introduces new AirTag with longer range and improved findability
Maybe a hot take, but I don't think this is as awful for e-waste as many other things.

I've had a set of airtags for a good few years now (shortly before Covid, I think?) and they mostly just kinda work. They don't insist upon a need to upgrade, the only part that ever goes bad is the battery -- which is a standard, user-replaceable CR2032, and while batteries going into the garbage isn't fantastic, there's really only so much you can do as long as depend on them.

Like -- this announcement is technically an upgrade, but I've never been less tempted to actually buy into it because the existing product does what it does plenty well enough for my needs.

I do think it's a bit funny to highlight anything Google does now as privacy-first, though. I can't play back Youtube embeds in Waterfox because the browser's default privacy-preserving setting doesn't send referrer information to those embeds, which Youtube now requires for embeds to work. As much as I take issue with Apple's politics over the past year, they do tend to lean towards on-device logic where possible, and their work in the homomorphic cryptography niche has been interesting to follow.

_verandaguy··on House vote keeps federal "kill switch" vehicle mandate
What?

A vehicle (presumably a car, since bikes are vehicles too) gets you and your stuff from point A to point B. Bikes do that too, though at a smaller scale.

If your commute or your errands aren't excessively long or require the use of a controlled-access highway, a bike's a perfectly fine alternative. The limiting factors are seasonal road or bike path maintenance and the discipline of other road users.

_verandaguy··on De-dollarization: Is the US dollar losing its dominance? (2025)
The Whigs would be new ground for me, but I'm quite familiar with modern Poland. The closest they've come was probably under the living Kaczynski's tenure as premier, or during Duda's early days as president, and neither have come close to what's going on with the police state in the US as it is today.

I'll read up on the Whig party, though if you have ledes that'd be good to start with, I'd love some links.

_verandaguy··on De-dollarization: Is the US dollar losing its dominance? (2025)
My outsider's POV: the fact that there's a Gestapo-analogue in place already tells me that an electoral solution alone is almost certainly no longer sufficient (or at least, unlikely to be effective) at this point.

The Democrats have also had very weak messaging ahead of the midterms. Like, pathetically weak in the current context.

This is to say nothing of the hypothetical where the US makes moves against allies' territories before the midterms.

_verandaguy··on Canada's Carney called out for 'utilizing' British spelling
It's a bit of both!

"Period" tends to be used in day-to-day speech when referring to the punctuation; you'll hear "full stop" if it's meant to emphasize a previous statement (though not universally), like with "you'll do the dishes, full stop."

_verandaguy··on United 777-200 fleet faces an uncertain future after Dulles engine failure
These are the exact points written in the article.

They also substantiate the idea that the United 777-200 fleet does face an uncertain future.

_verandaguy··on How Much Wealth an AI Stock Market Crash Could Destroy
It's so blatantly tied to who's likely to lose the most money. The unreal part to me is that the major news outlets are so much more obvious in their framing now.

AI has a lot of rich people riding on its success, and this time's different for, IMO, two major reasons...

- First, the companies most invested in AI are perfusing it everywhere. Many parts of these big businesses, if not the business as a whole, is invested heavily in the success of LLM-based products. Microsoft is probably the poster child for this, where you can't use practically any of their modern products without copilot or some such being shoved in your face. OpenAI and Anthropic are both companies whose existence is predicated only by a viable LLM-based product. Nvidia and (as of their last-week's announcement) Micron are both now also heavily invested in the success of this technology, though they're also surely not the only companies in the hardware sector to be following this path to some degree.

- Second, the actual individuals behind these companies are the world's richest people, and much of their fortune comes from stock in these companies, and loans taken out against that stock.

  They stand to *personally* lose a significant-even-to-them sum of money if the bottom falls out of this thing. If this weren't the case, I'm absolutely certain we wouldn't be seeing as much reporting about how an AI crash would hurt the average household. When smaller crashes happen (even those that affect more average households), it's inevitable, or it's good for the economy in the long-term (it's a correction, after all -- how could that possibly be bad?), or it's the consequence of people's personal choice to invest one way or another, but because the uber-rich were spared, it's *not really that bad.*
This is a disgusting turn in the state of journalism. I don't pretend know what comes next, or how this can be remedied. Crowdsourced news is as prone to manipulation as "traditional" centralized news, so that's not it, and I don't think people have the depth of knowledge to use something purely fact-based (like bellingcat) for every domain of day-to-day life (which is less an effect of the US education system being in continuous decline over decades, and more an effect of the cognitive load it takes to be familiar enough with everything to be able to draw reasonable conclusions about it.
← PreviousPage 4 of 11Next →