HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

a022311

358 karma · joined June 27, 2024

submissionscomments
a022311··on Ask HN: How to get started with robotics as a hobbyist?
As someone who has been learning robotics as a hobby for a decade, my advice is: forget all the buzzwords and what the industry is using and start small instead.

I started robotics at a young age and began with small builds with LEGO motors and sensors, getting a feel of how each one works and how to interact with them with code. Then I got to much more advanced programs with LEGO Mindstorms EV3, learned about things like PID controllers practically and even started taking part in some competitions. Next, I went to writing actual code (as opposed to block-based programming) on microcontrollers like the micro:bit (and a few years later the Raspberry Pi Pico). I deepened my knowledge of how electronics work and learned how circuits work. I eventually got into a team with a few friends and we built a human-size robot combining 3D printing, a bunch of circuitry, ROS, 2 SBCs, Arduinos, a LIDAR and OpenCV for face/object recognition. This took years of learning step-by-step to achieve.

This is obviously not the path you'd take, robotics was what brought me into programming and you're probably going for the opposite.

You're not going to build a perfect robot or electronic device from the start and you shouldn't try to either. Get a microcontroller that's newcomer-friendly and play around with it. A micro:bit mostly emphasizes on the end result, with a built-in display and sensors and many plug-and-play modules to get you going. A Raspberry Pi Pico is much more flexible, but also requires you to learn about wiring and doing more things yourself. If you prefer coding in C, go for an Arduino. An ESP32 is also a good choice. It's a good idea to get a 3D printer and learn CAD in parallel, as it's a great way for a hobbyist to create actual tools that are more than a bunch of wires.

Once you get enough experience and confidence in your skills, you'll want to get into more advanced projects. Use your knowledge to plan them out, research and learn the technologies you're going to use (you can't learn everything beforehand and each piece of hardware is something different) and enjoy the journey from prototype to finished project.

And by the way (you didn't mention it but other comments here are so I'll give you an opinion on that), ROS is nearly always overkill for hobbyist robotics projects :D

I hope that helps you start your journey!

a022311··on The Holy Grail of Linux Binary Compatibility: Musl and Dlopen
I agree. I've seen quite a few AUR packages built that way and I'm using a few myself too. The end user shouldn't be expected to do this though! :D
a022311··on Environmentalists worry Google behind bid to control Oregon town's water
Guess what people usually use to cool water vapor...

It does make sense that datacenters would be cooled just like your water-cooled PC but that's probably not very sustainable given the fact that they don't do so.

a022311··on I was right about ATProto key management
I totally agree. This is the fundamental reason I've stayed off there until now. I'm not about to tie my permanent identity to a domain which I might not own tomorrow. And did:plc is not an option for obvious reasons.
a022311··on The Holy Grail of Linux Binary Compatibility: Musl and Dlopen
It should be noted that AppImages tend to be noticeably slower at runtime than other packaging methods and also very big for typical systems which include most libraries. They're good as a "compile once, run everywhere" approach but you're really accommodating edge cases here.

A "works in most cases" build should also be available for that that it would benefit. And if you can, why not provide specialized packages for the edge cases?

Of course, don't take my advice as-is, you should always thoroughly benchmark your software on real systems and choose the tradeoffs you're willing to make.

a022311··on Doing gigabit Ethernet over my British phone wires
I wish I knew about this when I lived in a house without Ethernet sockets! I needed it in the attic for my PC and servers and all I had were slow, unreliable TP-Link Powerline adapters. My first speed test gave me 37.1Kbps (after painfully loading Cloudflare's test page). On a really good day I could get 3MBps. I'd get disconnected multiple times a day and I had to try all sorts of methods to get the adapter to connect again. I had to write a program in the end to tell me if I didn't have internet because the Powerline broke or my DNS server broke (normally it's always DNS but turns out it wasn't) :D

I had a phone socket in that room and I had already discussed the possibility of converting it into an Ethernet socket but decided it's not worth it because everything ended up in a cupboard far away from my router. These adapters would have solved the problem nicely!

By the way, I have more fun stories. The cabling in my current house (which has Ethernet sockets) is still miserable. I spent a year working with my PC over USB tethering to my phone until I finally called an electrician to find which of the 11 dangling cables in the cupboard went to my office...

One day some wires in there were slightly moved and the internet got disconnected because they were badly crimped. Nothing was working so in the end I got an RJ45 connector and managed to get the wires in there.

a022311··on The longest Greek word
I do this like... every single time (although with a shorter and slightly more common ancient Greek word). It's quite fun actually!
a022311··on The longest Greek word
Nope, it doesn't contain zeta (ζ), xi (ξ) and theta (θ).
a022311··on The longest Greek word
It will be much easier if you learn modern Greek first. Keep in mind that it's very hard, even for native Greek speakers. Be prepared to spend a few years doing that ;)
a022311··on Don't fall into the anti-AI hype
I think both of you are correct.

LLMs do empower you (and by "you" I mean the reader or any other person from now on) to actually complete projects you need in the very limited free time and have available. Manually coding the same could take months (I'm speaking from experience developing a personal project for about 3 hours every Friday and there's still much to be done). In a professional context, you're being paid to ship and AI can help you grow an idea to an MVP and then to a full implementation in record-breaking time. At the end of the day, you're satisfied because you built something useful and helped your company. You probably also used your problem solving skills.

Programming is also a hobby though. The whole process matters too. I'm one of the people who feels incredible joy when achieving a goal, knowing that I completed every step in the process with my own knowledge and skills. I know that I went from an idea to a complete design based on everything I know and probably learned a few new things too. I typed the variable names, I worked hard on the project for a long time and I'm finally seeing the fruits of my effort. I proudly share it with other people who may need the same and can attest its high quality (or low quality if it was a stupid script I hastily threw together, but anyway sharing is caring —the point is that I actually know what I've written).

The experience of writing that same code with an LLM will leave you feeling a bit empty. You're happy with the result: it does everything you wanted and you can easily extend it when you feel like it. But you didn't write the code, someone else did. You just reviewed an intern's work and gave feedback. Sometimes that's indeed what you want. You may need a tool for your job or your daily life, but you aren't too interested in the internals. AI is truly great for that.

I can't reach a better conclusion than the parent comment, everyone is unique and enjoys coding in a different way. You should always find a chance to code the way you want, it'll help maintain your self-esteem and make your life interesting. Don't be afraid of new technologies where they can help you though.

a022311··on PassSeeds – hijacking Passkeys to unlock new cryptographic use cases
It's interesting to see another use case for passkeys. The demo doesn't work with Bitwarden though :(
a022311··on It's hard to justify Tahoe icons
I'll have to second this. It's not even on Apple's homepage! I hadn't heard it mentioned for months before today. It had its niche share of users who actually found it useful, but apart from them it seems that the world is not ready for spatial computing (or maybe current spatial computing isn't ready for people, who knows?).
a022311··on It's hard to justify Tahoe icons
It's been a few years since I last used a Mac and the careful design I had known no longer exists. This made me realize the situation even worse than I imagined it to be based on Tahoe's reviews.

Even without a designer's detail-aware eyes, I couldn't stop facepalming with what I saw. I'd be embarrassed to ship that and call it an improvement! Apple icons may look cool and consistent when browsing them all together as part of SF Symbols, but all that disappears when used incorrectly.

a022311··on The Gentle Seduction (1989)
I read the whole thing and I think it's useful to view this topic under a different lens. The most astonishing part for me is that it was written over 30 years ago!

I'm a bit grateful that science today isn't nearly that advanced. It would be cool to be able to explore the world like the main character, but then again it seemed so sad and miserable.

I share her sentiment from the beginning of the story: I don't want to be immortal. Living a short, happy life is much better than being miserable forever even though you have everything you could possibly imagine. I think death should be treated as a gift and not something to be afraid of (of course I'm probably too young to say this, but this is how I feel currently). It's another motivation for us to enjoy our lives in a meaningful way and not waste them.

a022311··on Tell HN: Happy New Year
Φίλε έχουμε ακόμα κάνα οχτάωρο... Happy new year anyway!
a022311··on Tell HN: Merry Christmas
The Bible and the Big Bang theory are not mutually exclusive. The Old Testament is a very symbolic book and gives no specific details on how exactly the world was created, other than the seven days of creation. We know that the 7 days weren't referring to our current concept of a day. There's also no water above the sky. It was written like that, because it would be easier for people to understand. Science wasn't a thing back then. If it were written in 2025, it would obviously be very different and probably much more detailed.

Modern Christians know that religion and science can go together. Science researches _how_ something works. Religion answers _who_ created it. The Big Bang theory is actually accepted by them today.

a022311··on Tell HN: Merry Christmas
I'll admit it does look a bit like an IOCCC [0] entry. Can someone please do it for us?

[0]: https://www.ioccc.org/

a022311··on Backing up Spotify
The Pudding had a nice article explaining how streaming revenue is distributed: https://pudding.cool/2022/06/streaming/
a022311··on Show HN: Gemini Pro 3 imagines the HN front page 10 years from now
Nice touch that it thought of Bellard for 'Emulating Windows 10 in the browser'! He's already halfway there with the Windows 2000 emulator: https://bellard.org/jslinux/
a022311··on Self-hosting my photos with Immich
> You need to be a web dev or a sys admin to be able to wrangle that thing.

I totally disagree. You do need a tiny bit of command line experience to install and update it (nothing more than using a text editor and running `docker compose up`), but that's really it. All administration happens from the web UI after that. I've been using Immich for at least 2 years and I've never had to manually do something other than an update.

> Immich solves the wrong problem. I just want the household to share photos - I don't want to host a Google Photos for others.

Honestly, I can't understand what exactly you're expecting. If Google Photos suits your needs for sharing photos with others, that's great! As for Immich, have you read how it started[0]? I think it's solved the problem amazingly well and it still stays true to its initial ambitions.

[0]: https://v1.142.1.archive.immich.app/docs/overview/welcome

a022311··on Tell HN: Happy Thanksgiving
I'm here just under two years (I was browsing before creating an account) and I'm immensely grateful to have this in my life. HN is a tiny corner of the internet where I can consistently find high quality stories and learn something new every day. Not only that, I also get to interact with brilliant people and have meaningful conversations, unlike so many other internet forums that are just full of hate.

Thanks to the moderators, commenters and the whole community for building and maintaining this space of the internet and adding some value to my day!

a022311··on Shor's algorithm: the one quantum algo that ends RSA/ECC tomorrow
Shor's algorithm has been known for a while now (apparently since 1994) and is the main reason quantum-resistant cryptography became an important research subject. The article explains it nicely (for someone like me who doesn't know nearly enough physics or maths to fully understand the technical parts), but this bit at the end ruins it a bit:

> Rotate everything that lasts >10 years to pure PQC now

The author suggests switching to Post-Quantum Cryptography which uses relatively new ciphers that haven't been as battle-tested as older ones like RSA and ECC. Back when those were introduced, there weren't any stronger ciphers at the time, so if they were broken, at least people knew they did the best they could to protect their data.

Now, however, we have standardized encryption with (to the general public's knowledge at least) uncrackable algorithms (provided sane key lengths are chosen), so doing anything that could weaken our encryption makes us worse than the baseline. This proposal is theoretically stronger, but it is unknown whether it will stand the test of time, even with today's technology, due to it being relatively new and not widely deployed.

The standard practice of rolling out PQC is using it as an additional layer alongside current encryption standards. This adds redundancy, so that if one is broken the data will stay safe. Using only PQC or only RSA/ECC/whatever makes the system have a single point of failure.

FYI, this is exactly what governments want (I'll let you guess why). This related post was on the front page just a few days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46033151

a022311··on EU Council Approves New "Chat Control" Mandate Pushing Mass Surveillance
> Nothing substantial has happened to the three texts since last week, it's just that "chat control is back" drives traffic and "Council preparatory body formally approves draft position that got consensus previously but didn't formally get passed because people were fighting over Ukraine stuff for too long" doesn't.

While I agree with your point, it's still crucial to raise awareness of Europe's actions. It may be a small step, but it is not insignificant.

a022311··on GrapheneOS is leaving France after receiving threats from law enforcement
Oh, sorry! I searched to see if this was mentioned before, but I didn't find any results. I guess I could have used a slightly better query...
a022311··on I converted a rotary phone into a meeting handset
The latest iPhone is pretty close I think.
a022311··on Several core problems with Rust
> - Compile speed. Why do people care so much? Use debug for correctness and iterating your code. You're hardly going to change much between runs, and you'll get an incremental compile. Let rust-analyzer tell you if there are errors before you even try compiling. Let your CI do release optimization in its own time, who cares if CI is slow?

Even if you know you're code compiles, it's often easier and faster to validate the logic or complex interactions by running the code. In large (and even not so large actually) projects, debug builds can be painfully slow, even on good hardware. It's important to have a tight feedback loop so that you can interate quickly.

a022311··on I converted a rotary phone into a meeting handset
Interesting how 10 years later we saw an actual cellphone with this color...
a022311··on Hack Club: A story in three acts (a.k.a., the shit sandwich)
Exactly this. I was surprised to see these comments and then I realized that NoScript blocked the JS (as it should have). The web is so much nicer without JS.
a022311··on Ask HN: How would you set up a child’s first Linux computer?
> One of the actually most valuable thing my father did for me, definitely in terms of education outcome and career. Was getting me interested and spending time with me and explaining me things. The particulars do not matter, I can not remember them. It is totally irrelevant whether what Linux distro you use or what you teach them. What matters is that the parent is there, explains and encourages.

Yup, that's the essence of parenting and should totally not be overlooked!

a022311··on Ask HN: How would you set up a child’s first Linux computer?
I really like the idea and I wish I was introduced to Linux too as a kid! (although I did eventually get into it myself when I was 13)

Linux has a really steep learning curve for people who have only learned Windows at school or are used to the touch-based interface Chromebooks and smartphones/tablets provide. It can certainly be overwhelming for a kid who just wants to work on a school project or game with friends, so you'll need to maintain a delicate balance if you try to make this work.

If I was considering this for my kids, I'd try to give them something as friendly as possible. No terminals or writing code at all, unless they actually get interested and start asking you about how the computer works. Sit down together and teach them how to responsibly use the internet, protect their privacy and find free software.

Try to make the experience interactive and let them know that they can customize it however they want and help them do so. I always found Windows and macOS very limiting in that sense as a child and my only options were downloading sketchy apps or writing my own terrible scripts (I remember trying to animate my wallpaper on Windows with Python...).

It's also very important to ensure they're covered for schoolwork and any gaming needs. I won't recommend Libreoffice here, Office online or in a VM will be a much better experience and Proton is amazing at gaming on Linux these days (although if you've selected low-end hardware it may be worth considering a dedicated game console).

I generally think most people will appreciate Linux if they give it a try. People just tend to be negative because they've been taught to stay inside the closed ecosystem of big OS vendors and closed, user-hostile software. Once you experience freedom, there's no going back!

Good luck with your project!

EDIT: An important downside I forgot to mention is that there is practically no way to set screen-time or app limits, or block certain websites which is something important to have at least in the beginning when teaching responsible computer use. For those who have tried this, what's your approach?

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →